Personality Mafia!

Personality Mafia! - Page 3

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

August 23 2011 03:39 GMT

#1633

On August 23 2011 12:35 Ace wrote:
I find it amazing that Pandain role claims, role blocks two Townies(in public!), and yet you still think he's Town.

You people just dont think at all.

ETA: Make that 3 Townies, who all flipped Town on death. Silly.

I wanted to ban everyone every day and get away with it but was scared.

I feel like the best part was when I actually became pro town and posted what I felt a logical and amazing analysis of the bumatlarge situation, they started to accuse me and even my own mafia team wanted to bandwagon me.

Then I just stop posting for 3 days and wtf no one accuses me anymore.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

August 24 2011 00:07 GMT

#1699

On August 24 2011 08:38 Palmar wrote:
@Curu

I would never have defended Pandain like I did if we couldn't paint bum red. I'd have bussed him super hard.

Maybe I'm wrong(and I am certainly wrong alot of the times) but I feel like this kind of thinking is wrong. If a mafia does a super stupid scum slip(read me when I slipped about a mafia role that town didn't know about), then yeah of course immediately bus him. But almost every town acts scummy at times and in fact I feel that I wasn't playing scummily except for the times I banned people(and that was for the lols).

But even when a mafia player plays scummily, you shouldn't bus him immediately. I felt confident that I could get away in the end with just "oh its pandain he's just retarded" and so I played that up this game. But scum can't just hound on a player immediately, it creates an atmosphere that makes it that I AM mafia, rather than "this player" thinks I am.

That's why even when Redff was accusing me, I knew I was safe because the logic he used wasn't right. But afterwards when Palmar and syllo start to agree and even vote me, then town goes on a "slippery slope".

But on the other hand, bussing someone immediately makes for a lot of town cred(if they turn out mafia.) It means you took the initiative. So I feel its an interesting payout vs rewards type of scenario.

However something I did learn was to be more careful. Even if someone's logic is wrong that doesn't mean town will discount it. In fact, without alot of "vets" to help guide the town the right way, people just go running off at random areas. In fact, had we lurked all game and I not gone active, mafia might not have been under suspicion nearly all game. Rather than look at who was playing scummily, town was looking at people who were messing up. And I think that was at the core of why town lost.

Prev 1 2 3 All

Please or register to reply.

Personality Mafia! - Page 3

Completed

Ongoing

Upcoming