Pick Your Power Mafia 3! - Page 4

On January 15 2011 10:56 CubEdIn wrote:
I didn't protect anyone first night.

On January 15 2011 10:57 kitaman27 wrote:


Agreed, but it didn't realize we should pass up a town lynch due to the fact that we can't confirm a player is 100% red.

On January 15 2011 11:07 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
on a random note, did beneather or zeks get a prod earlier about being at risk for a modkill, cause if so, we lost 1-2 townies.

On January 15 2011 13:44 kitaman27 wrote:


Whether or not the traitor is recruited, he still has a mafia win condition and will contribute to their lynch target (probably you). Would you consider hitting fishball? I would make the hit myself, except there is a chance I could be role blocked so you should be the one hitting the most concrete target.

Amber who do you plan to role block tonight?

BC do you still plan to make your analysis of bum before night actions are due?

Bum did you fall down the rabbits hole again? Do you have any night hit suggestions?

On January 15 2011 14:38 Misder wrote:
Ok, so I missed out on a lot since I last posted (like a completely vanished from the face of the earth -.-), and I’ll put what I think about the situation. Oh, also, prob won’t post until Sunday 

@Cube
I think that Cube is most likely SK.

Cube is stupid. Really stupid. And I get a really bad vibe from him. He contradicts himself many times. He continues to say that we need to prove deconduo100%. There’s no way that we could do that without killing him.

1st Post (Cube’s fake claim)
He thinks that he’s the most important person in the game. He doesn’t want to risk dying in order to save someone. Now, the wording on this post is interesting. 1) “I have weird head issues”- I have no idea why he would want to post this at all. 2) “I may do either of the following” his wording is really weird- it seems like he claims that it will randomly choose every day. 3) “Not the most helpful in the game”- once we figure out what kind of doctor, it definitely could be helpful. Paranoid acts like a roleblocker, weak can guarantee a mafia kill.

2nd Post
Another scummy post. 1) “I was hoping to give the Mafia a reason not to hit me”- continues to think that he’s the most important person in the game. 2) “risk of killing someone -> good for mafia”- bad logic? Mafia always has a risk of killing someone? 3) “They basically have no reason not to hit me”- Uh, yeah they do now. You just said you’re too afraid to use your power. Contradiction. 4) “I’ll help you”- contradiction again. His entire reasoning day 1 he claims is that he doesn’t want to die; now he wants to die?

3rd Post
Seems like hes not paying attention to what is happening, like a townie would do :/

4th Post
1) Picks out grammar- like its important when it really isn’t. 2) “they just don’t work as they should”- its not like we didn’t know that- we knew that they wouldn’t be normal as it was in the OP

5th Post
I think I’m just confused…

6th Post
1) “fake claiming would be… leading the town to believe that my role is something different than it is”- you did- you claimed that role did something extra; that’s different that what it is 2) “Explain how this would make me a more efficient Mafia”- it would lead to another excuse not to use your power… 3) “I hoped that Mafia wouldn’t reread the rules”- uhh, why not? Your logic on this is that they wouldn’t because they didn’t pick doctor. I reread the rules all the time just to make sure of things- that doesn’t make me not mafia. Actually, I knew you were lying about the bad doctor part right away before I read BC’s post without even looking at the OP again. That’s just bad logic

7th Post
1) our entire discussion before from LSB was that we probably don’t have the JOAT role.

And it goes on and on and on

I still think we can use him as a medic- if we can figure out what kind he is. I suggest he protects deconduo- mafia has a reason to kill deconduo tonight, as he is siding with the town as of now- if hes paranoid, he would roleblock deconduo’s shot that he said he would fire- if naive weak, then deconduo will probably die (theres no way to guarantee this)- if hes weak- then Cube will die.

@deconduo situation
He agreed that he would use his day vig to survive today’s lynch. We can use that as many pointed out. Deconduo would need to help the town since if mafia makes it lylo, and town loses, deconduo loses too. So the best course of action for deconduo is to help the town until we get a few of the mafia lynched. That means we can use/trust him for a while.

@BC
BC being active day 2 is unusual. He did that in my other mafia game with him where he was mafia, where he didn’t post at all basically day 1, and then day 2, he emerged and completely piled on someone who was being scummy but not mafia, as seen with Cube. Just an FoS on BC. Don’t really want to go into analysis.

@LSB
I’m still following the analysis on this guy. Not positive on any of this on him, since at first I believed him to be mafia, but now, I’m questioning.


@Fishball
He’s posted less than from day 1- I can’t say much since I’m doing the same thing- but it is another reason why he might be mafia. Meh, I’m not pushing so hard on his lynch anymore- but I still think hes pretty mafiaish.

On January 15 2011 17:28 JimboSilvers wrote:


Oh hey nice of you to come in and post!

On your list : why would we kill the SK? First off we can't kill him at night since he's bulletproof, and second we need to kill mafia, not SK. We're in a terrible position given its 16 players and 5, potentially 6 mafia, and a bunch of KP.

Anything else to say about Fishball other than "likely traitor"?

Why Misder over other lurkers like zeks?

You mention bumatlarge and say other people seem to want to lynch him. What do YOU think? I'm not feeling conviction here. Along with the other questionable picks on your list, I'm just feeling like you're trying to pick easy candidates here.

Also:

Why do you think you'll be targetted again? And why do you think you're so important that we need to save your life? Your most recent post is just atrocious. kitaman, please ignore my last request and shoot this loser instead.

On January 16 2011 00:21 bumatlarge wrote:
Great, an SK is going to kill me now lol? Well, he does get props for dayvig'n a fellow SK, and no he really has to gun for scum now. Well I can tell you deconduo, if this is your new goal in helping town, killing me won't be helping you.

And BC has upgraded to 25% town 75% mafia in my book. Shame he decided to not help at all during the first day

And should I reveal what info I have now?

On January 16 2011 02:35 bumatlarge wrote:


Well if that's how you legitimately feel, I'm not going to argue with that. Doesn't help you though in the eyes of everyone else. Mafia want to kill SK a lot more desperately then town atm. Guess the next the thing on the agenda is lynching deconduo and then scouting around for anymore SKs?

And name one thing in this game I haven't given a correct output on. I'm not going to argue with you further until later, because I don't have the means to get rid you. You should probably try to kill me tonight while we townies still have this deficient intelligence. Maybe your mafia squad can still save face and help lynch you.

On January 16 2011 03:11 JimboSilvers wrote:


This is exactly what I mean. SK's are not mafia. So you really don't get any brownie points for finding them. You just pop out and accuse me, maybe for accusing you. But since I've now switched to Haplo, you should be all cool with that, right? Unless you're trying to defend some mafia buddies. But we can wait on that judgment.




There's a difference between being not being omnipresent in the thread and being useless. I may not respond to every post or give my thoughts on all the nonsense you people create, but I don't need to, and I don't have the time to. Notice how every time I do post, I post content. Notice how everytime I post something there's strong resistance to everything I say. I'd say its just the mafia afraid of me.

Ever notice how we aren't really getting anywhere? Especially you. Popping out and accusing me without really accusing me, and selectively reading my posts. Coolio. KP roles please read my above posts and think about it hard. I don't have to get into a shit flinging fest in order to get my point across.

On January 16 2011 05:51 kitaman27 wrote:
Some points I would like to be addressed if you don't mind, BC.

(I still would also like to hear from Amber about his roleblocking target and his reasons for moving off fishball in the previous lynch and from dec about his kp target so we don't overlap)







First, lets contrast this questionable reasoning:

Rol: Possibly a traitor. Experienced player, so probably scum.

Fish: Possibly a traitor. Experienced player, so great to keep around.

Ulterior motive?



This fits your style completely? You do realize that you have to be lynched in order to use this kp, right? If you are town, why would you foresee yourself getting lynched in the first place? Aren't you the type of player that gets sniped at night, not lynched during the day.

What did you intend to do if you got checked by bulletbill?
"Opps, its okay guys. I'm godfather. No worries!"



You actually say it best yourself. The godfather role has far more scum applications than town. I'm not sure I buy that you selected it to deny the role and use a lynch kp, over the possible remaining pro-town roles.



Yet you did. Many times. It's great you helped find a SK, but as a scum desperate to quickly find a day vig target, LSB would have been the best choice.



Huh? What is this even supposed to mean? Since the death list doesn't match your "system" you are supposed to be given a free pass?





You contradict yourself here. You don't vote for fish because you don't have a strong enough belief he is scum and don't want to accidentally vote off an innocent town. Yet now you agree if majority is about to be reached, you will join the bandwagon, regardless of your personal beliefs. Sounds as if you are just providing an excuse for yourself why you won't commit.



Heh flatery. I'm sure we've all seen this used before.

On January 17 2011 06:47 Kenpachi wrote:

Mafia hit was on Kita or Jimbo. JOAT/CPR/Unkown SK was on Zeks. You were hit by Deconduo. Kita hit BC.
Now, This doesnt make much sense and the only possibilities are a 2nd SK on Zeks and Mafia with a JOAT/CPR or SK with 2 KP.

On January 17 2011 07:06 Kenpachi wrote:

SK's hit goes through Bulletproof. We know that a SK hit Zeks or Kita because Jimbo is most likely BP

On January 17 2011 07:27 kitaman27 wrote:


This is kinda unrelated, but it was something I never got a chance to address BC. You repeatedly state that if Fishball is the traitor he has to provide reds for us to stay alive.

1) Why would the traitor in his situation ever consider hunting for a red?
2) What reds has he found?