|
I know you like incentives based arguments, thats why you posted this
On August 26 2010 04:21 citi.zen wrote: Hesmyrr He flips traitor: :D! Flips town: We know that Chaoser is town.
Please don't confuse roles with alignments.
That said, I will likely vote for Hesmyrr at this time.
|
Sunshine and puppy dogs :-)
|
|
I've made up my mind to vote for Hesmyrr.
As mentioned before, there shouldn't be any reason to doubt SR's claim, at least for the very first day. Assuming that the first 3 drafted their respective roles according to plan, that only leaves Hesmyrr and zeks. It was also brought up that Hesmyrr would have the highest incentive to choose Traitor compared to the others, due to the high probability of him getting a boring role, Vanilla Townie.
This is not a 100% shot, and worse case scenario Hesmyrr might end up just being a Vanilla Townie, but at least we will gain critical information from the SR Traitor claim, and a clearer picture of the top 6.
If the lynch does not go through and Mafia/SK doesn't hit anyone in the top 6, then Town is left to deal with this for at least another cycle. Is this the best way to go? Your call.
## Vote Hesmyrr
|
##Vote DarthThienAn - placeholder ofc.
I'm confused - why do we believe SR again?
|
Because he said he picked traitor. And didnt get it. He may die if hes telling the truth (killing hesmyr for reasons stated) or dies for sure if hes not. It just matters what hesmyr picked, CV(which he didnt get) or traitor. Basically vanilla of sorts, or traitor. Neutral/win situation.
|
On August 27 2010 05:23 DarthThienAn wrote: ##Vote DarthThienAn - placeholder ofc.
I'm confused - why do we believe SR again? If you don't believe him, its best to kill him in the night anyways. Because it is pretty likely that SR could have taken vengeful player. A lynch would give the mafia another KP
|
Radfield
Canada2720 Posts
Well, at any rate we need a lynch in the next 4 hours. Hesmyrr seems like the obvious choice, but unfortunately we don't really get any info from this lynch. Mafia are just as in the dark as anyone else about his potential alignment so we can't really draw any conclusions based on who votes what.
I don't feel particularly strongly about any other player, and even if I did I doubt I could change many minds at this juncture.
##Vote Hesmyrr
On August 26 2010 12:03 ~OpZ~ wrote:Show nested quote +On August 26 2010 11:49 Ace wrote:On August 26 2010 11:41 ~OpZ~ wrote: Obvious. He types my name, and breadcrumbs zeks, using my name for the z, so if mafia hit him and zeks is mafia, we know to lynch zeks...hurdur.... xD...
Or he makes a case against zeks, without saying he role checked him. If he starts going against someone he checked, then pops detective.
If he starts saying "blah blah, this person is right, blah blah" then that person is good.
Ace, Does RoleCop return role of mafia if the mafia investigated has another role, such as detective/medic/ect?
6.)What happens if a RoleCop checks someone without a role?
The result they get back is VANILLA. Otherwise the RC would be almost better than the Alignment Cop in this setup which would make no sense.
So if they do have a role the Role Cop...gets a role.
Right...Wow... ##Vote Radfield"Alignment Cop is weak compared to Role Cop" That ends my reasoning. Wow. We just walked down a windy road to death.
I love how you're complaining about the plan now. I posted my final plan about 36 hours before the drafting deadline, and posted my opening notes about 3 or 4 full days before the draft took place. Plenty of time for you to look through it and find any problems. Too bad you decided not to start playing until AFTER THE DRAFT. Really could have used your input about 3 days ago.
Not to mention you obviously never even read the plan in full. I detailed several times why I thought role cop was a far more powerful role then Alignment Cop, and I stand by that reasoning.
Twice this game you've tried to cast suspicion on me. Please focus your attentions elsewhere. I've said it before: If I'm still alive after Day 2, then you can start looking at me a little harder.
Anyways, Inactives. This game has been going almost a week(since we got our roles), who hasn't posted much:
Brownbear - on the verge of being Modkilled DarthThienAn - A few posts with content, not much. Claims he's SC2ing JeeJee - Lots of little posts addressing people, no content. Seems like actively lurking.
Chaoser - A bit of activity, not much content. Giving an excuse for less activity in the short term: Just got his wisdom teeth removed
Probably a few others, no one really jumps out at me though
|
## Vote Hesmyrr
There's 3 possibilities as I see it:
- Vanilla: Hesmyrr did exactly what he was told and paid for it with his life
- Traitor: Makes sense from a pre-game perspective. To take a useless role which will probably end up as Vanilla, or go with something a little more.. exciting?
- Mafia/SK: Not entirely impossible - it's a high number with a useless role in our list of assignments (expected to be Vanilla), so unlikely to get checked.
|
There's also a 4th possibility: Some Alternative Role: Didn't do what he was told and got some other role. Since he's claimed otherwise, I view this as most unlikely
|
On August 27 2010 07:34 SiNiquity wrote:## Vote HesmyrrThere's 3 possibilities as I see it: - Vanilla: Hesmyrr did exactly what he was told and paid for it with his life
- Traitor: Makes sense from a pre-game perspective. To take a useless role which will probably end up as Vanilla, or go with something a little more.. exciting?
- Mafia/SK: Not entirely impossible - it's a high number with a useless role in our list of assignments (expected to be Vanilla), so unlikely to get checked.
On August 27 2010 07:36 SiNiquity wrote: There's also a 4th possibility: Some Alternative Role: Didn't do what he was told and got some other role. Since he's claimed otherwise, I view this as most unlikely
More in a jokingly manner, but I'm inclined to say, "Duh?"
It's like saying, when you have a baby, the baby could be a boy, or a girl, and that slim chanceof being both.
You're kinda stating the obvious here.
|
Day 1 Votes
With 18 alive it is 10 to lynch!
Hesmyrr(9) rastaban southRawrea LSB bumatlarge citi.zen JeeJee Fishball Radfield SiNiquity
SouthRawrea(1) Hesmyrr
Radfield(1) ~Opz~
DarthThienAn(1) DarthThienAn
Not voting so far (6) Pandain Divinek BrownBear Subversion chaoser zeks
Day 1 ends @ 10:00PM ET/11:00KST on Thursday August 26th/27th(KST) which is ~3 hours from now.
|
On August 27 2010 07:47 Fishball wrote:Show nested quote +On August 27 2010 07:34 SiNiquity wrote:## Vote HesmyrrThere's 3 possibilities as I see it: - Vanilla: Hesmyrr did exactly what he was told and paid for it with his life
- Traitor: Makes sense from a pre-game perspective. To take a useless role which will probably end up as Vanilla, or go with something a little more.. exciting?
- Mafia/SK: Not entirely impossible - it's a high number with a useless role in our list of assignments (expected to be Vanilla), so unlikely to get checked.
Show nested quote +On August 27 2010 07:36 SiNiquity wrote: There's also a 4th possibility: Some Alternative Role: Didn't do what he was told and got some other role. Since he's claimed otherwise, I view this as most unlikely More in a jokingly manner, but I'm inclined to say, "Duh?" It's like saying, when you have a baby, the baby could be a boy, or a girl, and that slim chanceof being both. You're kinda stating the obvious here.
In similar jest I'm inclined to respond with, "Duh?"
It's like saying, when your friend has a baby, and your friend laments over the gender and lists out the possibilities, and you tell him, "Duh?"
You're kinda stating the obvious here.
|
Wise men speak because they have something to say; fools because they have to say something; trolls just because.
|
|
Ill put the nail in the coffin. I think we've had enough discussion (which is why I unvoted yesterday) but I feel relatively good about the lynch
##vote Hesmyrr
|
Day 1 Votes
With 18 alive it is 10 to lynch!
Hesmyrr(10) rastaban southRawrea LSB bumatlarge citi.zen JeeJee Fishball Radfield SiNiquity zeks
SouthRawrea(1) Hesmyrr
Radfield(1) ~Opz~
DarthThienAn(1) DarthThienAn
Not voting so far (5) Pandain Divinek BrownBear Subversion chaoser
Hesmyrr will be lynched at 10:35PM ET/11:3KST which is ~3 hours from now
|
|
oh we reached majority right before i got home well then my vote doesnt matter where it goes but i dun wanna be mod killed
i wonder how many out of the 6 that didnt vote are scum
##vote hesmyrr
|
|
|
|
|