TL Mafia XXVIII - Page 13

On July 25 2010 10:35 Pandain wrote:






Seriouslly, wtf man. It's been 5 minutes and look at everything you're saying "MUST BE DONE!"
Read, think,evaluate.
Dont rush to conclusions and rash plans.

On July 25 2010 10:38 iNfuNdiBuLuM wrote:


I'm serious; stop being a dick.

If South is blue then Day 3 was perfect for mafia. They have 1-2 people come out and argue for lynching citizen (someone like BC, tree hugger, or me) and a couple others to start the wagon on South (e.g. you, zeks, or lakrismamma). The town just eats up the bullshit since a mafia was never in danger of getting lynched due to citizen fronting for the mad hatter rather than actually being the mad hatter.

Basically the entire duality of Citi/South was thrown because citizen was not the role he said he was, so instead of being at Citi/South/Tricode we're at South/Tricode/Mystery Player.

On July 25 2010 10:42 Pandain wrote:


No. Shut up. I'm sorry, you're going to ruin the game if you keep acting like this. Your theories are not fact. Stop thinking that you can already know what the answer is 5 minutes in.

And the only thing that can come out of reading thinking and evaluating is a reasonable, logical thing. Listen to yourself. "MUST NOT THINK, MUST GO ALONG WITH PLAN NO MATTER WHAT".

I know you think you've won and "saved the day" but you haven't man.

If anything your going to ruin it.

On July 25 2010 10:43 tree.hugger wrote:
You have these abilities in varying qualities, but you don't have the most important trait in mafia, which is patience, and cool headedness.

On July 25 2010 10:49 Pandain wrote:


Wtf that is such a convuluted version of my story. In case I actually misled any of you, I'll say it again.

I find, through means I'm not going to tell, that ??? is DT. Now, ??? tells me he checked young and amber. Both are green. However, up to that point, and still up to THIS point, youngmini had been acting very rash, and rough, possibly anti town. Therefore, we were afraid young was GF.

Then here I am, Funkmaster K, and I'm like "Hey, I'll pretend to be DT to youngmini. If I die this night, young is probably GF and you can bust him. If I don't, we can trust him!"

There. Any more questions?

Also: Being loud doesn't mean your right -.-

On July 25 2010 10:51 BloodyC0bbler wrote:


The issue being, hes claiming you were checked by DT and claiming dt mouth, your claiming hes mafia who fake claimed. IF hes town that would in turn almost guarentee your guilt.

He is new however and his play may have been sloppy, but your not doing much better.

On July 25 2010 10:53 Pandain wrote:


I never said he checked me.
I think this is going to be flame war soon.
<--- Getting bit angry.
I'll try to let other people defend me unless everyone starts believing young.

On July 25 2010 11:03 tree.hugger wrote:
Basically, it works like this:

We lynched citi.zen because in doing so, we would find out which he was, and thus Southrawrea would be the other. Of course, we could've done the same thing by lynching Southrawrea, but due to suspicions I, and many others held, along with the advantage of catching a bigger fish, or using the skill of a superior hatter, we decided that citi.zen was the better target.

However, the fact that citi.zen is NOT the MH candidate, makes our choice a mistake. Whereas lynching Southrawrea would've had the same effect; either validating citi.zen and his friend/Tricode, lynching citi.zen means that we still have a third option on the table; namely that citi.zen was a pawn of the GF. And now we can't ask him about it. Not only that, but if this is the case, then the GF knows both detectives.

Or Southrawrea could be mafia.
Or Tricode and Bc could be mafia.

We should've had two choices, but now we still have three.

So here's what we need to do. If citi.zen's MH was the mafia, then we could probably call gg right now, because we're done. At any rate, our detectives should make sure to confide in someone that they trust, because they'll both die. A suicide bomber is likely in this scenario, and that means Southrawrea would die as well, leaving a total of five town deaths and one mafia death in a night.

But because of how bleak this other outlook is, I think we have no choice but to reject it. We can't win the game that way, and so we shouldn't even consider it, and pretend like citi.zen's death has given us the two-pronged choice that we aimed for.

On July 25 2010 11:08 Pandain wrote:


*facepalm*
Are you serious?

On July 25 2010 11:09 Pandain wrote:


Hahaha didn't mean that. Young, the sooner you stop trying to paint me as mafia and look at logic, the shorter the embarrasement is going to be after the game.

On July 25 2010 11:13 tree.hugger wrote:
I'm going to take some time off from this game. I'm sick of analyzing things only to have people turn out to not have been telling the truth, and then for the town to be worse off because of it.

And I'm sick of Youngminii.

On July 25 2010 23:01 Amber[LighT] wrote:
YM it would actually be a really good idea for you to give out your "DT." I know you think I'm scum, but the numbers don't add up. There's no possible way I could have been checked if three people + citi.zen were checked...

I can't find the post where someone listed everyone who claimed already. Think about it dude... either you are making some outrageous claim against me, or your DT is shady.

On July 26 2010 02:07 Pandain wrote:


Just clearing it up so everyone can hear my story.

I found out about DT, and confronted him. He didn't go up to me. He gave me the information because I already knew he was DT lol. And I didn't have any offer for citizen, don't know where that came from.



Yeah, that's still an incredibally stupid thing to do considering you had no proof I was fake claiming. What If I was the real DT? You could've just revealed me. This is why we can't just reveal anyone to the DT, cause they could do stupid stuff like this. I don't expect people to blindly follow me, I expect them to trust me. Just like how we now trust citizen. The difference being I came right out and said it while citizen delayed until like 5 minutes before night lol.