johnny why didnt u just PM me that PM from L, or post it in the thread at an earlier date. one of the main reasons i voted for you was your only credibility was the "medic protected me last night" and no-one else corroborated but you.

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 00:28 GMT

#2777

heh so i guess foolishness dozko and madness man jumping on the chance to kill you without medic protection.

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 00:29 GMT

#2778

oh good this is salvagable, vote for one of those next, if chezinu could make it clear he is not mafia (if he is not) before the next vote it would really be swell.

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 00:32 GMT

#2779

They jump voted on johnny at the last minute without posting reasons why or trying to persuade others to do so, seems very mafia like to me, especially dozko who has consistently been trying to have me lynched but then randomly changes to chezinu and johnny at the end without posting. Also thinking about it chezinu is most likely innocent given the voting.

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 00:34 GMT

#2781

And scamp (sorry for doing post after post, made initial before seeing incogs post and then kinda had stream of concience moment) I mainly wanted the medic to PM me so i could remove the vote, also depending on who it was//the nature of the PM it might be a way to lure out a mafia pretending to be a medic although that would only have been the case if Johnny had been Sumiyoshi and the mafia tried to make his claim of medic protection seem real.

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 00:39 GMT

#2786

By the way this would be a good spot for the medic to publically role claim, there is only 1 gambino left and the sumiyoshi only have 1 KP (as far as i can tell) so they essentially have one chance to hit the remaining gambino, if the medic role claims then the gambino can reveal himself to the medic who in turn can protect him.

This forces them to either waste their kill on the medic or attempt to confuse the medic by also claming to be gambino however it is right that Foolishness, Madnessman and Dozko are the 3 remaining mafia then they can't really do that.

Either way Medic reveal yourself so that you can protect the remaining gambino!

If you already know the remaining then that would also be pretty swell in which case simply smile happily behind your PC screen.

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 00:41 GMT

#2792

Alternatively we could use a go-between so the medic's identity remains hidden, I.E someone who the medic trusts to be town, this person then reveals that he is the go between and the gambino remaining can PM the go-between who can in turn pass on the protect information to the medic.

This would work better in theory but only if a legitimate "go-between" can be found.

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 00:47 GMT

#2796

So opz is the last gambino? :O

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 01:21 GMT

#2807

I'm the remaining BG btw

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 01:23 GMT

#2809

Chez this game is over, bar a miricle for the sumi, all that needs to happen is for the remaining medic to manage to find out who the remaining gambino is, If he is medic protected they simply cannot kill him without killing the medic first.

Just organise this whoever u are mr healer man and let us town bask in our own lucky brilliance

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 01:25 GMT

#2811

Dozko definately, foolishness looks like it and no not scamp, madnessman

OFC it is possible one or both of foolishness and madnessman are in fact townie which would complicate things slightly.

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 01:27 GMT

#2813

Chez really wished you would have just PM'd me a comprehensive list of your role checks or something else when I asked, you PM'd me yourself saying you didnt think I was mafia and it would have meant i needn't have been on your back all game.

ofc there is a very very small chance you could still be mafia so guess i will hold out in acting like the game is quite over.

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 01:31 GMT

#2816

lol posting that after he made it quite plain he is mafia isn't rlly proof, you are doing it wrong!

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 01:33 GMT

#2819

Why has no-one come forward as either the medic or a mouth for the medic to protect the remaining gambino? im impatient but unless this is already happening behind the scenes then it is of the utmost importance!

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 01:44 GMT

#2823

On March 03 2010 09:39 dozko wrote:
omfg i cant believe that the town's gonna win this.

talking through the plan for a day and then on the last minute 50% go inactive, fucking swell.

No madness dozko being Mafia is quite obvious, only other hypothetical is he wrote what he did just to fuck about and troll whilst actually being town which seems unlikely.

Also without further information, it would be a mistake not to follow up by killing foolishness and madnessman simply on the voting, however there are complications such as Foolishness PMing to protect L(who turned out Gambino), but this seems the most prudent thing to do.

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 02:00 GMT

#2831

On March 03 2010 10:50 madnessman wrote:
So you want to lynch me only based on my last voting?

Yes.

I accept its more than possible you could be a townie but unless something else pops up that highlights a better candidate then your voting is enough in my opinion to vote lynch//advise the mafia to night kill.

If the mafia wishes to use this night kill to pick off foolishness//madnessman and then rely on the town to kill Dozko (which we most certainly will do) then that might work, although mayb its best to just rip off the bandaid now and for the Gambino to kill Dozko.

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 02:02 GMT

#2833

Also

On March 03 2010 10:33 XeliN wrote:
Why has no-one come forward as either the medic or a mouth for the medic to protect the remaining gambino? im impatient but unless this is already happening behind the scenes then it is of the utmost importance!

This really needs to happen.

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 02:06 GMT

#2836

Madnessman I think you are wrong, the town are very likely to win now, we have a confirmed mafia in dozko, reducing the sumiyoshi to 2 members, in fact I think that in itself might be enough for our win conditions if iirc town only need to get rid of 8 of each of the two families to win so actually we have won as it is and all of this chatter is for nothing.

1) Medic protect gambino
2) Gambino lynches dozko
3) Mafia cannot kill Gambino with only 1 KP due to medic protection
4) Town wins, people celebrate, Portraits and statues are erected in Ver's honour, and everyone dances round naked engaging in copiuos yet satisfying sin.

5)We get to see what Chezinu's actual role was, thrilling for all I'm sure.

XeliN

United Kingdom1755 Posts

March 03 2010 02:09 GMT

#2838

Our win relies on the medic protecting the gambino although even if that does not happen unless the sumiyoshi luck out and kill the last Gambino then we still win.