• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 13:29
CET 19:29
KST 03:29
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #2312[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over6Dark completes military service, returns to SC217[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over SC4ALL: II Indiegogo Campaign Announcement No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Team Liquid Map Contest #23 StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon
Tourneys
RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16) Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 552 Secret Storm Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
List of top players active on ShieldBattery SC4ALL: II Indiegogo Campaign Announcement XUN appreciation thread BW General Discussion Potentially helpful Shield Battery feedback.
Tourneys
$3,000 Sijosae Tier 2,3,4 Cup (Nov 23-24 2026) [BSL23] Ro16 Group B - Saturday 21:00 CET 2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread The PlayStation 5 Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
The Games Industry And ATVI US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine Trading/Investing Thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Socialism Anyone?
GreenHorizons
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 13550 users

US Politics Mega-thread - Page 2058

Forum Index > General Forum
Post a Reply
Prev 1 2056 2057 2058 2059 2060 6095 Next
Now that we have a new thread, in order to ensure that this thread continues to meet TL standards and follows the proper guidelines, we will be enforcing the rules in the OP more strictly. Be sure to give them a complete and thorough read before posting!

NOTE: When providing a source, please provide a very brief summary on what it's about and what purpose it adds to the discussion. The supporting statement should clearly explain why the subject is relevant and needs to be discussed. Please follow this rule especially for tweets.

Your supporting statement should always come BEFORE you provide the source.


If you have any questions, comments, concern, or feedback regarding the USPMT, then please use this thread: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/website-feedback/510156-us-politics-thread
ChristianS
Profile Blog Joined March 2011
United States3319 Posts
January 26 2020 17:28 GMT
#41141
Asking allies to pay is one thing. I think I’ve made clear I don’t like antagonizing our allies for minor benefits because I don’t think it’ll ultimately be better for anyone; but if we’re, say, building a base in SK to help deter NK aggression I don’t mind SK covering some of the cost. On the scale of nations the difference between us paying and them paying will be kinda small anyway. Far more offensive to me is the idea that because we’re helping defend someone, they’re obligated to forego competing with us commercially. Did anyone ever agree to that? Or are we just trying to bully people into serving our interests instead of their own?

Japan is kind of a special case, because if I’m not mistaken we forced them to put in their constitution a ban on forming a military. Frankly, given that, I don’t think we have a right to demand a penny from them. What, are we gonna keep raising the rates on threat of leaving them out in the cold, all while they’re powerless to defend themselves?
"Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity." -Robert J. Hanlon
Xxio
Profile Blog Joined July 2009
Canada5565 Posts
January 26 2020 17:37 GMT
#41142
On January 27 2020 02:13 Blitzkrieg0 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 27 2020 02:08 Xxio wrote:
On January 27 2020 01:48 Blitzkrieg0 wrote:
On January 27 2020 01:34 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 16:13 ChristianS wrote:
On January 26 2020 15:00 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 13:59 ChristianS wrote:
On January 26 2020 13:00 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 11:19 FueledUpAndReadyToGo wrote:
On January 26 2020 09:29 ShoCkeyy wrote:
The full video of Trump asking to fire the ambassador to Ukraine has been released. You can watch it at the 43 minute mark.

Currently on the move but I’ll post the video when I get a chance or if some else can post it?



It takes the guy less than a minute to convince Trump to get rid of her, just by saying she's from the Clinton administration and that the ambassador was telling people Trump would be impeached. Trump has a real tone change compared to the rest of the dinner when he says the 'get rid of her, take her out, do it' part. He does sound agitated/serious.

The Ukraine part starts few minutes earlier around 39mins. Trump seems overly surprised to hear Ukraine has oil.

The rest of the vid is kind of interesting if you want to know how a lobbyist dinner with Trump is. Lots of ass kissing and lots of bad takes.

On 8 mins where they shit on South Korea, and Trump shows he has no clue why the US is even there or what the Korea war was about.

11min he talks about the US taking in billions from the tariffs. None of the businessmen affirm him because they know it's bullshit lol

On 16mins Trump says 'WTO is a weapon to hurt the United States. And the European Union the same thing, it's a group of countries that got together to screw the United States, and they are probably worse than China'

33m30s Kanye West will pull the millennials to Trump
He makes a good point about SK. I would trade Trudeau for Trump in an instant.

Care to elaborate what point about SK you like?
I didn't hear anything exceptional. Negotiate trade in favor of U.S.A. Hints that U.S.A. military shouldn't be there. Sadly I don't think he cares about much other than short term GDP and campaign slogans. He's a bad president but the contenders are disastrous imo. Good ones blocked by MSM and the parties.

+ Show Spoiler +
But I don’t care much about Trudeau. I do, however, care some about South Korea, and listening to that recording all I heard was some grumbling about how South Korea is ruining our steel industry (possibly with *gasp* Chinese steel) and how that’s really very ungrateful of them considering how we’re stopping North Korea from nuking them and all.

Personally I don’t understand what’s to like about that, and I’d be interested to hear what part appeals to you. The protectionism, I guess? The indignation that a state benefiting from our world policing would dare to compete with us commercially? I don’t know specifically what the “shipping Chinese steel on trains” business is about, maybe you do?

I don’t get protectionism’s appeal much honestly. The lazy argument I can make is “look at Trump’s trade war, it’s going bad for us and the stock market freaks out about it sometimes.” And I think it probably has been bad for us, but more broadly the whole premise of protectionism is “we’re going to try to set the rules of international trade to give our businesses a systemic advantage over foreign competition.” Why is that fair? If a foreign business is more efficient than ours but we manage to set the rules such that our business has an unfair advantage and runs them out of business, why is that a good outcome? If we so quickly demonstrate to other countries that we have no interest in fair dealings and will pick their pocket at first opportunity, how can we hope to maintain positive relationships with them, or expect them not to backstab us just as quickly?

Our troop presence in SK adds a twist to this. A lot of people are very critical of our wide military footprint and insistence on policing the world - I don’t like it much myself - but of all our international meddling, putting troops in South Korea to discourage North Korean aggression seems like one of the better causes we’ve taken up. North Korea invading South Korea would be a massive humanitarian catastrophe, and our troop presence meaningfully reduces the likelihood of that happening.

But it’s a bit rich for us to make all this fuss about keeping South Korea “free” and then turn around and say they don’t have the right to compete with us economically. Are they free, or aren’t they? I don’t have a bit of interest in hitting up our allies for protection money, as Trump likes to talk about, but demanding they direct their economy to grow ours rather than their own is even worse to me. Is this not extortion?

In game theory terminology, Trump’s foreign policy generally usually boils down to an “Always Forsake” policy. Shout and threaten our enemies unless they serve our interests; extort our allies out of their lunch money and threaten to sanction them or even refuse to protect them unless they pay up. It’s unabashedly immoral; but even in self-interest terms, it’s probably pretty bad policy. “Always Forsake” makes you an asshole, but also usually means nobody wants to cooperate with you so you’re ultimately worse off, too.
I wish US would stop playing world police and force/allow other countries to grow up. I don't have a problem with Trump asking for more money to cover the cost, if SK wants the US to continue as their bodyguard -- besides wishing they weren't there at all. It's reasonable to ask if it's still worth it to be there.
It's reasonable to ask sure, but you shouldn't need to. A stronger Korea and Japan keeps China's power in check. Do you think it is in US interest to maintain status as the global super power? The notion that everything comes down to money and extorting our allies because we can is misguided foreign policy. We didn't install ourselves into Korea and Japan to be their bodyguard. We installed ourselves there to exert power and influence in Asia.
In my opinion help Korea and Japan become strong enough to stand on their own as good allies, along with other nearby nations scared of China enough to do the same. I'd rather not have US or anyone as a global super power but independent nations in alliance. Doubt US will give up influence and leave, and also doubt SK wants them to.


Allowing Korea and Japan to militarize would just create an arms race in Asia (likely the world once you give up the idea of nuclear proliferation. The problem with independent nations in alliance is that they must have similar power levels. Do we want every nation in the world holding nuclear weapons? I'd say absolutely not. I'd rather not have the US or anyone as a global super power either, but I think it is better than the cold war.
Disagree about consequences of allowing them to have proper militaries. I don't think it would be necessary for every nation in the world to hold nuclear weapons. Independent nation alliance system is not achievable tomorrow. I believe we can get there eventually. To me it's a good that should be pursued. Your argument makes sense to me. Maybe you see my view as naively idealistic. That's OK.
KTY
Blitzkrieg0
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
United States13132 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-26 18:35:18
January 26 2020 18:06 GMT
#41143
On January 27 2020 02:37 Xxio wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 27 2020 02:13 Blitzkrieg0 wrote:
On January 27 2020 02:08 Xxio wrote:
On January 27 2020 01:48 Blitzkrieg0 wrote:
On January 27 2020 01:34 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 16:13 ChristianS wrote:
On January 26 2020 15:00 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 13:59 ChristianS wrote:
On January 26 2020 13:00 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 11:19 FueledUpAndReadyToGo wrote:
[quote]
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=789CORXvvRA&t=42m

It takes the guy less than a minute to convince Trump to get rid of her, just by saying she's from the Clinton administration and that the ambassador was telling people Trump would be impeached. Trump has a real tone change compared to the rest of the dinner when he says the 'get rid of her, take her out, do it' part. He does sound agitated/serious.

The Ukraine part starts few minutes earlier around 39mins. Trump seems overly surprised to hear Ukraine has oil.

The rest of the vid is kind of interesting if you want to know how a lobbyist dinner with Trump is. Lots of ass kissing and lots of bad takes.

On 8 mins where they shit on South Korea, and Trump shows he has no clue why the US is even there or what the Korea war was about.

11min he talks about the US taking in billions from the tariffs. None of the businessmen affirm him because they know it's bullshit lol

On 16mins Trump says 'WTO is a weapon to hurt the United States. And the European Union the same thing, it's a group of countries that got together to screw the United States, and they are probably worse than China'

33m30s Kanye West will pull the millennials to Trump
He makes a good point about SK. I would trade Trudeau for Trump in an instant.

Care to elaborate what point about SK you like?
I didn't hear anything exceptional. Negotiate trade in favor of U.S.A. Hints that U.S.A. military shouldn't be there. Sadly I don't think he cares about much other than short term GDP and campaign slogans. He's a bad president but the contenders are disastrous imo. Good ones blocked by MSM and the parties.

+ Show Spoiler +
But I don’t care much about Trudeau. I do, however, care some about South Korea, and listening to that recording all I heard was some grumbling about how South Korea is ruining our steel industry (possibly with *gasp* Chinese steel) and how that’s really very ungrateful of them considering how we’re stopping North Korea from nuking them and all.

Personally I don’t understand what’s to like about that, and I’d be interested to hear what part appeals to you. The protectionism, I guess? The indignation that a state benefiting from our world policing would dare to compete with us commercially? I don’t know specifically what the “shipping Chinese steel on trains” business is about, maybe you do?

I don’t get protectionism’s appeal much honestly. The lazy argument I can make is “look at Trump’s trade war, it’s going bad for us and the stock market freaks out about it sometimes.” And I think it probably has been bad for us, but more broadly the whole premise of protectionism is “we’re going to try to set the rules of international trade to give our businesses a systemic advantage over foreign competition.” Why is that fair? If a foreign business is more efficient than ours but we manage to set the rules such that our business has an unfair advantage and runs them out of business, why is that a good outcome? If we so quickly demonstrate to other countries that we have no interest in fair dealings and will pick their pocket at first opportunity, how can we hope to maintain positive relationships with them, or expect them not to backstab us just as quickly?

Our troop presence in SK adds a twist to this. A lot of people are very critical of our wide military footprint and insistence on policing the world - I don’t like it much myself - but of all our international meddling, putting troops in South Korea to discourage North Korean aggression seems like one of the better causes we’ve taken up. North Korea invading South Korea would be a massive humanitarian catastrophe, and our troop presence meaningfully reduces the likelihood of that happening.

But it’s a bit rich for us to make all this fuss about keeping South Korea “free” and then turn around and say they don’t have the right to compete with us economically. Are they free, or aren’t they? I don’t have a bit of interest in hitting up our allies for protection money, as Trump likes to talk about, but demanding they direct their economy to grow ours rather than their own is even worse to me. Is this not extortion?

In game theory terminology, Trump’s foreign policy generally usually boils down to an “Always Forsake” policy. Shout and threaten our enemies unless they serve our interests; extort our allies out of their lunch money and threaten to sanction them or even refuse to protect them unless they pay up. It’s unabashedly immoral; but even in self-interest terms, it’s probably pretty bad policy. “Always Forsake” makes you an asshole, but also usually means nobody wants to cooperate with you so you’re ultimately worse off, too.
I wish US would stop playing world police and force/allow other countries to grow up. I don't have a problem with Trump asking for more money to cover the cost, if SK wants the US to continue as their bodyguard -- besides wishing they weren't there at all. It's reasonable to ask if it's still worth it to be there.
It's reasonable to ask sure, but you shouldn't need to. A stronger Korea and Japan keeps China's power in check. Do you think it is in US interest to maintain status as the global super power? The notion that everything comes down to money and extorting our allies because we can is misguided foreign policy. We didn't install ourselves into Korea and Japan to be their bodyguard. We installed ourselves there to exert power and influence in Asia.
In my opinion help Korea and Japan become strong enough to stand on their own as good allies, along with other nearby nations scared of China enough to do the same. I'd rather not have US or anyone as a global super power but independent nations in alliance. Doubt US will give up influence and leave, and also doubt SK wants them to.


Allowing Korea and Japan to militarize would just create an arms race in Asia (likely the world once you give up the idea of nuclear proliferation. The problem with independent nations in alliance is that they must have similar power levels. Do we want every nation in the world holding nuclear weapons? I'd say absolutely not. I'd rather not have the US or anyone as a global super power either, but I think it is better than the cold war.
Disagree about consequences of allowing them to have proper militaries. I don't think it would be necessary for every nation in the world to hold nuclear weapons. Independent nation alliance system is not achievable tomorrow. I believe we can get there eventually. To me it's a good that should be pursued. Your argument makes sense to me. Maybe you see my view as naively idealistic. That's OK.


I'll elaborate on why I think your view is naively idealistic. Crimea is the example of a non nuclear power being abandoned by the nuclear powers. Sure we made a gesture of sanctions, but it would not have happened if Ukraine was still a nuclear power. The nuclear weapon states made it clear that sovereignty is only upheld when it is politically expedient for them. The situation in Korea and Japan currently is that US citizens are in the line of fire so there is an easy US obligation to defend them. Especially under an isolationist president like Trump, why would the US get involved if it wasn't directly under attack?

Consider current US foreign policy regarding Iran. Trump made it clear that he didn't retaliate because of no US casualties. Reality is that concussion symptoms don't manifest immediately and there are likely a non zero number of casualties. The US is also in a position where their credibility is completely in the dumpster due to reneging on the Iran treaty. How can Japan or Korea trust that the US will come to their aid when presidents can trash treaties for absolutely no reason?

I would not be opposed to us working towards what you're talking about, but I don't see it as a possibility just looking at recent history. Japan and Korea cannot be a co-equal powers to China without their own nuclear weapons in the current world order.
I'll always be your shadow and veil your eyes from states of ain soph aur.
Grumbels
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Netherlands7032 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-26 20:10:14
January 26 2020 20:07 GMT
#41144
On January 27 2020 02:08 Xxio wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 27 2020 01:48 Blitzkrieg0 wrote:
On January 27 2020 01:34 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 16:13 ChristianS wrote:
On January 26 2020 15:00 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 13:59 ChristianS wrote:
On January 26 2020 13:00 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 11:19 FueledUpAndReadyToGo wrote:
On January 26 2020 09:29 ShoCkeyy wrote:
The full video of Trump asking to fire the ambassador to Ukraine has been released. You can watch it at the 43 minute mark.

Currently on the move but I’ll post the video when I get a chance or if some else can post it?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=789CORXvvRA&t=42m

It takes the guy less than a minute to convince Trump to get rid of her, just by saying she's from the Clinton administration and that the ambassador was telling people Trump would be impeached. Trump has a real tone change compared to the rest of the dinner when he says the 'get rid of her, take her out, do it' part. He does sound agitated/serious.

The Ukraine part starts few minutes earlier around 39mins. Trump seems overly surprised to hear Ukraine has oil.

The rest of the vid is kind of interesting if you want to know how a lobbyist dinner with Trump is. Lots of ass kissing and lots of bad takes.

On 8 mins where they shit on South Korea, and Trump shows he has no clue why the US is even there or what the Korea war was about.

11min he talks about the US taking in billions from the tariffs. None of the businessmen affirm him because they know it's bullshit lol

On 16mins Trump says 'WTO is a weapon to hurt the United States. And the European Union the same thing, it's a group of countries that got together to screw the United States, and they are probably worse than China'

33m30s Kanye West will pull the millennials to Trump
He makes a good point about SK. I would trade Trudeau for Trump in an instant.

Care to elaborate what point about SK you like?
I didn't hear anything exceptional. Negotiate trade in favor of U.S.A. Hints that U.S.A. military shouldn't be there. Sadly I don't think he cares about much other than short term GDP and campaign slogans. He's a bad president but the contenders are disastrous imo. Good ones blocked by MSM and the parties.

+ Show Spoiler +
But I don’t care much about Trudeau. I do, however, care some about South Korea, and listening to that recording all I heard was some grumbling about how South Korea is ruining our steel industry (possibly with *gasp* Chinese steel) and how that’s really very ungrateful of them considering how we’re stopping North Korea from nuking them and all.

Personally I don’t understand what’s to like about that, and I’d be interested to hear what part appeals to you. The protectionism, I guess? The indignation that a state benefiting from our world policing would dare to compete with us commercially? I don’t know specifically what the “shipping Chinese steel on trains” business is about, maybe you do?

I don’t get protectionism’s appeal much honestly. The lazy argument I can make is “look at Trump’s trade war, it’s going bad for us and the stock market freaks out about it sometimes.” And I think it probably has been bad for us, but more broadly the whole premise of protectionism is “we’re going to try to set the rules of international trade to give our businesses a systemic advantage over foreign competition.” Why is that fair? If a foreign business is more efficient than ours but we manage to set the rules such that our business has an unfair advantage and runs them out of business, why is that a good outcome? If we so quickly demonstrate to other countries that we have no interest in fair dealings and will pick their pocket at first opportunity, how can we hope to maintain positive relationships with them, or expect them not to backstab us just as quickly?

Our troop presence in SK adds a twist to this. A lot of people are very critical of our wide military footprint and insistence on policing the world - I don’t like it much myself - but of all our international meddling, putting troops in South Korea to discourage North Korean aggression seems like one of the better causes we’ve taken up. North Korea invading South Korea would be a massive humanitarian catastrophe, and our troop presence meaningfully reduces the likelihood of that happening.

But it’s a bit rich for us to make all this fuss about keeping South Korea “free” and then turn around and say they don’t have the right to compete with us economically. Are they free, or aren’t they? I don’t have a bit of interest in hitting up our allies for protection money, as Trump likes to talk about, but demanding they direct their economy to grow ours rather than their own is even worse to me. Is this not extortion?

In game theory terminology, Trump’s foreign policy generally usually boils down to an “Always Forsake” policy. Shout and threaten our enemies unless they serve our interests; extort our allies out of their lunch money and threaten to sanction them or even refuse to protect them unless they pay up. It’s unabashedly immoral; but even in self-interest terms, it’s probably pretty bad policy. “Always Forsake” makes you an asshole, but also usually means nobody wants to cooperate with you so you’re ultimately worse off, too.
I wish US would stop playing world police and force/allow other countries to grow up. I don't have a problem with Trump asking for more money to cover the cost, if SK wants the US to continue as their bodyguard -- besides wishing they weren't there at all. It's reasonable to ask if it's still worth it to be there.
It's reasonable to ask sure, but you shouldn't need to. A stronger Korea and Japan keeps China's power in check. Do you think it is in US interest to maintain status as the global super power? The notion that everything comes down to money and extorting our allies because we can is misguided foreign policy. We didn't install ourselves into Korea and Japan to be their bodyguard. We installed ourselves there to exert power and influence in Asia.
In my opinion help Korea and Japan become strong enough to stand on their own as good allies, along with other nearby nations scared of China enough to do the same. I'd rather not have US or anyone as a global super power but independent nations in alliance. Doubt US will give up influence and leave, and also doubt SK wants them to.

I'm actually learning Japanese as a hobby, but it made me think that Japanese and Korean culture has always been very strongly tied to China. We had a look in my language class at some typical Japanese cultural traditions such as flower arrangements, tea ceremonies, various Buddhist rituals and schools, and it can all be directly traced from contact with China. Same for language, there are many words of Chinese origin in Japanese, and obviously they use Chinese symbols for writing. So on that level, which is a bit naive obviously, wouldn't it make much more sense for Japan and Korea to be allied with China? The USA wouldn't like it one bit if Mexico was an ally of China and had all sorts of naval bases there and so on. In Europe we wouldn't like it if, idk, Italy was a Russian client state. It would create incredible tension. I haven't been convinced that US presence in that region is not a destabilizing factor and that it is preferable to a more natural Chinese regional hegemony.

Same with Iran honestly. Isn't it more natural for Iran to be the regional power when it comes to the Middle East's shiite population instead of the USA?
Well, now I tell you, I never seen good come o' goodness yet. Him as strikes first is my fancy; dead men don't bite; them's my views--amen, so be it.
Starlightsun
Profile Blog Joined June 2016
United States1405 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-26 20:46:23
January 26 2020 20:45 GMT
#41145
On January 27 2020 05:07 Grumbels wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 27 2020 02:08 Xxio wrote:
On January 27 2020 01:48 Blitzkrieg0 wrote:
On January 27 2020 01:34 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 16:13 ChristianS wrote:
On January 26 2020 15:00 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 13:59 ChristianS wrote:
On January 26 2020 13:00 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 11:19 FueledUpAndReadyToGo wrote:
On January 26 2020 09:29 ShoCkeyy wrote:
The full video of Trump asking to fire the ambassador to Ukraine has been released. You can watch it at the 43 minute mark.

Currently on the move but I’ll post the video when I get a chance or if some else can post it?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=789CORXvvRA&t=42m

It takes the guy less than a minute to convince Trump to get rid of her, just by saying she's from the Clinton administration and that the ambassador was telling people Trump would be impeached. Trump has a real tone change compared to the rest of the dinner when he says the 'get rid of her, take her out, do it' part. He does sound agitated/serious.

The Ukraine part starts few minutes earlier around 39mins. Trump seems overly surprised to hear Ukraine has oil.

The rest of the vid is kind of interesting if you want to know how a lobbyist dinner with Trump is. Lots of ass kissing and lots of bad takes.

On 8 mins where they shit on South Korea, and Trump shows he has no clue why the US is even there or what the Korea war was about.

11min he talks about the US taking in billions from the tariffs. None of the businessmen affirm him because they know it's bullshit lol

On 16mins Trump says 'WTO is a weapon to hurt the United States. And the European Union the same thing, it's a group of countries that got together to screw the United States, and they are probably worse than China'

33m30s Kanye West will pull the millennials to Trump
He makes a good point about SK. I would trade Trudeau for Trump in an instant.

Care to elaborate what point about SK you like?
I didn't hear anything exceptional. Negotiate trade in favor of U.S.A. Hints that U.S.A. military shouldn't be there. Sadly I don't think he cares about much other than short term GDP and campaign slogans. He's a bad president but the contenders are disastrous imo. Good ones blocked by MSM and the parties.

+ Show Spoiler +
But I don’t care much about Trudeau. I do, however, care some about South Korea, and listening to that recording all I heard was some grumbling about how South Korea is ruining our steel industry (possibly with *gasp* Chinese steel) and how that’s really very ungrateful of them considering how we’re stopping North Korea from nuking them and all.

Personally I don’t understand what’s to like about that, and I’d be interested to hear what part appeals to you. The protectionism, I guess? The indignation that a state benefiting from our world policing would dare to compete with us commercially? I don’t know specifically what the “shipping Chinese steel on trains” business is about, maybe you do?

I don’t get protectionism’s appeal much honestly. The lazy argument I can make is “look at Trump’s trade war, it’s going bad for us and the stock market freaks out about it sometimes.” And I think it probably has been bad for us, but more broadly the whole premise of protectionism is “we’re going to try to set the rules of international trade to give our businesses a systemic advantage over foreign competition.” Why is that fair? If a foreign business is more efficient than ours but we manage to set the rules such that our business has an unfair advantage and runs them out of business, why is that a good outcome? If we so quickly demonstrate to other countries that we have no interest in fair dealings and will pick their pocket at first opportunity, how can we hope to maintain positive relationships with them, or expect them not to backstab us just as quickly?

Our troop presence in SK adds a twist to this. A lot of people are very critical of our wide military footprint and insistence on policing the world - I don’t like it much myself - but of all our international meddling, putting troops in South Korea to discourage North Korean aggression seems like one of the better causes we’ve taken up. North Korea invading South Korea would be a massive humanitarian catastrophe, and our troop presence meaningfully reduces the likelihood of that happening.

But it’s a bit rich for us to make all this fuss about keeping South Korea “free” and then turn around and say they don’t have the right to compete with us economically. Are they free, or aren’t they? I don’t have a bit of interest in hitting up our allies for protection money, as Trump likes to talk about, but demanding they direct their economy to grow ours rather than their own is even worse to me. Is this not extortion?

In game theory terminology, Trump’s foreign policy generally usually boils down to an “Always Forsake” policy. Shout and threaten our enemies unless they serve our interests; extort our allies out of their lunch money and threaten to sanction them or even refuse to protect them unless they pay up. It’s unabashedly immoral; but even in self-interest terms, it’s probably pretty bad policy. “Always Forsake” makes you an asshole, but also usually means nobody wants to cooperate with you so you’re ultimately worse off, too.
I wish US would stop playing world police and force/allow other countries to grow up. I don't have a problem with Trump asking for more money to cover the cost, if SK wants the US to continue as their bodyguard -- besides wishing they weren't there at all. It's reasonable to ask if it's still worth it to be there.
It's reasonable to ask sure, but you shouldn't need to. A stronger Korea and Japan keeps China's power in check. Do you think it is in US interest to maintain status as the global super power? The notion that everything comes down to money and extorting our allies because we can is misguided foreign policy. We didn't install ourselves into Korea and Japan to be their bodyguard. We installed ourselves there to exert power and influence in Asia.
In my opinion help Korea and Japan become strong enough to stand on their own as good allies, along with other nearby nations scared of China enough to do the same. I'd rather not have US or anyone as a global super power but independent nations in alliance. Doubt US will give up influence and leave, and also doubt SK wants them to.

I'm actually learning Japanese as a hobby, but it made me think that Japanese and Korean culture has always been very strongly tied to China. We had a look in my language class at some typical Japanese cultural traditions such as flower arrangements, tea ceremonies, various Buddhist rituals and schools, and it can all be directly traced from contact with China. Same for language, there are many words of Chinese origin in Japanese, and obviously they use Chinese symbols for writing. So on that level, which is a bit naive obviously, wouldn't it make much more sense for Japan and Korea to be allied with China? The USA wouldn't like it one bit if Mexico was an ally of China and had all sorts of naval bases there and so on. In Europe we wouldn't like it if, idk, Italy was a Russian client state. It would create incredible tension. I haven't been convinced that US presence in that region is not a destabilizing factor and that it is preferable to a more natural Chinese regional hegemony.

Same with Iran honestly. Isn't it more natural for Iran to be the regional power when it comes to the Middle East's shiite population instead of the USA?


This is how I feel as well. I can't imagine having to tolerate a powerful country having military bases in all of your neighboring countries and a hostile navy always offshore. The US justifies this by claiming to be a good and moral actor but we all know that that story is increasingly untenable. Some say that if the US doesn't dominate the whole world then China or Russia will do it, but I think there's such a thing as balance of power. It just doesn't seem right for the US to take such a threatening posture across the entire globe.
Belisarius
Profile Joined November 2010
Australia6233 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-26 21:41:25
January 26 2020 21:29 GMT
#41146
China's regional hegemony involves the map labels in its region changing to "China". Its neighbours have very good reasons to align against it. Those reasons are the-country-formerly-known-as-tibet, the-country-nobody-is-allowed-to-call-Taiwan, and the-sea-already-called-china-nobody-else-is-allowed-to-fish-in-anymore. There are many issues with the US's foreign policy stance, especially now, but China is aggressively expansionist in a way the US has never been, and its neighbours are very rightly wary of its borders encroaching towards them.

There's also thousands of years of complex history in the region that most westerners are ignorant of. It's tempting to say the nations are all Asian in the way euros are now all European, but the politics are extremely fraught and distrustful. Japan and SK, for example, have 1.3 billion reasons to be strategic parters, and recognise this, but also fucking hate each other due to a legacy of conflict going back well past ww2.
Xxio
Profile Blog Joined July 2009
Canada5565 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-26 22:13:42
January 26 2020 22:11 GMT
#41147
On January 27 2020 05:07 Grumbels wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 27 2020 02:08 Xxio wrote:
On January 27 2020 01:48 Blitzkrieg0 wrote:
On January 27 2020 01:34 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 16:13 ChristianS wrote:
On January 26 2020 15:00 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 13:59 ChristianS wrote:
On January 26 2020 13:00 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 11:19 FueledUpAndReadyToGo wrote:
On January 26 2020 09:29 ShoCkeyy wrote:
The full video of Trump asking to fire the ambassador to Ukraine has been released. You can watch it at the 43 minute mark.

Currently on the move but I’ll post the video when I get a chance or if some else can post it?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=789CORXvvRA&t=42m

It takes the guy less than a minute to convince Trump to get rid of her, just by saying she's from the Clinton administration and that the ambassador was telling people Trump would be impeached. Trump has a real tone change compared to the rest of the dinner when he says the 'get rid of her, take her out, do it' part. He does sound agitated/serious.

The Ukraine part starts few minutes earlier around 39mins. Trump seems overly surprised to hear Ukraine has oil.

The rest of the vid is kind of interesting if you want to know how a lobbyist dinner with Trump is. Lots of ass kissing and lots of bad takes.

On 8 mins where they shit on South Korea, and Trump shows he has no clue why the US is even there or what the Korea war was about.

11min he talks about the US taking in billions from the tariffs. None of the businessmen affirm him because they know it's bullshit lol

On 16mins Trump says 'WTO is a weapon to hurt the United States. And the European Union the same thing, it's a group of countries that got together to screw the United States, and they are probably worse than China'

33m30s Kanye West will pull the millennials to Trump
He makes a good point about SK. I would trade Trudeau for Trump in an instant.

Care to elaborate what point about SK you like?
I didn't hear anything exceptional. Negotiate trade in favor of U.S.A. Hints that U.S.A. military shouldn't be there. Sadly I don't think he cares about much other than short term GDP and campaign slogans. He's a bad president but the contenders are disastrous imo. Good ones blocked by MSM and the parties.

+ Show Spoiler +
But I don’t care much about Trudeau. I do, however, care some about South Korea, and listening to that recording all I heard was some grumbling about how South Korea is ruining our steel industry (possibly with *gasp* Chinese steel) and how that’s really very ungrateful of them considering how we’re stopping North Korea from nuking them and all.

Personally I don’t understand what’s to like about that, and I’d be interested to hear what part appeals to you. The protectionism, I guess? The indignation that a state benefiting from our world policing would dare to compete with us commercially? I don’t know specifically what the “shipping Chinese steel on trains” business is about, maybe you do?

I don’t get protectionism’s appeal much honestly. The lazy argument I can make is “look at Trump’s trade war, it’s going bad for us and the stock market freaks out about it sometimes.” And I think it probably has been bad for us, but more broadly the whole premise of protectionism is “we’re going to try to set the rules of international trade to give our businesses a systemic advantage over foreign competition.” Why is that fair? If a foreign business is more efficient than ours but we manage to set the rules such that our business has an unfair advantage and runs them out of business, why is that a good outcome? If we so quickly demonstrate to other countries that we have no interest in fair dealings and will pick their pocket at first opportunity, how can we hope to maintain positive relationships with them, or expect them not to backstab us just as quickly?

Our troop presence in SK adds a twist to this. A lot of people are very critical of our wide military footprint and insistence on policing the world - I don’t like it much myself - but of all our international meddling, putting troops in South Korea to discourage North Korean aggression seems like one of the better causes we’ve taken up. North Korea invading South Korea would be a massive humanitarian catastrophe, and our troop presence meaningfully reduces the likelihood of that happening.

But it’s a bit rich for us to make all this fuss about keeping South Korea “free” and then turn around and say they don’t have the right to compete with us economically. Are they free, or aren’t they? I don’t have a bit of interest in hitting up our allies for protection money, as Trump likes to talk about, but demanding they direct their economy to grow ours rather than their own is even worse to me. Is this not extortion?

In game theory terminology, Trump’s foreign policy generally usually boils down to an “Always Forsake” policy. Shout and threaten our enemies unless they serve our interests; extort our allies out of their lunch money and threaten to sanction them or even refuse to protect them unless they pay up. It’s unabashedly immoral; but even in self-interest terms, it’s probably pretty bad policy. “Always Forsake” makes you an asshole, but also usually means nobody wants to cooperate with you so you’re ultimately worse off, too.
I wish US would stop playing world police and force/allow other countries to grow up. I don't have a problem with Trump asking for more money to cover the cost, if SK wants the US to continue as their bodyguard -- besides wishing they weren't there at all. It's reasonable to ask if it's still worth it to be there.
It's reasonable to ask sure, but you shouldn't need to. A stronger Korea and Japan keeps China's power in check. Do you think it is in US interest to maintain status as the global super power? The notion that everything comes down to money and extorting our allies because we can is misguided foreign policy. We didn't install ourselves into Korea and Japan to be their bodyguard. We installed ourselves there to exert power and influence in Asia.
In my opinion help Korea and Japan become strong enough to stand on their own as good allies, along with other nearby nations scared of China enough to do the same. I'd rather not have US or anyone as a global super power but independent nations in alliance. Doubt US will give up influence and leave, and also doubt SK wants them to.

I'm actually learning Japanese as a hobby, but it made me think that Japanese and Korean culture has always been very strongly tied to China. We had a look in my language class at some typical Japanese cultural traditions such as flower arrangements, tea ceremonies, various Buddhist rituals and schools, and it can all be directly traced from contact with China. Same for language, there are many words of Chinese origin in Japanese, and obviously they use Chinese symbols for writing. So on that level, which is a bit naive obviously, wouldn't it make much more sense for Japan and Korea to be allied with China? The USA wouldn't like it one bit if Mexico was an ally of China and had all sorts of naval bases there and so on. In Europe we wouldn't like it if, idk, Italy was a Russian client state. It would create incredible tension. I haven't been convinced that US presence in that region is not a destabilizing factor and that it is preferable to a more natural Chinese regional hegemony.

Same with Iran honestly. Isn't it more natural for Iran to be the regional power when it comes to the Middle East's shiite population instead of the USA?
I agree but doubt Japan, Korea and others trust China enough (at all?) to make that kind of alliance. Middle East is a much worse situation in my mind because of the artificial states created from the Ottoman Empire. Paper on artificial states I found insightful.
KTY
FueledUpAndReadyToGo
Profile Blog Joined March 2013
Netherlands30548 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-27 03:44:06
January 27 2020 03:43 GMT
#41148
A draft of Boltons book was seen by NYT and in it he confirms the link between withholding of Ukraine aid and them having to start investigations in Trumps political opponents. What kind of person doesn't want to tell this to congress or public but sell it in a book instead. A book that would come out after the trial too.

Though I guess we already knew Bolton was a shitty person before this.

I wonder if it will change anything on Republican senator side though, while it is a first hand confirmation, it's not like there was much doubt of what happened before this either, the no first hand/ hearsay thing was already just an excuse at this point.

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/26/us/politics/trump-bolton-book-ukraine.html
Neosteel Enthusiast
Yurie
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
12201 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-27 05:44:00
January 27 2020 05:42 GMT
#41149
On January 27 2020 06:29 Belisarius wrote:
China's regional hegemony involves the map labels in its region changing to "China". Its neighbours have very good reasons to align against it. Those reasons are the-country-formerly-known-as-tibet, the-country-nobody-is-allowed-to-call-Taiwan, and the-sea-already-called-china-nobody-else-is-allowed-to-fish-in-anymore. There are many issues with the US's foreign policy stance, especially now, but China is aggressively expansionist in a way the US has never been, and its neighbours are very rightly wary of its borders encroaching towards them.

There's also thousands of years of complex history in the region that most westerners are ignorant of. It's tempting to say the nations are all Asian in the way euros are now all European, but the politics are extremely fraught and distrustful. Japan and SK, for example, have 1.3 billion reasons to be strategic parters, and recognise this, but also fucking hate each other due to a legacy of conflict going back well past ww2.


The Mexican-American war? Pretty much anything west of the halfway line of the US on the north American continent, excluding Alaska. Prior to that it was other countries occupying land for you.
GreenHorizons
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States24527 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-27 05:48:38
January 27 2020 05:47 GMT
#41150
On January 27 2020 14:42 Yurie wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 27 2020 06:29 Belisarius wrote:
China's regional hegemony involves the map labels in its region changing to "China". Its neighbours have very good reasons to align against it. Those reasons are the-country-formerly-known-as-tibet, the-country-nobody-is-allowed-to-call-Taiwan, and the-sea-already-called-china-nobody-else-is-allowed-to-fish-in-anymore. There are many issues with the US's foreign policy stance, especially now, but China is aggressively expansionist in a way the US has never been, and its neighbours are very rightly wary of its borders encroaching towards them.

There's also thousands of years of complex history in the region that most westerners are ignorant of. It's tempting to say the nations are all Asian in the way euros are now all European, but the politics are extremely fraught and distrustful. Japan and SK, for example, have 1.3 billion reasons to be strategic parters, and recognise this, but also fucking hate each other due to a legacy of conflict going back well past ww2.


The Mexican-American war? Pretty much anything west of the halfway line of the US on the north American continent, excluding Alaska. Prior to that it was other countries occupying land for you.


The way I understand expansionism, it is not strictly a reference to territory anyway, so I find the claim specious at best. The second half of the 20th century was US expansionism on a level that is unlikely to ever be matched in the future.
"People like to look at history and think 'If that was me back then, I would have...' We're living through history, and the truth is, whatever you are doing now is probably what you would have done then" "Scratch a Liberal..."
Belisarius
Profile Joined November 2010
Australia6233 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-27 11:22:56
January 27 2020 09:29 GMT
#41151
On January 27 2020 14:42 Yurie wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 27 2020 06:29 Belisarius wrote:
China's regional hegemony involves the map labels in its region changing to "China". Its neighbours have very good reasons to align against it. Those reasons are the-country-formerly-known-as-tibet, the-country-nobody-is-allowed-to-call-Taiwan, and the-sea-already-called-china-nobody-else-is-allowed-to-fish-in-anymore. There are many issues with the US's foreign policy stance, especially now, but China is aggressively expansionist in a way the US has never been, and its neighbours are very rightly wary of its borders encroaching towards them.

There's also thousands of years of complex history in the region that most westerners are ignorant of. It's tempting to say the nations are all Asian in the way euros are now all European, but the politics are extremely fraught and distrustful. Japan and SK, for example, have 1.3 billion reasons to be strategic parters, and recognise this, but also fucking hate each other due to a legacy of conflict going back well past ww2.


The Mexican-American war? Pretty much anything west of the halfway line of the US on the north American continent, excluding Alaska. Prior to that it was other countries occupying land for you.

Sure, but if you think a conflict from a century and a half ago has the same bearing on the region as the military bases China built in its neighbours' EEZs in the last couple of years, I don't know what to tell you.

The shift in US foreign policy under Trump does factor in, of course. There's a rapidly crystallising timeline in which a neofascist US faces off against a hyper-authoritarian China for what's left of a planet in ecological collapse. If that eventuates, Japan, SK and, indeed, Australia, will have to do whatever we can to survive.

In the meantime, however, for SK and Japan to turn to China would require them to take a good look at the last year in Xinjiang and Hong Kong, and decide those are outcomes they can tolerate in the long run.
iamthedave
Profile Joined February 2011
England2814 Posts
January 27 2020 13:49 GMT
#41152
On January 27 2020 05:07 Grumbels wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 27 2020 02:08 Xxio wrote:
On January 27 2020 01:48 Blitzkrieg0 wrote:
On January 27 2020 01:34 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 16:13 ChristianS wrote:
On January 26 2020 15:00 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 13:59 ChristianS wrote:
On January 26 2020 13:00 Xxio wrote:
On January 26 2020 11:19 FueledUpAndReadyToGo wrote:
On January 26 2020 09:29 ShoCkeyy wrote:
The full video of Trump asking to fire the ambassador to Ukraine has been released. You can watch it at the 43 minute mark.

Currently on the move but I’ll post the video when I get a chance or if some else can post it?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=789CORXvvRA&t=42m

It takes the guy less than a minute to convince Trump to get rid of her, just by saying she's from the Clinton administration and that the ambassador was telling people Trump would be impeached. Trump has a real tone change compared to the rest of the dinner when he says the 'get rid of her, take her out, do it' part. He does sound agitated/serious.

The Ukraine part starts few minutes earlier around 39mins. Trump seems overly surprised to hear Ukraine has oil.

The rest of the vid is kind of interesting if you want to know how a lobbyist dinner with Trump is. Lots of ass kissing and lots of bad takes.

On 8 mins where they shit on South Korea, and Trump shows he has no clue why the US is even there or what the Korea war was about.

11min he talks about the US taking in billions from the tariffs. None of the businessmen affirm him because they know it's bullshit lol

On 16mins Trump says 'WTO is a weapon to hurt the United States. And the European Union the same thing, it's a group of countries that got together to screw the United States, and they are probably worse than China'

33m30s Kanye West will pull the millennials to Trump
He makes a good point about SK. I would trade Trudeau for Trump in an instant.

Care to elaborate what point about SK you like?
I didn't hear anything exceptional. Negotiate trade in favor of U.S.A. Hints that U.S.A. military shouldn't be there. Sadly I don't think he cares about much other than short term GDP and campaign slogans. He's a bad president but the contenders are disastrous imo. Good ones blocked by MSM and the parties.

+ Show Spoiler +
But I don’t care much about Trudeau. I do, however, care some about South Korea, and listening to that recording all I heard was some grumbling about how South Korea is ruining our steel industry (possibly with *gasp* Chinese steel) and how that’s really very ungrateful of them considering how we’re stopping North Korea from nuking them and all.

Personally I don’t understand what’s to like about that, and I’d be interested to hear what part appeals to you. The protectionism, I guess? The indignation that a state benefiting from our world policing would dare to compete with us commercially? I don’t know specifically what the “shipping Chinese steel on trains” business is about, maybe you do?

I don’t get protectionism’s appeal much honestly. The lazy argument I can make is “look at Trump’s trade war, it’s going bad for us and the stock market freaks out about it sometimes.” And I think it probably has been bad for us, but more broadly the whole premise of protectionism is “we’re going to try to set the rules of international trade to give our businesses a systemic advantage over foreign competition.” Why is that fair? If a foreign business is more efficient than ours but we manage to set the rules such that our business has an unfair advantage and runs them out of business, why is that a good outcome? If we so quickly demonstrate to other countries that we have no interest in fair dealings and will pick their pocket at first opportunity, how can we hope to maintain positive relationships with them, or expect them not to backstab us just as quickly?

Our troop presence in SK adds a twist to this. A lot of people are very critical of our wide military footprint and insistence on policing the world - I don’t like it much myself - but of all our international meddling, putting troops in South Korea to discourage North Korean aggression seems like one of the better causes we’ve taken up. North Korea invading South Korea would be a massive humanitarian catastrophe, and our troop presence meaningfully reduces the likelihood of that happening.

But it’s a bit rich for us to make all this fuss about keeping South Korea “free” and then turn around and say they don’t have the right to compete with us economically. Are they free, or aren’t they? I don’t have a bit of interest in hitting up our allies for protection money, as Trump likes to talk about, but demanding they direct their economy to grow ours rather than their own is even worse to me. Is this not extortion?

In game theory terminology, Trump’s foreign policy generally usually boils down to an “Always Forsake” policy. Shout and threaten our enemies unless they serve our interests; extort our allies out of their lunch money and threaten to sanction them or even refuse to protect them unless they pay up. It’s unabashedly immoral; but even in self-interest terms, it’s probably pretty bad policy. “Always Forsake” makes you an asshole, but also usually means nobody wants to cooperate with you so you’re ultimately worse off, too.
I wish US would stop playing world police and force/allow other countries to grow up. I don't have a problem with Trump asking for more money to cover the cost, if SK wants the US to continue as their bodyguard -- besides wishing they weren't there at all. It's reasonable to ask if it's still worth it to be there.
It's reasonable to ask sure, but you shouldn't need to. A stronger Korea and Japan keeps China's power in check. Do you think it is in US interest to maintain status as the global super power? The notion that everything comes down to money and extorting our allies because we can is misguided foreign policy. We didn't install ourselves into Korea and Japan to be their bodyguard. We installed ourselves there to exert power and influence in Asia.
In my opinion help Korea and Japan become strong enough to stand on their own as good allies, along with other nearby nations scared of China enough to do the same. I'd rather not have US or anyone as a global super power but independent nations in alliance. Doubt US will give up influence and leave, and also doubt SK wants them to.

I'm actually learning Japanese as a hobby, but it made me think that Japanese and Korean culture has always been very strongly tied to China. We had a look in my language class at some typical Japanese cultural traditions such as flower arrangements, tea ceremonies, various Buddhist rituals and schools, and it can all be directly traced from contact with China. Same for language, there are many words of Chinese origin in Japanese, and obviously they use Chinese symbols for writing. So on that level, which is a bit naive obviously, wouldn't it make much more sense for Japan and Korea to be allied with China? The USA wouldn't like it one bit if Mexico was an ally of China and had all sorts of naval bases there and so on. In Europe we wouldn't like it if, idk, Italy was a Russian client state. It would create incredible tension. I haven't been convinced that US presence in that region is not a destabilizing factor and that it is preferable to a more natural Chinese regional hegemony.

Same with Iran honestly. Isn't it more natural for Iran to be the regional power when it comes to the Middle East's shiite population instead of the USA?


Learning the language isn't knowing the history or the culture.

Back in the formative years of both nations China was the cultural and political superpower. It's not unfair to compare it to the British Empire, but even more locally influential. Japan was a client state giving tribute to China for a long period. But like a lot of island-states, both grew out of it and eventually asserted their independence and individual cultures.

China is - and has always been - strongly about one-culture. You can totally see echoes of that in Japan and Korea, but their visions of that one-culture are divergent. China would never be willing to see either of them as equal partners and they would never deign to be seen as less than that. It's fine to accept the US as a more powerful ally because the US is outside of the cultural history, but Japan's got a solid history of kicking China's face in and inflicting war crimes on them.

Likewise, Japan attacked and brutalised Korea. The Koreans don't trust the Japanese or Chinese, and the Japanese don't trust the Chinese and see the Koreans as inferior. There's really zero chance of those three nations ever really allying with each other. A united Korea would be as stridently independent of larger Asia as South Korea tries to be now.

So yes, you would end up with an arms race in Asia if you left them to their own devices. The Japanese/Chinese are going to expect an invasion from the other, and Korea will be expecting an aggressive knock from one or both at some point, because that's what's happened throughout their history.
I'm not bad at Starcraft; I just think winning's rude.
WombaT
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Northern Ireland27497 Posts
January 27 2020 15:41 GMT
#41153
On January 27 2020 14:47 GreenHorizons wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 27 2020 14:42 Yurie wrote:
On January 27 2020 06:29 Belisarius wrote:
China's regional hegemony involves the map labels in its region changing to "China". Its neighbours have very good reasons to align against it. Those reasons are the-country-formerly-known-as-tibet, the-country-nobody-is-allowed-to-call-Taiwan, and the-sea-already-called-china-nobody-else-is-allowed-to-fish-in-anymore. There are many issues with the US's foreign policy stance, especially now, but China is aggressively expansionist in a way the US has never been, and its neighbours are very rightly wary of its borders encroaching towards them.

There's also thousands of years of complex history in the region that most westerners are ignorant of. It's tempting to say the nations are all Asian in the way euros are now all European, but the politics are extremely fraught and distrustful. Japan and SK, for example, have 1.3 billion reasons to be strategic parters, and recognise this, but also fucking hate each other due to a legacy of conflict going back well past ww2.


The Mexican-American war? Pretty much anything west of the halfway line of the US on the north American continent, excluding Alaska. Prior to that it was other countries occupying land for you.


The way I understand expansionism, it is not strictly a reference to territory anyway, so I find the claim specious at best. The second half of the 20th century was US expansionism on a level that is unlikely to ever be matched in the future.

Hard to really think of similarly effective expansion basically ever. But as much as the US did wield hard power here and there, they were spreading a certain system and ideas and letting those play out.

Basically succeeding in establishing a global order in which most nations have bought into capitalism is pretty damn advantageous, and I guess is the more sophisticated way to do empire, no doubt influenced by the pitfalls others fell into.

China is a bit more old-school in sabre rattling over territories and talking about the honour of the country, more reminiscent of classic imperialism like us Brits used to partake in.

China does have a huge amount of economic leverage going for it, one thing I can’t see is the ground being fertile for China exporting Chinese culture and values like America did in the 20th century, especially in the post-WW2 period.

I don’t know how one puts a number on all that cultural output but American culture was a big part in them advertising the American way as aspirational and getting a lot of buy in.
'You'll always be the cuddly marsupial of my heart, despite the inherent flaws of your ancestry' - Squat
TL+ Member
farvacola
Profile Blog Joined January 2011
United States18877 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-27 18:28:40
January 27 2020 18:28 GMT
#41154
It’s looking more and more like we’re gonna get witnesses in the Senate, the impeachment trial might be getting extra spicy soon.
"when the Dead Kennedys found out they had skinhead fans, they literally wrote a song titled 'Nazi Punks Fuck Off'"
brian
Profile Blog Joined August 2004
United States9644 Posts
January 27 2020 18:59 GMT
#41155
did anyone have any money on John Bolton being the person to make the senate trial actually substantive? no? nobody? what a timeline.
GreenHorizons
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States24527 Posts
January 27 2020 19:01 GMT
#41156
On January 28 2020 03:28 farvacola wrote:
It’s looking more and more like we’re gonna get witnesses in the Senate, the impeachment trial might be getting extra spicy soon.


What makes you think that?
"People like to look at history and think 'If that was me back then, I would have...' We're living through history, and the truth is, whatever you are doing now is probably what you would have done then" "Scratch a Liberal..."
mahrgell
Profile Blog Joined December 2009
Germany3943 Posts
January 27 2020 19:03 GMT
#41157
On January 28 2020 03:59 brian wrote:
did anyone have any money on John Bolton being the person to make the senate trial actually substantive? no? nobody? what a timeline.

The enemy in your bed is always the most powerful. Especially once enraged because you pushed him or her out of the bed.

And the obvious "defense" strategy by Mr Infantile Ego will be to declare him to be the worst at his job ever(which might not even be a lie), which obviously speaks highly for the guy who hired him...
plated.rawr
Profile Blog Joined June 2008
Norway1676 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-27 19:16:30
January 27 2020 19:12 GMT
#41158
There is absolutely nothing to gain for the Republicans to allow witnesses. They're already at banana-republic level political partiality. I mean, if they allow witnesses yet still lock-step vote against going through with the impeachment, they'll only further underline their complete disrepect for the split of political power in the country. They might as well just remove the elector system and judiciary branch, and rename the US an absolute monarchy, with the Republican senators as the new nobility.

If they do allow witnesses, I'd assume it'd only be to rub it in peoples' noses how powerless the rules governing the elected officials are. Kinda a "Hey look, here's all kinds of stuff the rules tell us not to do, and there ain't shit you can do to prevent us from doing it"-move.
Savior broke my heart ;_; || twitch.tv/onnings
Mohdoo
Profile Joined August 2007
United States15743 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-27 19:27:10
January 27 2020 19:25 GMT
#41159
I agree we are now closer to Bolton testifying than we previously were. When the excuse for not pulling in Bolton is "nothing bad happened and Bolton would confirm that, so lets stop this circus", then Bolton says "something bad definitely happened" in a book, it certainly hurts their ability to play dumb. If Bolton read his book under oath, it would be considered air tight evidence. They can't just ignore that. But maybe they will!
CorsairHero
Profile Joined December 2008
Canada9491 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-27 19:29:57
January 27 2020 19:29 GMT
#41160
On January 28 2020 04:01 GreenHorizons wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 28 2020 03:28 farvacola wrote:
It’s looking more and more like we’re gonna get witnesses in the Senate, the impeachment trial might be getting extra spicy soon.


What makes you think that?

new comments from the typical R senators
© Current year.
Prev 1 2056 2057 2058 2059 2060 6095 Next
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
IPSL
02:00
Ro16 Group A
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
Airneanach87
Liquipedia
RSL Revival
22:00
Offline Finals: Playoffs
Clem vs RogueLIVE!
Serral vs herO
Tasteless1977
ComeBackTV 1709
RotterdaM974
IntoTheiNu 752
TaKeTV 524
IndyStarCraft 424
LamboSC2201
kabyraGe 192
Rex87
3DClanTV 50
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
Tasteless 1977
RotterdaM 974
IndyStarCraft 424
LamboSC2 201
ProTech133
Liquid`TLO 87
Rex 87
BRAT_OK 41
SHIN 31
StarCraft: Brood War
Britney 31538
actioN 299
Dewaltoss 108
sSak 30
Hm[arnc] 27
Noble 11
Dota 2
Gorgc8650
XaKoH 382
League of Legends
KnowMe518
Counter-Strike
pashabiceps1140
Heroes of the Storm
Khaldor437
Other Games
singsing4385
Grubby2521
FrodaN1105
Beastyqt536
B2W.Neo402
Mew2King91
Railgan10
febbydoto1
Organizations
Other Games
EGCTV852
gamesdonequick775
[ Show 15 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• Adnapsc2 9
• Reevou 4
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• Pr0nogo 3
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• WagamamaTV625
League of Legends
• Nemesis3033
Other Games
• imaqtpie534
• Shiphtur356
Upcoming Events
BSL
1h 31m
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
4h 31m
Tournament
13h 31m
WardiTV Weekly
17h 31m
Ultimate Battle
17h 31m
Bisu vs Light
Kung Fu Cup
1d 16h
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
2 days
The PondCast
3 days
KCM Race Survival
3 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-17
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
RSL Offline Finals
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3

Upcoming

CSL Season 23: Qualifier 1
Sector 591
Sijosae Cup
CSL Season 23: Qualifier 2
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
CSL 2026 Winter (S23) - 3v3
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.