User was warned for this post
California Raids Rawesome Food - Page 10
Forum Index > General Forum |
NikonTC
United Kingdom418 Posts
User was warned for this post | ||
jmack
Canada285 Posts
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food,_Inc. | ||
Nagano
United States1157 Posts
On August 06 2011 23:42 Papulatus wrote: This is a joke, right? Yes, Just follow the fucking rules! What a brilliant idea! Don't question faulty laws! Don't question potential problems in our society! Just follow the fucking rules! Buy into every rule that is put in place and we'll all be happy, living under a government that controls every fucking aspect of our lives. This country was based on individual freedom. If I want to buy unpasteurized milk, then for fucks sake let me buy unpasteurized milk. No doubt there should be a warning that it is potentially harmful. The issue with buying unpasteurized milk is that I'm not buying from corporate farmers. God forbid we farm our own food, and sell food that we farm. We should have to buy into huge farms. Make organic farmers just through every fucking loop so that eventually, we don't have any organic, local farms. I find it disgusting that I am allowed to buy cigarettes, but not local organic products that don't have corporate ties. When it comes down to it, cigarette company's are huge corporations that have pull in the government. Organic farms are small companies with weak ties to the government. Both are potentially harmful yet one is able to legally operate its business. Sadly, most people aren't fully educated on our nation's origins and thus don't fully respect the principles upon which it was founded. It's threads like these that make me firmly believe the viewership of TL comprises of mostly teenagers, because I can model their thought processes based on their posts and compare it to when I was that age. | ||
xarthaz
1704 Posts
| ||
Parnage
United States7414 Posts
However the moment it could hurt others yes regulation is needed and needs to be enforced, it's a matter of public safety at that point. In short saying "freedom" doesn't give you the freedom to hurt others around you. I find it mind boggling that no one has brought this up by this point. | ||
Zzoram
Canada7115 Posts
Framing the argument as a war against organic food is completely propaganda. The raid was about selling and distributing raw milk. You can legally buy organic pasteurized milk, just not raw milk. Raw milk can contain E.coli, Salmonella, Tuberculosis, among other things. Those are deadly bacteria that can be spread between people by something as simple as not washing their hands properly after their diarrhea, and then shaking hands, preparing food for others, or touching something that someone else will touch within a short period of time. Even if you don't die after drinking raw milk, if you visit a retirement home to see grandma and you still have some bacteria on your hands from wiping your ass, you could spread it all over the facility and cause and outbreak that kills tons of old people. Same thing could happen if you visit McDonald's after your diarrhea, and transfer some bacteria to the door. The people who touch the door afterwards can pick up the bacteria, and people often eat without washing their hands at restaurants, so it's a common way to get infected. This type of thing happens all the time and is incredibly difficult to trace and stop. It's far safer for the public to limit contact with those deadly bacteria whenever possible because of how quickly they can be spread. These things can kill middle-aged healthy people sometimes too, not just old people or young children. Even if they don't kill you, they can cause long lasting health complications, and the hospitalization uses up a bed and resources that could go towards other sick people. Prevention is easier and cheaper than dealing with an outbreak. | ||
Traeon
Austria366 Posts
On August 07 2011 03:54 jmack wrote: I find it insane how hard they'll regulate homegrown "illegal" food operations under the guise that they're not safe or "approved" by the FDA; when in reality the FDA barely even regulates the food that makes into grocery stores. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food,_Inc. Not to mention that the FDA also approves drugs as safe which end up killing hundred thousand people in the US every year. It's quite a dichotomy. PS: in the EU we have lots of cheeses made of raw milk. You can find them in any decent supermarket and we're not dying left and right from tuberculosis ![]() | ||
Necrophantasia
Japan299 Posts
[ That doesn't mean the government should ban you from eating the food, just informing you that it may be dangerous and shutting down any false advertizing. You people make no sense. The food is inherently dangerous with an extremely high risk for contamination, AND it has demonstrated time and time again that it will poison people and/or kill them whenever people are exposed. Yet you argue the government should allow it on the market? You say no ban, just make sure everyone is informed about the risks? Ahem, do you expect everyone to read the fine print on every food item about what "may" be dangerous? Then do you expect them to go see ok, this food has an X% probability of killing me, but I will gamble on it any way? and then repeat this for every food item? How about we just ban dangerous foods and try our best to make sure that everything we can get our hands on is safe? Rather than put dangerous things on the shelves and risk having people die. Also, according to the article, this isn't even about organic or raw milk being illegal (it's not in manufactured dairy products), this is about people running blatant holes around the laws governing milk, and after showing no intention to comply, they were shut down as they should be. On August 07 2011 04:10 Traeon wrote: Not to mention that the FDA also approves drugs as safe which end up killing hundred thousand people in the US every year. Drugs that kill hundreds of thousands of people in the US every year, what? Name me a drug that has FDA approval that has directly killed 100,000 people. | ||
Zzoram
Canada7115 Posts
On August 07 2011 04:10 Traeon wrote: Not to mention that the FDA also approves drugs as safe which end up killing hundred thousand people in the US every year. It's quite a dichotomy. PS: in the EU we have lots of cheeses made of raw milk. You can find them in any decent supermarket and we're not dying left and right from tuberculosis ![]() Cheese made of raw milk is completely different from raw milk. It is legal, because if you age it for at least 60 days, the pathogenic bacteria get crowded out by safe bacteria and die off, making it safe. Raw milk cheese was declared safe because of scientific studies showing that proper aging makes them safe. However, drinking raw milk provides no safety mechanism to kill pathogenic bacteria, which is why it's not safe. | ||
Nagano
United States1157 Posts
On August 07 2011 01:04 Voros wrote: Most posters are missing the point, namely that this is an imposition on private citizens by government agents who are acting in no one's best interests but their own. Whether you believe raw or organic foods to be superior in terms of ethics or quality to their mainstream counterparts is irrelevant--this is about choice, not hippie beliefs vs. those of the commodities industry. This is what my nation has come to: private citizens are no longer permitted to purchase the food or drink they desire without first receiving permission from government regulators and bureaucrats. In fact, in some states (including my home state), you would be guilty of a felony if you were to milk a cow and gift that raw, unpasteurized milk to your neighbor or relative for human consumption. And yes, anyone raised on a farm can attest to the fact that there is a noticeable and undeniable difference in quality between raw milk and pasteurized milk. The same is also true for cheese, butter, and eggs. I'd want to point out that the argument for the OP is also a proxy for other invasive laws in the country. I just recently bought a Harley from Florida and had it shipped to California. Guess what, can't drive it here because it doesn't have a CA-only emissions canister. Can't I just buy one and put it on? DMV doesn't allow it even though it would pass the emissions test. Called up the dealer and they said it's because CA is broke and wants money from the dealers and registrants. Had to sell the bike out of state only and buy a new one from a CA dealer. Example 2: The staircase to my house had to be inspected because of a corner in the ceiling was about 2 inches too short. Guess what, $8000 to get it to comply. Can't walk my dog in any of the public parks in my neighborhood. Decade after decade, laws are piled on, bogging the country down under dense regulation. I can't wait to see what kind of a country the U.S. will be in 50 years. | ||
phosphorylation
United States2935 Posts
On August 07 2011 02:59 Playguuu wrote: There was me that is Alex, and my three droogs, that is Pete, Georgie Boy and Dim. And we sat in the Rawsome Milk Bar trying to make up our rassoodocks what to do with the evening. The Rawsome Milk Bar sold milk plus - milk plus vellocet or synthemesc or drencrom which is what we were drinking. This would sharpen you up and make you ready for a bit of the old Ultra-Violence. lol this makes the whole thread worth it | ||
NET
United States703 Posts
To begin with, it is not an attack on organic food, its an attack on illegal vendors selling potentially hazardous foods. Without oversight of that illegal vendor, how do consumers know if the proper measurements were taken to properly transport the product. How do we know if the milk and cheese being stored in their refrigerators is the correct temperature so that bacterial growth is at least not exponential. Also I don't understand the fad of drinking raw milk. People assume its healthier, but scientific evidence proves otherwise. Think about it for a second. Milk is taken from a cow by a farmer for example. How do we know if his hands are clean or if they are full of either cow feces or feces of his own. That contamination spreads, from that one instance, to the entire container holding all of the milk, therefore contaminating the entire product. Raw milk will sell the product as is. (As stated before I think people are confused about the difference between organic and raw milk, its completely understandable because how many people really know and study this topic anyways?) Pasteurization, and even better, ultra pasteurization helps kill many of the bacteria and other mircboes that are proven to be harmful to your health using heat (The only downside to using this method is that some people think it taste different(ergo worse), but that's just a matter of preference, you like to play zerg over terran because you like their style better, etc) . Lets talk Listeria monocytogenes. Here is an excerpt, but hopefully you will read the entire page: "It is one of the most virulent foodborne pathogens, with 20 to 30 percent of clinical infections resulting in death.[1] Responsible for approximately 2,500 illnesses and 500 deaths in the United States (U.S.) annually, listeriosis is the leading cause of death among foodborne bacterial pathogens, with fatality rates exceeding even Salmonella and Clostridium botulinum.[2]" Milk and milk products are some of the most common sources of listeria. I think because there is so much regulation in the food industry and that not as many outbreaks occur due to the this fact, people over time forget how dangerous raw milk truly is. In truth though, there is not enough people to check every batch of milk or every carton of eggs even in the regulated industry, so we do see cases appear every so often, which is when we hear about huge recalls on food. You have to remember that the regulations in place are not there for your average healthy adult, but rather for you susceptible young children, your elderly, and your immunocompromised. Hopefully I helped clear a few things up, and not just add more confusing to this already controversial topic. | ||
Eppa!
Sweden4641 Posts
On August 06 2011 15:19 Zzoram wrote: You can make cheese from unpasteurized milk as long as you store it at the right temperature and hold it for 60+ days to age. That's not dangerous. Milk is a different story, raw milk is considered a safety hazard because of all the deaths it has caused. It still kills people every couple of years, and makes thousands of others sick. Eating unpasteurized cheese is considered a risk. Unpasteurized milk is not really dangerous if you keep it correctly (and throw it a way after 2-3 days. And do not give it to people with type 1 diabetes or children.) Also most cheeses in EU are from pasteurized milk. This includes most goat and moldy cheeses as well. On August 07 2011 03:58 Nagano wrote: Sadly, most people aren't fully educated on our nation's origins and thus don't fully respect the principles upon which it was founded. It's threads like these that make me firmly believe the viewership of TL comprises of mostly teenagers, because I can model their thought processes based on their posts and compare it to when I was that age. It is not like these laws are baseless. Reminds of the melamine scandal in china were it was found in milk hundreds of children got sick. People were pissed of yet now people think it is ok to sell potentially lethal milk in the black market is a right? | ||
oldmansay
5 Posts
On August 07 2011 03:58 Nagano wrote: Sadly, most people aren't fully educated on our nation's origins and thus don't fully respect the principles upon which it was founded. It's threads like these that make me firmly believe the viewership of TL comprises of mostly teenagers, because I can model their thought processes based on their posts and compare it to when I was that age. story from my village. one day young tree say to him father "father why do you stay in village? the world is for tree, is it not?" to the young tree, father reply, "the world is for tree, it is true, but the roots which nourish tree and the bark that protect tree make it harder to move. so we must move slow" "that is dumb", ambition sapling say, "i will be free. root will not hold me, i will find my own nourishment, bark will not restrain me for i am young and strong" this he say for all to hear. next day he die. | ||
Traeon
Austria366 Posts
On August 07 2011 04:11 Necrophantasia wrote: Drugs that kill hundreds of thousands of people in the US every year, what? Name me a drug that has FDA approval that has directly killed 100,000 people. http://jama.ama-assn.org/content/279/15/1200.abstract We estimated that in 1994 overall 2216000 (1721000-2711000) hospitalized patients had serious ADRs and 106000 (76000-137000) had fatal ADRs ADR = adverse drug reaction. That is, the drug having an unexpected harmful side effect. We're not talking about toddlers swallowing some pills or elderly not taking their meds properly. We're talking about people being cured by doctors and nurses with prescription drugs that were approved as safe by the FDA. | ||
StrangrDangr
United States291 Posts
I have tried raw milk and I while I understand that some people think it tastes better, the thought that I am drinking something that undoubtedly has cow/farmer feces in it spoiled any liking I had for it. Beyond that the taste didn't seem better to me. | ||
SpiffD
Denmark1264 Posts
On August 07 2011 04:31 NET wrote: (I am not here to quarrel with anyone, I am humbly here to just give some of my basic knowledge in order to help others understand what is going on.) To begin with, it is not an attack on organic food, its an attack on illegal vendors selling potentially hazardous foods. Without oversight of that illegal vendor, how do consumers know if the proper measurements were taken to properly transport the product. How do we know if the milk and cheese being stored in their refrigerators is the correct temperature so that bacterial growth is at least not exponential. Also I don't understand the fad of drinking raw milk. People assume its healthier, but scientific evidence proves otherwise. Think about it for a second. Milk is taken from a cow by a farmer for example. How do we know if his hands are clean or if they are full of either cow feces or feces of his own. That contamination spreads, from that one instance, to the entire container holding all of the milk, therefore contaminating the entire product. Raw milk will sell the product as is. (As stated before I think people are confused about the difference between organic and raw milk, its completely understandable because how many people really know and study this topic anyways?) Pasteurization, and even better, ultra pasteurization helps kill many of the bacteria and other mircboes that are proven to be harmful to your health using heat (The only downside to using this method is that some people think it taste different(ergo worse), but that's just a matter of preference, you like to play zerg over terran because you like their style better, etc) . Lets talk Listeria monocytogenes. Here is an excerpt, but hopefully you will read the entire page: "It is one of the most virulent foodborne pathogens, with 20 to 30 percent of clinical infections resulting in death.[1] Responsible for approximately 2,500 illnesses and 500 deaths in the United States (U.S.) annually, listeriosis is the leading cause of death among foodborne bacterial pathogens, with fatality rates exceeding even Salmonella and Clostridium botulinum.[2]" Milk and milk products are some of the most common sources of listeria. I think because there is so much regulation in the food industry and that not as many outbreaks occur due to the this fact, people over time forget how dangerous raw milk truly is. In truth though, there is not enough people to check every batch of milk or every carton of eggs even in the regulated industry, so we do see cases appear every so often, which is when we hear about huge recalls on food. You have to remember that the regulations in place are not there for your average healthy adult, but rather for you susceptible young children, your elderly, and your immunocompromised. Hopefully I helped clear a few things up, and not just add more confusing to this already controversial topic. Great post. Also, what a bunch of obnoxious people in OP's youtube clips. | ||
caradoc
Canada3022 Posts
On August 07 2011 03:38 Gamegene wrote: You took the phrase "anti government extremists" and accused him of "marginalizing dissent" with a ludicrous explanation. You have no right to talk. haha, speaking of marginalizing dissent. =) Essentially that was my point, and your responses are precisely in line with his original response, which further emphasizes it. I see that you take issue with my post. That's fabulous. I would be more than happy to respond to a sensible critique of it, or even a request for clarification. I urge you to make such a reply in the near future so that we can contribute to the overall quality of this thread, provided it is on topic, as I believe that we are dangerously close to being off on a tangent, and we don't want to derail this thread. On topic: I'm also surprised that so few people have pointed out that raw milk is pretty commonplace in Europe. | ||
semantics
10040 Posts
On August 07 2011 04:42 Traeon wrote: http://jama.ama-assn.org/content/279/15/1200.abstract We estimated that in 1994 overall 2216000 (1721000-2711000) hospitalized patients had serious ADRs and 106000 (76000-137000) had fatal ADRs ADR = adverse drug reaction. That is, the drug having an unexpected harmful side effect. We're not talking about toddlers swallowing some pills or elderly not taking their meds properly. We're talking about people being cured by doctors and nurses with prescription drugs that were approved as safe by the FDA. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adverse_drug_reaction It's a quite broad term it includes people getting heart attack like events from popping penis pills and often drugs interact with other drugs something companies can't really test for too much until a doctor subscribes something that doesn't paly well with another. Yup bad drugs bad! dam those drugs that let the avg life expediency to be 78 | ||
caradoc
Canada3022 Posts
On August 07 2011 04:31 NET wrote: (I am not here to quarrel with anyone, I am humbly here to just give some of my basic knowledge in order to help others understand what is going on.) To begin with, it is not an attack on organic food, its an attack on illegal vendors selling potentially hazardous foods. Without oversight of that illegal vendor, how do consumers know if the proper measurements were taken to properly transport the product. How do we know if the milk and cheese being stored in their refrigerators is the correct temperature so that bacterial growth is at least not exponential. Also I don't understand the fad of drinking raw milk. People assume its healthier, but scientific evidence proves otherwise. Think about it for a second. Milk is taken from a cow by a farmer for example. How do we know if his hands are clean or if they are full of either cow feces or feces of his own. That contamination spreads, from that one instance, to the entire container holding all of the milk, therefore contaminating the entire product. Raw milk will sell the product as is. (As stated before I think people are confused about the difference between organic and raw milk, its completely understandable because how many people really know and study this topic anyways?) Pasteurization, and even better, ultra pasteurization helps kill many of the bacteria and other mircboes that are proven to be harmful to your health using heat (The only downside to using this method is that some people think it taste different(ergo worse), but that's just a matter of preference, you like to play zerg over terran because you like their style better, etc) . Lets talk Listeria monocytogenes. Here is an excerpt, but hopefully you will read the entire page: "It is one of the most virulent foodborne pathogens, with 20 to 30 percent of clinical infections resulting in death.[1] Responsible for approximately 2,500 illnesses and 500 deaths in the United States (U.S.) annually, listeriosis is the leading cause of death among foodborne bacterial pathogens, with fatality rates exceeding even Salmonella and Clostridium botulinum.[2]" Milk and milk products are some of the most common sources of listeria. I think because there is so much regulation in the food industry and that not as many outbreaks occur due to the this fact, people over time forget how dangerous raw milk truly is. In truth though, there is not enough people to check every batch of milk or every carton of eggs even in the regulated industry, so we do see cases appear every so often, which is when we hear about huge recalls on food. You have to remember that the regulations in place are not there for your average healthy adult, but rather for you susceptible young children, your elderly, and your immunocompromised. Hopefully I helped clear a few things up, and not just add more confusing to this already controversial topic. it should be mentioned that the increasing occurrence of listeriosis poisonings is precisely one of the reasons that people are turning increasingly to small scale, local organic food (of which organic raw milk is an example). Industrial food production in and of itself guarantees neither health nor safety. | ||
| ||