• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 20:59
CET 02:59
KST 10:59
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #2312[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over6Dark completes military service, returns to SC217[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over SC4ALL: II Indiegogo Campaign Announcement No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Team Liquid Map Contest #23 StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon
Tourneys
RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16) Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
People still play BW? SC4ALL: II Indiegogo Campaign Announcement Potentially helpful Shield Battery feedback. List of top players active on ShieldBattery XUN appreciation thread
Tourneys
2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players [BSL23] Ro16 Group B - Saturday 21:00 CET KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4 SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19)
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread The PlayStation 5 Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread The Games Industry And ATVI Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Trading/Investing Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 19080 users

The Elephant in the Room - Page 202

Forum Index > Final Edits
6515 CommentsPost a Reply
Prev 1 200 201 202 203 204 326 Next
rysecake
Profile Joined October 2010
United States2632 Posts
December 08 2011 20:23 GMT
#4021
On December 09 2011 05:19 Klondikebar wrote:
I think this debate is a farce. The OP was interesting because it was well researched and came from someone who has some cred, but even that was speculation. Now the debate has turned into a glorified "uh huh!" "nu-uh!"

We're going to have data very soon! If you guys can just sit back and wait a little bit we'll all see very soon who is right.

I read the thread because I wanna learn more about the BW legacy...I'm not learning much anymore.


The debate has too many sides to it. One is people saying the sc1 greats will become the best in sc2 after their 1st game on ladder, that is bullshit. Another is saying they won't become the best in sc2 because they won't be able to keep up with the current best sc2 pros (a woongjin terran lol...). A third group is saying they will become the best in sc2 over time, that is an assumption yes...but it's a very very damn good one.
The Notorious Winkles
GolemMadness
Profile Blog Joined September 2010
Canada11044 Posts
December 08 2011 20:26 GMT
#4022
On December 09 2011 04:52 MasterBlasterCaster wrote:
I doubt they will become the best because they are already too old.

Someone like Jjakji or Leenock will be the best. Probably someone even younger than them.

Some of them may be the best for a time, sure, but they will never be the best of the best. They have spent too little an amount of time playing the one game and too much playing the other. Their brains are wired for SCBW, not SC2.

They will still dominate, because their brains are wired for RTS's too, but they will not be the best of best IMO.


Nestea and MVP both played Brood War for years, and Nestea is 28. Flash is 9 years younger. Pretty sure that if Nestea can adapt, then Flash can too.
http://na.op.gg/summoner/userName=FLABREZU
hunts
Profile Joined September 2010
United States2113 Posts
December 08 2011 20:28 GMT
#4023
On December 09 2011 05:15 rysecake wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 09 2011 05:11 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:05 wassbix wrote:
On December 09 2011 04:52 MasterBlasterCaster wrote:
I doubt they will become the best because they are already too old.

Someone like Jjakji or Leenock will be the best. Probably someone even younger than them.

Some of them may be the best for a time, sure, but they will never be the best of the best. They have spent too little an amount of time playing the one game and too much playing the other. Their brains are wired for SCBW, not SC2.

They will still dominate, because their brains are wired for RTS's too, but they will not be the best of best IMO.


Nestea was a bad BW player in his prime and in his 30s he is considered the best SC2 player so lolllll.


will you still be laughing though when the current top BW pros switch over to SC2 and get spanked by nestea/mvp/mc?

I mean I'm sure they'll all do well, but can you BW people really not see the audacity of trying to say that any of the BW pros can come into SC2 and dominate the SC2 gods?


Yes, I'm saying that they will dominate the sc2 "gods" (if you can even call them that). How much time they will take to become the best I don't know. But they will become the best in time.


hahah we shall see I'm sure some of them will reach that high of a level, I'm sure plenty won't, and to outright say that all the Bw pros will dominate all the SC2 pros is just an arrogant and audacious statement, which seems to stem from resentment. I hope I'm not being too harsh here, but in this thread it really feels like a lot of the BW fans are coming over here to bash on SC2s skill because they are angry that in time SC2 will take over and BW will eventually be dead.

I have plenty of respect for BW and its fans and players, but really so many people in this thread just seem so spiteful in their comments of "bah sc2 pros are trash bw pros will take over in no time if they switch!" But like I said, we will see in due time.
twitch.tv/huntstv 7x legend streamer
DarkMatter_
Profile Joined January 2010
Canada1774 Posts
December 08 2011 20:29 GMT
#4024
On December 09 2011 05:28 hunts wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 09 2011 05:15 rysecake wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:11 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:05 wassbix wrote:
On December 09 2011 04:52 MasterBlasterCaster wrote:
I doubt they will become the best because they are already too old.

Someone like Jjakji or Leenock will be the best. Probably someone even younger than them.

Some of them may be the best for a time, sure, but they will never be the best of the best. They have spent too little an amount of time playing the one game and too much playing the other. Their brains are wired for SCBW, not SC2.

They will still dominate, because their brains are wired for RTS's too, but they will not be the best of best IMO.


Nestea was a bad BW player in his prime and in his 30s he is considered the best SC2 player so lolllll.


will you still be laughing though when the current top BW pros switch over to SC2 and get spanked by nestea/mvp/mc?

I mean I'm sure they'll all do well, but can you BW people really not see the audacity of trying to say that any of the BW pros can come into SC2 and dominate the SC2 gods?


Yes, I'm saying that they will dominate the sc2 "gods" (if you can even call them that). How much time they will take to become the best I don't know. But they will become the best in time.


hahah we shall see I'm sure some of them will reach that high of a level, I'm sure plenty won't, and to outright say that all the Bw pros will dominate all the SC2 pros is just an arrogant and audacious statement, which seems to stem from resentment. I hope I'm not being too harsh here, but in this thread it really feels like a lot of the BW fans are coming over here to bash on SC2s skill because they are angry that in time SC2 will take over and BW will eventually be dead.

I have plenty of respect for BW and its fans and players, but really so many people in this thread just seem so spiteful in their comments of "bah sc2 pros are trash bw pros will take over in no time if they switch!" But like I said, we will see in due time.

I don't think anyone said that all that BW pros would dominate all SC2 pros. We've been mainly talking about the very best BW pros.
hunts
Profile Joined September 2010
United States2113 Posts
December 08 2011 20:35 GMT
#4025
On December 09 2011 05:29 DarkMatter_ wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 09 2011 05:28 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:15 rysecake wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:11 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:05 wassbix wrote:
On December 09 2011 04:52 MasterBlasterCaster wrote:
I doubt they will become the best because they are already too old.

Someone like Jjakji or Leenock will be the best. Probably someone even younger than them.

Some of them may be the best for a time, sure, but they will never be the best of the best. They have spent too little an amount of time playing the one game and too much playing the other. Their brains are wired for SCBW, not SC2.

They will still dominate, because their brains are wired for RTS's too, but they will not be the best of best IMO.


Nestea was a bad BW player in his prime and in his 30s he is considered the best SC2 player so lolllll.


will you still be laughing though when the current top BW pros switch over to SC2 and get spanked by nestea/mvp/mc?

I mean I'm sure they'll all do well, but can you BW people really not see the audacity of trying to say that any of the BW pros can come into SC2 and dominate the SC2 gods?


Yes, I'm saying that they will dominate the sc2 "gods" (if you can even call them that). How much time they will take to become the best I don't know. But they will become the best in time.


hahah we shall see I'm sure some of them will reach that high of a level, I'm sure plenty won't, and to outright say that all the Bw pros will dominate all the SC2 pros is just an arrogant and audacious statement, which seems to stem from resentment. I hope I'm not being too harsh here, but in this thread it really feels like a lot of the BW fans are coming over here to bash on SC2s skill because they are angry that in time SC2 will take over and BW will eventually be dead.

I have plenty of respect for BW and its fans and players, but really so many people in this thread just seem so spiteful in their comments of "bah sc2 pros are trash bw pros will take over in no time if they switch!" But like I said, we will see in due time.

I don't think anyone said that all that BW pros would dominate all SC2 pros. We've been mainly talking about the very best BW pros.


Well I have no doubt that the very best BW pros will do very well in SC2. I don't think they will really overthrow the current top SC2 pros, but I'm sure they will be up there with them.
twitch.tv/huntstv 7x legend streamer
MrCon
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
France29748 Posts
December 08 2011 20:44 GMT
#4026
The Elephant was at least partially right. The level of play at the time the article was written and the current level of play are night and day. With fOrGG and soon Hyun we'll have more concrete results soon.
The current sc2 pros (ex bw or not) skill level is rapidly increasing.
Broodwar pros converting to sc2 will obviously have a headstart, but imo that doesn't mean that someone who never played broodwar can't attain the same level. It'll just take more time as practice is everything.
hewley
Profile Joined February 2011
Germany1063 Posts
December 08 2011 20:45 GMT
#4027
On December 09 2011 05:35 hunts wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 09 2011 05:29 DarkMatter_ wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:28 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:15 rysecake wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:11 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:05 wassbix wrote:
On December 09 2011 04:52 MasterBlasterCaster wrote:
I doubt they will become the best because they are already too old.

Someone like Jjakji or Leenock will be the best. Probably someone even younger than them.

Some of them may be the best for a time, sure, but they will never be the best of the best. They have spent too little an amount of time playing the one game and too much playing the other. Their brains are wired for SCBW, not SC2.

They will still dominate, because their brains are wired for RTS's too, but they will not be the best of best IMO.


Nestea was a bad BW player in his prime and in his 30s he is considered the best SC2 player so lolllll.


will you still be laughing though when the current top BW pros switch over to SC2 and get spanked by nestea/mvp/mc?

I mean I'm sure they'll all do well, but can you BW people really not see the audacity of trying to say that any of the BW pros can come into SC2 and dominate the SC2 gods?


Yes, I'm saying that they will dominate the sc2 "gods" (if you can even call them that). How much time they will take to become the best I don't know. But they will become the best in time.


hahah we shall see I'm sure some of them will reach that high of a level, I'm sure plenty won't, and to outright say that all the Bw pros will dominate all the SC2 pros is just an arrogant and audacious statement, which seems to stem from resentment. I hope I'm not being too harsh here, but in this thread it really feels like a lot of the BW fans are coming over here to bash on SC2s skill because they are angry that in time SC2 will take over and BW will eventually be dead.

I have plenty of respect for BW and its fans and players, but really so many people in this thread just seem so spiteful in their comments of "bah sc2 pros are trash bw pros will take over in no time if they switch!" But like I said, we will see in due time.

I don't think anyone said that all that BW pros would dominate all SC2 pros. We've been mainly talking about the very best BW pros.


Well I have no doubt that the very best BW pros will do very well in SC2. I don't think they will really overthrow the current top SC2 pros, but I'm sure they will be up there with them.


But thats the point of the article. Mediocre BW pros (A-teamers like Mvp in his past) will be up there with the current top Sc2 pros, while Flash, JD etc. will most likely overthrow them in the future.
Do you really think that there isn't a significant higher skill level/ceiling than Mvp or Nestea show us now? If not, it would be pretty sad, if the highest level of Sc2 skill is already displayed at the moment.
Esports bubble pop, bubble pop
GolemMadness
Profile Blog Joined September 2010
Canada11044 Posts
December 08 2011 20:46 GMT
#4028
ForGG is already in Code S and he's only been seriously training for two months. He was playing on the ladder for several months before that, but even now, he says the training is very laid back compared to Brood War.
http://na.op.gg/summoner/userName=FLABREZU
alhazrel
Profile Joined November 2011
98 Posts
December 08 2011 21:07 GMT
#4029
This article begins with a fundamentally stupid headline and unfortunately never quite manages to escape it despite having some good points buried in there.

'The competition in SC2 thus far has been a farce' - Does anyone want to support this because it's ridiculous to base this on the fact that there are players in BW who haven't switched that have the potential to excel at sc2.

Every time anyone mentions 'skill' at the game they should chop off their fingers. In SC2 we see people winning with numerous different approaches, often things that only work for one tournament before people learn how to scout and counter them. I'd rather discuss 'strategy' and 'fundamentals'.

SC players will definitely have extremely strong fundamentals with top class macro to rival the best macro players in sc2. In itself, this almost guarantees that they'll be competitive, but the strategy, under which loose header I include understanding unit behaviour, composition and the space control that various units can maintain, brood war players may find themselves with expectations that hinder their effectiveness.

I am saying that there are 300 current pros and semi-pros that have the potential to come in and dominate SC2 at any moment, with a latency of a few months from the day they switch. Among this group there are a notable few that CRUSH any other players in terms of raw talent and/or work ethic and/or ability to learn. This knowledge cheapens any form of competition I see right now, no matter how much I try to enjoy the games.


This is either sensationalist to the point of vapidity or a poorly stated point. Brood war players do not uniformly have a better work ethic than SC2 players, the games are currently in completely different states and can't even be compared at that level. There will be brood war players that have more refined practise techniques but then the number of professional BW players is still higher than the total of SC2 pros so probability wise that was likely. If any were to cross over and bring a practise style that blew everyone else out of the water, others would soon adopt it.

Although top BW players will in most cases also make top SC2 players, you should know better than to assume people who have had success in the past are guaranteed it in the future. I don't see how OP is distinguishing 'raw talent' from 'ability to learn' as the former is a fictional facet of the latter. There are some BW pros who will be very good at SC2, a few will contend at the very top, a few will be in the top pool without ever distinguishing themselves and some will have only extremely limited success.

In fact, you could say that it will be as if the professional player pool is slightly more than doubling with a group of players who have a proven ability to excel in an RTS. Anything else is the same kind of rubbish counter-strike: source has been plagued with since its inception, 'OMG TOP CS TEAMS WILL PWN EVERY1'; a perception that's so far proved way off the mark. Although many BW players switched for the money, had they stayed in SC they would now be competing among the best with the marginal disadvantage of having started later than the other guys. Instead the roles will be reversed.

Let's just be sensible about it please. I don't know why the article was set out in such an incendiary tone because it relies on no properly comparable facts. What does how much someone says they practise have to do with anything? I bet there's a lot of children wishing their mums would let them off with such innocuous excuses.

I'm excited to see how top players with a history of playing BW a certain way adapt units to their expectations and I'm looking forward to seeing how these high level BW strats will translate into SC2 and how the competition from people forced into a highly professional approach pushes the whole scene upwards.
hunts
Profile Joined September 2010
United States2113 Posts
December 08 2011 21:08 GMT
#4030
On December 09 2011 05:45 hewley wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 09 2011 05:35 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:29 DarkMatter_ wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:28 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:15 rysecake wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:11 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:05 wassbix wrote:
On December 09 2011 04:52 MasterBlasterCaster wrote:
I doubt they will become the best because they are already too old.

Someone like Jjakji or Leenock will be the best. Probably someone even younger than them.

Some of them may be the best for a time, sure, but they will never be the best of the best. They have spent too little an amount of time playing the one game and too much playing the other. Their brains are wired for SCBW, not SC2.

They will still dominate, because their brains are wired for RTS's too, but they will not be the best of best IMO.


Nestea was a bad BW player in his prime and in his 30s he is considered the best SC2 player so lolllll.


will you still be laughing though when the current top BW pros switch over to SC2 and get spanked by nestea/mvp/mc?

I mean I'm sure they'll all do well, but can you BW people really not see the audacity of trying to say that any of the BW pros can come into SC2 and dominate the SC2 gods?


Yes, I'm saying that they will dominate the sc2 "gods" (if you can even call them that). How much time they will take to become the best I don't know. But they will become the best in time.


hahah we shall see I'm sure some of them will reach that high of a level, I'm sure plenty won't, and to outright say that all the Bw pros will dominate all the SC2 pros is just an arrogant and audacious statement, which seems to stem from resentment. I hope I'm not being too harsh here, but in this thread it really feels like a lot of the BW fans are coming over here to bash on SC2s skill because they are angry that in time SC2 will take over and BW will eventually be dead.

I have plenty of respect for BW and its fans and players, but really so many people in this thread just seem so spiteful in their comments of "bah sc2 pros are trash bw pros will take over in no time if they switch!" But like I said, we will see in due time.

I don't think anyone said that all that BW pros would dominate all SC2 pros. We've been mainly talking about the very best BW pros.


Well I have no doubt that the very best BW pros will do very well in SC2. I don't think they will really overthrow the current top SC2 pros, but I'm sure they will be up there with them.


But thats the point of the article. Mediocre BW pros (A-teamers like Mvp in his past) will be up there with the current top Sc2 pros, while Flash, JD etc. will most likely overthrow them in the future.
Do you really think that there isn't a significant higher skill level/ceiling than Mvp or Nestea show us now? If not, it would be pretty sad, if the highest level of Sc2 skill is already displayed at the moment.


There definitely is a much higher skill cap, no ones reached it yet. But's it's just asinine and silly to try and say that the top SC2 pros will be stuck where they are now while the BW pros will come in and overthrow all of them. It's silly to think that mediocre BW pros will be up there with the likes of mvp/nnestea and that the top bw pros like flash will zoom past them in skill while they're all practicing. This thinking really seems to stem from the attitude of "SC2 will kill our game so we will shit talk them until they feel like ours is superior." I'm sorry but I don't buy that, and neither do most other people.
twitch.tv/huntstv 7x legend streamer
DarkMatter_
Profile Joined January 2010
Canada1774 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-08 21:49:38
December 08 2011 21:42 GMT
#4031
On December 09 2011 06:07 alhazrel wrote:
This article begins with a fundamentally stupid headline and unfortunately never quite manages to escape it despite having some good points buried in there.

'The competition in SC2 thus far has been a farce' - Does anyone want to support this because it's ridiculous to base this on the fact that there are players in BW who haven't switched that have the potential to excel at sc2.

That statement might be a bit too harsh and unfair, but I can definitely see where he's coming from. Right now, SC2 feels like the place for BW rejects to make a name for themselves by taking advantage of the inferior competition in SC2 and succeed when they never could in BW. This knowledge definitely makes it harder to take the SC2 competition seriously. For long time BW followers, it's hard not to roll your eyes when you see Tastosis rambling on about how godly Nestea and MVP are.

Every time anyone mentions 'skill' at the game they should chop off their fingers. In SC2 we see people winning with numerous different approaches, often things that only work for one tournament before people learn how to scout and counter them. I'd rather discuss 'strategy' and 'fundamentals'.

SC players will definitely have extremely strong fundamentals with top class macro to rival the best macro players in sc2. In itself, this almost guarantees that they'll be competitive, but the strategy, under which loose header I include understanding unit behaviour, composition and the space control that various units can maintain, brood war players may find themselves with expectations that hinder their effectiveness.

What is the basis for that statement? Because up to this point, it hasn't proven to be true. BW players aren't mindless robots who are going to play SC2 exactly like it was BW.

This is either sensationalist to the point of vapidity or a poorly stated point. Brood war players do not uniformly have a better work ethic than SC2 players, the games are currently in completely different states and can't even be compared at that level. There will be brood war players that have more refined practise techniques but then the number of professional BW players is still higher than the total of SC2 pros so probability wise that was likely. If any were to cross over and bring a practise style that blew everyone else out of the water, others would soon adopt it.

Actually, it's more or less true. The BW practice regime is far more rigorous and strict than that of any SC2 proteam. Moreover, BW teams are a lot more organized and there's a huge amount of money invested just into coaching and managing the teams.

Although top BW players will in most cases also make top SC2 players, you should know better than to assume people who have had success in the past are guaranteed it in the future. I don't see how OP is distinguishing 'raw talent' from 'ability to learn' as the former is a fictional facet of the latter. There are some BW pros who will be very good at SC2, a few will contend at the very top, a few will be in the top pool without ever distinguishing themselves and some will have only extremely limited success.

In fact, you could say that it will be as if the professional player pool is slightly more than doubling with a group of players who have a proven ability to excel in an RTS. Anything else is the same kind of rubbish counter-strike: source has been plagued with since its inception, 'OMG TOP CS TEAMS WILL PWN EVERY1'; a perception that's so far proved way off the mark. Although many BW players switched for the money, had they stayed in SC they would now be competing among the best with the marginal disadvantage of having started later than the other guys. Instead the roles will be reversed.

Let's just be sensible about it please. I don't know why the article was set out in such an incendiary tone because it relies on no properly comparable facts. What does how much someone says they practise have to do with anything? I bet there's a lot of children wishing their mums would let them off with such innocuous excuses.

I'm excited to see how top players with a history of playing BW a certain way adapt units to their expectations and I'm looking forward to seeing how these high level BW strats
will translate into SC2 and how the competition from people forced into a highly professional approach pushes the whole scene upwards.

Uh, what? Again, you seem to be implying that BW players are all morons who are going to play SC2 exactly like it was BW and control units in the identical way and use the same strategies from BW. BW strats translating to SC2? What makes you think they're going to be using BW strats?
DarkMatter_
Profile Joined January 2010
Canada1774 Posts
December 08 2011 21:48 GMT
#4032
On December 09 2011 06:08 hunts wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 09 2011 05:45 hewley wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:35 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:29 DarkMatter_ wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:28 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:15 rysecake wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:11 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:05 wassbix wrote:
On December 09 2011 04:52 MasterBlasterCaster wrote:
I doubt they will become the best because they are already too old.

Someone like Jjakji or Leenock will be the best. Probably someone even younger than them.

Some of them may be the best for a time, sure, but they will never be the best of the best. They have spent too little an amount of time playing the one game and too much playing the other. Their brains are wired for SCBW, not SC2.

They will still dominate, because their brains are wired for RTS's too, but they will not be the best of best IMO.


Nestea was a bad BW player in his prime and in his 30s he is considered the best SC2 player so lolllll.


will you still be laughing though when the current top BW pros switch over to SC2 and get spanked by nestea/mvp/mc?

I mean I'm sure they'll all do well, but can you BW people really not see the audacity of trying to say that any of the BW pros can come into SC2 and dominate the SC2 gods?


Yes, I'm saying that they will dominate the sc2 "gods" (if you can even call them that). How much time they will take to become the best I don't know. But they will become the best in time.


hahah we shall see I'm sure some of them will reach that high of a level, I'm sure plenty won't, and to outright say that all the Bw pros will dominate all the SC2 pros is just an arrogant and audacious statement, which seems to stem from resentment. I hope I'm not being too harsh here, but in this thread it really feels like a lot of the BW fans are coming over here to bash on SC2s skill because they are angry that in time SC2 will take over and BW will eventually be dead.

I have plenty of respect for BW and its fans and players, but really so many people in this thread just seem so spiteful in their comments of "bah sc2 pros are trash bw pros will take over in no time if they switch!" But like I said, we will see in due time.

I don't think anyone said that all that BW pros would dominate all SC2 pros. We've been mainly talking about the very best BW pros.


Well I have no doubt that the very best BW pros will do very well in SC2. I don't think they will really overthrow the current top SC2 pros, but I'm sure they will be up there with them.


But thats the point of the article. Mediocre BW pros (A-teamers like Mvp in his past) will be up there with the current top Sc2 pros, while Flash, JD etc. will most likely overthrow them in the future.
Do you really think that there isn't a significant higher skill level/ceiling than Mvp or Nestea show us now? If not, it would be pretty sad, if the highest level of Sc2 skill is already displayed at the moment.


There definitely is a much higher skill cap, no ones reached it yet. But's it's just asinine and silly to try and say that the top SC2 pros will be stuck where they are now while the BW pros will come in and overthrow all of them. It's silly to think that mediocre BW pros will be up there with the likes of mvp/nnestea and that the top bw pros like flash will zoom past them in skill while they're all practicing. This thinking really seems to stem from the attitude of "SC2 will kill our game so we will shit talk them until they feel like ours is superior." I'm sorry but I don't buy that, and neither do most other people.

How is it silly? And FYI, it's not just "bitter BW fanboys" making these claims. If you don't want to take our word for it, why not atleast listen to the likes of intrigue and Hot_Bid? Those guys are almost entirely invested in the SC2 scene.
setzer
Profile Joined March 2010
United States3284 Posts
December 08 2011 21:55 GMT
#4033
On December 09 2011 06:08 hunts wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 09 2011 05:45 hewley wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:35 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:29 DarkMatter_ wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:28 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:15 rysecake wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:11 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:05 wassbix wrote:
On December 09 2011 04:52 MasterBlasterCaster wrote:
I doubt they will become the best because they are already too old.

Someone like Jjakji or Leenock will be the best. Probably someone even younger than them.

Some of them may be the best for a time, sure, but they will never be the best of the best. They have spent too little an amount of time playing the one game and too much playing the other. Their brains are wired for SCBW, not SC2.

They will still dominate, because their brains are wired for RTS's too, but they will not be the best of best IMO.


Nestea was a bad BW player in his prime and in his 30s he is considered the best SC2 player so lolllll.


will you still be laughing though when the current top BW pros switch over to SC2 and get spanked by nestea/mvp/mc?

I mean I'm sure they'll all do well, but can you BW people really not see the audacity of trying to say that any of the BW pros can come into SC2 and dominate the SC2 gods?


Yes, I'm saying that they will dominate the sc2 "gods" (if you can even call them that). How much time they will take to become the best I don't know. But they will become the best in time.


hahah we shall see I'm sure some of them will reach that high of a level, I'm sure plenty won't, and to outright say that all the Bw pros will dominate all the SC2 pros is just an arrogant and audacious statement, which seems to stem from resentment. I hope I'm not being too harsh here, but in this thread it really feels like a lot of the BW fans are coming over here to bash on SC2s skill because they are angry that in time SC2 will take over and BW will eventually be dead.

I have plenty of respect for BW and its fans and players, but really so many people in this thread just seem so spiteful in their comments of "bah sc2 pros are trash bw pros will take over in no time if they switch!" But like I said, we will see in due time.

I don't think anyone said that all that BW pros would dominate all SC2 pros. We've been mainly talking about the very best BW pros.


Well I have no doubt that the very best BW pros will do very well in SC2. I don't think they will really overthrow the current top SC2 pros, but I'm sure they will be up there with them.


But thats the point of the article. Mediocre BW pros (A-teamers like Mvp in his past) will be up there with the current top Sc2 pros, while Flash, JD etc. will most likely overthrow them in the future.
Do you really think that there isn't a significant higher skill level/ceiling than Mvp or Nestea show us now? If not, it would be pretty sad, if the highest level of Sc2 skill is already displayed at the moment.


There definitely is a much higher skill cap, no ones reached it yet. But's it's just asinine and silly to try and say that the top SC2 pros will be stuck where they are now while the BW pros will come in and overthrow all of them. It's silly to think that mediocre BW pros will be up there with the likes of mvp/nnestea and that the top bw pros like flash will zoom past them in skill while they're all practicing. This thinking really seems to stem from the attitude of "SC2 will kill our game so we will shit talk them until they feel like ours is superior." I'm sorry but I don't buy that, and neither do most other people.


Nestea was a terrible BW player and MVP was a below-average A-teamer on a team with weak terran line up. Yes, MVP was improving but Nestea had almost a decade to make any significant impact on 1v1 and didn't. Why is it impossible to believe that players with far superior mechanics, superior practice, superior dedication, superior teammates (assuming a whole BW team switches, for instance) wouldn't be better given enough time?

A name like S2 doesn't get you out of his seat but he is still a more well-rounded player now than Boxer has ever been at any one point in his career. S2 might not dominate like Flash would but he would be up there with the best.
Boonbag
Profile Blog Joined March 2008
France3318 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-08 21:57:22
December 08 2011 21:55 GMT
#4034
Sc2 competition is a joke, anyone can lose to anyone

edit : and it will fade soon
infinity2k9
Profile Blog Joined January 2009
United Kingdom2397 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-08 22:05:50
December 08 2011 22:01 GMT
#4035
On December 09 2011 05:44 MrCon wrote:
The Elephant was at least partially right. The level of play at the time the article was written and the current level of play are night and day. With fOrGG and soon Hyun we'll have more concrete results soon.
The current sc2 pros (ex bw or not) skill level is rapidly increasing.
Broodwar pros converting to sc2 will obviously have a headstart, but imo that doesn't mean that someone who never played broodwar can't attain the same level. It'll just take more time as practice is everything.


HyuN i think would have been a likely candidate for a BW player who would retire after the end of the season if SC2 wasn't around.. he was seemingly past his peak and more likely imo a player who isn't going to show much in SC2.

Funny that the players who would potentially do the best just decided to quit (Midas/HiyA). Cause they were in better condition than even fOrGG and would have shown it more clearly, but apparently SC2 isn't a big enough deal to bother switching to haha.

edit: and people thinking MVP and Nestea are exceptional will always be funny to me
SeaSwift
Profile Blog Joined February 2011
Scotland4486 Posts
December 08 2011 22:09 GMT
#4036
On December 09 2011 06:55 setzer wrote:

Nestea was a terrible BW player and MVP was a below-average A-teamer on a team with weak terran line up. Yes, MVP was improving but Nestea had almost a decade to make any significant impact on 1v1 and didn't. Why is it impossible to believe that players with far superior mechanics, superior practice, superior dedication, superior teammates (assuming a whole BW team switches, for instance) wouldn't be better given enough time?

A name like S2 doesn't get you out of his seat but he is still a more well-rounded player now than Boxer has ever been at any one point in his career. S2 might not dominate like Flash would but he would be up there with the best.


I know this has done the rounds many times in this very thread, but Nestea was put out as a 2v2 player before he even had a chance to get good at 1v1. Then, when Proleague dropped 2v2 after he had practiced for ages, he was so far behind everyone in 1v1 that he had no chance.

Also, having practiced 1v1 for only a fraction of a time Nestea managed to qualify for the preliminaries of a StarLeague, ahead of dozens of dedicated 1v1 players who practiced 8-10 hours a day.

If anyone can be exempted from the general "SC2 champions are all failed BW players" rule, it is Nestea.
rysecake
Profile Joined October 2010
United States2632 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-08 22:14:51
December 08 2011 22:11 GMT
#4037
On December 09 2011 06:08 hunts wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 09 2011 05:45 hewley wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:35 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:29 DarkMatter_ wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:28 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:15 rysecake wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:11 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:05 wassbix wrote:
On December 09 2011 04:52 MasterBlasterCaster wrote:
I doubt they will become the best because they are already too old.

Someone like Jjakji or Leenock will be the best. Probably someone even younger than them.

Some of them may be the best for a time, sure, but they will never be the best of the best. They have spent too little an amount of time playing the one game and too much playing the other. Their brains are wired for SCBW, not SC2.

They will still dominate, because their brains are wired for RTS's too, but they will not be the best of best IMO.


Nestea was a bad BW player in his prime and in his 30s he is considered the best SC2 player so lolllll.


will you still be laughing though when the current top BW pros switch over to SC2 and get spanked by nestea/mvp/mc?

I mean I'm sure they'll all do well, but can you BW people really not see the audacity of trying to say that any of the BW pros can come into SC2 and dominate the SC2 gods?


Yes, I'm saying that they will dominate the sc2 "gods" (if you can even call them that). How much time they will take to become the best I don't know. But they will become the best in time.


hahah we shall see I'm sure some of them will reach that high of a level, I'm sure plenty won't, and to outright say that all the Bw pros will dominate all the SC2 pros is just an arrogant and audacious statement, which seems to stem from resentment. I hope I'm not being too harsh here, but in this thread it really feels like a lot of the BW fans are coming over here to bash on SC2s skill because they are angry that in time SC2 will take over and BW will eventually be dead.

I have plenty of respect for BW and its fans and players, but really so many people in this thread just seem so spiteful in their comments of "bah sc2 pros are trash bw pros will take over in no time if they switch!" But like I said, we will see in due time.

I don't think anyone said that all that BW pros would dominate all SC2 pros. We've been mainly talking about the very best BW pros.


Well I have no doubt that the very best BW pros will do very well in SC2. I don't think they will really overthrow the current top SC2 pros, but I'm sure they will be up there with them.


But thats the point of the article. Mediocre BW pros (A-teamers like Mvp in his past) will be up there with the current top Sc2 pros, while Flash, JD etc. will most likely overthrow them in the future.
Do you really think that there isn't a significant higher skill level/ceiling than Mvp or Nestea show us now? If not, it would be pretty sad, if the highest level of Sc2 skill is already displayed at the moment.


There definitely is a much higher skill cap, no ones reached it yet. But's it's just asinine and silly to try and say that the top SC2 pros will be stuck where they are now while the BW pros will come in and overthrow all of them. It's silly to think that mediocre BW pros will be up there with the likes of mvp/nnestea and that the top bw pros like flash will zoom past them in skill while they're all practicing. This thinking really seems to stem from the attitude of "SC2 will kill our game so we will shit talk them until they feel like ours is superior." I'm sorry but I don't buy that, and neither do most other people.



No, most people do not "not buy into it", only people who have no knowledge of sc1 think what you think. What makes you think mvp and nestea are special? Nestea had a very very long time to improve in sc1, he never did. Mvp was a "poor" a-teamer. What is it about mvp and nestea that make you think they're the end all be all of sc2? They're the best of the worst, that's why they're at the top right now.

I honestly don't have a clue why sc2 purists are so naive to think that the current top players are here to stay, it didn't stay for sc1, it won't stay for sc2. IT'S A GOOD THING to have the skill level keep rising. Do you guys not want to see higher level play? Or are you guys such fan boys of the current top tier players that you would quit the game to see them get overtaken? I love mvp and nestea, they're amazing players, but to think they will always be at the top of sc2 is retardedly naive and you know it.

There is nothing special about mvp or nestea. They aren't just naturally talented at sc2 or whatever bullshit you think. They're the best of the worst I'll say that again. Once the better switch over, it's only a matter of time before the current top tier drops down. Why do you think boxer, nada and oov fell in sc1?
The Notorious Winkles
bgx
Profile Joined August 2010
Poland6595 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-12-08 22:13:10
December 08 2011 22:12 GMT
#4038
On December 09 2011 06:08 hunts wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 09 2011 05:45 hewley wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:35 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:29 DarkMatter_ wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:28 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:15 rysecake wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:11 hunts wrote:
On December 09 2011 05:05 wassbix wrote:
On December 09 2011 04:52 MasterBlasterCaster wrote:
I doubt they will become the best because they are already too old.

Someone like Jjakji or Leenock will be the best. Probably someone even younger than them.

Some of them may be the best for a time, sure, but they will never be the best of the best. They have spent too little an amount of time playing the one game and too much playing the other. Their brains are wired for SCBW, not SC2.

They will still dominate, because their brains are wired for RTS's too, but they will not be the best of best IMO.


Nestea was a bad BW player in his prime and in his 30s he is considered the best SC2 player so lolllll.


will you still be laughing though when the current top BW pros switch over to SC2 and get spanked by nestea/mvp/mc?

I mean I'm sure they'll all do well, but can you BW people really not see the audacity of trying to say that any of the BW pros can come into SC2 and dominate the SC2 gods?


Yes, I'm saying that they will dominate the sc2 "gods" (if you can even call them that). How much time they will take to become the best I don't know. But they will become the best in time.


hahah we shall see I'm sure some of them will reach that high of a level, I'm sure plenty won't, and to outright say that all the Bw pros will dominate all the SC2 pros is just an arrogant and audacious statement, which seems to stem from resentment. I hope I'm not being too harsh here, but in this thread it really feels like a lot of the BW fans are coming over here to bash on SC2s skill because they are angry that in time SC2 will take over and BW will eventually be dead.

I have plenty of respect for BW and its fans and players, but really so many people in this thread just seem so spiteful in their comments of "bah sc2 pros are trash bw pros will take over in no time if they switch!" But like I said, we will see in due time.

I don't think anyone said that all that BW pros would dominate all SC2 pros. We've been mainly talking about the very best BW pros.


Well I have no doubt that the very best BW pros will do very well in SC2. I don't think they will really overthrow the current top SC2 pros, but I'm sure they will be up there with them.


But thats the point of the article. Mediocre BW pros (A-teamers like Mvp in his past) will be up there with the current top Sc2 pros, while Flash, JD etc. will most likely overthrow them in the future.
Do you really think that there isn't a significant higher skill level/ceiling than Mvp or Nestea show us now? If not, it would be pretty sad, if the highest level of Sc2 skill is already displayed at the moment.


There definitely is a much higher skill cap, no ones reached it yet. But's it's just asinine and silly to try and say that the top SC2 pros will be stuck where they are now while the BW pros will come in and overthrow all of them. It's silly to think that mediocre BW pros will be up there with the likes of mvp/nnestea and that the top bw pros like flash will zoom past them in skill while they're all practicing. This thinking really seems to stem from the attitude of "SC2 will kill our game so we will shit talk them until they feel like ours is superior." I'm sorry but I don't buy that, and neither do most other people.

first i dont like the idea of people like flash switching and i highly doubt it will happen in 1-2 years, NOTHING indicates them willing to switch yet

but hypothetically if they switch they will have actually an easier road, because blizzard will reset meta game at least twice (starcraft --> BW was completely different game), myriads of balance patches and new developments will also help, if they switch within that time they will (or should given their career history) catch up AT LEAST as fast as Nestea, and later it will be the question if Nestea/MVP will live through it.
Stork[gm]
drgonzhere
Profile Joined November 2010
United States447 Posts
December 08 2011 22:13 GMT
#4039
Jesus this thread has grown into some sort of frankenstein monster that cannot be stopped! God help us all.
Dictator for Life of the PuMa Fanclub/ DRG, PuMA, Sage, Puzzle, MMA Fighting!
ZeromuS
Profile Blog Joined October 2010
Canada13431 Posts
December 08 2011 22:13 GMT
#4040
Every time i come into this thread I'm amazed it hasn't been closed yet. Why are we having an SC2 vs BW flame war?

>.<
StrategyRTS forever | @ZeromuS_plays | www.twitch.tv/Zeromus_
Prev 1 200 201 202 203 204 326 Next
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
The PiG Daily
06:25
Best Games of SC
Clem vs Classic
Rogue vs Neeb
MaxPax vs Bunny
SHIN vs Clem
GuMiho vs SHIN
PiGStarcraft490
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
PiGStarcraft490
StarCraft: Brood War
Shuttle 478
MaD[AoV]25
910 10
Counter-Strike
fl0m382
Heroes of the Storm
Khaldor213
Other Games
gofns10371
summit1g8001
JimRising 432
Trikslyr66
Mew2King57
WinterStarcraft23
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick1029
BasetradeTV108
[ Show 13 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• Hupsaiya 98
• Airneanach16
• davetesta9
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• Pr0nogo 2
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Other Games
• Scarra777
Upcoming Events
RSL Revival
11h 1m
Clem vs Serral
herO vs Rogue
OSC
11h 1m
IPSL
15h 1m
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
18h 1m
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
21h 1m
WardiTV Weekly
1d 10h
Kung Fu Cup
2 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
2 days
The PondCast
4 days
KCM Race Survival
4 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-17
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
RSL Offline Finals
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3

Upcoming

CSL Season 23: Qualifier 1
Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
CSL 2026 Winter (S23) - 3v3
CSL 2026 Winter (S23)
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.