|
This is a thread that is dedicated to discussing One Piece. Do not read this thread if you are not currently caught up as there are spoilers in here.
If an episode or a chapter has already been officially released, then it is not necessary to post using spoilers.
If you have knowledge on a chapter that has not been officially released yet, do NOT post it in this thread. Ignoring this public note will result in a mod action. |
On May 10 2012 10:56 Dac wrote:Show nested quote +On May 10 2012 10:53 Sentenal wrote:On May 10 2012 10:37 Forikorder wrote:On May 10 2012 10:21 BlackMagister wrote:
Arlong didn't die? Why did you bring him up? If you mean characters he killed, that happened in flash backs. One Piece yes doesn't use death of important characters very often which is fine by me. It really shouldn't be surprising that Bon Clay is alive when you think about it though if Magellen just beat him with his fists.
Law apparently needs to hide for some reason so is willing to do grunt work for CC until it becomes inconvenient. For some reason Law wants to talk/deal with Smoker on his own. Originally I thought Law was being black mailed by CC who was holding his crew hostage, but apparently Law is theire voluntarily and his crew are somewhere else. Interesting why he doesn't have his crew with hm. dude Arlong is dead Luffy kinda dropped a building on him Arlong's fate isn't clear. Not to mention plenty of people in One Piece have survived worse things than "dropping a building on them." Ace and Whitebeard are the best counter-examples for people complaining that no one dies in One Piece, so IDK why Arlong got brought up. actually there is also a bunch of people in flashbacks dying ;P
like Sabo
and Brook
|
On May 10 2012 10:56 Dac wrote:Show nested quote +On May 10 2012 10:53 Sentenal wrote:On May 10 2012 10:37 Forikorder wrote:On May 10 2012 10:21 BlackMagister wrote:
Arlong didn't die? Why did you bring him up? If you mean characters he killed, that happened in flash backs. One Piece yes doesn't use death of important characters very often which is fine by me. It really shouldn't be surprising that Bon Clay is alive when you think about it though if Magellen just beat him with his fists.
Law apparently needs to hide for some reason so is willing to do grunt work for CC until it becomes inconvenient. For some reason Law wants to talk/deal with Smoker on his own. Originally I thought Law was being black mailed by CC who was holding his crew hostage, but apparently Law is theire voluntarily and his crew are somewhere else. Interesting why he doesn't have his crew with hm. dude Arlong is dead Luffy kinda dropped a building on him Arlong's fate isn't clear. Not to mention plenty of people in One Piece have survived worse things than "dropping a building on them." Ace and Whitebeard are the best counter-examples for people complaining that no one dies in One Piece, so IDK why Arlong got brought up. actually there is also a bunch of people in flashbacks dying ;P
Yeah, in flashbacks. But the usual complaint is that "no one ever dies in the present". Pell was a great example of that, back in Alabasta. And until Ace/Whitebeard, that was true. Now it isn't.
|
I'm a big friggin' idiot for forgetting about Ace nad Whitebeard. But to be fair, Whitebeard was set up as the most powerful character in the world JUST so Oda could kill him off to showcase why Teach is so dangerous. WB was not really important to plot otherwise and we don't learn much else about him/feel anything for him.
As for Ace, VERY minor character until the Marineford Arc, and then, yeah, we do learn quite a bit about him and the past.
I suppose Oda can't be killing off characters left and right, but you'd think there'd be more deaths (both major and minor characters) in a manga going for 11 years.
+ Show Spoiler +Brownbeard just died though. Yay!
|
On May 10 2012 11:07 WaveofShadow wrote:I'm a big friggin' idiot for forgetting about Ace nad Whitebeard. But to be fair, Whitebeard was set up as the most powerful character in the world JUST so Oda could kill him off to showcase why Teach is so dangerous. WB was not really important to plot otherwise and we don't learn much else about him/feel anything for him. As for Ace, VERY minor character until the Marineford Arc, and then, yeah, we do learn quite a bit about him and the past. I suppose Oda can't be killing off characters left and right, but you'd think there'd be more deaths (both major and minor characters) in a manga going for 11 years. + Show Spoiler +Brownbeard just died though. Yay!
he probably didnt die
unless its a seinen manga theres pretty much never any death ever one piece bleach and naruto never have enyone die
|
On May 10 2012 11:09 Forikorder wrote:Show nested quote +On May 10 2012 11:07 WaveofShadow wrote:I'm a big friggin' idiot for forgetting about Ace nad Whitebeard. But to be fair, Whitebeard was set up as the most powerful character in the world JUST so Oda could kill him off to showcase why Teach is so dangerous. WB was not really important to plot otherwise and we don't learn much else about him/feel anything for him. As for Ace, VERY minor character until the Marineford Arc, and then, yeah, we do learn quite a bit about him and the past. I suppose Oda can't be killing off characters left and right, but you'd think there'd be more deaths (both major and minor characters) in a manga going for 11 years. + Show Spoiler +Brownbeard just died though. Yay! he probably didnt die unless its a seinen manga theres pretty much never any death ever one piece bleach and naruto never have enyone die
Bleach doesn't. Naruto kills off important and semi-important characters all the time. 3rd hokage, jiraiya... all the villains... that guy with the fists.
|
when they were talking to Hachi while he was in the cage at the fish riders base. He said that Arlong and the others go captured. He's probably at Impel Down or got executed we don't know. I'm sure that every single prisoner from level 1 to 5 didn't get released when luffy and the gang broke out. Also there is always the chance that Arlong died while in ID whether it was from Shiliew or naturally.
|
I guess if you take away flashbacks you can say people don't die, but to me, that logic doesn't really make sense. They still died in the manga... Robin's whole island population was killed, and that was really freaking sad.
But, Caribou's crew did die in the sea. Also, Pell was the eagle guy from Alabasta, right? I thought when he looked at his tombstone, he was actually a ghost realizing he was dead.
But, I guess you can argue that, outside of flashbacks, no one important dies. There are plenty of people dying in One Piece. The war of the strongest had so many casualties, and I doubt that all of the fishmen zoro attacked at Arlong Park survived. Or that no one in the Alabasta war died.
And didn't Vivi's partner from Baroque works die? He got exploded.
|
Nobody really dies in One Piece. That is a valid point really no matter what. A lot of no name characters are shown being killed or implied to have died. Flash back deaths yes, but many characters of the present go through things that should kill them, but do not.
Pell did not die either. That was confirmed even before the time skip
http://onepiece.wikia.com/wiki/Pell#After_the_War
Mr 9 did not die. He even got a panel page telling his post time skip status
http://onepiece.wikia.com/wiki/Mr._9#Two_Years_Later
|
On May 10 2012 12:22 Dark_Chill wrote:
I guess if you take away flashbacks you can say people don't die, but to me, that logic doesn't really make sense. They still died in the manga... Robin's whole island population was killed, and that was really freaking sad.
But, Caribou's crew did die in the sea. Also, Pell was the eagle guy from Alabasta, right? I thought when he looked at his tombstone, he was actually a ghost realizing he was dead.
But, I guess you can argue that, outside of flashbacks, no one important dies. There are plenty of people dying in One Piece. The war of the strongest had so many casualties, and I doubt that all of the fishmen zoro attacked at Arlong Park survived. Or that no one in the Alabasta war died.
And didn't Vivi's partner from Baroque works die? He got exploded.
Somewhat true. No.3 didn't die even though he got melted by Mallegan off-screen. Was pretty sure that was the last we'd see of him. Now he's on the front page lol.
|
Bon chan is alive whoppee. Fucking invincible.
|
On May 10 2012 12:22 Dark_Chill wrote:
I guess if you take away flashbacks you can say people don't die, but to me, that logic doesn't really make sense. They still died in the manga... Robin's whole island population was killed, and that was really freaking sad.
But, Caribou's crew did die in the sea. Also, Pell was the eagle guy from Alabasta, right? I thought when he looked at his tombstone, he was actually a ghost realizing he was dead.
But, I guess you can argue that, outside of flashbacks, no one important dies. There are plenty of people dying in One Piece. The war of the strongest had so many casualties, and I doubt that all of the fishmen zoro attacked at Arlong Park survived. Or that no one in the Alabasta war died.
And didn't Vivi's partner from Baroque works die? He got exploded.
Btw, I read somewhere Coribou isn't dead, the one whose ship exploded.
|
On May 10 2012 12:29 Heh_ wrote:Show nested quote +On May 10 2012 12:22 Dark_Chill wrote:
I guess if you take away flashbacks you can say people don't die, but to me, that logic doesn't really make sense. They still died in the manga... Robin's whole island population was killed, and that was really freaking sad.
But, Caribou's crew did die in the sea. Also, Pell was the eagle guy from Alabasta, right? I thought when he looked at his tombstone, he was actually a ghost realizing he was dead.
But, I guess you can argue that, outside of flashbacks, no one important dies. There are plenty of people dying in One Piece. The war of the strongest had so many casualties, and I doubt that all of the fishmen zoro attacked at Arlong Park survived. Or that no one in the Alabasta war died.
And didn't Vivi's partner from Baroque works die? He got exploded. Somewhat true. No.3 didn't die even though he got melted by Mallegan off-screen. Was pretty sure that was the last we'd see of him. Now he's on the front page lol.
Given that we didn't see his face, I think his face was melted.
|
On May 10 2012 13:41 killa_robot wrote:Show nested quote +On May 10 2012 12:29 Heh_ wrote:On May 10 2012 12:22 Dark_Chill wrote:
I guess if you take away flashbacks you can say people don't die, but to me, that logic doesn't really make sense. They still died in the manga... Robin's whole island population was killed, and that was really freaking sad.
But, Caribou's crew did die in the sea. Also, Pell was the eagle guy from Alabasta, right? I thought when he looked at his tombstone, he was actually a ghost realizing he was dead.
But, I guess you can argue that, outside of flashbacks, no one important dies. There are plenty of people dying in One Piece. The war of the strongest had so many casualties, and I doubt that all of the fishmen zoro attacked at Arlong Park survived. Or that no one in the Alabasta war died.
And didn't Vivi's partner from Baroque works die? He got exploded. Somewhat true. No.3 didn't die even though he got melted by Mallegan off-screen. Was pretty sure that was the last we'd see of him. Now he's on the front page lol. Given that we didn't see his face, I think his face was melted.
didnt N0.3 just get a fadeout instead of actually shown getting attacked? Magellan doesnt seem the type to kill in cold blood it took alot to really push him to actually start going into massacre mod which is why Luffy survived so since No.3 was the only prisoner left and was all alone im not surprised Magellan just immobilized him and threw him in a cell
|
You guys should reread the manga to get the facts right ...
Somewhat true. No.3 didn't die even though he got melted by Mallegan off-screen. Was pretty sure that was the last we'd see of him. Now he's on the front page lol.
didnt N0.3 just get a fadeout instead of actually shown getting attacked? Magellan doesnt seem the type to kill in cold blood it took alot to really push him to actually start going into massacre mod which is why Luffy survived so since No.3 was the only prisoner left and was all alone im not surprised Magellan just immobilized him and threw him in a cell
It's Mr.2 , Bon kurei , is mr. 2 !!!! , Mr.3 is now with Buggy.
On May 10 2012 10:57 Forikorder wrote:Show nested quote +On May 10 2012 10:56 Dac wrote:On May 10 2012 10:53 Sentenal wrote:On May 10 2012 10:37 Forikorder wrote:On May 10 2012 10:21 BlackMagister wrote:
Arlong didn't die? Why did you bring him up? If you mean characters he killed, that happened in flash backs. One Piece yes doesn't use death of important characters very often which is fine by me. It really shouldn't be surprising that Bon Clay is alive when you think about it though if Magellen just beat him with his fists.
Law apparently needs to hide for some reason so is willing to do grunt work for CC until it becomes inconvenient. For some reason Law wants to talk/deal with Smoker on his own. Originally I thought Law was being black mailed by CC who was holding his crew hostage, but apparently Law is theire voluntarily and his crew are somewhere else. Interesting why he doesn't have his crew with hm. dude Arlong is dead Luffy kinda dropped a building on him Arlong's fate isn't clear. Not to mention plenty of people in One Piece have survived worse things than "dropping a building on them." Ace and Whitebeard are the best counter-examples for people complaining that no one dies in One Piece, so IDK why Arlong got brought up. actually there is also a bunch of people in flashbacks dying ;P like Sabo and Brook
Sabo was never confirmed to be dead ... in OP people don't die by explosions ...
But, Caribou's crew did die in the sea.
Caribou's current crew is still alive. Dunno if he had a previous crew....
|
On May 10 2012 11:20 Gummy wrote:Show nested quote +On May 10 2012 11:09 Forikorder wrote:On May 10 2012 11:07 WaveofShadow wrote:I'm a big friggin' idiot for forgetting about Ace nad Whitebeard. But to be fair, Whitebeard was set up as the most powerful character in the world JUST so Oda could kill him off to showcase why Teach is so dangerous. WB was not really important to plot otherwise and we don't learn much else about him/feel anything for him. As for Ace, VERY minor character until the Marineford Arc, and then, yeah, we do learn quite a bit about him and the past. I suppose Oda can't be killing off characters left and right, but you'd think there'd be more deaths (both major and minor characters) in a manga going for 11 years. + Show Spoiler +Brownbeard just died though. Yay! he probably didnt die unless its a seinen manga theres pretty much never any death ever one piece bleach and naruto never have enyone die Bleach doesn't. Naruto kills off important and semi-important characters all the time. 3rd hokage, jiraiya... all the villains... that guy with the fists.
Two words: Edo Tensai
Nobody really dies in Naruto because they just get resurrected to form a super army anyway!
|
On May 10 2012 11:07 WaveofShadow wrote:I'm a big friggin' idiot for forgetting about Ace nad Whitebeard. But to be fair, Whitebeard was set up as the most powerful character in the world JUST so Oda could kill him off to showcase why Teach is so dangerous. WB was not really important to plot otherwise and we don't learn much else about him/feel anything for him. As for Ace, VERY minor character until the Marineford Arc, and then, yeah, we do learn quite a bit about him and the past. I suppose Oda can't be killing off characters left and right, but you'd think there'd be more deaths (both major and minor characters) in a manga going for 11 years. + Show Spoiler +Brownbeard just died though. Yay!
Whitebeard was about as important to the plot as characters get... Fishman Islands were under his protection, the whole war was because of dark dealings inside his own crew ( Teach's betrayal ).
|
On May 11 2012 01:12 LaughingTulkas wrote:Show nested quote +On May 10 2012 11:20 Gummy wrote:On May 10 2012 11:09 Forikorder wrote:On May 10 2012 11:07 WaveofShadow wrote:I'm a big friggin' idiot for forgetting about Ace nad Whitebeard. But to be fair, Whitebeard was set up as the most powerful character in the world JUST so Oda could kill him off to showcase why Teach is so dangerous. WB was not really important to plot otherwise and we don't learn much else about him/feel anything for him. As for Ace, VERY minor character until the Marineford Arc, and then, yeah, we do learn quite a bit about him and the past. I suppose Oda can't be killing off characters left and right, but you'd think there'd be more deaths (both major and minor characters) in a manga going for 11 years. + Show Spoiler +Brownbeard just died though. Yay! he probably didnt die unless its a seinen manga theres pretty much never any death ever one piece bleach and naruto never have enyone die Bleach doesn't. Naruto kills off important and semi-important characters all the time. 3rd hokage, jiraiya... all the villains... that guy with the fists. Two words: Edo Tensai Nobody really dies in Naruto because they just get resurrected to form a super army anyway!
They're still dead though, not really a true resurrection by any means.
|
|
|
Wow I didn't noticed it until just now ! Monet - Ceasar Clowns chick. She might be an Zoan user ...
check this : http://mangastream.com/read/one_piece/10761248/11
When we first saw her, she had wings instead of arms, but she seems to be able to transform them to normal arms ...
Is she some Bird Zoan ?
|
On May 11 2012 03:18 eaT_Mi_Lquid wrote:Wow I didn't noticed it until just now ! Monet - Ceasar Clowns chick. She might be an Zoan user ... check this : http://mangastream.com/read/one_piece/10761248/11When we first saw her, she had wings instead of arms, but she seems to be able to transform them to normal arms ... Is she some Bird Zoan ?
The way she appeared, I thought she might be another mythological zoan like Marco's phoenix. Moent looked a lot like the image of a harpy.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
