EPT[TV] HBO Game of Thrones - Page 1086
| Forum Index > Media & Entertainment |
All book discussion in this thread is now allowed. | ||
|
urboss
Austria1223 Posts
| ||
|
albis
United States652 Posts
| ||
|
Geo.Rion
7377 Posts
On April 20 2014 18:04 albis wrote: what about the band without banners bowman guy? Or the girl assisting bran, Meera Reed. And yigrette for that matter. All are super heroes at the bow and arrow. They each have like ridiculous accuracy. Would take those 3 into battle before i took the best swordman battle yes, but when peopl talk about best fighter, they usually mean in a 1v1 duel scenario, who would win. Archers dont really rank on those lists, since a duel between a swordsman and an archer would be the most boring thing ever, the archer has 1 shot, if the other dodges, deflects, GG. If not, GG | ||
|
FrogOfWar
Germany1406 Posts
On April 20 2014 15:29 urboss wrote: Something's strange about Beric Dondarrion: It seems that his eye didn't get restored during resurrection. If his organs do not get restored, how can he become resurrected in the first place? If someone stabs him in the liver, he will get resurrected and then he will die again because his liver isn't working. That would also suggest that he cannot fight in kamikaze style, because he could still get maimed permanently. But he it physically no different from other people, i.e. has no magical regenerating powers by himself, it is the fire god who resurrects him. I can imagine that the fire god restores everything that he needs to be alive and kicking (e.g. liver), but not everything needed to look pretty. | ||
|
Paperplane
Netherlands1823 Posts
On April 20 2014 15:29 urboss wrote: Something's strange about Beric Dondarrion: It seems that his eye didn't get restored during resurrection. If his organs do not get restored, how can he become resurrected in the first place? If someone stabs him in the liver, he will get resurrected and then he will die again because his liver isn't working. That would also suggest that he cannot fight in kamikaze style, because he could still get maimed permanently. The eye didn't get restored because an eyepatch makes you look cool. They had to give him some scars to show the resurrection isn't perfect and what's better than a scar that makes you look badass. | ||
|
misirlou
Portugal3308 Posts
| ||
|
icystorage
Jollibee19350 Posts
funniest shit in a while | ||
|
RPR_Tempest
Australia7799 Posts
One of the people he was referring to was Barristan. No question about that. I believe that the other two are The Mountain and The Hound. As for Bronn or whoever being able to take them, I dunno. Bronn was ready to fight two Kingsguard at once last season so he clearly is no slouch. But, he relies mainly on his smarts and I think if you were the just chuck him in a circular arena with either Clegane, he'd lose. Ned Stark was obviously a fantastic swordsman as well. I think people are overrating Drogo a bit, he's a beast but IIRC he has no experience battling trained, armored swordsmen. | ||
|
Edlina
Denmark28 Posts
On April 20 2014 18:13 Geo.Rion wrote: battle yes, but when peopl talk about best fighter, they usually mean in a 1v1 duel scenario, who would win. Archers dont really rank on those lists, since a duel between a swordsman and an archer would be the most boring thing ever, the archer has 1 shot, if the other dodges, deflects, GG. If not, GG Not necessarily just one shot... http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=2zGnxeSbb3g But agreed, the duel would be boring and archers are not really relevant to the discussion. | ||
|
goody153
44282 Posts
On April 20 2014 20:33 RPR_Tempest wrote: Jamie says (last season) there are three people who could possibly take him in a fight. Now obviously, he's talking present tense, so people like Ned and Khal Drogo are out. One of the people he was referring to was Barristan. No question about that. I believe that the other two are The Mountain and The Hound. As for Bronn or whoever being able to take them, I dunno. Bronn was ready to fight two Kingsguard at once last season so he clearly is no slouch. But, he relies mainly on his smarts and I think if you were the just chuck him in a circular arena with either Clegane, he'd lose. Ned Stark was obviously a fantastic swordsman as well. I think people are overrating Drogo a bit, he's a beast but IIRC he has no experience battling trained, armored swordsmen. Idk there are a lot of broken fighting style in where drogo grew up and to maintain dominance in that land would mean he is no joke. And as far as i remember the knights in westeros doesn't go YOLO 1 vs 1 all the time. While if IIRC dothrakis go YOLO 1v1 all the time and drogo is dominating at that. Although i would say Jaime is good but not the best. In westeros the hound and clegane definitely. | ||
|
FrogOfWar
Germany1406 Posts
| ||
|
Mensol
14536 Posts
On April 20 2014 21:14 FrogOfWar wrote: What about Joffrey? He killed a prostitute tied to a bedpost from a distance without taking a scratch. He also destroyed a book without taking a scratch. He is legit. | ||
|
Excludos
Norway8272 Posts
On April 20 2014 21:16 Mensol wrote: He also destroyed a book without taking a scratch. He is legit. He used valyrian steel. It doesn't count | ||
|
Vesimias
Finland135 Posts
On April 20 2014 20:33 RPR_Tempest wrote: Jamie says (last season) there are three people who could possibly take him in a fight. Now obviously, he's talking present tense, so people like Ned and Khal Drogo are out. One of the people he was referring to was Barristan. No question about that. I believe that the other two are The Mountain and The Hound. As for Bronn or whoever being able to take them, I dunno. Bronn was ready to fight two Kingsguard at once last season so he clearly is no slouch. But, he relies mainly on his smarts and I think if you were the just chuck him in a circular arena with either Clegane, he'd lose. Ned Stark was obviously a fantastic swordsman as well. I think people are overrating Drogo a bit, he's a beast but IIRC he has no experience battling trained, armored swordsmen. I'd like to add that the weapon Drogo uses (arakh I believe) is completely useless against an armored foe as Jorah stated in one of the past episodes. And him being a reckless Dothraki warrior, he wouldn't use a sword. He would have no chance against a great swordsman with armor. | ||
|
Geo.Rion
7377 Posts
On April 20 2014 21:51 Vesimias wrote: I'd like to add that the weapon Drogo uses (arakh I believe) is completely useless against an armored foe as Jorah stated in one of the past episodes. And him being a reckless Dothraki warrior, he wouldn't use a sword. He would have no chance against a great swordsman with armor. tbh, history has shown that armor is not enough, eastern tribes with mass light-cavalry time and time again humiliated western style heavily armored armies. And Arakhs might not penetrate breastplate, but those armors have weak points, plus u could disarm a warrior or get him down on his back, without scratching his armor. And then he s dead, pretty much | ||
|
Vesimias
Finland135 Posts
On April 20 2014 21:59 Geo.Rion wrote: tbh, history has shown that armor is not enough, eastern tribes with mass light-cavalry time and time again humiliated western style heavily armored armies. And Arakhs might not penetrate breastplate, but those armors have weak points, plus u could disarm a warrior or get him down on his back, without scratching his armor. And then he s dead, pretty much With cavalry they are much more useful for sure. I was thinking in 1on1 though. You have a point in that Drogo could probably bring a man down with his agility and skill, but I doubt he could disarm/bring down someone like Mountain for example. He's massive and wearing armor. You could argue though that Mountain wouldn't be able to land a hit on Drogo because he's slow. It's debatable. | ||
|
Zandar
Netherlands1541 Posts
On April 20 2014 18:04 albis wrote: what about the band without banners bowman guy? Or the girl assisting bran, Meera Reed. And yigrette for that matter. All are super heroes at the bow and arrow. They each have like ridiculous accuracy. Would take those 3 into battle before i took the best swordman And the blackfish, Catelyns uncle, he seems to be one of those insanely accurate archers too | ||
|
hzflank
United Kingdom2991 Posts
On April 20 2014 20:33 RPR_Tempest wrote: Jamie says (last season) there are three people who could possibly take him in a fight. Now obviously, he's talking present tense, so people like Ned and Khal Drogo are out. One of the people he was referring to was Barristan. No question about that. I believe that the other two are The Mountain and The Hound. As for Bronn or whoever being able to take them, I dunno. Bronn was ready to fight two Kingsguard at once last season so he clearly is no slouch. But, he relies mainly on his smarts and I think if you were the just chuck him in a circular arena with either Clegane, he'd lose. Ned Stark was obviously a fantastic swordsman as well. I think people are overrating Drogo a bit, he's a beast but IIRC he has no experience battling trained, armored swordsmen. That was Jaime's own opinion. It is like Huk saying he has top 3 control  | ||
|
fartosis77
Belgium461 Posts
On April 20 2014 17:36 urboss wrote: Sometimes holidays cause a broadcast to be scheduled a week later iirc. Is this the same for Easter? Thanks. | ||
|
hugman
Sweden4644 Posts
On April 20 2014 15:29 urboss wrote: Something's strange about Beric Dondarrion: It seems that his eye didn't get restored during resurrection. If his organs do not get restored, how can he become resurrected in the first place? If someone stabs him in the liver, he will get resurrected and then he will die again because his liver isn't working. That would also suggest that he cannot fight in kamikaze style, because he could still get maimed permanently. Regarding the liver, do we ever see him eat? Maybe he's just a weird reanimated thing and not really alive. | ||
| ||
