• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 06:49
CET 12:49
KST 20:49
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11[ASL22] Ro16 Preview: Holy Diver5
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over0Dark completes military service, returns to SC212[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 Serral's getting trashed by New Catsle's Mind Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?
Tourneys
RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
List of top players active on ShieldBattery BW General Discussion NaDa's Body Shield Battery Server New Patch BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/
Tourneys
[IPSL] Winter 26-27 Round of 16! [Megathread] Daily Proleagues 2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players [$1250] International ShieldBattery League
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc Nintendo Switch Thread List of Game Threads The PlayStation 5
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine Trading/Investing Thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 MLB/Baseball 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Socialism Anyone?
GreenHorizons
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 12471 users

Simple Questions, Simple Answers - Page 11

Forum Index > Diablo 3
Post a Reply
Prev 1 9 10 11 12 13 90 Next
VoirDire
Profile Joined February 2009
Sweden1923 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-09-21 19:30:54
September 21 2011 19:29 GMT
#201
On September 21 2011 20:36 NeoLearner wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 21 2011 20:26 VoirDire wrote:
On September 21 2011 19:48 NeoLearner wrote:
On September 21 2011 19:31 VoirDire wrote:
With monk and the barbarian, there's a balance between fast and slow weapons of equal dps: where fast weapons generate resources (rage/spirit) faster due to more skills being used per time, slow weapons do more damage per spent resource.

Demon hunter on the other hand, has no resource generating skill as far as I can see. Instead their resource (hatred) regenerate over time. Wouldn't it be pointless with a fast shooting weapon for a demon hunter as that would only drain their resource faster without increasing the damage output? Am I missing something?

It's the same trade off in D2.

If the weapon used has a useful "on hit" modifier or the skill has a debuff effect, fast hitting weapons will cause it to trigger faster and on more enemies.

If the skill has a flat damage increase, faster hitting weapons will cause more DPS because of it.

In case of low hit point enemies, the "overkill" from high damage (2 handed) weapons is useless. Thus, fast hitting weapons would make more sense for smaller enemies.

Dual wielding weapons can have twice the amount of modifiers, for example Increased total damage.

It's the same trade off in D2.
In d2, basically everyone had mana steal on their weapons so the regen vs spending wasn't an issue. You could basically spam the skill of your choice as much as you wanted with enough mana steal.

If the weapon used has a useful "on hit" modifier or the skill has a debuff effect, fast hitting weapons will cause it to trigger faster and on more enemies.
True, but that would make the demon hunter very weapon dependent

If the skill has a flat damage increase, faster hitting weapons will cause more DPS because of it.
Doesn't apply. The DH has no skills which add flat weapon damage.

In case of low hit point enemies, the "overkill" from high damage (2 handed) weapons is useless. Thus, fast hitting weapons would make more sense for smaller enemies.

True. But on the other hand since heavier hitting weapons do more damage on the initial hit, they will be ahead in the damage curve. DPS doesn't factor in that the initial hit has no delay.

Dual wielding weapons can have twice the amount of modifiers, for example Increased total damage.
This is true, but blizzard usually try to balance that by making the modifiers of 2h weapons more potent.

My point still remains. If the DH regens 10 per second and wishes to use multi shot (30 hatred) as their main skill. They will only be able to sustain 3.33 shots per second, regardless of weapon speed.

Sorry, I thought we were brainstorming on whether you might have missed something. I wasn't making a point at all.

The overkilling still stands, DPS is just the damage you will do per second when hitting a wall of infinite health points.
Example: Your big 2 handed weapon does 30 damage in 1.5 seconds (DPS = 20). Your 1 handed 1 does 10 damage in 1 second (DPS = 10). There are 10 enemies with 10 health each.
Both weapons need 10 hits, but the one handed weapon will do it in 10 seconds while the 2 handed needs 15. If you check the DPS over the complete group, DPS of the one handed weapon is higher.

You are completely right about the hatred cost though, a faster hitting weapon will deplete it's hatred faster. I presume that's one of the points they will be changing when they talked about reordening the Demon Hunter's skills a bit?

I'm sorry too, good sir. I misunderstood you. I think your presumption about blizz reordering DH skills is correct too. I just hope it's enough to balance the use of fast/slow weapons of the class.

Your point about overkilling indeed remains. But so does the point about hard hitting weapons being a few steps ahead in the damage over time graph. They counter-balance each other.

In your example, you are indeed correct that potential damage will be wasted in overkill. But let me make another example in which a little more sturdy monster requires between 3 and10 hits to kill depending on weapon type.

+ Show Spoiler +

Lets say that our monster has 100 hp and we have 2 weapons with the same DPS: One faster but lighter hitting weapon (Fast) that does 10 damage and hits once every second, and one slower but heavier hitting weapon (Slow) that does 40 damage and hits every 4th second. Both weapons have the raw DPS of 10 (damage / attack delay in seconds = 10 damage per second).

But a weapon with x dps doesn't necessarily kill a monster with t*x hp in t seconds. This is because we get the first hit in every fight "for free" before weapon cool down and dps calculation begins.

If we were to draw a graph with "HP left on monster on one axis" and "time" on the other with our previously defined Fast and Slow weapons, it will show that the slow weapon will kill the monster in less time, even considering overkill.

Time: x seconds since fight begun.
Monster HP left with fast weapon in time(x)
Monster HP left with slow weapon in time(x)

Time: 0 seconds.
Fast: 90hp left.
Slow: 60hp left

Time: 1 seconds.
Fast: 80hp left.
Slow: 60hp left

Time: 2 seconds.
Fast: 70hp left.
Slow: 60hp left

Time: 3 seconds.
Fast: 60hp left.
Slow: 60hp left

Time: 4 seconds.
Fast: 50hp left.
Slow: 20hp left

Time: 5 seconds.
Fast: 40hp left.
Slow: 20hp left

Time: 6 seconds.
Fast: 30hp left.
Slow: 20hp left

Time: 7 seconds.
Fast: 20hp left.
Slow: 20hp left

Time: 8 seconds.
Fast: 10hp left.
Slow: 0hp left (20 damage wasted in overkill)

Time: 9 seconds.
Fast: 0hp left.
Slow: still 0hp left

The "true" dps is something like:

Monster total HP / ( [hits required to kill monster-1] * [weapon attack delay] )

For Fast, it takes 9 seconds to kill a monster with 100 hp, making the true "dps" 11.11

100 / ((10-1)*1) = 11.11 dps

For Slow, it takes 8 seconds to kill a monster with 100 hp, making the "true" dps 12.5.

100 / (3-1)*4 = 12.5 dps.


There are off course situations where the initial hit advantage doesn't doesn't compensate for the damage lost in overkill. But I would chose a slower, heavier hitting weapon over a faster weapon with the same DPS in most situations due to the fact that every time you take a break in your fight longer than the attack delay (for moving, using other skills, fleeing etc) you gain the initial hit advantage once more.
andrewlt
Profile Joined August 2009
United States7702 Posts
September 21 2011 19:42 GMT
#202
On September 21 2011 19:48 NeoLearner wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 21 2011 19:31 VoirDire wrote:
With monk and the barbarian, there's a balance between fast and slow weapons of equal dps: where fast weapons generate resources (rage/spirit) faster due to more skills being used per time, slow weapons do more damage per spent resource.

Demon hunter on the other hand, has no resource generating skill as far as I can see. Instead their resource (hatred) regenerate over time. Wouldn't it be pointless with a fast shooting weapon for a demon hunter as that would only drain their resource faster without increasing the damage output? Am I missing something?

It's the same trade off in D2.

If the weapon used has a useful "on hit" modifier or the skill has a debuff effect, fast hitting weapons will cause it to trigger faster and on more enemies.

If the skill has a flat damage increase, faster hitting weapons will cause more DPS because of it.

In case of low hit point enemies, the "overkill" from high damage (2 handed) weapons is useless. Thus, fast hitting weapons would make more sense for smaller enemies.

Dual wielding weapons can have twice the amount of modifiers, for example Increased total damage.



Keep in mind this isn't Blizzard North anymore. Procs were changed in WoW so that the % chance scales with weapon speed. They may or may not have done the same with Diablo 3 to balance out faster vs slower weapons.
perser84
Profile Joined October 2010
Germany399 Posts
September 22 2011 12:11 GMT
#203
i dont find the quest where you must hold off the monster hordes for 2 min quest

where is it ?
NeoLearner
Profile Blog Joined January 2010
Belgium1847 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-09-22 12:19:17
September 22 2011 12:18 GMT
#204
On September 22 2011 21:11 perser84 wrote:
i dont find the quest where you must hold off the monster hordes for 2 min quest

where is it ?

The event is called "The Jar of Souls".

It seems to be a random event, so it's not in every playthrough. So I would suggest to start a new one and look for it again. You should find it in one of the defiled crypts in the cemetery.

Oketh @ Blizzard Forums:
Random event in one of the three crypts. Run some Shattered Crowns and it'll pop if you do full clears.

But I don't know what that means.

EDIT: Changed "somerandomguy"s name to his real name.
Bankai - Correlation does not imply causation
Xedat
Profile Joined October 2010
Germany358 Posts
September 22 2011 13:43 GMT
#205
On September 22 2011 04:29 VoirDire wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 21 2011 20:36 NeoLearner wrote:
On September 21 2011 20:26 VoirDire wrote:
On September 21 2011 19:48 NeoLearner wrote:
On September 21 2011 19:31 VoirDire wrote:
With monk and the barbarian, there's a balance between fast and slow weapons of equal dps: where fast weapons generate resources (rage/spirit) faster due to more skills being used per time, slow weapons do more damage per spent resource.

Demon hunter on the other hand, has no resource generating skill as far as I can see. Instead their resource (hatred) regenerate over time. Wouldn't it be pointless with a fast shooting weapon for a demon hunter as that would only drain their resource faster without increasing the damage output? Am I missing something?

It's the same trade off in D2.

If the weapon used has a useful "on hit" modifier or the skill has a debuff effect, fast hitting weapons will cause it to trigger faster and on more enemies.

If the skill has a flat damage increase, faster hitting weapons will cause more DPS because of it.

In case of low hit point enemies, the "overkill" from high damage (2 handed) weapons is useless. Thus, fast hitting weapons would make more sense for smaller enemies.

Dual wielding weapons can have twice the amount of modifiers, for example Increased total damage.

It's the same trade off in D2.
In d2, basically everyone had mana steal on their weapons so the regen vs spending wasn't an issue. You could basically spam the skill of your choice as much as you wanted with enough mana steal.

If the weapon used has a useful "on hit" modifier or the skill has a debuff effect, fast hitting weapons will cause it to trigger faster and on more enemies.
True, but that would make the demon hunter very weapon dependent

If the skill has a flat damage increase, faster hitting weapons will cause more DPS because of it.
Doesn't apply. The DH has no skills which add flat weapon damage.

In case of low hit point enemies, the "overkill" from high damage (2 handed) weapons is useless. Thus, fast hitting weapons would make more sense for smaller enemies.

True. But on the other hand since heavier hitting weapons do more damage on the initial hit, they will be ahead in the damage curve. DPS doesn't factor in that the initial hit has no delay.

Dual wielding weapons can have twice the amount of modifiers, for example Increased total damage.
This is true, but blizzard usually try to balance that by making the modifiers of 2h weapons more potent.

My point still remains. If the DH regens 10 per second and wishes to use multi shot (30 hatred) as their main skill. They will only be able to sustain 3.33 shots per second, regardless of weapon speed.

Sorry, I thought we were brainstorming on whether you might have missed something. I wasn't making a point at all.

The overkilling still stands, DPS is just the damage you will do per second when hitting a wall of infinite health points.
Example: Your big 2 handed weapon does 30 damage in 1.5 seconds (DPS = 20). Your 1 handed 1 does 10 damage in 1 second (DPS = 10). There are 10 enemies with 10 health each.
Both weapons need 10 hits, but the one handed weapon will do it in 10 seconds while the 2 handed needs 15. If you check the DPS over the complete group, DPS of the one handed weapon is higher.

You are completely right about the hatred cost though, a faster hitting weapon will deplete it's hatred faster. I presume that's one of the points they will be changing when they talked about reordening the Demon Hunter's skills a bit?

I'm sorry too, good sir. I misunderstood you. I think your presumption about blizz reordering DH skills is correct too. I just hope it's enough to balance the use of fast/slow weapons of the class.

Your point about overkilling indeed remains. But so does the point about hard hitting weapons being a few steps ahead in the damage over time graph. They counter-balance each other.

In your example, you are indeed correct that potential damage will be wasted in overkill. But let me make another example in which a little more sturdy monster requires between 3 and10 hits to kill depending on weapon type.

+ Show Spoiler +

Lets say that our monster has 100 hp and we have 2 weapons with the same DPS: One faster but lighter hitting weapon (Fast) that does 10 damage and hits once every second, and one slower but heavier hitting weapon (Slow) that does 40 damage and hits every 4th second. Both weapons have the raw DPS of 10 (damage / attack delay in seconds = 10 damage per second).

But a weapon with x dps doesn't necessarily kill a monster with t*x hp in t seconds. This is because we get the first hit in every fight "for free" before weapon cool down and dps calculation begins.

If we were to draw a graph with "HP left on monster on one axis" and "time" on the other with our previously defined Fast and Slow weapons, it will show that the slow weapon will kill the monster in less time, even considering overkill.

Time: x seconds since fight begun.
Monster HP left with fast weapon in time(x)
Monster HP left with slow weapon in time(x)

Time: 0 seconds.
Fast: 90hp left.
Slow: 60hp left

Time: 1 seconds.
Fast: 80hp left.
Slow: 60hp left

Time: 2 seconds.
Fast: 70hp left.
Slow: 60hp left

Time: 3 seconds.
Fast: 60hp left.
Slow: 60hp left

Time: 4 seconds.
Fast: 50hp left.
Slow: 20hp left

Time: 5 seconds.
Fast: 40hp left.
Slow: 20hp left

Time: 6 seconds.
Fast: 30hp left.
Slow: 20hp left

Time: 7 seconds.
Fast: 20hp left.
Slow: 20hp left

Time: 8 seconds.
Fast: 10hp left.
Slow: 0hp left (20 damage wasted in overkill)

Time: 9 seconds.
Fast: 0hp left.
Slow: still 0hp left

The "true" dps is something like:

Monster total HP / ( [hits required to kill monster-1] * [weapon attack delay] )

For Fast, it takes 9 seconds to kill a monster with 100 hp, making the true "dps" 11.11

100 / ((10-1)*1) = 11.11 dps

For Slow, it takes 8 seconds to kill a monster with 100 hp, making the "true" dps 12.5.

100 / (3-1)*4 = 12.5 dps.


There are off course situations where the initial hit advantage doesn't doesn't compensate for the damage lost in overkill. But I would chose a slower, heavier hitting weapon over a faster weapon with the same DPS in most situations due to the fact that every time you take a break in your fight longer than the attack delay (for moving, using other skills, fleeing etc) you gain the initial hit advantage once more.


Your calculation is right, also at second 9 while the faster weapon killed the first target you already would have damaged the next target with the slower weapon.
Did I understand it correctly that skills in D3 have a "cooldown" that is tied to your weapon speed? So the Barbarian can use cleave as many times per second as the attack speed of his mainhand weapon allows him to do normal attacks? And the WD and Wizard have a casting speed spell? Or is the casting speed also bound to the attackspeed of their weapon?
Ender.bg
Profile Joined January 2011
Bulgaria20 Posts
September 22 2011 15:14 GMT
#206
Is there going to be any restrictions for playing Co-Op with people, like region locking in Sc2, or you'd be able to play cross server regardless of ping ?
Junichi
Profile Joined January 2011
Germany1056 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-09-22 15:54:16
September 22 2011 15:53 GMT
#207
Is it known how much of the first act is included in the beta? Or is that already the complete first act?
"Until the very, very top, in almost anything all that matters, is how much work you put in. The only problem is that most people can't work hard even at things they do enjoy, much less things they don't have a real passion for." - Greg "IdrA" Fields
biomech
Profile Joined April 2010
Germany380 Posts
September 22 2011 16:05 GMT
#208
On September 23 2011 00:53 Junichi wrote:
Is it known how much of the first act is included in the beta? Or is that already the complete first act?

It's a rather small part of act 1, until the Skeleton king. Not the complete first act.
trainRiderJ
Profile Joined August 2010
United States615 Posts
September 22 2011 16:12 GMT
#209
On September 23 2011 00:53 Junichi wrote:
Is it known how much of the first act is included in the beta? Or is that already the complete first act?

Supposedly it's roughly one-third of the first act.
skyR
Profile Joined July 2009
Canada13817 Posts
September 23 2011 00:37 GMT
#210
Is there going to be enhancement scrolls or anything similar to the enchantment scrolls found in WoW? ex. you can enchant a scroll and put it up on the auction house or give it to another character on the same account to use.
VoirDire
Profile Joined February 2009
Sweden1923 Posts
September 23 2011 01:12 GMT
#211
On September 22 2011 22:43 Xedat wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 22 2011 04:29 VoirDire wrote:
On September 21 2011 20:36 NeoLearner wrote:
On September 21 2011 20:26 VoirDire wrote:
On September 21 2011 19:48 NeoLearner wrote:
On September 21 2011 19:31 VoirDire wrote:
With monk and the barbarian, there's a balance between fast and slow weapons of equal dps: where fast weapons generate resources (rage/spirit) faster due to more skills being used per time, slow weapons do more damage per spent resource.

Demon hunter on the other hand, has no resource generating skill as far as I can see. Instead their resource (hatred) regenerate over time. Wouldn't it be pointless with a fast shooting weapon for a demon hunter as that would only drain their resource faster without increasing the damage output? Am I missing something?

It's the same trade off in D2.

If the weapon used has a useful "on hit" modifier or the skill has a debuff effect, fast hitting weapons will cause it to trigger faster and on more enemies.

If the skill has a flat damage increase, faster hitting weapons will cause more DPS because of it.

In case of low hit point enemies, the "overkill" from high damage (2 handed) weapons is useless. Thus, fast hitting weapons would make more sense for smaller enemies.

Dual wielding weapons can have twice the amount of modifiers, for example Increased total damage.

It's the same trade off in D2.
In d2, basically everyone had mana steal on their weapons so the regen vs spending wasn't an issue. You could basically spam the skill of your choice as much as you wanted with enough mana steal.

If the weapon used has a useful "on hit" modifier or the skill has a debuff effect, fast hitting weapons will cause it to trigger faster and on more enemies.
True, but that would make the demon hunter very weapon dependent

If the skill has a flat damage increase, faster hitting weapons will cause more DPS because of it.
Doesn't apply. The DH has no skills which add flat weapon damage.

In case of low hit point enemies, the "overkill" from high damage (2 handed) weapons is useless. Thus, fast hitting weapons would make more sense for smaller enemies.

True. But on the other hand since heavier hitting weapons do more damage on the initial hit, they will be ahead in the damage curve. DPS doesn't factor in that the initial hit has no delay.

Dual wielding weapons can have twice the amount of modifiers, for example Increased total damage.
This is true, but blizzard usually try to balance that by making the modifiers of 2h weapons more potent.

My point still remains. If the DH regens 10 per second and wishes to use multi shot (30 hatred) as their main skill. They will only be able to sustain 3.33 shots per second, regardless of weapon speed.

Sorry, I thought we were brainstorming on whether you might have missed something. I wasn't making a point at all.

The overkilling still stands, DPS is just the damage you will do per second when hitting a wall of infinite health points.
Example: Your big 2 handed weapon does 30 damage in 1.5 seconds (DPS = 20). Your 1 handed 1 does 10 damage in 1 second (DPS = 10). There are 10 enemies with 10 health each.
Both weapons need 10 hits, but the one handed weapon will do it in 10 seconds while the 2 handed needs 15. If you check the DPS over the complete group, DPS of the one handed weapon is higher.

You are completely right about the hatred cost though, a faster hitting weapon will deplete it's hatred faster. I presume that's one of the points they will be changing when they talked about reordening the Demon Hunter's skills a bit?

I'm sorry too, good sir. I misunderstood you. I think your presumption about blizz reordering DH skills is correct too. I just hope it's enough to balance the use of fast/slow weapons of the class.

Your point about overkilling indeed remains. But so does the point about hard hitting weapons being a few steps ahead in the damage over time graph. They counter-balance each other.

In your example, you are indeed correct that potential damage will be wasted in overkill. But let me make another example in which a little more sturdy monster requires between 3 and10 hits to kill depending on weapon type.

+ Show Spoiler +

Lets say that our monster has 100 hp and we have 2 weapons with the same DPS: One faster but lighter hitting weapon (Fast) that does 10 damage and hits once every second, and one slower but heavier hitting weapon (Slow) that does 40 damage and hits every 4th second. Both weapons have the raw DPS of 10 (damage / attack delay in seconds = 10 damage per second).

But a weapon with x dps doesn't necessarily kill a monster with t*x hp in t seconds. This is because we get the first hit in every fight "for free" before weapon cool down and dps calculation begins.

If we were to draw a graph with "HP left on monster on one axis" and "time" on the other with our previously defined Fast and Slow weapons, it will show that the slow weapon will kill the monster in less time, even considering overkill.

Time: x seconds since fight begun.
Monster HP left with fast weapon in time(x)
Monster HP left with slow weapon in time(x)

Time: 0 seconds.
Fast: 90hp left.
Slow: 60hp left

Time: 1 seconds.
Fast: 80hp left.
Slow: 60hp left

Time: 2 seconds.
Fast: 70hp left.
Slow: 60hp left

Time: 3 seconds.
Fast: 60hp left.
Slow: 60hp left

Time: 4 seconds.
Fast: 50hp left.
Slow: 20hp left

Time: 5 seconds.
Fast: 40hp left.
Slow: 20hp left

Time: 6 seconds.
Fast: 30hp left.
Slow: 20hp left

Time: 7 seconds.
Fast: 20hp left.
Slow: 20hp left

Time: 8 seconds.
Fast: 10hp left.
Slow: 0hp left (20 damage wasted in overkill)

Time: 9 seconds.
Fast: 0hp left.
Slow: still 0hp left

The "true" dps is something like:

Monster total HP / ( [hits required to kill monster-1] * [weapon attack delay] )

For Fast, it takes 9 seconds to kill a monster with 100 hp, making the true "dps" 11.11

100 / ((10-1)*1) = 11.11 dps

For Slow, it takes 8 seconds to kill a monster with 100 hp, making the "true" dps 12.5.

100 / (3-1)*4 = 12.5 dps.


There are off course situations where the initial hit advantage doesn't doesn't compensate for the damage lost in overkill. But I would chose a slower, heavier hitting weapon over a faster weapon with the same DPS in most situations due to the fact that every time you take a break in your fight longer than the attack delay (for moving, using other skills, fleeing etc) you gain the initial hit advantage once more.


Your calculation is right, also at second 9 while the faster weapon killed the first target you already would have damaged the next target with the slower weapon.
Did I understand it correctly that skills in D3 have a "cooldown" that is tied to your weapon speed? So the Barbarian can use cleave as many times per second as the attack speed of his mainhand weapon allows him to do normal attacks? And the WD and Wizard have a casting speed spell? Or is the casting speed also bound to the attackspeed of their weapon?

From what I've understood it works the same as in diablo 2, i.e. Spell casters have a global casting speed that affects all spells which have no set cool-down. The global casting speed can be modified by "+Casting Speed" items.

While we're on the subject of weaponspeed for DH. Their class specific weapons, hand crossbows, all have a comparatively high attack rate of 1.8 for the highest level. The crossbows have 1.0 and the bows have 1.4.

http://us.battle.net/d3/en/item/hand-crossbow/

I hope there are some incentive for using fast attacking weapons.
VoirDire
Profile Joined February 2009
Sweden1923 Posts
September 23 2011 01:38 GMT
#212
On September 23 2011 09:37 skyR wrote:
Is there going to be enhancement scrolls or anything similar to the enchantment scrolls found in WoW? ex. you can enchant a scroll and put it up on the auction house or give it to another character on the same account to use.

Good question. I'd like to know if you can somehow trade enchants (or other artisan services) myself.

From what I gather, you can find plans for enchantments that you can teach to your mystic (or sell in the AH), and you can obviously sell the end product (i.e. an enchanted item). But I don't know if you somehow can lend your artisan's services to other players. It doesn't seem like it, but it would be a nice feature.

Another question. Is there even a trade window for use between players in-game, like there was in d2?
Bigpon86
Profile Blog Joined September 2009
United States238 Posts
September 23 2011 02:12 GMT
#213
What does +armor on gear do? I know +defense stat reduces damage taken, does +armor just improve your dodge chance?
This is my quote.
skyR
Profile Joined July 2009
Canada13817 Posts
September 23 2011 02:32 GMT
#214
On September 23 2011 10:38 VoirDire wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 23 2011 09:37 skyR wrote:
Is there going to be enhancement scrolls or anything similar to the enchantment scrolls found in WoW? ex. you can enchant a scroll and put it up on the auction house or give it to another character on the same account to use.

Good question. I'd like to know if you can somehow trade enchants (or other artisan services) myself.

From what I gather, you can find plans for enchantments that you can teach to your mystic (or sell in the AH), and you can obviously sell the end product (i.e. an enchanted item). But I don't know if you somehow can lend your artisan's services to other players. It doesn't seem like it, but it would be a nice feature.

Another question. Is there even a trade window for use between players in-game, like there was in d2?


Ya there is a trade window, it's been mentioned here and there.

I don't think enhancements are unique or else that would be super dumb ><
VoirDire
Profile Joined February 2009
Sweden1923 Posts
September 23 2011 02:58 GMT
#215
On September 23 2011 11:12 Bigpon86 wrote:
What does +armor on gear do? I know +defense stat reduces damage taken, does +armor just improve your dodge chance?

Defense reduces all damage taken while resists reduces magical damage taken. It would be logical to assume that armor would reduce physical damage. Especially since there is no "attack rating" or "to hit", precision only affects crit chance.

Not 100% sure though. If someone can confirm this, please do.
VoirDire
Profile Joined February 2009
Sweden1923 Posts
September 23 2011 03:18 GMT
#216
On September 22 2011 04:29 VoirDire wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 21 2011 20:36 NeoLearner wrote:
On September 21 2011 20:26 VoirDire wrote:
On September 21 2011 19:48 NeoLearner wrote:
On September 21 2011 19:31 VoirDire wrote:
With monk and the barbarian, there's a balance between fast and slow weapons of equal dps: where fast weapons generate resources (rage/spirit) faster due to more skills being used per time, slow weapons do more damage per spent resource.

Demon hunter on the other hand, has no resource generating skill as far as I can see. Instead their resource (hatred) regenerate over time. Wouldn't it be pointless with a fast shooting weapon for a demon hunter as that would only drain their resource faster without increasing the damage output? Am I missing something?

It's the same trade off in D2.

If the weapon used has a useful "on hit" modifier or the skill has a debuff effect, fast hitting weapons will cause it to trigger faster and on more enemies.

If the skill has a flat damage increase, faster hitting weapons will cause more DPS because of it.

In case of low hit point enemies, the "overkill" from high damage (2 handed) weapons is useless. Thus, fast hitting weapons would make more sense for smaller enemies.

Dual wielding weapons can have twice the amount of modifiers, for example Increased total damage.

It's the same trade off in D2.
In d2, basically everyone had mana steal on their weapons so the regen vs spending wasn't an issue. You could basically spam the skill of your choice as much as you wanted with enough mana steal.

If the weapon used has a useful "on hit" modifier or the skill has a debuff effect, fast hitting weapons will cause it to trigger faster and on more enemies.
True, but that would make the demon hunter very weapon dependent

If the skill has a flat damage increase, faster hitting weapons will cause more DPS because of it.
Doesn't apply. The DH has no skills which add flat weapon damage.

In case of low hit point enemies, the "overkill" from high damage (2 handed) weapons is useless. Thus, fast hitting weapons would make more sense for smaller enemies.

True. But on the other hand since heavier hitting weapons do more damage on the initial hit, they will be ahead in the damage curve. DPS doesn't factor in that the initial hit has no delay.

Dual wielding weapons can have twice the amount of modifiers, for example Increased total damage.
This is true, but blizzard usually try to balance that by making the modifiers of 2h weapons more potent.

My point still remains. If the DH regens 10 per second and wishes to use multi shot (30 hatred) as their main skill. They will only be able to sustain 3.33 shots per second, regardless of weapon speed.

Sorry, I thought we were brainstorming on whether you might have missed something. I wasn't making a point at all.

The overkilling still stands, DPS is just the damage you will do per second when hitting a wall of infinite health points.
Example: Your big 2 handed weapon does 30 damage in 1.5 seconds (DPS = 20). Your 1 handed 1 does 10 damage in 1 second (DPS = 10). There are 10 enemies with 10 health each.
Both weapons need 10 hits, but the one handed weapon will do it in 10 seconds while the 2 handed needs 15. If you check the DPS over the complete group, DPS of the one handed weapon is higher.

You are completely right about the hatred cost though, a faster hitting weapon will deplete it's hatred faster. I presume that's one of the points they will be changing when they talked about reordening the Demon Hunter's skills a bit?

I'm sorry too, good sir. I misunderstood you. I think your presumption about blizz reordering DH skills is correct too. I just hope it's enough to balance the use of fast/slow weapons of the class.

Your point about overkilling indeed remains. But so does the point about hard hitting weapons being a few steps ahead in the damage over time graph. They counter-balance each other.

In your example, you are indeed correct that potential damage will be wasted in overkill. But let me make another example in which a little more sturdy monster requires between 3 and10 hits to kill depending on weapon type.

+ Show Spoiler +

Lets say that our monster has 100 hp and we have 2 weapons with the same DPS: One faster but lighter hitting weapon (Fast) that does 10 damage and hits once every second, and one slower but heavier hitting weapon (Slow) that does 40 damage and hits every 4th second. Both weapons have the raw DPS of 10 (damage / attack delay in seconds = 10 damage per second).

But a weapon with x dps doesn't necessarily kill a monster with t*x hp in t seconds. This is because we get the first hit in every fight "for free" before weapon cool down and dps calculation begins.

If we were to draw a graph with "HP left on monster on one axis" and "time" on the other with our previously defined Fast and Slow weapons, it will show that the slow weapon will kill the monster in less time, even considering overkill.

Time: x seconds since fight begun.
Monster HP left with fast weapon in time(x)
Monster HP left with slow weapon in time(x)

Time: 0 seconds.
Fast: 90hp left.
Slow: 60hp left

Time: 1 seconds.
Fast: 80hp left.
Slow: 60hp left

Time: 2 seconds.
Fast: 70hp left.
Slow: 60hp left

Time: 3 seconds.
Fast: 60hp left.
Slow: 60hp left

Time: 4 seconds.
Fast: 50hp left.
Slow: 20hp left

Time: 5 seconds.
Fast: 40hp left.
Slow: 20hp left

Time: 6 seconds.
Fast: 30hp left.
Slow: 20hp left

Time: 7 seconds.
Fast: 20hp left.
Slow: 20hp left

Time: 8 seconds.
Fast: 10hp left.
Slow: 0hp left (20 damage wasted in overkill)

Time: 9 seconds.
Fast: 0hp left.
Slow: still 0hp left

The "true" dps is something like:

Monster total HP / ( [hits required to kill monster-1] * [weapon attack delay] )

For Fast, it takes 9 seconds to kill a monster with 100 hp, making the true "dps" 11.11

100 / ((10-1)*1) = 11.11 dps

For Slow, it takes 8 seconds to kill a monster with 100 hp, making the "true" dps 12.5.

100 / (3-1)*4 = 12.5 dps.


There are off course situations where the initial hit advantage doesn't doesn't compensate for the damage lost in overkill. But I would chose a slower, heavier hitting weapon over a faster weapon with the same DPS in most situations due to the fact that every time you take a break in your fight longer than the attack delay (for moving, using other skills, fleeing etc) you gain the initial hit advantage once more.

Just an update on the situation. Blizzard acknowledged the problem and demon hunters now have spending and generating skills, much like the the monk and the barbarian.

http://us.battle.net/d3/en/class/demon-hunter/active/
NeoLearner
Profile Blog Joined January 2010
Belgium1847 Posts
September 23 2011 06:46 GMT
#217
I was looking through the "Crafting Materials" section of the item database and I see that the materials you get from salvaging are
1) Item dependent: Magic, rare and legendary give different materials.
2) Difficulty dependent: Normal drops different stuff than Inferno

Anyone have any idea what happens when I take a Legendary Item that dropped in Normal to Inferno and salvage it there? What will I get? Does it show anywhere on the item that it dropped in Inferno? Will there be NO overlap between Nightmare/Hell.Inferno drops?
Bankai - Correlation does not imply causation
x1r0
Profile Joined April 2011
Austria156 Posts
September 23 2011 07:04 GMT
#218
Do you have to level the followers or are they always at the same level like my hero?
düdelü!
Enox
Profile Joined April 2010
Germany1667 Posts
September 23 2011 08:10 GMT
#219
On September 23 2011 16:04 x1r0 wrote:
Do you have to level the followers or are they always at the same level like my hero?

you have to level them up. you see their XP bar in the follower screen where you can equip them and select their skills
If you think it's too hard there are solutions other than asking for a nerf, getting better is the first that comes to mind.
DarkPlasmaBall
Profile Blog Joined March 2010
United States46729 Posts
September 23 2011 15:21 GMT
#220
If you sell your items using that Cauldron of Jordan item... are items sold for the same amount of gold that you would make if you sold it to a vendor? Or is it less (because it conveniently saves you a trip to town)? Or heck, is it more? Just wondering, in case I really need gold for some reason. Thanks
"There is nothing more satisfying than looking at a crowd of people and helping them get what I love." ~Day[9] Daily #100
Prev 1 9 10 11 12 13 90 Next
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
LiuLi Cup
20:00
#55
Maru vs RogueLIVE!
Clem vs herO
IntoTheiNu 1016
TKL 189
IndyStarCraft 139
Rex109
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
TKL 189
IndyStarCraft 139
Rex 109
StarCraft: Brood War
Britney 32916
Calm 5746
GuemChi 1561
Zeus 1116
Horang2 783
Bisu 765
Jaedong 493
BeSt 393
actioN 380
Soulkey 370
[ Show more ]
Light 327
Larva 254
Mini 236
ggaemo 199
firebathero 191
EffOrt 159
Leta 139
Stork 119
Rush 118
Killer 94
Hyun 85
Pusan 81
ZerO 65
hero 63
Barracks 63
JYJ 62
Free 55
Sea.KH 43
Sacsri 34
Classic 30
Movie 24
ToSsGirL 24
sorry 20
Sharp 19
soO 18
NotJumperer 16
yabsab 15
Noble 13
zelot 13
Bishop 10
scan(afreeca) 9
sOs 8
Dota 2
syndereN338
monkeys_forever163
XcaliburYe122
Counter-Strike
olofmeister1527
shoxiejesuss1249
markeloff0
Heroes of the Storm
Trikslyr19
Other Games
B2W.Neo380
Lowko297
Fuzer 162
Pyrionflax144
dupreeh138
crisheroes122
Mew2King59
ZerO(Twitch)12
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick485
StarCraft: Brood War
lovetv 7
[ Show 9 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• iopq 1
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Upcoming Events
Monday Night Weeklies
5h 11m
PiGosaur Cup
13h 11m
The PondCast
22h 11m
LiuLi Cup
23h 11m
OSC
1d 4h
Replay Cast
1d 11h
GSL
1d 23h
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
2 days
OSC
2 days
Replay Cast
2 days
[ Show More ]
KCM Race Survival
2 days
RSL Revival
3 days
BSL
4 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
5 days
IPSL
5 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
5 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
5 days
WardiTV Weekly
6 days
Kung Fu Cup
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-16
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.