|
On August 31 2009 01:24 vaMpYr wrote: 1. jaedong 2. bisu 3. calm 4. fantasy 5. flash 6. yellow[arnc] 7. kwanro 8. stork 9. iris 10. effort
pretty good but it feels like effort's just there for the hell of it. probably should put luxury or someone who has won more than 2 games since the last PR there (even hyuk LOL).
|
On August 31 2009 01:24 vaMpYr wrote: 1. jaedong 2. bisu 3. calm 4. fantasy 5. flash 6. yellow[arnc] 7. kwanro 8. stork 9. iris 10. effort I can't agree with yellow being so high in the PR and Iris should be a little higher. Oh and effort is currently 5-6 this month so there shouldn't even be an argument if he is there.
|
On August 31 2009 12:23 baubo wrote: You mean like Fakesteve with his unabashed Sea[Shield] love and Stork hate?
PR is by definition biased. It's one man's opinion anyway. And I'm assuming no one on the TL actually watches all pro games in an objective manner anyway. that was actually quite funny. rember the Manifesto joke? Best one FS ever had. And the Sea-love was ok, cuz you knew you have to look over that+ Sea[shield] was on TL attack so he deserved a bit of protection. But his work had serious issues beside those, so i'm glad we've got JWD even if he loves SKT a bit too much
|
Its really hard to put up a list with few games. How about this?
1. Jaedong (I have a small problem with this, but there is no other place to put him, since all other behind him havent played nearly as much as him. Jaedong has actually lost alot this month, losses that he could have been without. But despite that, he is still no1, OSL champ and in WCG) 2. Calm (He has proven himself? He is showing stronger than ever, rolling over kwanro (ironicly enough) and having a easy time against Jaedong.) 3. Bisu (Proving absolutley monsterious strength by winning WCG korea) 4. Flash (This might be abit much, but still he showed a very easy time against Iris and against Effort, and played quite well against Bisu in WCG) 5. Stork (He has show really amazing games, first against Upmagic, Fantasy and then crushing Jaedong. Only to lose to Bisu in the finals. Stork is looking good! He is back again!) 6. Fantasy (Obviously he prepared well for his matches in the Grand Finals of Proleague. But after that, Fantasy has done nothing much but lose when it mattered the most) 7. Kwanro 8. Iris 9. Luxury 10. Effort
Luxury has actually played better than Yellow[arnc] this month. What have Yellow done but fail?
|
On August 31 2009 13:16 Ideas wrote: pretty good but it feels like effort's just there for the hell of it. probably should put luxury or someone who has won more than 2 games since the last PR there (even hyuk LOL).
Luxury? For serious? I know he had to beat some people to get to WCG semis.
Oh wait. No he didn't, he was a seed from last time when he was actually good. He just beat Calm and Yarnc. ZvZ, so meh, but 4-0, okay. Then he got stomped by Bisu, including blowing a candidate for "world's biggest lead", and lost to Jaedong. 5-4 with no results and his relatively bad level of play before that does not a PR candidate make.
Granted EffOrt has no results either, but he's at least played some impressive games recently and, you know, has actually been good some time in the last six months.
As for this:
On August 31 2009 21:13 ThePhan2m wrote: Luxury has actually played better than Yellow[arnc] this month. What have Yellow done but fail?
Lux: 5-4 against Calm, Yarnc (wins), JD, and Bisu (losses) Yarnc: 8-7 against type-b, Sea, Jangbi, s2 (wins), Jaedong, mong, and Luxury (losses)
Not much to choose, really. Lux beat Yarnc and took a game off JD, but Yarnc has more games, more wins, a better showing in a better tournament, and wins against non-Z. (No idea what happened vs mong.) Oh, and as EffOrt, has actually looked good some time in the last six months.
|
Show nested quote +On August 31 2009 21:13 ThePhan2m wrote: Luxury has actually played better than Yellow[arnc] this month. What have Yellow done but fail? Lux: 5-4 against Calm, Yarnc (wins), JD, and Bisu (losses) Yarnc: 8-7 against type-b, Sea, Jangbi, s2 (wins), Jaedong, mong, and Luxury (losses) Not much to choose, really. Lux beat Yarnc and took a game off JD, but Yarnc has more games, more wins, a better showing in a better tournament, and wins against non-Z. (No idea what happened vs mong.) Oh, and as EffOrt, has actually looked good some time in the last six months. Yarncs wins was vs players that arent even PR material. If there was a 11th place, he would get it imo.
|
On August 31 2009 22:44 Musoeun wrote:Show nested quote +On August 31 2009 13:16 Ideas wrote: pretty good but it feels like effort's just there for the hell of it. probably should put luxury or someone who has won more than 2 games since the last PR there (even hyuk LOL). Luxury? For serious? I know he had to beat some people to get to WCG semis. Oh wait. No he didn't, he was a seed from last time when he was actually good. He just beat Calm and Yarnc. ZvZ, so meh, but 4-0, okay. Then he got stomped by Bisu, including blowing a candidate for "world's biggest lead", and lost to Jaedong. 5-4 with no results and his relatively bad level of play before that does not a PR candidate make. Granted EffOrt has no results either, but he's at least played some impressive games recently and, you know, has actually been good some time in the last six months. As for this: Show nested quote +On August 31 2009 21:13 ThePhan2m wrote: Luxury has actually played better than Yellow[arnc] this month. What have Yellow done but fail? Lux: 5-4 against Calm, Yarnc (wins), JD, and Bisu (losses) Yarnc: 8-7 against type-b, Sea, Jangbi, s2 (wins), Jaedong, mong, and Luxury (losses) Not much to choose, really. Lux beat Yarnc and took a game off JD, but Yarnc has more games, more wins, a better showing in a better tournament, and wins against non-Z. (No idea what happened vs mong.) Oh, and as EffOrt, has actually looked good some time in the last six months.
lol wut
I guess ZvZ as a MU just shouldnt be counted any more, cuz you know, lots of people dont like it.
|
No, I'm just saying, two ZvZ wins on the month and no results don't mean squat. I tend to discount all mirrors a little bit, but maybe that's just me.
|
|
|
|