On February 12 2018 19:23 raynpelikoneet wrote:The reason why i think Holyflare is our final mafia here is the following:
I went back to read the D1 from ppl's filters, and actually properly read it. I am going to assume the following things from D1:
Show nested quote +On February 08 2018 05:03 Skynx wrote:Day One Final Vote Count
mderg (5)::
Koshi, ritoky, Mocsta,
rsoultin, trfel, Koshi, Holyflare
rsoultin (4): Mocsta, Conversion,
Trfel, darthfoley,
mderg,
raynpelikoneet, raynpelikoneet, Damdred
Koshi (1): Holyflare,
TrfelTrfel (1): prplhz
darthfoley (2): raynpelikoneet, mderg, rsoultin
prplhz (0)::
Koshi,
rsoultinConversion (0): rsoultinHolyflare (0): mdergritoky (0): rsoultinNot Voting (1): Rels
mderg is the lynch.
That's the final votecount from D1. What we know from there is this:
Mafia bussed real hard. The only people who are not confirmed town are on not confirmed mafia are our flipped mafia. So regardless of who is mafia they have bussed super hard (since disformation is town the final mafia is in the active players).
Now what i do believe is that the the reason for mderg to refuse to vote rsoultin is that the mafia thinks they win more often with rsoultin alive. I also think the mafia thinks the people on rsoultin are easier to lynch in total than the people on mderg. Anyone, just anyone could have claimed "credit" by switching from rsoultin to mderg (like Holyflare did), yet the people on rsoultin refused to do so. Honestly what i just said is just better play as scum and more likely to come from mafia than anything anyone on rsoultin did.
I mean, at this point mafia is 100% getting lynched. There is absolutely no reason to stay on rsoultin because mderg flipping mafia doesn't make rsoultin town (darthfoley and Damdred realized this). The better play is just to "hammer mafia" and then say "maybe i was wrong on rsoultin" and try to paint her as town for the following phases.
First of all, on Holyflare, is that. The vote switch is actually scummy lol (more on this below).
Secondly is this; If you go to rsoultin's filter and know something about her scum play you will notice this. She likes to put all other things aside when she's defending herself. If you read her filter almost everything is her defending herself until i tell her to prove she is town by scumhunting. What is weird about Holyflare regarding this is that rsoultin defends against
everyone else's cases than Holyflares!!! Literally, big rants with Mocsta, big rants with me, stuff with Conversion, stuff with darthfoley, no stuff... literally zero stuff with Holyflare. This is what she says about Holyflare:
Show nested quote +On February 06 2018 18:50 rsoultin wrote:On February 06 2018 18:33 Holyflare wrote:
Even though you're just repeating the same things that I disagreed with. I'm changing my stance to agreement.
You're making it impossible for me to get a read off you, btw
Show nested quote +On February 07 2018 22:49 rsoultin wrote:
Holyflare is whatever the fuck. I can never tell even when I care.
Then there is some soft comments about what other people did regarding Holyflare's read on her, but never confronting him about anything, ever. Here is the
last game filter for Tina, you don't even need to go further that first page to see the above and how she treats Holyflare this game is completely bullshit. I honestly didn't even see those posts earlier, i just didn't care about Holyflare because he was gunning for rsoultin so i didn't care.
Now i must say, this is not a good reason to call Holyflare scum. I mean what rsoultin did is not a reason why Holyflare is scum, but the reason is that Holyflare should have noticed this and called rsoultin mafia for it, and do it fucking hard. Because when someone acts super scummy towards you then they are mafia. If Holyflare is town in this game he should have realized that for whatever reason rsoultin is scared to call him any alignment ever in this game and gunned her down for it, 100%.
Then there is Holyflare's vote swtich from rsoultin to mderg. Here are the facts:
- Holyflare has a super big scumread on rsoultin
- Holyflare has never really talked anything about mderg
- The vote switch happens when it is 100% certain that mafia is getting lynched no matter what
Here is what Holyflare has said about mderg:
Show nested quote +I think it's more that I don't remember anything mderg has posted and that resonated with how I felt about him last game.
mderg's only scumread at this point is rsoultin who is Holyflare's #1 scumread. Ant this is funny because:Show nested quote +On February 08 2018 04:33 Holyflare wrote:On February 08 2018 04:29 darthfoley wrote:
Current thoughts are something like this
Town
Conversion
Koshi
Rayn
Ritoky
prplhz
Damdred
Rels
HF
Trfel
Mocsta
rsoultin/mderg
Mafia
Fine with mderg/rsoultin lynch. I will note how thread sentiment has kind of awkwardly turned away from rsoultin while people are simultaneously covering their asses saying they don't mind if she dies. I will also note how Mocsta has followed pretty much the same formula from last game with his treatment of rsoultin
I don't like that I can't remember a single thing HF said. Not a good sign
Mate you having a fucking laugh? Your biggest scum read is started by a wagon on reasoning I created. This is so bad. I also made a giant collection of where are rsoul conversion reads case??
So df should notice that HF has said stuff (and tbh i was the one that created rsoultin lynch, not holyflare), but he doesn't have to recognize mderg's #1 scumread is the same that his (which btw happened before HF even scumread rsoultin).
Then this happens:
Show nested quote +On February 08 2018 04:40 Holyflare wrote:
I'll vote to save the talking people to kill the non talking people. Honestly haven't been able to catch up and read into mderg or prplhz though. Just finishing work
Show nested quote +On February 08 2018 04:52 Holyflare wrote:
I don't care if mderg is town and getting lynched though.
Here's the reason Holyflare decided to vote for mderg over rsoultin:
Show nested quote +On February 08 2018 04:53 Holyflare wrote:
I don't need to consolidate on anything though. If I have to I'll save rsoul because she types words though.
His biggest fucking scumread he is so proud of he needs to shout other people HE is the one who created the wagon and NEVER anyone else and everyone is sheeping him, can be excused on D1 over a dude he doesn't have any clue what he even wrote???????????? This is literally bullshit, lite-fucking-rally. And for the record the words rsoultin typed after Holyflare made the "you have 4 pages of filter and nothing in there" continued to be absolutely nothing so the vote switch in itself makes no fucking sense at all.
Come day 2 and i made my case on rsoultin. Holyflare instantly agrees. Then this happens:
Show nested quote +On February 10 2018 08:34 Holyflare wrote:
I also think rsoultin is a good vote too. No idea where she's at on any read whatsoever. My case about her conversion read day 1 still stands and her mderg read progression is even worse.
But he didn't manage to vote rsoultin over a dude he doesn't even remember what they wrote.
Show nested quote +On February 10 2018 09:28 Holyflare wrote:
I want rsoultin to make a case for me to vote rayn. And also explain damdred.
rsoultin never does this.
Show nested quote +On February 11 2018 01:29 Holyflare wrote:
I don't think rsoultin is mafia purely based on mderg's multiple interactions with her. Seems like 50% of his filter is arguing with her.
Mmmm now it's the other way around than it was in the first quote?
Like..... I understand the reasons Holyflare was voting for Damdred for. But i don't understand how he fucking ends up on Damdred over rsoultin here. Once again it doesn't make any fucking sense since with logic he should end up on rsoultin. Another thing to note here is that he sees many many "scummy stuff" other people do but never anything on rsoultin, never, it is always just a generic read of "i think she is scum but i vote for this other guy". And i fell like Holyflare as town would have always voted for rsoultin D1, and D2, over what he did.
Two more points, a bit minor though but still a point. from D3 this:
- Holyflare never even registers the point i made in my rsoultin case D2. The point is that as mafia, Damdred and darthfoley were pushing an anti-mafia idea from the beginning of N1. Ne never touches this with even a long stick, he never actually reconsiders he can be wrong here (when he most likely is).
- Second point, he says this after my claim:
Show nested quote +On February 12 2018 07:10 Holyflare wrote:
Btw if darthfoley is town I'm lynching rayn tomorrow.
When HF makes stupid jokes like this he is mafia. He did in the last game i played when he was mafia. I can look it up if you want to, but it always makes me feel something is wrong about this guy when he does it and while it's not really a reason to call him mafia it probably should be because it has always been correct. This is just a retarded thing to even suggest and i am quite sure he can make the obvious conclusion that "if rayn is alive at lylo then just lynch him". Notice that only mafia knows i am lying here about the check on prplhz / df, and i realize it must be fucking annoying when your possible mislynches towntell and you can do nothing about it. I think this is the result.
#vote Holyflare