On January 04 2015 22:52 KelsierSC wrote:Show nested quote +On January 04 2015 20:46 Palmar wrote:
I am actually going to vote him. I'm unsure if it's my final vote today, but he's been awol for like... 48 hours or something stupid?
I understand there might be a reason for that, and it also seems like the people defending him (mostly koshi) were actually town. And I still have the fact I didn't really think he was mafia day 1.
Still, gonna drop a vote, see if he wakes up. Aside from him I think we really should work towards reducing the number of people up for the lynch today. As I see it now, we have the following:
geript
superbia
vivax
iamrobik
ritoky
VE
Damdred
TheChyz
I need to eliminate a few more off this list, but it looks ok for now.
Also, if someone is in the mood for meta, marv has repeatedly done something this game that I don't recall him doing before. He's doing my thing where he asks other people to confirm for him. "I think this was x, can someone confirm". Maybe it's nothing though. In any case I'm not sure marv is the lynch today.
I am sorely tempted to actually go hard after Damdred. If I get the chance to read his filter I'll see what I think of it.
I'd take VE and Chyz off that list.
The rest are all ok I want to give some thoughts on Robik
k. I was a bit fucked up yesterday and passed out but I remember trying to get a read on Robik and what bugged me was his reason for voting on bats,
Show nested quote +On January 04 2015 12:10 KelsierSC wrote:On January 04 2015 12:05 IAmRobik wrote:On January 04 2015 11:02 KelsierSC wrote:On January 04 2015 06:08 IAmRobik wrote:On January 04 2015 05:56 Vivax wrote:On January 04 2015 05:35 IAmRobik wrote:On January 04 2015 05:34 justanothertownie wrote:On January 04 2015 05:31 IAmRobik wrote:On January 04 2015 05:30 Vivax wrote:
[quote]
What agenda is possibly more important than talking about the guys you suspect before the night and instantly after?
i said my top 2 scum pre-nk were ritoky and superbia. my post flip is you, but also think superbia and ritoky are scum.
Then why do you suddenly think Vivax is scum? Only because of the nightkills?
yes...because koshi got killed...
also havemt called you scum since the flip since koshi had you solid town iirc based off of your eod1
Wait a minute. So for the fact that Koshi was the NK I'm scum, but when it's about reading JAT, it's cause you feel like sheeping Koshi.
How do you feel about yourself and geript then.
i have no feelings towards geript. He could be town. he could be scum.
his wagon was by far filled with scummier voters than bats'I feel like i'm town and I'm sticking to this read
Robik you say that the geript wagon was uglier than the bats wagon.
But here you point to this wagon being ugly
On January 02 2015 10:44 IAmRobik wrote:On January 02 2015 10:43 Alakaslam wrote:
TheChyz (5): Eden1892, DoctorHelvetica, Vivax, TheChyz, Batsnacks, DoctorHelvetica
until deadline.
Oh jeez, that's one ugly looking wagon to be on.
Where to move my vote -.-
that wagon contains Eden and DrH .
Why is the bats wagon suddenly clean even though the same people voted on a "dirty" wagon
Chyz, vivax and batsnacks were FOS of mine, but Chyz was self-voting so meh. I don't know if I TR Eden until later or if I had TR him up to that point. but it just felt meh
Fair enough, you did townread DrH so him being on bats kind of helps you out aswell.
Who didn't you like on the geript wagon?
So like this discussion felt pretty important to me, he thinks the geript wagon is worse than bats wagon but bats wagon has eden on it , who at the time robik did not TR and was part of the ugly wagon
He said the geript wagon looked scummier but I guess apart from palmar I don't know who he scumread on that wagon.
One of the major issues is that he doesn't give a read on a lot of these people beforehand.
But when I look through his filter his main read I guess d1 is that DrH is town and palmar is mafia, I am a question mark. I guess it is plausible I just wish he had expanded on all of his reads d1.
You also look at the way the votes went down and it appears that Robik's vote didn't actually matter.
I admit I have no idea of Robik's usual play style, the only game we played together he was scum and AFK'd d1 and got lynched end of day.
His early play hasn't really overwhelmed me it just felt like he was shitting on people and calling people bad because they didn't have the same read as him. Like calling JAT bad because he was asking Eden questions.
I don't really understand why after the night kills vivax is mafia and the only person worth lynching according to Robik.
He has a giant scum list (admittedly viv is on it) but he loves Eden's "baller" analysis which has superbia,rit and geript as mafia but after the NK's viv is mafia and he doesn't want to go any further.
Despite all of this when I read through Robik's game he hasn't made any attempt to ingratiate himself with anyone, d2 his play has been more active and he has tried to push his thoughts specifically getting in JAT's face.
This post also felt really town
Show nested quote +On January 04 2015 06:57 IAmRobik wrote:On January 04 2015 06:50 justanothertownie wrote:On January 04 2015 06:47 IAmRobik wrote:On January 04 2015 06:39 justanothertownie wrote:On January 04 2015 06:34 IAmRobik wrote:On January 02 2015 09:09 IAmRobik wrote:
From the 2-3 posts I've read of Vivax's, Vivax seems like he could be scum regardless of geript's role. But my plan on d1 is to just sheep. sheep sheep sheep and hope it works in my favor
i don't remember exactly what the posts were, but this is where i first bring up vivax.
Marv felt good to start the game because i thought he was participating but then he seemed to fade. His participation today is more in line with how i think his town game is. He would be another person i might be skeptical of if vivax flips town,
but then again, i think his whole thing about "highest filter" "numbers don't lie" was genuine and typical town!marv type argument Yes, it was. But if you think marv isn't able to say smart stuff or stuff he believes in general as scum then you are mistaken.
So now it's your turn...why are my reads off? Why do you think I'm not trying this game? Maybe I'm not as verbose or articulate, but I don't think I ever am really. I wasn't confident d1 based off of NYE and not being able to participate really, but I was around enough to actually make a vote that could possibly matter. In fact, I think the reasoning that I gave for sheeping you wasn't all that bad either.
I guess your reads aren't the worst but they aren't many either. Meh.
i don't need to have a read on every player in the game. I can take stances on people if you'd like, but they wouldn't be justified and they'd probably be wrong as fuck anyway
Which is much better than what geript did which was spend ages not giving reads and getting pissed off when people asked him questions, then making a giant list post of nonsense.
Overall I am still undecided on Robik but something makes me feel he is town with an abrasive manner. Either way I don't think he should be a lynch discussion today