|
On January 27 2013 09:24 Promethelax wrote: Hapa, you just hard called Imp scum and soft called him town. Which is it?
No damn clue. Trying to hash out my opinion of him right now.
|
On January 27 2013 07:07 Hapahauli wrote: Just to test things;
@ EmileZola//MrZ
Gimme a summary of our history from Witchcraft Mafia. Some verification would be cool.
oh shit... history... Did we make out?
|
Okay Hapa, why do I have you as not scum right now? (Srsly)
Mr Zola, could you tell us truthfully who you are please and thanks. Assume I know your deepest secret and that you shouldn't lie to me.
|
Surprised that ghost's barely been mentioned, that's some pretty extreme lurking. I can understand taking a while to post due to time differences or whatever, but the rest of us have already been playing for 24 hours.
I re-read this little interaction and I still can't get my head around it. EmileZola switches his vote from thrawn to Hapa with no explanation, and thrawn still hasn't posted by then. So the only event that could change his mind would have to have come from Hapa, right?
On January 27 2013 06:38 xsksc wrote: I'd like him to explain his thought process behind the vote on you.
On January 27 2013 06:41 EmileZola wrote: i wanted to see if he's there and delurks if i vote him... and he has only 1 filterpage of game right now. I heard as town he usually has more :-] Hapa has been one of the more active players so far, and his posts have been pretty solid. Seems like a really silly reason to be voting him.
Then there's this...
On January 27 2013 06:42 EmileZola wrote: there is also one additional reason, a reason i will tell you in exactly 22 hours from now on. Apparently he has a secret reason for voting Hapa too, but he won't share it with us until 3 hours before the lynch, wtf? Does that not strike anyone else as incredibly anti-town? ##vote EmileZola You guys seem reluctant to lynch him IF he's zentor, why is that? Is he somehow excused from scummy behavior if his identity is different?
|
lets kill thrawn
he is much more lurkey when he is scum
why him as opposed to other lurkers like ghost?
because he made posts to appear like he was contributing we have no info on ghost right now
lets kill him
## vote thrawn
|
YOU RANG
Should be on to read the thread in a bit. Kind of doubt anything interesting has happened, but who knows!
|
|
Oh hey. Well we'll see if ghost wants to contribute I'm not unhappy with a thrawn lynch at all right now. For those of you interested look at Mario mini day one for scum thrawn.
Imp, which of the active players is scummiest?
|
On January 27 2013 09:56 Promethelax wrote: Why Tfunk over ghost? i have zero info on ghost looks like we are about to get some
grab your
|
On January 27 2013 09:58 Promethelax wrote:
Imp, which of the active players is scummiest? none at the moment stick out to me that much
|
On January 27 2013 07:39 Vivax wrote: His questions. His questions and his casual comments.
The questions don't point towards him having a target, a direction on where to push on to determine whether someone is scum.
Can you elaborate on this please? I don't see what's inherently scummy about asking questions for information about players, rather than to push on someone. Early day one is full of people asking each other small questions and seeing how they reply. If nobody did it, we'd have very little discussion to read.
|
So xsksc explain the result of you questioning. What have you learned from your little questions and who is scum?
|
On January 27 2013 09:30 Promethelax wrote: Okay Hapa, why do I have you as not scum right now? (Srsly)
Mr Zola, could you tell us truthfully who you are please and thanks. Assume I know your deepest secret and that you shouldn't lie to me.
I am Batman.
|
Holy shit. I'm playing a mafia game with Batman. OMG.
|
got anything useful ghost?
|
Looks like Prom and VE rolled scum. Emile is town. Really tempted to believe Yamato on the miller claim. I'm treating him as confirmed town at this point.
Hapa's being super aggressive. I don't think that's a scum tell, but I haven't spent enough time figuring out exactly what's up with that.
I'll post some thoughts on Prom in just a sec with my vote for the time being.
|
what you think of thrawn ghost?
|
On January 27 2013 10:17 Promethelax wrote: So xsksc explain the result of you questioning. What have you learned from your little questions and who is scum?
Some notable things I got from responses - Iamp dodged my reads question. Djodref did not give me a satisfiable answer about WHY he was wasting so much time arguing about my semantics. Felt like he was making posts for the sake of it, left a bad taste in my mouth. Emilezola's attitude is pretty anti-town. I asked him what impressions he had and he just turns around and asked me to summarize it for him...not impressed.
Who is scum, eh? I think emilezola. I see no town agenda coming from him, he seems content to just sit there and let everybody else play the game, and I really really don't like his withholding of information.
|
On January 27 2013 10:33 ghost_403 wrote: Emile is town. Why?
|
Really Ghost? Well okay, do tell.
EZ I meant what I said. Don't lie to me or to the thread.
Ghost, you played with Hapa recently. Are you really suggesting aggression is a scum tell for him?
|
|
|
|