so at the worst right now you think I might be making an error in that Snarfs MIGHT be SK and not mafia.

Why are you antagonising your confirmed townie?

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

June 29 2012 15:20 GMT

#1522

We kill scum tonight it's 3-2-1 night.

Say scum hits townie and blocks SK, it's 2-2-1. Okay we lynch scum again 2-1-1.

Scum doesn't want to shoot a townie in this situation because then he'll lose to SK. SK can shoot townie but then he'll get in a draw with scum if scum hits him I believe. The best actions for everybody on this night (if they want to win) is that scum shoots SK and hope that SK misses him for a draw, and SK shoots scum and doesn't care what else happens and then we'll be in 2-1(SK) situation.

This only requires us to scum hunt today which is the most reliable thing we can do. I don't like this roleblocker thing one bit and we can do that tomorrow if we absolutely have to. There's no reason to compromise on our scum reads today to kill roleblocker. It's a lot better to be sure to kill scum and then get another day and more time in similar situation.

From 3-2-1, scum hits SK and blocks SK. It's 3-2-1 and we have a situation like today except the SK is a lot weaker to scum which doesn't benefit town. We still need to lynch scum on this day even though we didn't get roleblocker so we have another shot at killing him here.

From 3-2-1, scum doesn't block SK, then it didn't matter if we lynched roleblocker anyway.

Correct me if I'm wrong.

Shraft

Sweden701 Posts

June 29 2012 15:22 GMT

#1523

Because you have the strange thing of saying that both him (Snarfs) and me are not town aligned, which is false, and I don't know what reasoning you've used to arrive at that conclusion, which means that I can't see where you went wrong... All I can do is bitch and whine at you, because when you die the coming night, everyone will just sheep vote me and town will lose.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 29 2012 15:22 GMT

#1524

I think Shraft is easily most anti-town but I also thought he had a pretty decent chance at SK.

So Snarfs.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

June 29 2012 15:22 GMT

#1525

Yea, I read the thread again and I don't know, I got Shraft+Mattchew scum team and remaining scum + SK in Snarfs/rastaban just by elimination. I have no idea how to look for SK and I was kind hoping he'd just go away or something.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

June 29 2012 15:23 GMT

#1526

How did you get your SK read marvellosity?

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 29 2012 15:24 GMT

#1527

Shraft

Attacks rastaban. wants to hold off on me.

For some bizarre reason wants to lynch zephirdd instead of rastaban based on prplhz’s case.

SEEMS MORE AGGRESSIVE HERE THAN EMERGENCY.

bought in easily to Probulous’ case against me.

Pops up during day 2 lynch to say that he’s happy to lynch Mattchew instead of me.

rastaban/prplhz scum, plrplhz based on false meta = bad, especially when i corrected him.

repushes on rastaban day 3. WHY NOT MATTCHEW? seems to not really care who gets lynched as he merrily hopped from me to Matt day 2? SK?

Terrible ‘joke’ comment to me about just lynching rastaban. just terrible.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 29 2012 15:26 GMT

#1528

EBWOP: those are just some of my sketched notes obviously

Shraft

Sweden701 Posts

June 29 2012 15:30 GMT

#1529

Ok so I'm anti-town for having a lynch preference during D1 and being uncertain on the D2 lynch...

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 29 2012 15:35 GMT

#1530

Just be happy I'm not lynching you today, eh?

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 29 2012 15:36 GMT

#1531

Pitch at me during the night if the lynch goes well.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

June 29 2012 15:55 GMT

#1532

I don't want to follow your plan marvellosity.

##Vote Shraft

I think it's more likely that the SK appears less scummy than everybody else and Shraft is easily the scummiest in the thread and if we lynch SK then we lose.

gl hf

marvellosity

United Kingdom36156 Posts

June 29 2012 15:58 GMT

#1533

How scummy someone is is down to the quality of the player.

In this game with the marv/VE fuckup, neither scum nor SK have had to put their neck on the line.

There is no real reason for scum to look any scummier than SK.