I was thinking it might be fun to have one of the matches in each TL Attack be played on a map made by some member of the TL community.
Could be interesting to see how people play on a map they have never seen before and it would get more people involved in the event. It could also offer for something interesting for the commentators and the pro to discuss perhaps.

I hope this is in the right section and posted properly and such. Sorry in advance if not...
Thanks to everyone for the awesome TL Attck events!

ShaLLoW[baY]

Canada12499 Posts

March 25 2008 01:27 GMT

I see through your disguise Nightmarejoo! Chill already said they're never going to play Faoi!

Manifesto7

Osaka27173 Posts

March 25 2008 01:29 GMT

I think this is a really good idea. We'll talk about it. Glad you are enjoying the events.

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

March 25 2008 01:55 GMT

I like this idea a lot. Is there still an active map-making community, on TL or otherwise? Not poking fun or anything, I honestly don't know.

CTStalker

Canada9720 Posts

March 25 2008 01:57 GMT

i just played (and lost T_T) an hour long 2v2 on faoi. great map!

yubee

United States3826 Posts

March 25 2008 01:58 GMT

i don't think this is a good idea. i think the less short, unspectacular games we get due to people walling incorrectly or blocking their nat with cannons, the better

useLess

United States4781 Posts

March 25 2008 03:07 GMT

good idea, but not for tl attack. theres a difference between an interesting game on a known map and dicking around on an unknown map.

Nitrogen

United States5345 Posts

March 25 2008 03:11 GMT

On March 25 2008 10:27 ShaLLoW[baY] wrote:
I see through your disguise Nightmarejoo! Chill already said they're never going to play Faoi!

Chill

Calgary25998 Posts

March 25 2008 03:13 GMT

Luddite

United States2315 Posts

March 25 2008 03:30 GMT

#10

On March 25 2008 12:07 useLess wrote:
good idea, but not for tl attack. theres a difference between an interesting game on a known map and dicking around on an unknown map.

I think this is perfect for TL attack. You could give them a couple minutes to look at the map, though, so they can at least see the basic features of it. Or show it the the challenger ahead of time, and only give the pro a few minutes to look at it.

ShaLLoW[baY]

Canada12499 Posts

March 25 2008 03:34 GMT

#11

On March 25 2008 12:30 Luddite wrote:

Show nested quote +

I think this is perfect for TL attack. You could give them a couple minutes to look at the map, though, so they can at least see the basic features of it. Or show it the the challenger ahead of time, and only give the pro a few minutes to look at it.

That's actually a pretty cool idea, would be fun to watch the pro flounder as the joe exploits an unknown cannon placement behind his workers that he can't do shit about.

Phyre

United States1288 Posts

March 25 2008 06:08 GMT

#12

I think this could use a poll. Put it to a vote, see what the viewers want to see. I personally would prefer if they stuck to maps from the star leagues and a few old classics (LT, Requiem, etc). But if the majority want to see matches on TL made maps that's fine too.

That said, if we can get our hands on the new maps that were just announced those might be interesting.

Chill

Calgary25998 Posts

March 25 2008 12:49 GMT

#13

Do you really think it will be interesting to watch them bumble around on maps they don't know?

ATeddyBear

Canada2843 Posts

March 25 2008 13:00 GMT

#14

some of the newbs dont even know the current maps/are 2v2 players -.-;

Milzo

France656 Posts

March 25 2008 13:11 GMT

#15

Would be nice to see some old school maps

Chill

Calgary25998 Posts

March 25 2008 13:57 GMT

#16

I'm talking about the pro. It would be pretty silly to force them to play maps they don't know, in my eyes.

Lenwe

Netherlands757 Posts

March 25 2008 14:10 GMT

#17

I watch TL.attack mostly because I can see player that is better than I ever can even hope to be play a game. I think the commentary is a lot of fun, the newb-bashing that happens is also fun, but my main reason to watch is to see the 'pro' defeat a lesser player with a weird strategy, beautiful micro or what not.

I think that this idea would take away from that.

Purind

Canada3562 Posts

March 25 2008 15:40 GMT

#18

I think it could be interesting to have a TL exclusive map that you use every episode. It would be new to everyone, but if you release it ahead of time, it gives everyone a chance to look at it.

I dunno if some of the pro's will ever have a chance to see it, but so far, we've had 3 TL regulars guest star on TL Attack, and I'm sure if TL released a new map, those 3 would know about the map instantly.

It might screw over the guests that don't frequent TL and have no clue what the map is though. But I think it's a pretty interesting idea

Senx

Sweden5901 Posts

March 25 2008 15:46 GMT

#19

This is a bad idea beacuse its not what we watch TL.net attack for.
We don't want to see a pro player wander around a map with no clue instead of showing good micro/macro or good fights and creative play.

decafchicken

United States20159 Posts

March 25 2008 15:47 GMT

#20

On March 25 2008 10:55 Lemonwalrus wrote:
I like this idea a lot. Is there still an active map-making community, on TL or otherwise? Not poking fun or anything, I honestly don't know.

broodwarmaps.net