Wow, looks like I got in just under the clock. Whew.

I haven't played forum mafia before, and I've only played the SC2 mod of it, but that seems to take a few rules from F11's version and adds some new roles in it too. But I generally dislike having a lynch day one, although it seems to be mandatory, so I'm going to go with the safer option here and vote for

##Vote: Skrammen

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 18 2011 01:00 GMT

#211

I think there's one hour? Good thing I woke up early today.

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 18 2011 09:18 GMT

#245

Hi! Sorry, can dead people still post? Probably not, right?

Anyways, sorry for the wrong vote - decided to go with the safer vote rather than have a bunch of suspect innocents. I'll hopefully participate more tomorrow!

Just to clarify, we can PM anyone here right? To have like secret conversations?

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 19 2011 10:52 GMT

#316

I may have stepped too deep here, the level of analysis is quite mindboggling. I'd love to contribute, but I'm not sure how or where to start, even after reading a lot of the newbie guides... One thing that can be said though is that VisEyes, Palmar and Mataza are all very active, and I do believe at least one of them is Mafia.

Sadly, I don't have much proof and I'm not sure how all of you guys have to time to sift through and analyze everyone's posts :< what does FoSing someone actually do, other than make your suspicions more concrete?

I will try to monitor this situation more, but I think a lot of my opinions are siding with VisEyes right now, though I'm not sure why.

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 19 2011 11:00 GMT

#320

@Palmar: But what does that entail? Does it just mean that everyone knows you think that X is mafia? Is that all it does?

Also, I agree with VisEyes that all his calls, though a bit irrational, are somewhat based from the information in front of him. I do think that purplehaze could be suspicious, and that him and the other mafioso turned GiygaS in, in an attempt to throw a few people off their tail. I currently have my eye of both Palmar and PurpleHaze

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 19 2011 11:17 GMT

#325

@Nard: pretty nice post, and... pretty bad pun

I agree somewhat with your analysis, however I doubt a lot of the inactive people would be mafia, especially since reading the newbie guide one would assume mafioso to be active, rather than inactive.

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 19 2011 11:30 GMT

#329

@Palmar: Oh. Ok

That makes sense then. FoS on Palmar and PurpleHaze

@VisEyes: I agree. Palmar's argument and evidence against you have been somewhat shakey, though I'd have to go through and analyze it word for word ><

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 19 2011 14:38 GMT

#340

Well, Mataza has been particularly quiet today, hopefully we'll see some analysis from him tomorrow, but I will save my vote till then. For now, I retract my FoS from PurpleHaze. There is still a FoS on Palmar and will probably be till the end of the day.

Also of note, VisceraEyes is defending HiroProtagonist, calling him rational and analytical. I think we should note that down depending on who gets lynches tomorrow, as VisEyes could still very well be a scum manipulating the town.

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 20 2011 07:05 GMT

#415

Wait, so what's happening here? PurpleHaze is claiming he got roleblocked and so we have a potential roleblocker and with that, either 8 vanilla townies, or 6 vanilla townies, 1 doctor and a Detective.

Mataza is claiming he knows who the doctor is because of 'observational skills'. I doubt a mafia would openly expose himself to such a thing as the only guarantee he'd know is if he was a mafia and one of them roleblocked the doctor, thus sealing the only way Karshe could have survived.

Am I right in this analysis? o-o

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 20 2011 07:06 GMT

#416

Also, when do we have to vote?

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 20 2011 14:11 GMT

#422

On May 20 2011 20:28 stefftastiq wrote:
its also noteworth that Karshe also voted for skrammen - though he was town -which kind of proves that votingpattern isnt bound to make that player scum or town,

Aha, this is something important that hadn't been addressed. If mafia were apart of the offvoter group, why would they narrow it down further by killing off an innocent offvoter? That doesn't mean that all offvoters are suddenly innocent, but it does make it a somewhat level playing field.

Unfortunately I won't be able to stay up to read the rest of the day's discussion, so I'm going to have to bandwagon again. The 4 votes already cast are all over the place, but I think there's one person here that currently stands out relative to the other active posters.

##Vote: Palmar

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 21 2011 02:41 GMT

#489

Ah fuck. The people who voted for Mataza didn't really think of the implications. What does this achieve? That the doubters of Mataza are now all possible mafia?

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 21 2011 13:00 GMT

#494

you dun goof'd.

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 22 2011 00:31 GMT

#503

Hmm, I don't have time to do the analysis, but I'll say this much, looking at the votelist from two days ago as well as the general back and forth in the posts, I have a heavy FoS on Prplhz. This is due to the fact that he swung the vote against GiygaS, meaning the third scum convinced him to let GiygaS go as he wasn't a great scum player.

This is backed up by his vote against Mataza, who tried to come up with a plan to expose at least one scum in the process. Unfortunately it was stopped by a starting vote by nard, and then followed by Prplhz, hiro, Skrammen, and most importantly VisceraEyes. Now Vis, why did you suddenly change your vote from being so adamantly against Palmar?

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 22 2011 04:17 GMT

#510

Fantastic. I'm pretty staunch on my vote today, so I will throw it out immediately.

##Vote: Palmar

From the evidence that VisEyes has presented, it is clear that Palmar is one of the 2 remaining scum and that he was simply waiting for instruction, but prplhz took action and got rid of GiygaS at the last minute. I'm not too sure who the other scum is, but the possibility of it being prplhz or VisEyes is quite high.

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 24 2011 01:31 GMT

#552

Aaaah this is too confusing T_T, poor Mataza, we should have listened to him more closely.

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 24 2011 03:05 GMT

#573

Hi sinani~

Wunder

United Kingdom2950 Posts

May 26 2011 04:00 GMT

#611

Well, as I suspected from a day ago, Palmar jumps at any opportunity to continue his lynching. Unfortunately, I lack the time and the intelligence to construct a long analysis on either Palmar or VisEyes, but I congratulate the mafia for playing as well as they did.

There's probably nothing I can do to change the other townies minds, but I will throw my vote in incase there's some change of heart.

##Vote: Palmar