World at War Mafia

On March 23 2010 01:48 Ace wrote:
Oh, RoL can't play because he told me he'd be on Spring Break. So 1 more needed instead.

On March 25 2010 08:54 JeeJee wrote:
ok, i see..

this mason situation is interesting. i hope abenson is at least active behind the scenes with opz as otherwise they are just throwing this away. masons are a huge buff to the town (well, well-played masons are), and unless ace did something hilarious like make them all siblings too (i wouldn't put it past him lolol), i'm feeling a bit more confident. elemenope does have a point that of course they are not confirmed, but that's not relevant atm. what IS relevant is we know they're on the same team. how many mafia do you think there are? losing two has got to be brutal.

anyway i agree with voting for deliberately inactive people like rol. hell, he even READ THE POSTS of people that voted for him and all he had to say is "you are insane". you have to put in more effort than that, man, it's been two full days.
i will keep my vote on him for now.

--

ok so i f5'd the thread before posting and saw your latest post RoL
zona contributing nothing? means a lot, coming from a poster who only posted three one-liners up until he's on the chopping block. actually zona has created plans, bounced off ideas, driven discussion. if everyone would do this, we would be in much better shape. conversely, if everyone would do what YOU do (nothing), we'd be screwed.
i am still happy with you as the candidate for day one. feel free to convince me otherwise, i will be here.

On March 25 2010 08:55 Elemenope wrote:
Actually, you don't die before the nuke lands.

Read the rules? Jesus christ.

Nukes will stay in the air for 24 hours after they were fired. A player that has been nuked has until the nuclear missiles hit to retaliate. You can only launch 1 nuke/anti-nuke once per day, BUT you may launch a nuke AND retaliate to a nuclear strike if you have enough missiles left. You are not allowed to retaliate strike on a retaliation. Day ends when a player is lynched, and of course no one may nuke at night.

On March 25 2010 09:07 Versatile wrote:
hey, just a question here. why does everyone think mafia has only 1KP?

the OP states "Mafia have night kills just like in normal games. Mafia can kill 1 player per night no matter how many of them are alive".

however, that doesn't mean that they cannot have a higher KP. did ace address that somewhere else where i may have missed it? or is this just a town assumption based on the wording?

On March 25 2010 10:29 ~OpZ~ wrote:
Well I read through the rules again...I'm assuming I can post PM's between me and him...

If you would like this I will post them...Wow...I'm thoroughly appalled by this...

I've asked him prior to him getting voted for to post some content, he hasn't replied...He could of talked it over to me his plans or what not....

-_-

But no sense lynching him anyway, he is townie.

No talking about the game outside the thread. This includes Private Messages unless your role gives you permission to do so. You will be mod-killed if this rule is broken.

On March 25 2010 11:39 Iaaan wrote:
Xelin, he has to die because he used a nuke. There isn't any discussion about weather he is mafia or not, he has to die, that was the decision made to control nukes.

I kind of want to hear what Zona has to say, but I'm thinking it might be a good idea to let the nuke fall on caller.

On March 25 2010 11:57 Zona wrote:
Wow. You're a star, RoL. You're a real star. But more on that later.

I think we as a town have two options. One: anti-nuke, and lynch RoL. Alternatively: let the nuke fall on Caller as some have suggested, and lynch RoL if Caller is not mafia.

Option one is what we've been discussing all game, and the reasoning for taking this path is well established.

Why does the alternative option have some merit to make it worth considering? Well it centers on the fact that Caller hasn't really contributed, despite being a veteran mod and player. Now that the nuke is already in the air, if you subscribe to my earlier idea that we should be stingy with anti-nukes to have some going to the late-game, we need to think twice before using them. Caller does claim to plan to participate more later, but it's a claim we cannot prove or disprove during the time to make the decision to anti-nuke. If the nuke lands and by some tiny chance Caller is mafia, then RoL is actually okay. He somehow got rid of a mafia for us, even if it was against everything the town has established together in its ground rules. If Caller is revealed as town-aligned OR EVEN THIRD PARTY, then RoL is lynched. Lynch RoL even if Caller is third party because mafia could have easily targeted their nuke at anyone not on their team and just happened to hit third party.

But in any case, this is not something we can vote on, since anti-nukes are used privately. We can't hold anti-nuke users accountable in public, so basically all our discussion takes place so those who actually have anti-nukes can read it and make their decision. So those WITH anti-nukes, consider what has been said in the thread and make your decision.

What I suggest is that we as a town place 10 or 11 votes on RoL. Then the moment the nuke is resolved, we can finish the lynch by placing the last 1 or 2 votes, or shift the votes away, in the slim chance that the nuke lands and Caller is mafia.