|
Lilbow can't be the next bad boy of StarCraft. He's a nice guy who made the mistake of clumsily making excuses of a bad showing because he didn't practice enough. Disappointing, but not seduced to the dark side. I believe neither Idra nor Naniwa are really "bad boys". They were just clumsy, socially awkward, miscommunicating and shit happened, so they had to play the role. Lilbow should do that too to make himself more prominent. Next time people will pay to see him lose to a Korean .
|
On November 03 2015 09:12 rfv14 wrote:Show nested quote +Lilbow can't be the next bad boy of StarCraft. He's a nice guy who made the mistake of clumsily making excuses of a bad showing because he didn't practice enough. Disappointing, but not seduced to the dark side. I believe neither Idra nor Naniwa are really "bad boys". They were just clumsy, socially awkward, miscommunicating and shit happened, so they had to play the role. Lilbow should do that too to make himself more prominent. Next time people will pay to see him lose to a Korean data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c81e3/c81e334f952fa6a3b77a0f55297a8c05972c04b5" alt="" . I don't think Idra and Nani are actually Sith but they were/ are bm and ragers. Lilbow has a lot to learn yet.
|
I respect Lilbow as a player in terms of skill, however I do not respect him as a person anymore. He turned his back to whole foreign scene, Starcraft 2 scene in general. He probably does not care about my feelings, and the feeling is mutual. For me, his attitude is pure disgrace of esports and from now on, in my eyes, Lilbow is the equivalent of someone, who absolutely does not know the meaning of word "sportsmanship" at all.
|
By the way if anyone missed it, CatZ statement on the case in response to Chuddinator on reddit.
https://www.reddit.com/r/starcraft/comments/3r51gs/this_is_why_foreigners_will_always_be_foreigners/cwlg2i2
Show nested quote +Korean players in SC2 and LoL understand the burden of taking on the title of progamer and will practice and play their hearts out to honor that title. Why is there so many cases of Matchfixing then?... See blanket statements aren't fair, it's not fair to downplay western/foreign players nor put them all in the same basket. Lilbow's chances were the worst in the tournament to begin with and had no access to an active ladder or active practice partners to prepare with, as I said before, I wouldn't do the same, but I can respect his adult decision. He believes that doing this is what gives his career as a player the best chances, wether that is correct or not is irrelevant, his intentions are clear and have no malice attached to them. These were extraordinary circumstances not likely to repeat themselves, LOTV Beta being up makes it incredibly hard to prepare, so being the weakest player and knowing that he has virtually have no practice partners or even a ladder going up against -the best- KeSPA players living and preparing in houses with their teammates and the still active KR ladder... it's a tough situation to be in. No one likes losing or giving up, but Lilbow made it clear his goal was to win WCS and after that stated more than once that he lost motivation in Hots, he said multiple times that he didn't think he had a chance at Blizzcon, does that make him such a horrible monster? To the second part of your blanket statement if it counts for anything I've been around eSports and poured my heart and soul into it for a good 5+ years trying to do my bit to help it grow to where it is right now, and Lilbow isn't a disgrace to me, he's an adult who made an honest (perhaps dumb, perhaps not) decision, with no malice whatsoever for what he believes is the best for his career, that's all. I promise you he tried his best in the games, he wasn't throwing or matchfixing, he just didn't prepare as much - and I can't give him shit for that because I know how hard it has been to find anyone to prepare with outside of Korea in the last month+ for Hots. (Again, an extraordinary circumstance that won't be repeating itself in sc2). I get that I'm going against the circle jerk, and I understand that him explicitly saying 'he didn't practice' as an excuse or whatever that is doesn't look good on anyone involved, himself included and is kind of 'weak', his biggest mistake was to type that tweet, but how much preparation he decides to put in is kind of up to him, he earned that spot, not anyone else. He didn't matchfix or break any rules, he did what he thought was best for him - selfish? absolutely, but that's about his biggest sin here. I'm sure everyone (yourself included) has found themselves guilty of being selfish more than once in your lifetime, just saying, judging helps no one and I'm sure he learned his lesson, jump off the high horses and lay down the pitchforks - those help no one either.
|
Very very disappointing. I didn't expect any players would do this at blizzcon
|
Lilbow didn't stand a chance against Life. Lilbow, Life, and the entire scene knows that. Everyone expected a 3-0, and that's what actually happened. Why the drama?
We don't need ethics lessons here. The guy didn't kill anybody. Calm down guys.
|
On November 03 2015 01:32 Ctone23 wrote: Lilbow is a WCS Champion, no twitter BM can take that away. He is a young man who in the end made a poor choice of words. That's just it, words...
Look at Life's pre and post game interview. Pre game he says he knows nothing of Lilbow and will simply crush him because he's a foreigner, yet post game he admitted to studying him and planning the all in strategies for each game. Players are full of shit and always looking for the #mindgames.
Twisting his words and pitchforking him as a disrespectful player is utter bullshit. He gave his all this year and deserved his spot. The timing wasn't great with DH winter qualifiers just happening, etc. Let's not crucify this young man for a poor choice of words for attention. He's clearly one of, if not THE best foreigner we have. Let's calm down and wish him well in the future.
I agree, lets give him a chance to redeem himself. Because not doing anything to give good games is disrespectful to the game and the fans! But anyone can do stupid something stupid and Come back!
|
Here is my thought.
Lilbow was afraid. Not afraid of Life or afraid of losing, because he would never be as good as he is if he had these fears. He was just afraid of trying REALLY hard, and still coming up 0-3. Now at least, it has some validity and he saves face.
I know this fear because it is the same (sad) reason I am not masters. I piddle around against AI and ladder every so often, but never sit down and say OKAY for this month I am going to bust my ass and try to get masters. Because what if I cant? What if I really try and I just can't then I'm just bad or something.
I totally understand why he did not want to try. It's scary to give your all and to come up short. That is the same reason Stephano always had his excuses. You just undersell everything then its okay to lose.
No one is going to say, "I've been training really hard, and I've put my whole life into this for a month" and then get 0-3'd? Ouch.
The only foreigner who would do this is Snute, and that is why he is so loved! I don't blame Lilbow, but I would have loved to see him move to Korea for a month and play smurf Korean account and ladder or something to train. Even at the risk that this would expose his practice to the Koreans, at least he would have tried. O well.
I think he could have won. I think he was good enough, when giving 100% effort, to have a 30 or 40% chance against Life. I guess we will never know.
|
Aotearoa39261 Posts
On November 03 2015 11:27 CursOr wrote: Here is my thought.
Lilbow was afraid. Not afraid of Life or afraid of losing, because he would never be as good as he is if he had these fears. He was just afraid of trying REALLY hard, and still coming up 0-3. Now at least, it has some validity and he saves face.
I know this fear because it is the same (sad) reason I am not masters. I piddle around against AI and ladder every so often, but never sit down and say OKAY for this month I am going to bust my ass and try to get masters. Because what if I cant? What if I really try and I just can't then I'm just bad or something.
I totally understand why he did not want to try. It's scary to give your all and to come up short. That is the same reason Stephano always had his excuses. You just undersell everything then its okay to lose.
No one is going to say, "I've been training really hard, and I've put my whole life into this for a month" and then get 0-3'd? Ouch.
The only foreigner who would do this is Snute, and that is why he is so loved! I don't blame Lilbow, but I would have loved to see him move to Korea for a month and play smurf Korean account and ladder or something to train. Even at the risk that this would expose his practice to the Koreans, at least he would have tried. O well.
I think he could have won. I think he was good enough, when giving 100% effort, to have a 30 or 40% chance against Life. I guess we will never know. I dont think he was afraid, but your analysis is right. Giving 100% effort he could get a 30-40% chance vs life at best. So why not focus on LotV, get really good at that, and crush the tournaments after that. The payoff there is far greater since his chance of winning R1 was so low. It's a disappointing stance from the spectator point of view, but understandable from his point of view.
|
On November 03 2015 11:34 Plexa wrote:Show nested quote +On November 03 2015 11:27 CursOr wrote: Here is my thought.
Lilbow was afraid. Not afraid of Life or afraid of losing, because he would never be as good as he is if he had these fears. He was just afraid of trying REALLY hard, and still coming up 0-3. Now at least, it has some validity and he saves face.
I know this fear because it is the same (sad) reason I am not masters. I piddle around against AI and ladder every so often, but never sit down and say OKAY for this month I am going to bust my ass and try to get masters. Because what if I cant? What if I really try and I just can't then I'm just bad or something.
I totally understand why he did not want to try. It's scary to give your all and to come up short. That is the same reason Stephano always had his excuses. You just undersell everything then its okay to lose.
No one is going to say, "I've been training really hard, and I've put my whole life into this for a month" and then get 0-3'd? Ouch.
The only foreigner who would do this is Snute, and that is why he is so loved! I don't blame Lilbow, but I would have loved to see him move to Korea for a month and play smurf Korean account and ladder or something to train. Even at the risk that this would expose his practice to the Koreans, at least he would have tried. O well.
I think he could have won. I think he was good enough, when giving 100% effort, to have a 30 or 40% chance against Life. I guess we will never know. I dont think he was afraid, but your analysis is right. Giving 100% effort he could get a 30-40% chance vs life at best. So why not focus on LotV, get really good at that, and crush the tournaments after that. The payoff there is far greater since his chance of winning R1 was so low. It's a disappointing stance from the spectator point of view, but understandable from his point of view.
The problem is this: he did not do all he can to compete against a group of top players in one of the most prestigious tournament. If he is a _professional_ gamer, then his #1 job is to do all he can to compete, period. In this case, he just quit, and that's the point that most of us are accusing him of.
|
I don't understand why people are giving Lilbow such a hard time. I mean it's not like he was going to beat Life even if he did practice.
|
More disappointed in Life for cheesing him. He had just as much responsibility as Lilbow did to put on an entertaining show.
|
On November 03 2015 12:12 phodacbiet wrote: I don't understand why people are giving Lilbow such a hard time. I mean it's not like he was going to beat Life even if he did practice. The Toronto Maple Leafs are tanking and rebuilding this season. Does that mean they can play like crap and leave the net wide open for their opponents? No. They still have to give it their best in practice and games even if the chance of winning is slim What Lilbow did is leaving the net wide open and saying "I'm not even going to bother trying." Such a disgrace. And he calls himself a professional.
|
Canada11355 Posts
On November 03 2015 12:17 Larkin wrote: More disappointed in Life for cheesing him. He had just as much responsibility as Lilbow did to put on an entertaining show. Neither player's job is to put on an entertaining show. Their job is to win at Starcraft 2. There are no style points awarded in the game of Starcraft 2.
|
On November 03 2015 12:12 phodacbiet wrote: I don't understand why people are giving Lilbow such a hard time. I mean it's not like he was going to beat Life even if he did practice.
I don't understand why everyone thinks Lilbow has no chance against Life. Is Hydra that worst compared to Life? Didn't Lilbow went 0-2 against Hydra and was on the verge of losing, but to only do the impossible and made a come back and win the entire WCS tournament?
It just boggles my mind that after doing that and being a champion, he surrendered before the biggest tournament.
|
Mute City2363 Posts
On November 03 2015 12:28 Fecalfeast wrote:Show nested quote +On November 03 2015 12:17 Larkin wrote: More disappointed in Life for cheesing him. He had just as much responsibility as Lilbow did to put on an entertaining show. Neither player's job is to put on an entertaining show. Their job is to win at Starcraft 2. There are no style points awarded in the game of Starcraft 2.
Well, there kind of are. And Life won them all. Anyone who says that that series wasn't profoundly hilarious purely because of Lilbow's complete inability to defend predictable aggression and Life's willingness to completely show up his opponent is kidding themselves.
|
Canada11355 Posts
On November 03 2015 12:32 thecrazymunchkin wrote:Show nested quote +On November 03 2015 12:28 Fecalfeast wrote:On November 03 2015 12:17 Larkin wrote: More disappointed in Life for cheesing him. He had just as much responsibility as Lilbow did to put on an entertaining show. Neither player's job is to put on an entertaining show. Their job is to win at Starcraft 2. There are no style points awarded in the game of Starcraft 2. Well, there kind of are. And Life won them all. Anyone who says that that series wasn't profoundly hilarious purely because of Lilbow's complete inability to defend predictable aggression and Life's willingness to completely show up his opponent is kidding themselves. I didn't mean to suggest that I personally wasn't entertained; just that it's ridiculous to say that a tournament player is obligated to play in a certain way for entertainment.
|
The funny thing about lilbow is, that he had generated an incredible amount of positive comment in Korean Communities as well. As I might have explained in a past topic (WCS Region Lock), many people believed that the foreign community can flourish when left alone, and Lilbow was the best example everyone could give.
I am sure with this kind of sentiment back in Korea, the foreign sentiment for Lilbow wouldn't even compare.
Just know, whoever is defending him at this point, that you are agreeing to be completely fine with him taking every foreigner's dream, every foreigner's hope, and spitting into it, crumpling it up into a little tiny ball, and throwing it in the trash can.
I have read some facebook comments stating that the Koreans would have leaked lilbow's builds if he had chosen to practice with them. Korean progamers have more honour than that. Before they question us on ours, I would like them to think about how Lilbow threw away his honor as a professional gamer.
Lilbow first says he practiced 2 HOTS games. Then he declares he lost only because Life cheesed. Then, he declares he lost because nobody would practice with him in HOTS. And finally, he blocks TLO.
People hated Life so much for his plays until lilbow came out and tweeted for whatever braindead thoughts he was having. Now, Lilbow is just another whining foreigner.
Compare him to FanTaSy, who, amidst all odds that herO would dominate 3-0, actually took an insane first game and lost others but making it look so close.
Compare him to Polt and Hydra, (who, by the way, beat Dream who beat Life who beat Lilbow) who clearly came prepared with clear builds in their mind, knew how their opponent would play, and crushed them in the end.
Remind me to say that Lilbow beat Hydra back in WCS. Guess who went up to Ro8 and who didn't?
Lilbow now keeps resorting to 'Life cheesed me', after building not a single forge nor mothership core. If Lilbow sincerely thought he would have a chance vs Life based on some mid game build orders that he wrote down after 2 games of HOTS, he just disrespected the entire SC2 scene.
Maybe, Lilbow should stop playing LoL and get practicing. Really hope he comes through in Dreamhack and proves us wrong that foreigners have no professionalism in ESports. Or maybe I should cheer on Snute, Mana, TLO, or Bunny. They would have played their hearts out.
I wonder what HyuN was thinking, and Dark, and every other progamer who was following this entire scene.
Go look at PartinG's tweet after he lost.
We're not your fans anymore Lilbow.
Private comment: The tweet that made sd_andeh sick? I was the one who asked him that. It made me sick too and I quit tweeting him after that. I wanted something that would restore my faith in him, that 2 games of HOTS was a really bad comment because he was angry and he actually played 2000 or something. Really wanted him to get through, but I don't think he deserves anything anymore.
|
Mute City2363 Posts
On November 03 2015 12:35 Fecalfeast wrote:Show nested quote +On November 03 2015 12:32 thecrazymunchkin wrote:On November 03 2015 12:28 Fecalfeast wrote:On November 03 2015 12:17 Larkin wrote: More disappointed in Life for cheesing him. He had just as much responsibility as Lilbow did to put on an entertaining show. Neither player's job is to put on an entertaining show. Their job is to win at Starcraft 2. There are no style points awarded in the game of Starcraft 2. Well, there kind of are. And Life won them all. Anyone who says that that series wasn't profoundly hilarious purely because of Lilbow's complete inability to defend predictable aggression and Life's willingness to completely show up his opponent is kidding themselves. I didn't mean to suggest that I personally wasn't entertained; just that it's ridiculous to say that a tournament player is obligated to play in a certain way for entertainment.
Yeah, I completely agree; it's just that in this context, I find it amusing that people are bashing Life for not "putting on an entertaining show". Firstly, he doesn't have to (as you said), and secondly, that dismantling was much more entertaining than any +2 stalker attack Lilbow would have had planned.
|
On November 03 2015 11:34 Plexa wrote:Show nested quote +On November 03 2015 11:27 CursOr wrote: Here is my thought.
Lilbow was afraid. Not afraid of Life or afraid of losing, because he would never be as good as he is if he had these fears. He was just afraid of trying REALLY hard, and still coming up 0-3. Now at least, it has some validity and he saves face.
I know this fear because it is the same (sad) reason I am not masters. I piddle around against AI and ladder every so often, but never sit down and say OKAY for this month I am going to bust my ass and try to get masters. Because what if I cant? What if I really try and I just can't then I'm just bad or something.
I totally understand why he did not want to try. It's scary to give your all and to come up short. That is the same reason Stephano always had his excuses. You just undersell everything then its okay to lose.
No one is going to say, "I've been training really hard, and I've put my whole life into this for a month" and then get 0-3'd? Ouch.
The only foreigner who would do this is Snute, and that is why he is so loved! I don't blame Lilbow, but I would have loved to see him move to Korea for a month and play smurf Korean account and ladder or something to train. Even at the risk that this would expose his practice to the Koreans, at least he would have tried. O well.
I think he could have won. I think he was good enough, when giving 100% effort, to have a 30 or 40% chance against Life. I guess we will never know. I dont think he was afraid, but your analysis is right. Giving 100% effort he could get a 30-40% chance vs life at best. So why not focus on LotV, get really good at that, and crush the tournaments after that. The payoff there is far greater since his chance of winning R1 was so low. It's a disappointing stance from the spectator point of view, but understandable from his point of view.
Do you really think the extra 2 weeks he's going to be practicing the unbalanced LotV beta is going to be the difference between him being great at LotV and not? So much of a difference that it's worth throwing his reputation as a pro player in the mud? When people switched from WoL to HotS, it was generally the bad players who started playing beta as early as possible in hopes of getting an advantage when HotS was released. The good players were still on WoL right up until the end playing tournaments. Yet, when HotS came out, for the most part, the good players were still good and the bad players were still bad. The extra little bit of practice didn't make a huge difference at all. This is the same for Lilbow, practicing LotV an extra month early won't offer a huge advantage worth throwing away a fucking Blizzcon for.
|
|
|
|