| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Blargh
United States2103 Posts
But, PL format does at allow for a more "strategic" player system. It also allows the horribly balanced maps to be used, but that is partially why there are so many mirror match-ups to begin with. Anyway, half-and-half is nice. And thank you for the videos! | ||
|
bluQ
Germany1724 Posts
On April 13 2013 06:51 achan1058 wrote: But how do you decrease the number of mirrors? If a given map X favours a given race Y, then it is likely that both sides knows this, and send race Y to play it. Or they meta it with a prepared sniper for race Y on map X. Thats why it's fun! | ||
|
riyanme
Philippines940 Posts
as for the rants about mirror match ups, why not use other race if you think its boring? (for the team who "values" netizens call) as if that happens! mirror matches were there for a reason. edit: all kill format doesnt really shows the team strength in general. 1 or 2 man "team" is isn't worth to be called a team. thats why its called proleague for that reason. *though i admit sc2 is boring compared to bw. i cant find myself cheering/shouting as fight engages on.* | ||
|
MateShade
Australia736 Posts
| ||
|
vinsang1000
Belgium365 Posts
| ||
|
L3gendary
Canada1470 Posts
Proleague format allows the fans to get more of a connection to the team. They become fans of the team and not just the ace player. This makes watching non-ace players more interesting as you come to know them and you take an interest in their progress throughout the season. And the proleague format has more merit as a team competition. With winner's league you are basically just asking "Which team has the best player?" instead of "Which team has the deepest roster?". | ||
|
TeslasPigeon
464 Posts
On April 13 2013 07:10 bluQ wrote: Or they meta it with a prepared sniper for race Y on map X. Thats why it's fun! But then the opposing team knows that you prepared a sniper with race Y, then the other team will prepare a counter sniper using race Z. Now since X is a constant which is equal to the variables Y and Z, we must include the proleague factor PL. If we divide by R and subtract Z, X is now equal to Y times PL. But if PL is equal to or greater than 1, Y will approach Z. Thus transforming the original equation X = (Y + Z) * PL into X = Y + Y, a mirror match. It's basic math people. | ||
|
Bobbias
Canada1373 Posts
I'm by no means saying that all-kill is bad. It has it's good points. It is generally more exciting since there is more on the line, and you get a chance to see players possibly roll through an entire team's roster for the all-kill, or even better, the reverse all-kill, but I believe we need a balanced representation of team leagues. Proleague is one of the only leagues that has a format that really truly emphasizes the team aspect over the individual players. Anyone remember "Team Taeja"? | ||
|
mechengineer123
Ukraine711 Posts
| ||
GTR
51593 Posts
On April 12 2013 15:46 dtz wrote: I think the regular season format is alright. The mix of PL and WL is already good. But the playoff format during the last few seasons of BW was just dumb and i think was one of the reason ( not main reason but part of) that viewership of PL was down Basically it made the more successful team( who is usually the more popular teams with the better players) wait in the final. So SKT1 was the regular season winner. They had the most fans. But that means they had to wait in the final and only play BO1 when every other round was Bo3. That's so much viewership wasted.Imagine if the NBA makes Miami Heat wait in the final instead of them starting from the same round as everyone else and make the NBA Final Bo3 I actually don't know this season's playoff format but I hope they have changed it. It's a logistics issue more than anything that the final has to be a Bo1. Unfortunate, but no real way around it. As for seeding the #1 team directly into the final, it's a common occurrence in all Korean sports leagues, whether it would be football, baseball or basketball. It's designed to make the regular season worth playing for. | ||
|
StarVe
Germany13591 Posts
It rewards depth more and you get to see more players instead of mostly the aces. Bo1 isn't ideal, but you've got to deal with it. | ||
|
SkimGuy
Canada709 Posts
I was talking about BW Brave: http://www.teamliquid.net/tlpd/details.php?section=korean&type=players&id=549&part=games&league=standard | ||
|
Warpath
Canada1242 Posts
| ||
|
lolmlg
619 Posts
| ||
|
LighT.
Canada4501 Posts
On April 13 2013 06:51 achan1058 wrote: But how do you decrease the number of mirrors? If a given map X favours a given race Y, then it is likely that both sides knows this, and send race Y to play it. Simple. Have the coaches meet up at the KeSPA office once every week when the line ups are made. Coaches take turns placing the players on the maps using a (122112211221 formula) with the rule of 1 mirror match maximum per choosing per match So for example...Samsung vs KT 1st pick Jangbi <Neo Planet S> 2nd Pick: Flash 4th Pick: Reality <Akion Wastes) 3rd Pick: Zest 5th pick: Stork <Fighting Spirit> 6th: Stork So every per match..you are guaranteed for 4 Non-mirror match ups per week. Pros: - ZvZ/PvP specialists are still kept with use - less mirror Cons: - less TvT - less ZvZ/PvP to people who enjoy watching those. | ||
|
LighT.
Canada4501 Posts
| ||
|
Fischbacher
Canada666 Posts
I would actually be interested in seeing a form of hybrid format tested out where the first match is set in advance (like in AK). After the first match, the losing team chose a map, the wining team chose a player that hasn't played yet and the losing team then picks an opponent for that player (who also hasn't played yet). This would give the trailing team an advantage, allow more snipers and team strategies while still preventing a player from AKing. | ||
|
MetalPanda
Canada1152 Posts
| ||
|
sluggaslamoo
Australia4494 Posts
1. Whether you enjoy AK more or not, All Kill format is simply unsustainable Team Flash and Team Jaedong took great tolls on their respective ace players. Not only did bad players feel bad about not having televised matches, Ace players would have to deal with a huge amount of depression and anxiety due to the responsibility they had for their teams. The Aces would play for 2 and a half hours at a physical disadvantage against a barrage of snipe builds designed by multiple special coaches. I'm not saying we should have no winners league, but the seasons should be kept short and far apart to allow aces to recouperate. The only good thing about winners league is showing how truly remarkable the top players are, out thinking multiple players and coaches with no preparation while playing for hours against fresh opponents. 2. The ACE match hype myth Ace matches still happen in SPL because often Ace confidence mattered much more than what you put down on paper, and also its much harder to predict who you will face, so preparation is not as easy. Nothing worse than sending out a PvT sniper against a Zerg and losing a whole bunch of fans in the process. It was Winners League where all the sniping happened, get all your 5 players to prepare builds against Flash and one is bound to win, often times due to this, you would miss Ace vs Ace matches. It doesn't get better, there's nothing worse than seeing Jaedong fight against 4 snipers and then just lose in 7 mins to Flash because his brain is fried. PL is much better because you still get to see the Aces fight against each other, and they are feeling fresh and confident. On top of that you had the hype of "is the coach really going to send out Flash/Bisu/JD/Stork?" then when they do get selected everyone goes nuts, its awesome. When Bisu was losing matches, he still got sent out for the Ace match because of his ability to play under pressure and often win against all odds. In Winners League you didn't get this same sensation. | ||
opterown
Australia54784 Posts
| ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Britney Dota 2  23899Calm  5158EffOrt 773Soma 250Hyuk 191actioN 191ggaemo 124hero 113Mind  57sSak 51[ Show more ] Counter-Strike Other Games Grubby4502 FrodaN1618 Liquid`RaSZi1155 B2W.Neo977 Beastyqt723 ceh9574 ArmadaUGS214 RotterdaM100 QueenE62 C9.Mang046 Trikslyr34 Fuzer  19 |
|
GSL
SHIN vs Zoun
ByuN vs herO
OSC
OSC
Replay Cast
Escore
The PondCast
WardiTV Invitational
Zoun vs Ryung
Lambo vs ShoWTimE
OSC
Replay Cast
CranKy Ducklings
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
