07:06 KST - method linked here has been disproved here
10:54 KST - Find a full timeline of pro comments (including Spades) in the topic here.
08:47 KST - Summary: Accusations of maphacking have the potential to destroy a player's career if left unaddressed. Because of the potential consequences, we should be careful about accepting unproven accusations. The principle of 'innocent until proven guilty' should be applied here. That does not mean that there has been a conclusion about this case, however, which is why this thread remains tentatively open.
Please discuss with caution and use evidence to back up your claims.
(also a summary post by an unnamed pro on reddit here)
On June 05 2012 13:17 rhs408 wrote: *REGARDING THE "MAGIC SCANS"*
I just did a custom game to be sure of exactly where the center of the scan hits when you target the very top of the screen - YOU DO NOT SEE THE CENTER OF THE SCAN! IT COMES OUT EXACTLY LIKE HOW YOU SAW IN THE REPLAYS! TRY IT YOURSELF PLEASE!
I'm still on the fence though as to if he hacks or not, and I was always a fan... the quick siege and then unsiege was very, very strange, as well as not looking at the scouting scv... need some more explanation from Spades on those.
More people need to try this.
Doesn't matter, the scan was so far away from the screen that the only way he could had done it was if he did it on the minimap, and why the hell do you scan but never look at the area you just scanned?
On June 05 2012 13:20 sureup wrote: I tested the magic scan, and yes you cannot see the center!
It seemed like the center of spades' scan was even further away, it most definitely lookedlike it was a minimap scan. and wouldn't be possible when he was simultaneously moving his mouse up to scroll the screen upward and then somehow down to the minimap perfectly and simultaneously not move the camera
On June 05 2012 12:13 Mirhi wrote: Well, while it's bad form to throw someone under the bus, I'm just going to do it because all this came out and I have a fact that actually matters.
Spades stream cheated during showmatches that he played while he lived with me at what was the Reign house. It's a carry over from the stream cheating that many Koreans do in the Korean prohouses (Both Spades and Artist have confirmed with me that Koreans frequently stream cheat in team leagues and showmatches against foreigners out of pride).
If ever I saw it happen when I was in the house, I would immediately try to stop them, but I know on occasion it still occured, most notably in a match Spades played against Gatored last year.
About maphacking, I have no idea and have no opinion on the matter other than either option wouldn't surprise me.
I would want to say though, that cheating occurs way more than people realize, and I actually would not be so hard on him for this evidence, even if it is true. Players better than Spades actively cheat, particularly stream cheat or simply ghosting, because of how easy it is.
Example - Leenock was over a player's shoulder at MLG Providence helping them during a game, giving them hints in Korean.
It's pretty common.
This is really scary, I don't doubt there are a lot of people out there who know shit is going down but are afraid of being the ones doing it.
When you think about it, it 's not surprising at all. Imagine you're at a team house surrounded by team mates playing in a Playhem tournament for 100$ or whatever which is being streamed with no delay. It's so easy for a team mate to just on the stream and start telling you what's going on. Every online tournament needs to start using significant delays. It's just madness that they don't and expect people not to cheat.
Yeah I was afraid of this, if the poorer Korean teams and player have the means to make money in online tournaments by cheating easily I can see the younger ones doing it. especially in a team house environment where it's easy to give into peer pressure.
I really doubt this happens in the Slayers/IM houses though.
And not just Koreans. Any foreigner who lives in a house with other gamers is going to be just as likely to do this. It just seems so silly to broadcast online tournaments live with no delay when there's money involved.
Diamond:
This is probably the single largest accusation ever in SC2 history, I hope it has no basis (Korean stream cheating in pro houses) because if true stands to shake the entire foundation of Starcraft.
I asked people I know in Korea and some confirmed it but not people I would trust enough to say it's a 100% thing, but the person I trust the most in Korea told me they has not seen it but believes it. The general consensus is that if you build a system that allows it than it's your fault.
PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE do not take this as confirming it, it is far from it, but now would be a good time for someone to look into this, both from the journalism side and that ever useless SC2CON or w/e it's called now.
Again I really hope this is not true about the Korean houses, as well as Leenock.
Spades is really the smallest revelation in that I feel.....
tgun:
I've just asked a few people and they've also confirmed that stream cheating is pretty common.
On June 05 2012 13:17 rhs408 wrote: *REGARDING THE "MAGIC SCANS"*
I just did a custom game to be sure of exactly where the center of the scan hits when you target the very top of the screen - YOU DO NOT SEE THE CENTER OF THE SCAN! IT COMES OUT EXACTLY LIKE HOW YOU SAW IN THE REPLAYS! TRY IT YOURSELF PLEASE!
I'm still on the fence though as to if he hacks or not, and I was always a fan... the quick siege and then unsiege was very, very strange, as well as not looking at the scouting scv... need some more explanation from Spades on those.
More people need to try this.
Doesn't matter, the scan was so far away from the screen that the only way he could had done it was if he did it on the minimap, and why the hell do you scan but never look at the area you just scanned?
On June 05 2012 13:20 algorithm0r wrote: It is sad that the TL community should decide these things. We the community have no stakes in this.
If Blizzard wishes to protect the integrity of its ladder it can do so with bans or demotions based on whatever evidence it wants (see the ToS if you like) but we don't have the right or even the responsibility to help them find and accuse these violations.
If a tournament wishes to eliminate misconduct in its games it can and may set the conditions under which a player may be disqualified. Again we don't have any right or responsibility to participate in deciding these issues.
There is a reason why courts do not conduct hearings on public internet forums. This and all threads like these should be IMMEDIATELY CLOSED due to the damage they do to the player regardless of whether they were in the wrong or not. Spades does not deserve his name dragged through the mud EVEN IF HE IS GUILTY!!!! Maphacking is at best a "crime" of an insecure person whose insecurities are already sufficient punishment.
GL HF Spades.
cause blizzard acts so fast at banning bots/hackers.
It is Blizzards business only, not ours. If they want to leave them on there forever they can.
yah cuz this has nothing to do with tournaments or prize moneyz.
just ladder points rite?
Do you work for a tournament? If so then please apply what ever measures you need to stop hacking in your tournament. If not then you have no business determining who is a cheater or not.
On June 05 2012 13:11 soon.Cloak wrote: Just a clarification... It seems that some people are annoyed with this whole thing because they say there is no concrete evidence.
And they're right. But missing the point.
Nobody here can say with 100% certainty that Spades hacked. But that shouldn't matter. If he would have kept his camera locked on his base for 100 seconds as he blindly moved his army with the minimap to avoid the opponent's army, that also wouldn't be a 100% proof, but would be good enough for everyone to assume he was watching the other army. What people are saying is that there is enough circumstantial evidence that he hacked. Enough circumstantial evidence is good enough at a point, and what some are arguing is that it reached that point.
If you don't think it reached that point, fine. But please stop saying it's illegitimate because it's circumstantial.
Anything short of a computer scan that is proven to detect all hacks could be considered circumstantial.
I think the camera lock and these "magic scans" are rather conclusive though.
I would tend to agree, but I don't know anything about the replay being not perfectly in sync.
That's also why I think "Innocent until proven guilty" is being misused, and should not be taken literally. Even in court, DNA evidence is taken, because it's 99.9999% good. What about the .0001%? Nobody cares- "proven" just means beyond a reasonable doubt.
Same thing here. Nobody can literally prove he cheated, but to demand that is ridiculous.
On June 05 2012 13:24 DjDickGrayson wrote: Stream Arrest! And request to keep thread open!!
Why don't we watch his streamed games and see if he plays the same then compare results to the accused hacked matches. I also, and I'm sure the pro's feel the same way, encourage anyone that might have a suspicious replay to come forward. Livelihood's are at stake here and we must reach a conclusion quickly, we don't want a smear/bullying campaign on our hands.
Wouldn't be hard to turn it "off" and play normally.
On June 05 2012 13:16 poeticEnnui wrote: I just saw CatZ's analysis of the "Magic Scan."
Consensus says that it's impossible, but we all know how reliable consensus is -- so howabout we try to empirically verify the truth of it? So: let's load up a game vs. AI and try to recreate a "Magic Scan." If we can reproduce it without hacks, we can throw this evidence out. If not, it's still on the table.
I didn't read every page of the thread, but this seems to be in the vein of what Nerchio tried to do. Let's follow his example -- the abundance of induction-based and lack of logic-based ethics in this debate is disturbing.
I'm thinking about doing it myself, but the question is also why? I play terran, over 2500 games and never in my life have I scanned without a reason for scanning. Following that, I have to think about scanning before I scan. And following that, and perhaps this is a stretch, but I have never scrolled my screen in a direction away from the minimap if I plan to use a minimap scan.
His defense (or at least one of them)was that he was suffering mouse problems, in which case, if we were to believe that, there wouldn't be a reason to test it. Even if no one can produce a magic scan, surely someone with a malfunctioning mouse can.
Someone people are also claiming the possibility of a 4:3 resolution. Possible, but 1) i'd like to see him confirm if he is using such a resolution, and then 2) someone with a similar resolution can try to produce it (although this has the same faults as the malfunction mouse argument).
My point being how do people who have been caught once already still have a career? and be invited to such things as the redbull BG? He gets so much attention even after being a cheat. I guess there are different standards for different people in the community.
On June 05 2012 13:20 algorithm0r wrote: It is sad that the TL community should decide these things. We the community have no stakes in this.
If Blizzard wishes to protect the integrity of its ladder it can do so with bans or demotions based on whatever evidence it wants (see the ToS if you like) but we don't have the right or even the responsibility to help them find and accuse these violations.
If a tournament wishes to eliminate misconduct in its games it can and may set the conditions under which a player may be disqualified. Again we don't have any right or responsibility to participate in deciding these issues.
There is a reason why courts do not conduct hearings on public internet forums. This and all threads like these should be IMMEDIATELY CLOSED due to the damage they do to the player regardless of whether they were in the wrong or not. Spades does not deserve his name dragged through the mud EVEN IF HE IS GUILTY!!!! Maphacking is at best a "crime" of an insecure person whose insecurities are already sufficient punishment.
GL HF Spades.
I strongly disagree. We, the community, have a responsibility to police ourselves and weed out the bad apples. We do not and should not delegate this responsibility to anyone. If anything, Blizzard should be helping us.
On June 05 2012 12:13 Mirhi wrote: Well, while it's bad form to throw someone under the bus, I'm just going to do it because all this came out and I have a fact that actually matters.
Spades stream cheated during showmatches that he played while he lived with me at what was the Reign house. It's a carry over from the stream cheating that many Koreans do in the Korean prohouses (Both Spades and Artist have confirmed with me that Koreans frequently stream cheat in team leagues and showmatches against foreigners out of pride).
If ever I saw it happen when I was in the house, I would immediately try to stop them, but I know on occasion it still occured, most notably in a match Spades played against Gatored last year.
About maphacking, I have no idea and have no opinion on the matter other than either option wouldn't surprise me.
I would want to say though, that cheating occurs way more than people realize, and I actually would not be so hard on him for this evidence, even if it is true. Players better than Spades actively cheat, particularly stream cheat or simply ghosting, because of how easy it is.
Example - Leenock was over a player's shoulder at MLG Providence helping them during a game, giving them hints in Korean.
It's pretty common.
Quick question: How does Spades and Artist know MANY Koreans frequently stream cheat? That's a big accusation.
Time spent in multiple Korean prohouses. They both told me it was standard in Korea and even more wide spread there than it is here. The exact scenario was, I asked Artist if Koreans cheated, he shrugged and said "Yes. Korean standard." It was almost a joke, but we discussed it more later. There's a completely different view point of it there. I had to explain to Artist how badly America and Europe thought of it and stress he could never do it, it would be the end of his career if he did. It took me like 30 minutes to really make it clear how unacceptable it was to everyone, and to me personally.
If you're going to be a whistleblower for this (which would likely lead to the end of live-streamed showmatches or tournaments where the players weren't inhouse and bring in pure replay-casted games) could you please make a thread about it and detail it all?
You answered your own question.
So you aren't going to make a thread about it? I understand not wanting to risk your career, which would obviously be put at stake with such a huge accusation, but if that stream cheating shit is true it really should be brought to light. Obviously you shouldn't take the hit for it, but I wish a number of people (since lots of people seem to know about it) would come out and lift the veil. Eventually someone's gonna come clean and by then it may just destroy everything.
eSports is just like real sports. There's girls, there's drugs, there's cheating, there are people 100% legit.
I question whether people really want to know.
I see what you're saying, but as with real sports, these things usually eventually come out and often with catastrophic consequences. Keeping this stuff beneath the surface may not do the community any favors in the future, because if not revealed these things fester, grow, and get worse. (Again, this is not on you to reveal)
On June 05 2012 13:20 algorithm0r wrote: It is sad that the TL community should decide these things. We the community have no stakes in this.
If Blizzard wishes to protect the integrity of its ladder it can do so with bans or demotions based on whatever evidence it wants (see the ToS if you like) but we don't have the right or even the responsibility to help them find and accuse these violations.
If a tournament wishes to eliminate misconduct in its games it can and may set the conditions under which a player may be disqualified. Again we don't have any right or responsibility to participate in deciding these issues.
There is a reason why courts do not conduct hearings on public internet forums. This and all threads like these should be IMMEDIATELY CLOSED due to the damage they do to the player regardless of whether they were in the wrong or not. Spades does not deserve his name dragged through the mud EVEN IF HE IS GUILTY!!!! Maphacking is at best a "crime" of an insecure person whose insecurities are already sufficient punishment.
GL HF Spades.
cause blizzard acts so fast at banning bots/hackers.
It is Blizzards business only, not ours. If they want to leave them on there forever they can.
yah cuz this has nothing to do with tournaments or prize moneyz.
just ladder points rite?
Do you work for a tournament? If so then please apply what ever measures you need to stop hacking in your tournament. If not then you have no business determining who is a cheater or not.
yeah we shouldn't give him any negative attention or backlash.
otherwise he might feel the repercussions of cheating. that wouldn't be nice.
I finally made it to the last page of the thread, man I was reading for so long, but the thread just kept growing and growing. This feels like an episode of Law and Order: SCV, with everyone working the evidence and developing their cases. It is very interesting to see take shape.
On June 05 2012 13:20 algorithm0r wrote: It is sad that the TL community should decide these things. We the community have no stakes in this.
If Blizzard wishes to protect the integrity of its ladder it can do so with bans or demotions based on whatever evidence it wants (see the ToS if you like) but we don't have the right or even the responsibility to help them find and accuse these violations.
If a tournament wishes to eliminate misconduct in its games it can and may set the conditions under which a player may be disqualified. Again we don't have any right or responsibility to participate in deciding these issues.
There is a reason why courts do not conduct hearings on public internet forums. This and all threads like these should be IMMEDIATELY CLOSED due to the damage they do to the player regardless of whether they were in the wrong or not. Spades does not deserve his name dragged through the mud EVEN IF HE IS GUILTY!!!! Maphacking is at best a "crime" of an insecure person whose insecurities are already sufficient punishment.
GL HF Spades.
cause blizzard acts so fast at banning bots/hackers.
It is Blizzards business only, not ours. If they want to leave them on there forever they can.
and risk destroying the legitimacy of competitive gaming for sc2. yeah
its not impossible to scan like that, but if someone does it like that he very well alyways scans this way, guess what, spades doesnt, in games on stream u see him scan like every other terran does...
i saw the game against avilo live on stream... its just obvious that hes a hacker and just rediculous that hes still denying it... any experienced terran saves scans when he lost airsuperiority, thats nothing you can explain with cutting corners and gamesense, that is bullshit, if ur not doing it ur not a good player and therefore u dont play the level spades plays or ur a hacker