ThorZain and viOlet possible Code S seeds?
Forum Index > SC2 General |
Official statement by Snowbird: The brackets that were up for like 1min were not correct. There will be adjustments because of schedule conflicts of some players (MLG, Dreamhack). We will most likely post a final version of the brackets tomorrow. | ||
shockaslim
United States1104 Posts
| ||
MeLo
Australia192 Posts
| ||
IMoperator
4476 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:22 MeLo wrote: What Stephano rejected? He's going to KR in August, so season 4. | ||
snowbird
Germany2044 Posts
There will be adjustments because of schedule conflicts of some players (MLG, Dreamhack). We will most likely post a final version of the brackets tomorrow. | ||
blade55555
United States17423 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:22 MeLo wrote: What Stephano rejected? He won't be until the next season, the one in august or whatever unless I am mistaken. | ||
Opera
France469 Posts
Here they are : ![]() Edit : THESE GROUPS MAY NOT BE CORRECT ! | ||
Kergy
Peru2011 Posts
![]() Edit: ahh will check it out tomorrow, Go Violet! | ||
snowbird
Germany2044 Posts
We will make an official announcement of the groups by tomorrow. | ||
Amlitzer
United States471 Posts
| ||
aznball123
2759 Posts
| ||
Adreme
United States5574 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:32 aznball123 wrote: Violet? MLG/GSL still have that program? Well if stephano declined than only 2 people left who won foreign events who arent code S players are Violet and Squirtle. | ||
Angelbelow
United States3728 Posts
Don't worry, stephano will be there too, just not yet. | ||
chipmonklord17
United States11944 Posts
EDIT: Well if those groups don't get changed I'm going to retract my belief about violet, that's just fucking brutal. Thorzain I think could still do it | ||
Naded
Canada174 Posts
| ||
Boblhead
United States2577 Posts
| ||
![]()
Fionn
United States23455 Posts
And Thorzain is the right pick due to his win vs. Polt at Dreamhack. All in all, the 100% right choices with Stephano not being able to do Code S till Season 4. | ||
Fubi
2228 Posts
| ||
pdd
Australia9933 Posts
Although Violet and Thorzain are far better Code S seeds than Nightend. | ||
Yaki
France4234 Posts
| ||
![]()
opterown
![]()
Australia54784 Posts
| ||
polyphonyEX
United States2539 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:39 Boblhead wrote: stop giving foreigners seeds, even violet is iffy for me. Foreigners like all others just get knocked out first round, for the few who get mirror match ups like huk/naniwa in which they are good at then its different. But srsly mr chae needs to stop giving them seeds. If they aren't ready for GSL then they'll just get knocked out so it all balanced out eventually. | ||
SaetZero
United States855 Posts
god damn that group is stacked (well..... 75% anyway lol) | ||
RPR_Tempest
Australia7798 Posts
| ||
![]()
Olli
Austria24417 Posts
| ||
bittman
Australia8759 Posts
Hopefully both Violet and Thorzain are the seeds though. That will make me happy. | ||
pinball777
![]()
United States134 Posts
| ||
Kaiyotic
United States90 Posts
| ||
![]()
Fionn
United States23455 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:41 pdd wrote: Hmm.. what happened to Nightend then? He was mysteriously absent from Code A qualifiers and there doesn't seem to be a space for him in Code A already (40 players in it already). Although Violet and Thorzain are far better Code S seeds than Nightend. I have a feeling that Violet was invited, but declined due to wanting to stay in America and focus on MLG and other foreign tournaments. If so, then the seed will probably go to NightEnd like rumored and we'll see probably a 50+ page thread on how this is the worst decision in the history of e-sports. | ||
Opera
France469 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:49 Fionn wrote: I have a feeling that Violet was invited, but declined due to wanting to stay in America and focus on MLG and other foreign tournaments. If so, then the seed will probably go to NightEnd like rumored and we'll see probably a 50+ page thread on how this is the worst decision in the history of e-sports. Nightend doesn't have the skill to play in Code S. I'd much rather see Polt seeded once more. | ||
ObliviousNA
United States535 Posts
| ||
babylon
8765 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:53 ObliviousNA wrote: Anyone know who SuHoSin is? I kind of feel bad for him, I can't imagine him getting out of there... MVP is winning again, Genius is decent vs zerg (and a GSL finalist no less) and Happy is IM's vs Z specialist. Suhosin = Line. Don't discount him. He's pretty damn good when he chooses to be. Parting hates his Zergy group. | ||
Darion
Canada265 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:39 Fubi wrote: lol MKP/Parting/Symbol and poor Yugioh Yugioh got into Code S by beating MKP. He's legit. | ||
ObliviousNA
United States535 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:54 babylon wrote: Suhosin = Line. Don't discount him. He's pretty damn good when he chooses to be. Parting hates his Zergy group. Ah, I didn't make the connection. Yeah I guess not as terrible for him. I still can't see him beating MVP or Happy though. | ||
![]()
opterown
![]()
Australia54784 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:53 ObliviousNA wrote: Anyone know who SuHoSin is? I kind of feel bad for him, I can't imagine him getting out of there... MVP is winning again, Genius is decent vs zerg (and a GSL finalist no less) and Happy is IM's vs Z specialist. zenexline! | ||
Amlitzer
United States471 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:39 Boblhead wrote: stop giving foreigners seeds, even violet is iffy for me. Foreigners like all others just get knocked out first round, for the few who get mirror match ups like huk/naniwa in which they are good at then its different. But srsly mr chae needs to stop giving them seeds. Can't blame Mr. Chae for needing to cater to foreigners in order to put food on the table. Once the GSL becomes sufficiently popular enough I'm sure he will stop giving out these petty seeds, but in till then it's just good business sense. It also seems strange that GOM would give a seed to viOlet when he is in America dodging his military service. | ||
lisward
Singapore959 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:58 Amlitzer wrote: Can't blame Mr. Chae for needing to cater to foreigners in order to put food on the table. Once the GSL becomes sufficiently popular enough I'm sure he will stop giving out these petty seeds, but in till then it's just good business sense. It also seems strange that GOM would give a seed to viOlet when he is in America dodging his military service. Wait since when was Naniwa just a PvP specialist.... Naniwa earned his Code S spot as far as I am concerned. | ||
pdd
Australia9933 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:49 Fionn wrote: I have a feeling that Violet was invited, but declined due to wanting to stay in America and focus on MLG and other foreign tournaments. If so, then the seed will probably go to NightEnd like rumored and we'll see probably a 50+ page thread on how this is the worst decision in the history of e-sports. Maybe they seeded MMA or another Code A player (Polt?) and gave Nightend that player's Code A spot. | ||
johnnywup
United States3858 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:07 pdd wrote: Maybe they seeded MMA or another Code A player (Polt?) and gave Nightend that player's Code A spot. i can't see gom doing something like that | ||
Fueled
United States1610 Posts
| ||
Aunvilgod
2653 Posts
| ||
Farone
Netherlands1219 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:35 Adreme wrote: Well if stephano declined than only 2 people left who won foreign events who arent code S players are Violet and Squirtle. Squirtle was 2nd last GSL code S.... ![]() | ||
Mooneyes
Sweden72 Posts
I may not agree with Code S seeds, id much rather se Up and Down seeds all the way. requires preformance to enter Code S will still be giving them 2 chances before falling out. | ||
AxionSteel
United States7754 Posts
I like Mvp's group, apart from having to teamkill Happy. Hopefully those two groups stay the same ![]() I don't like MarineKing's group, 2 zergs, and Parting. Please change that ![]() | ||
LimeNade
United States2125 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:39 Fionn wrote: Very happy to see Violet back in Code S. He has somehow improved double since leaving MvP and moving to his new home in America. Could go very far. And Thorzain is the right pick due to his win vs. Polt at Dreamhack. All in all, the 100% right choices with Stephano not being able to do Code S till Season 4. heh i would say violet has prob gotten even better then double what he used to be when he was in code s before. At least a lot of his unique style of playing has become more solidified rather then what it used to be which was a bit gimmicky at times. | ||
FakeDeath
Malaysia6060 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:19 AxionSteel wrote: not the worst group for ThorZaIN tbh, although all groups would be extremely difficult for him ofc, as all players are really strong these days. I like Mvp's group, apart from having to teamkill Happy. Hopefully those two groups stay the same ![]() I don't like MarineKing's group, 2 zergs, and Parting. Please change that ![]() What do you mean? Its the MOST STACKED GROUP. It would be interesting to see who can make it out of that group. (Parting,Symbol,Yugioh,MKP).XD | ||
TAMinator
Australia2706 Posts
| ||
AxionSteel
United States7754 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:22 FakeDeath wrote: What do you mean? Its the MOST STACKED GROUP. It would be interesting to see who can make it out of that group. (Parting,Symbol,Yugioh,MKP).XD I mean as a fan of MarineKing ![]() | ||
S_SienZ
1878 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:55 ObliviousNA wrote: Ah, I didn't make the connection. Yeah I guess not as terrible for him. I still can't see him beating MVP or Happy though. Funny considering this guy got famous for knocking Mvp out of Super tournament. ![]() | ||
FakeDeath
Malaysia6060 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:23 AxionSteel wrote: I mean as a fan of MarineKing ![]() Well MKP shown us he can take down top zergs but Yugioh and Symbol are not pushovers though as they are also getting better. So excited. | ||
AxionSteel
United States7754 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:26 S_SienZ wrote: Funny considering this guy got famous for knocking Mvp out of Super tournament. ![]() Ganzi Beat Mvp in that tournament. | ||
S_SienZ
1878 Posts
Owait. LOL my bad. This guy was the guy that MKP knocked out with Mech on Terminus wasn't he? Who did he knock out again? | ||
RPR_Tempest
Australia7798 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:29 S_SienZ wrote: Owait. LOL my bad. This guy was the guy that MKP knocked out with Mech on Terminus wasn't he? Who did he knock out again? MKP beat Kyrix with Zerg on Terminus. Line was the underdog against all his opponents, but he just kept winning. He took out Jinro, Kyrix and NaDa before finally falling to TOP in an epic series 2-3. | ||
AxionSteel
United States7754 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:29 S_SienZ wrote: Owait. LOL my bad. This guy was the guy that MKP knocked out with Mech on Terminus wasn't he? Who did he knock out again? http://wiki.teamliquid.net/starcraft2/2011_GSL_Super_Tournament/Group_D The demise of Jinro ![]() | ||
arvinds94
United States40 Posts
| ||
Wroshe
Netherlands1051 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:49 Fionn wrote: I have a feeling that Violet was invited, but declined due to wanting to stay in America and focus on MLG and other foreign tournaments. If so, then the seed will probably go to NightEnd like rumored and we'll see probably a 50+ page thread on how this is the worst decision in the history of e-sports. Makes sense to me. All of the constant whine about seeds is getting annoying btw. It's the monthly (both when announced and when speculating who gets the next time) time the forums are filled with crap and people forget that GoM doesn't give a damn about making a tournament with the 32 best players but that they are actually running a business. Having seeded foreigners in there means they simply sell a lot more season tickets; especially if they start to do well. I feel the reason that most seeds got elimininated so quickly was either due to back luck (Polt 0-2 in the Group of Death) or simply picking the wrong players (IdrA). + Show Spoiler + who at the time had not won a single series since the NASL 2 finals and got destroyed at WCG by players not just one but two tiers below him If it isn't NightEnd then I'm not sure who they'll pick. I don't see them elevating someone who is already in Code A so my guess would be SaSe? Wouldn't be the most obvious choice but if they need someone in a pinch who has no plans leaving Korea he could be your guy. | ||
Wroshe
Netherlands1051 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:31 AxionSteel wrote: http://wiki.teamliquid.net/starcraft2/2011_GSL_Super_Tournament/Group_D The demise of Jinro ![]() In retrospect Jinro also really got bent over with those maps. That was still old Belshir with what feels like 96 different entrances to your natural (ok, ok, 3) and then of course Metalopolis in TvZ. Can't remember the games close enough to know how well he played but at least the maps did not help. | ||
AxionSteel
United States7754 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:37 Wroshe wrote: In retrospect Jinro also really got bent over with those maps. That was still old Belshir with what feels like 96 different entrances to your natural (ok, ok, 3) and then of course Metalopolis in TvZ. Can't remember the games close enough to know how well he played but at least the maps did not help. the matches were extremely one sided if i recall, lots of mutas just raping. That's my memory. Could be wrong ![]() And yeh I like seeds in general, but I think NightEnd getting one just seems a little weird. Thorzain won dreamhack, violet won MLG, that makes perfect sense. NightEnd is a decent player with no results but so happens to be in Korea, so they hand out a seed to him on a silver platter. I know he's been kicking ass on KR GM ladder, but that hardly qualifies lol. Nothing against NightEnd, he has the coolest voice ever and I'd like to see him succed ![]() | ||
Wrathsc2
United States2025 Posts
| ||
Yoshi Kirishima
United States10344 Posts
MKP and parting Nestea and naniwa xD top right group is gonna be hell though =O i like thorzain and gumiho, but i like squirtle too esp since he was up vs mvp last season, who i hate lol =O well actually a shit load of these groups should be hard X) nice to see ghostking back in code S! | ||
Asha
United Kingdom38255 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:41 pdd wrote: Hmm.. what happened to Nightend then? He was mysteriously absent from Code A qualifiers and there doesn't seem to be a space for him in Code A already (40 players in it already). Although Violet and Thorzain are far better Code S seeds than Nightend. I heard Nightend was just heading back to Europe so didn't attend. Maybe people spouting more BS though hah =p === Violet back in Code S would be awesome, he deserves it so much if he wants it. | ||
Wroshe
Netherlands1051 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:39 AxionSteel wrote: the matches were extremely one sided if i recall, lots of mutas just raping. That's my memory. Could be wrong ![]() And yeh I like seeds in general, but I think NightEnd getting one just seems a little weird. Thorzain won dreamhack, violet won MLG, that makes perfect sense. NightEnd is a decent player with no results but so happens to be in Korea, so they hand out a seed to him on a silver platter. I know he's been kicking ass on KR GM ladder, but that hardly qualifies lol. Nothing against NightEnd, he has the coolest voice ever and I'd like to see him succed ![]() To be fair it's not that NightEnd has no results, just not as prominent as others have. He got 3rd/4th at DreamHack Winter after giving PuMa a run for his money in the semi final. Which already made him a better choice then IdrA at the time but then again that also was a last minute replacement (NaNiwa's probe rush) so they likely couldn't be picky or else have an empty slot. But just think about it: which other foreigner living in Korea would make more sense? Only other ones I could think of would be SaSe or else TLO/DeathAngel but those have hardly any recent results except for making it very far in Code A Qualifier(s). -> Also I didn't say that NightEnd was a natural pick. I speculated on him being a replacement for viOlet. I do feel however that he'd be pretty much the best available substitute. | ||
![]()
NovemberstOrm
Canada16217 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:39 Boblhead wrote: stop giving foreigners seeds, even violet is iffy for me. Foreigners like all others just get knocked out first round, for the few who get mirror match ups like huk/naniwa in which they are good at then its different. But srsly mr chae needs to stop giving them seeds. Violet is korean not a foreigner, and Thorzain deserves his seed, he's top3 foreigners. Foreigners attract non-korean audience which theyw ant so their viewer numbers increase, without foreigners it would probably dip quite a bit. | ||
Malinor
Germany4727 Posts
| ||
S_SienZ
1878 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:49 Wroshe wrote: To be fair it's not that NightEnd has no results, just not as prominent as others have. He got 3rd/4th at DreamHack Winter after giving PuMa a run for his money in the semi final. Which already made him a better choice then IdrA at the time but then again that also was a last minute replacement (NaNiwa's probe rush) so they likely couldn't be picky or else have an empty slot. But just think about it: which other foreigner living in Korea would make more sense? Only other ones I could think of would be SaSe or else TLO/DeathAngel but those have hardly any recent results except for making it very far in Code A Qualifier(s). -> Also I didn't say that NightEnd was a natural pick. I speculated on him being a replacement for viOlet. I do feel however that he'd be pretty much the best available substitute. PuMa would be a better choice then by that logic. | ||
AxionSteel
United States7754 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:49 Wroshe wrote: To be fair it's not that NightEnd has no results, just not as prominent as others have. He got 3rd/4th at DreamHack Winter after giving PuMa a run for his money in the semi final. Which already made him a better choice then IdrA at the time but then again that also was a last minute replacement (NaNiwa's probe rush) so they likely couldn't be picky or else have an empty slot. But just think about it: which other foreigner living in Korea would make more sense? Only other ones I could think of would be SaSe or else TLO/DeathAngel but those have hardly any recent results except for making it very far in Code A Qualifier(s). -> Also I didn't say that NightEnd was a natural pick. I speculated on him being a replacement for viOlet. I do feel however that he'd be pretty much the best available substitute. I'd rather they held a mini tournament with the players who finished 3rd in their Up/Down groups, and have the winner of that get the code S seed, not just hand it to some foreigner who happens to be in Korea. Or give it to PuMa himself, I mean they originally gave it to viOlet anyway who is Korean, so yeh. Maybe viOlet didn't decline in any case, but people seem to think he did. | ||
Wroshe
Netherlands1051 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:53 S_SienZ wrote: PuMa would be a better choice then by that logic. True. The "downside" to taking a korean on that seed is that it could likely hurt you in the season ticket sales but I would guess that PuMa has enough foreign fans that he'd not really create that same problem. If they for example would give a Code S seed to IM Yongwha (first Korean in Code B without huge foreign fanbase I thought of) now that would cost them a truckload of money. | ||
Wroshe
Netherlands1051 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:54 AxionSteel wrote: I'd rather they held a mini tournament with the players who finished 3rd in their Up/Down groups, and have the winner of that get the code S seed, not just hand it to some foreigner who happens to be in Korea. Or give it to PuMa himself, I mean they originally gave it to viOlet anyway who is Korean, so yeh. Maybe viOlet didn't decline in any case, but people seem to think he did. For creating the strongest league possible your bolded idea would be the best idea. However that is not Gom's goal, they're running a business and giving a seed or two to foreigners increases season ticket sale by a lot. | ||
AxionSteel
United States7754 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:57 Wroshe wrote: For creating the strongest league possible your bolded idea would be the best idea. However that is not Gom's goal, they're running a business and giving a seed or two to foreigners increases season ticket sale by a lot. That is fine, but NightEnd doesn't exactly have a big fan base. I mean maybe some extras will tune in to see how he fares, but I bet plenty also wouldn't really care less. | ||
Wroshe
Netherlands1051 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:59 AxionSteel wrote: That is fine, but NightEnd doesn't exactly have a big fan base. I mean maybe some extras will tune in to see how he fares, but I bet plenty also wouldn't really care less. Which is why NightEnd won't be your first pick becuase he also hasn't had OMGWTF Amazing results lately either. It does however make for a good last resort pick after your initial ones (and ThorZaIN viOlet are simply the best picks) don't both come. | ||
FakeDeath
Malaysia6060 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:49 Wroshe wrote: To be fair it's not that NightEnd has no results, just not as prominent as others have. He got 3rd/4th at DreamHack Winter after giving PuMa a run for his money in the semi final. Which already made him a better choice then IdrA at the time but then again that also was a last minute replacement (NaNiwa's probe rush) so they likely couldn't be picky or else have an empty slot. But just think about it: which other foreigner living in Korea would make more sense? Only other ones I could think of would be SaSe or else TLO/DeathAngel but those have hardly any recent results except for making it very far in Code A Qualifier(s). -> Also I didn't say that NightEnd was a natural pick. I speculated on him being a replacement for viOlet. I do feel however that he'd be pretty much the best available substitute. First question i want to ask you? Do you think Nightend can legitimately challenged the Code S player and he is a deserving Code S player? But then we dun really know whether or not violet rejected the Code S seed. | ||
Blennd
United States266 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:58 Amlitzer wrote: Can't blame Mr. Chae for needing to cater to foreigners in order to put food on the table. Once the GSL becomes sufficiently popular enough I'm sure he will stop giving out these petty seeds, but in till then it's just good business sense. It also seems strange that GOM would give a seed to viOlet when he is in America dodging his military service. Source on the bolded? | ||
Lysanias
Netherlands8351 Posts
| ||
kAelle_sc
287 Posts
| ||
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
DRAAAMMAAAAA! | ||
jmbthirteen
United States10734 Posts
On May 31 2012 17:16 kaelle_sc wrote: NOT STEPHANO? one, these brackets and players aren't final. two, stephano isn't going to korea until August. | ||
![]()
Shellshock
United States97276 Posts
| ||
![]()
opterown
![]()
Australia54784 Posts
MarineKing DongRaeGu GanZi MC Ryung viOLet Symbol Leenock Oz ThorZaIN (seeded into open bracket) Players at DreamHack Open Summer (best to have them play in week 1) HerO NaNiwa GanZi TaeJa ThorZaIN wow ThorZaIN and GanZi going to both, gonna be hard to schedule those guys. | ||
FakeDeath
Malaysia6060 Posts
On May 31 2012 17:18 Shellshock1122 wrote: Marineking vs Parting. Naniwa vs Nestea? totally randomized guys Plus Ganzi vs MC.LOL | ||
ThePlayer33
Australia2378 Posts
| ||
Naniwa
Sweden477 Posts
On May 31 2012 17:18 Shellshock1122 wrote: Marineking vs Parting. Naniwa vs Nestea? totally randomized guys my thoughts exactly haha, so obvious that its not random }} but what to do what to do. will be fun to play either way | ||
![]()
opterown
![]()
Australia54784 Posts
| ||
Naniwa
Sweden477 Posts
On May 31 2012 17:38 opterown wrote: one thing i guess we can confirm though is that Mvp picked Line and Squirtle picked ThorZaIN? its rando | ||
![]()
opterown
![]()
Australia54784 Posts
Top 2 of last season get to pick their first match though afaik? ie drg picked thestc, genius picked bbbb last season Also, hi nani ^^ | ||
SealOverseer
Netherlands159 Posts
He's not going to Korea anytime soon. | ||
Chromodoris
Sweden136 Posts
On May 31 2012 17:43 opterown wrote: Top 2 of last season get to pick their first match though afaik? ie drg picked thestc, genius picked bbbb last season Also, hi nani ^^ No that's for Ro16 groups. Ro32 groups are seeded, Ro8 last season are always at the top, but the picks are random. | ||
Tommylew
Wales2717 Posts
| ||
Canucklehead
Canada5074 Posts
On May 31 2012 17:49 Chromodoris wrote: No that's for Ro16 groups. Ro32 groups are seeded, Ro8 last season are always at the top, but the picks are random. No, the 2 finalists from the previous season get to pick their opponents. The players are broken into 4 tiers based on gsl points and the 2 finalists each choose a player from tier 4. I remember MVP picked Sen the very first season of this format. | ||
![]()
opterown
![]()
Australia54784 Posts
On May 31 2012 17:49 Chromodoris wrote: No that's for Ro16 groups. Ro32 groups are seeded, Ro8 last season are always at the top, but the picks are random. nope On May 31 2012 17:54 Canucklehead wrote: No, the 2 finalists from the previous season get to pick their opponents. The players are broken into 4 tiers based on gsl points and the 2 finalists each choose a player from tier 4. I remember MVP picked Sen the very first season of this format. that was jjkaji; leenock picked fin | ||
Canucklehead
Canada5074 Posts
On May 31 2012 17:55 opterown wrote: nope that was jjkaji; leenock picked fin Ah right. Got it mixed up, but remembered someone picked Sen. | ||
JustPassingBy
10776 Posts
| ||
-Switch-
Canada506 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:39 Boblhead wrote: stop giving foreigners seeds, even violet is iffy for me. Foreigners like all others just get knocked out first round, for the few who get mirror match ups like huk/naniwa in which they are good at then its different. But srsly mr chae needs to stop giving them seeds. This is true for the most part. | ||
nufcrulz
Singapore934 Posts
| ||
Coal
Sweden1535 Posts
On May 31 2012 18:03 nufcrulz wrote: i feel like gom needs to start giving out more seeds to foreigners.. i completely stopped watching the previous season after naniwa got knocked out. Foreigners = more viewers Why don't we invite everyone that's GM@ NA? Imagine the viewer numbers!! Who needs Koreans when we could have a full foreigner league, in KOREA!!! ^_^ | ||
![]()
opterown
![]()
Australia54784 Posts
| ||
PradamadeR
123 Posts
![]() | ||
gedatsu
1286 Posts
On May 31 2012 18:03 nufcrulz wrote: i feel like gom needs to start giving out more seeds to foreigners.. i completely stopped watching the previous season after naniwa got knocked out. Foreigners = more viewers They want to. Stephano has a standing invite. But, there honestly are not that many to choose from. They need to be able to commit two months to Korea, they need somewhere to live and since you're talking about getting more viewers, we should only count those who have realistic a chance to make it out of RO32. It's no fun with foreigners if we know that they are going to get demolished. | ||
Koesader
Netherlands424 Posts
I feel there isn't a single group that isn't stacked as hell tho | ||
Sorkoas
549 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:39 Boblhead wrote: stop giving foreigners seeds, even violet is iffy for me. Foreigners like all others just get knocked out first round, for the few who get mirror match ups like huk/naniwa in which they are good at then its different. But srsly mr chae needs to stop giving them seeds. I understand your point completely but what you are doing is arguing for a closed league. To be able to compete as a foreigner in GSL on the same conditions as the Koreans they have to live there and go through the same system with Code B and A. Is this really what we want to see? The few foreigners who do get a chance in Code S usually already have beaten a lot of top Code S/A players to deserve that spot. I don't see how this can be such an issue for some people. Especially not considering how many viewers these foreign players probably attract when competing in Code S. | ||
Aeroplaneoverthesea
United Kingdom1977 Posts
Don't see Thorzain getting out of that group. Naniwa probably could, but all Code S groups are tough. | ||
Aeroplaneoverthesea
United Kingdom1977 Posts
On May 31 2012 18:15 Sorkoas wrote: I understand your point completely but what you are doing is arguing for a closed league. To be able to compete as a foreigner in GSL on the same conditions as the Koreans they have to live there and go through the same system with Code B and A. Is this really what we want to see? The few foreigners who do get a chance in Code S usually already have beaten a lot of top Code S/A players to deserve that spot. I don't see how this can be such an issue for some people. Especially not considering how many viewers these foreign players probably attract when competing in Code S. The GSL isn't just another league. It is THE league. If NASL or IPL expected this of people I would say that's not practicle but GSL is a whole new level. | ||
Die4Ever
United States17676 Posts
| ||
Wroshe
Netherlands1051 Posts
On May 31 2012 17:01 FakeDeath wrote: First question i want to ask you? Do you think Nightend can legitimately challenged the Code S player and he is a deserving Code S player? But then we dun really know whether or not violet rejected the Code S seed. I doubt NightEnd would win a Code S series straight up, he'd have to get some luck. Looking at this leaked (but apparantly wrong) we know that viOlet and ThorZaIN were the first choices for seeds and if either one of them is not in at the new group draw then we know that either one of them declined. | ||
Cirqueenflex
499 Posts
| ||
![]()
opterown
![]()
Australia54784 Posts
On May 31 2012 18:31 Cirqueenflex wrote: i feel like ZeNEX Life deserves a seat after his performance in GSTL while life's probably better than a few code s players, it's not much grounds to give him a code s seed... he'll be in there next season anyway ;D | ||
Wroshe
Netherlands1051 Posts
On May 31 2012 18:03 nufcrulz wrote: i feel like gom needs to start giving out more seeds to foreigners.. i completely stopped watching the previous season after naniwa got knocked out. Foreigners = more viewers You appear to be the first one that actually gets it. Having said the pool of possible players is quite small: you're basically required to move to Korea for two months and have had some recent results. Having said that though there are some foreigners that are living in Korea so you could allways fall back on people like ToD or SaSe; having said that though their results are not as high as some foreigners outside of Korea. | ||
Wroshe
Netherlands1051 Posts
On May 31 2012 17:24 ThePlayer33 wrote: give code a seeds gomtv... They for some reason appear to no longer give out seeds to Up and Down. MorroW and HuK had one of those in the past. I guess that they can't attract the foreigners with they want with a (likely) run in Code A. The amount of money you opt out on in order to go to Korea is still huge. It does make you wonder why they have never given one of those Code A seeds to some of the foreigners living in Korea full time such as ToD or SaSe. Benefit of giving them a seed is that you also don't have the "issue" of players forfeiting the GSL after a single season because they are going home again. | ||
Die4Ever
United States17676 Posts
| ||
iNcontroL
![]()
USA29055 Posts
but fuck that is a tough group lol | ||
Sorkoas
549 Posts
When the BW scene makes a full switch I'm sure we will see A LOT of foreigners constantly in Korea since the spots in all leagues that will be going on combined with the Korean players will to participate in foreign events makes it much easier to balance out the competition. And I'm certain that GomTV will be the first company to take in a lot more foreigners. On May 31 2012 18:30 Die4Ever wrote: I wonder if Puma will ever get a seed... Sorry for my ignorance, but what has PuMa done recently to deserve any sort of seed? (Please don't compare with the foreign players who get invited, because I think GomTV have shown clear intentions to make it easier for players not living in Korea to get a chance to qualify without going through Code B/A.) | ||
Wrathsc2
United States2025 Posts
On May 31 2012 19:00 iNcontroL wrote: GO THORZAIN but fuck that is a tough group lol Aren't they all? | ||
teddyoojo
Germany22369 Posts
| ||
yawnoC
United States3704 Posts
On May 31 2012 18:30 Die4Ever wrote: I hope he gets on eventually I wonder if Puma will ever get a seed... | ||
Sorkoas
549 Posts
No matter what group Thorzain would end up in, he wouldn't be one of the favorites to advance. However a group with something like ZZP would favor him more than having to play a lot of TvT and possibly face the PvT monster that is Squirtle. | ||
![]()
opterown
![]()
Australia54784 Posts
On May 31 2012 19:00 Sorkoas wrote: I think GomTV are working hard to get foreigners in their tournaments but at the same time making sure they are actually able to compete. Let's face it, very few foreigners have made it past the first stage of the GSL's they've been participating in. When the BW scene makes a full switch I'm sure we will see A LOT of foreigners constantly in Korea since the spots in all leagues that will be going on combined with the Korean players will to participate in foreign events makes it much easier to balance out the competition. And I'm certain that GomTV will be the first company to take in a lot more foreigners. Sorry for my ignorance, but what has PuMa done recently to deserve any sort of seed? (Please don't compare with the foreign players who get invited, because I think GomTV have shown clear intentions to make it easier for players not living in Korea to get a chance to qualify without going through Code B/A.) Puma's done better internationally than polt (historically, at least). NASL was a bigger tournament than assembly. | ||
Sorkoas
549 Posts
On May 31 2012 19:05 opterown wrote: Puma's done better internationally than polt (historically, at least). NASL was a bigger tournament than assembly. Oh, did Polt earn a seed from international results? | ||
ThatGuyDoMo
Australia516 Posts
| ||
![]()
opterown
![]()
Australia54784 Posts
On May 31 2012 19:09 Sorkoas wrote: Oh, did Polt earn a seed from international results? polt got a seed for assembly afaik | ||
Wroshe
Netherlands1051 Posts
On May 31 2012 19:09 Sorkoas wrote: Oh, did Polt earn a seed from international results? Absolutely. Although Polt had a recent hot streak in foreign tournaments with winning Assembly and qualifying for IPL4 and NALS3 (and something else, forgot that). While PuMa has had big foreign results he's never been on such a tear as Polt was that month. | ||
Sorkoas
549 Posts
On May 31 2012 19:14 ThatGuyDoMo wrote: Naniwa and Nestea in the same group :D HYPE I see. Thanks. | ||
Theovide
Sweden914 Posts
| ||
Cirqueenflex
499 Posts
On May 31 2012 18:03 nufcrulz wrote: i feel like gom needs to start giving out more seeds to foreigners.. i completely stopped watching the previous season after naniwa got knocked out. Foreigners = more viewers i completely stopped watching after the last zerg got knocked out. Zergs = more viewers (of course i watched part of the finals as well, but other than that no GSL code S for me last season) | ||
snailz
Croatia900 Posts
ThorZain already did well in GSL, and Violet is just....... i think both of those guys really are the most deserving. in regards to foreigners getting free tickets, to me GSL starts losing interest when there are no foreigners, so even though i sometimes grumble "ah crap why do they get these seeds and get roflstomped", deep down i know i actually get way more excited to see foreigners vs koreans in GSL than just plain best player in the world GSL that goes on when no foreigners attend/fail early in example, i made time to watch Morrow and Idra even though that was super busy month for me, and had to miss most of rest of GSL that was going on in those days... | ||
Gecko4lif
United States42 Posts
thorzain and naniwa have some rough groups | ||
bokchoi
Korea (South)9498 Posts
| ||
FrostedMiniWheats
United States30730 Posts
| ||
FakeDeath
Malaysia6060 Posts
On May 31 2012 19:31 snailz wrote: i'm sorry but NightEnd in EU is like random code b korean in GSTL: you may have heard of him and seen him play here and there, but doesn't have anything to justify a seed by gomtv. ThorZain already did well in GSL, and Violet is just....... i think both of those guys really are the most deserving. in regards to foreigners getting free tickets, to me GSL starts losing interest when there are no foreigners, so even though i sometimes grumble "ah crap why do they get these seeds and get roflstomped", deep down i know i actually get way more excited to see foreigners vs koreans in GSL than just plain best player in the world GSL that goes on when no foreigners attend/fail early in example, i made time to watch Morrow and Idra even though that was super busy month for me, and had to miss most of rest of GSL that was going on in those days... Giving out Code S seeds to the foreigners is like feeding fish to cats.(exception is Naniwa though) Other than that, the other foreigners(Idra,Huk,Sen) all crashed out from Code S. | ||
Mario1209
United States1077 Posts
| ||
Irave
United States9965 Posts
![]() | ||
ES.Genie
Germany1370 Posts
On May 31 2012 16:52 NovemberstOrm wrote: Violet is korean not a foreigner, and Thorzain deserves his seed, he's top3 foreigners. Foreigners attract non-korean audience which theyw ant so their viewer numbers increase, without foreigners it would probably dip quite a bit. Violet lives in America, how can he be considered korean? Just like Naniwa and Huk can't really be seen as foreigners. They live in Korea, train in Korea, focus heavily on the GSL - they don't represent the foreign scene. Their success shows even more how the korean-model is far superior to how the foreign scene approaches SC2. | ||
arChieSC2
Spain162 Posts
On May 31 2012 21:14 Irave wrote: Yay code S will have an American! Go Violet! ![]() Hahahahahahahhaahaha, sorry. Good luck thorzain !. | ||
The KY
United Kingdom6252 Posts
On May 31 2012 19:32 Gecko4lif wrote: ouch thorzain and naniwa have some rough groups Thorzain is gonna get destroyed in that group. Naniwa's got his though. Creator is good but he's still an up and comer and Nani has beaten better Code S protoss frequently. Naniwa has Nestea's number and although it could go either way in that match I'm still betting on Nani. And Naniwa's PvT is good enough to take out any (sorry STC) second tier korean terran. | ||
ES.Genie
Germany1370 Posts
On May 31 2012 21:24 The KY wrote: Thorzain is gonna get destroyed in that group. Naniwa's got his though. Creator is good but he's still an up and comer and Nani has beaten better Code S protoss frequently. Naniwa has Nestea's number and although it could go either way in that match I'm still betting on Nani. And Naniwa's PvT is good enough to take out any (sorry STC) second tier korean terran. Oh that foreigner bias... | ||
Torte de Lini
Germany38463 Posts
| ||
ChaosArcher
Germany956 Posts
| ||
Wampaibist
United States478 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:38 Naded wrote: Naniwa and NesTea in same group? That'd be epic! yeah should be epic on a side note I wish they gave foreigners free code A seeds and not code S seeds. | ||
The KY
United Kingdom6252 Posts
I think that's a pretty fair bet to be 100% honest. Nestea isn't the zerg he was and Creator and TheSTC are definitely not the top of the top. Naniwa's groups last season were harder. I don't think it's unfair to call him the favourite in the group. EDIT: And, thinking about it... On May 31 2012 21:24 The KY wrote: Thorzain is gonna get destroyed in that group. That foreigner bias? | ||
Irave
United States9965 Posts
On May 31 2012 21:29 ChaosArcher wrote: TLO gets the missing Code S seed after his great Qualifier performance and due to his huge fanbase, heard it here first! He wouldn't accept it. | ||
Marou
Germany1371 Posts
| ||
Mordiford
4448 Posts
On May 31 2012 18:03 nufcrulz wrote: i feel like gom needs to start giving out more seeds to foreigners.. i completely stopped watching the previous season after naniwa got knocked out. Foreigners = more viewers Yeah, I have to disagree. I feel like so far, that foreigner performance has just dicked up the competition. I'd be fine with GOM handing out seeds if the foreign players were consistently doing well and it was evident that with the right push they could compete but in recent memory only Naniwa has had a decent run through Code S. I suppose that's enough to extend a hand further to Thorzain but if this doesn't work out then I don't want to see GOM up the foreigner seeds as I feel that ruins the image of Code S being the absolute cream of the crop, I want Code S at the very least to remain a league that you have to break into on the merit of your play, not your place of birth. I'm absolutely fine with GOM loading out Code A and Up/Down seeds as that still requires players to fight for a spot in what is the most prestigious league in the world. However, even here I don't think they should be handing out repeat spots to players who consistently fail to perform in the league. A prime example here is Huk(who I have absolutely nothing against), who was knocked out of Code A, invited back, knocked out in the first round again, and then in that very same season he was invited to the Up/Downs. He was literally brought back into the same season of the tournament and bumped up a round despite losing. I don't want to see this kind of stuff happen because it just shits on the competition. I understand it's difficult to go to compete in Korea, and that's why I'm fine with non-Code S seeds and maybe even the occasional single Code S seed, but what happened with Huk was really ridiculous and he should be expected to qualify normally at this point. | ||
AxionSteel
United States7754 Posts
On May 31 2012 21:32 The KY wrote: I think that's a pretty fair bet to be 100% honest. Nestea isn't the zerg he was and Creator and TheSTC are definitely not the top of the top. Naniwa's groups last season were harder. I don't think it's unfair to call him the favourite in the group. EDIT: And, thinking about it... That foreigner bias? Creator is excellent, I wouldn't be surprised to see him stomp that group. | ||
The KY
United Kingdom6252 Posts
On May 31 2012 22:01 AxionSteel wrote: Creator is excellent, I wouldn't be surprised to see him stomp that group. He's very good yes. But I'm still giving it a couple seasons more until he starts showing really good results in Code S. | ||
Assirra
Belgium4169 Posts
On May 31 2012 18:03 nufcrulz wrote: i feel like gom needs to start giving out more seeds to foreigners.. i completely stopped watching the previous season after naniwa got knocked out. Foreigners = more viewers I thought you watched the game rather then the players. I will never understand statements like that. Why would you prefer lower play over higher play? | ||
GreyKnight
United States4720 Posts
| ||
Durp
Canada3117 Posts
| ||
Fighter
Korea (South)1531 Posts
On May 31 2012 21:17 ES.Genie wrote: Violet lives in America, how can he be considered korean? Just like Naniwa and Huk can't really be seen as foreigners. They live in Korea, train in Korea, focus heavily on the GSL - they don't represent the foreign scene. Their success shows even more how the korean-model is far superior to how the foreign scene approaches SC2. For real? How can Violet be considered Korean? He is from Korea. He was born there. He has Korean parents. He grew up speaking Korean. No one really cares about the "scene", they care about players they have more in common with. Just because Violet happens to be living in Texas, that doesn't mean he and I have anything in common. Nothing personal against him, but he's only MARGINALLY more interesting than the average Korean player. | ||
Noocta
France12578 Posts
| ||
shaippen
Sweden88 Posts
On May 31 2012 22:21 Assirra wrote: I thought you watched the game rather then the players. I will never understand statements like that. Why would you prefer lower play over higher play? It's just because the game gets more exciting when you have someone you really cheer for. If it's just any match you don't have much invested in players. For me, the TL previews are great since I can read a about a game and it will add a bit of drama, making me more engaged in the game. Even if a game is high level, if I don't care about the result at all, a lot of the enjoyment is lost. Might not be the same for you. | ||
Whynaut
Canada367 Posts
On May 31 2012 22:21 Assirra wrote: I thought you watched the game rather then the players. I will never understand statements like that. Why would you prefer lower play over higher play? In pro sports, don't you have a team you cheer for? Whose games you preferentially watch compared to those of some other two teams of potentially higher skill? When you're watching the olympics, don't you cheer for the Belgian team/athletes, even though they might not be the best? Ever notice how whoever broadcasts the olympics in your country usually focuses on your country's athletes? All this is becasue most people are not emotionless fucking robots; it's alot more fun to watch anything competitive when you're rooting for one side to win. "Team foreigner" is a classic underdog story (though the script's getting a tad old at this point). | ||
Destroyr
Germany299 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:27 Opera wrote: The groups have been posted on GomTV twitter. Here they are : ![]() Edit : THESE GROUPS MAY NOT BE CORRECT ! If this is correct: Nani and nestea... shit thats a sad constelation even group a dont know maybe poor zenex line gets crushed right away. Hope for DRG he has no easy group but maybe he can make it | ||
ES.Genie
Germany1370 Posts
On May 31 2012 22:27 Fighter wrote: For real? How can Violet be considered Korean? He is from Korea. He was born there. He has Korean parents. He grew up speaking Korean. No one really cares about the "scene", they care about players they have more in common with. Just because Violet happens to be living in Texas, that doesn't mean he and I have anything in common. Nothing personal against him, but he's only MARGINALLY more interesting than the average Korean player. I am talking about "korean" and "foreigner" gamewise. Ofcourse his nationality is Korean, but this whole "Korea vs the world" thing is not really about nationality, it's about where you train. Or do you honestly think having Korean citizenship makes you somehow better at Starcraft? oO And really? Do people still believe in this "foreigner are interessting"-bullshit? Foreign fans are just idiots and go nuts, when some fat nerd queues up 5 tanks in his factory... But I guess that's fucking interessting and makes you a great personality. ^^ User was temp banned for this post. | ||
FairForever
Canada2392 Posts
Now if they want to move the group playing time that's okay, but to me it just seems like this system could cause problems. | ||
brokenLoL
United Kingdom419 Posts
| ||
Dexington
Canada7276 Posts
| ||
jobber123rd
United States501 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:27 Opera wrote: The groups have been posted on GomTV twitter. Here they are : + Show Spoiler + ![]() Edit : THESE GROUPS MAY NOT BE CORRECT ! Brief thoughts: - IIRC Fionn called Mvp's pick of Line immediately after Line qualified. Well played. ![]() - No surprise with Squirtle's pick. - If the groups hold, MKP dodged a 75% chance of drawing a Terran for his first matchup (see my mockup of the group draw tiers) - Again, if the groups hold, the seed choices are the best ones given the current criteria (international tournament performance) and Stephano sitting out this season. Beyond those two, the choices are a bit ugly IMO (either promoting someone who just failed at U&D, or giving a seed to someone who doesn't have the resutlts). - There's lots of reaction here about NaNiwa and NesTea, but it's pretty easy to imagine a scenario in which they wouldn't play each other. - It's nice to see GOM once again trying to accomodate players going to foreign tournaments around the time of the Round of 32. | ||
StarStruck
25339 Posts
On May 31 2012 22:21 Assirra wrote: I thought you watched the game rather then the players. I will never understand statements like that. Why would you prefer lower play over higher play? I have to agree. The handouts are getting quite ridiculous and I hope this trend discontinues soon. We've seen enough bush league shit and it doesn't stop here. | ||
Roxor9999
Netherlands771 Posts
On May 31 2012 22:43 ES.Genie wrote: I am talking about "korean" and "foreigner" gamewise. Ofcourse his nationality is Korean, but this whole "Korea vs the world" thing is not really about nationality, it's about where you train. Or do you honestly think having Korean citizenship makes you somehow better at Starcraft? oO And really? Do people still believe in this "foreigner are interessting"-bullshit? Foreign fans are just idiots and go nuts, when some fat nerd queues up 5 tanks in his factory... But I guess that's fucking interessting and makes you a great personality. ^^ I guess being an ass online makes you sound more convincing. | ||
Yonnua
United Kingdom2331 Posts
On May 31 2012 22:57 jobber123rd wrote: Brief thoughts: - IIRC Fionn called Mvp's pick of Line immediately after Line qualified. Well played. ![]() - No surprise with Squirtle's pick. - If the groups hold, MKP dodged a 75% chance of drawing a Terran for his first matchup (see my mockup of the group draw tiers) - Again, if the groups hold, the seed choices are the best ones given the current criteria (international tournament performance) and Stephano sitting out this season. Beyond those two, the choices are a bit ugly IMO (either promoting someone who just failed at U&D, or giving a seed to someone who doesn't have the resutlts). - There's lots of reaction here about NaNiwa and NesTea, but it's pretty easy to imagine a scenario in which they wouldn't play each other. - It's nice to see GOM once again trying to accomodate players going to foreign tournaments around the time of the Round of 32. I swear Mvp and Squirtle don't pick, the Ro32 is random based on how they qualified and the Ro16 is where they group select. | ||
JustPassingBy
10776 Posts
On May 31 2012 22:42 Destroyr wrote: If this is correct: Nani and nestea... shit thats a sad constelation even group a dont know maybe poor zenex line gets crushed right away. Hope for DRG he has no easy group but maybe he can make it Well, there are definitely not correct, else they wouldn't have said that they are not correct, haha. Anyways, Thorzain and Violet are good choices for the Code S seeds. | ||
.Riot
Philippines242 Posts
On May 31 2012 23:01 Yonnua wrote: I swear Mvp and Squirtle don't pick, the Ro32 is random based on how they qualified and the Ro16 is where they group select. iirc, the finalists get to pick the second people in their group and then e verything else is randomized, much like how Jjakji picked Sen in that GSL season, and how Leenock picked Fin in his first code S run. ![]() | ||
jobber123rd
United States501 Posts
On May 31 2012 23:01 Yonnua wrote: I swear Mvp and Squirtle don't pick, the Ro32 is random based on how they qualified and the Ro16 is where they group select. The previous season's finalists get to choose their first opponent (out of the eight players in the lowest tier). The rest of the group placements are random (with each group getting one player from each tier -- Tier 1 is just last season's top 8, and Tiers 2-4 are the rest of the players, in order of 2012 GSL Points). | ||
Mordiford
4448 Posts
On May 31 2012 22:35 Whynaut wrote: In pro sports, don't you have a team you cheer for? Whose games you preferentially watch compared to those of some other two teams of potentially higher skill? When you're watching the olympics, don't you cheer for the Belgian team/athletes, even though they might not be the best? Ever notice how whoever broadcasts the olympics in your country usually focuses on your country's athletes? All this is becasue most people are not emotionless fucking robots; it's alot more fun to watch anything competitive when you're rooting for one side to win. "Team foreigner" is a classic underdog story (though the script's getting a tad old at this point). I have a team I cheer for, but honestly(and I'm responding more to the idea of wanting more seeds here) I wouldn't want my team to get preferential treatment just because I'm a fan of them, I'd want them to succeed on their own merits. I'm a fan of the Patriots, but if they performed horribly in the regular season, I wouldn't want them to be handed a playoff spot just because they're a popular team. This can be applied directly to a couple of foreign players who have gotten repeat handouts from GOM. Yes, I would love to root for my favorite foreign players competing at the highest level of play in the world but only if they've proven that they can actually compete the same way as everyone else. | ||
FidoDido
United States1292 Posts
| ||
Elwar
953 Posts
| ||
Kiwiandapple
Belgium240 Posts
| ||
FakeDeath
Malaysia6060 Posts
On May 31 2012 23:22 Elwar wrote: So many NightEnd doubters. If he did get Violets spot in *that* group I've no doubt he'd get Ro16 at least. We don't have to doubt. He won't make it. NightEnd is nowhere near Code S level. | ||
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
On May 31 2012 23:15 Mordiford wrote: I have a team I cheer for, but honestly(and I'm responding more to the idea of wanting more seeds here) I wouldn't want my team to get preferential treatment just because I'm a fan of them, I'd want them to succeed on their own merits. I'm a fan of the Patriots, but if they performed horribly in the regular season, I wouldn't want them to be handed a playoff spot just because they're a popular team. This can be applied directly to a couple of foreign players who have gotten repeat handouts from GOM. Yes, I would love to root for my favorite foreign players competing at the highest level of play in the world but only if they've proven that they can actually compete the same way as everyone else. Exactly... it's one thing to root for someone, another to blindly follow them to the detrimental of the game. I love go to AA games near by, but if they compete in MLB, well, it would not be good at all. I'm fine with GOM giving out seed to who have shown that they can compete, but SC2 is not beauty pageant and should not be dictated by popularity. | ||
Kkxtrouble
Brazil575 Posts
On May 31 2012 22:57 jobber123rd wrote: Brief thoughts: - IIRC Fionn called Mvp's pick of Line immediately after Line qualified. Well played. ![]() - No surprise with Squirtle's pick. - If the groups hold, MKP dodged a 75% chance of drawing a Terran for his first matchup (see my mockup of the group draw tiers) - Again, if the groups hold, the seed choices are the best ones given the current criteria (international tournament performance) and Stephano sitting out this season. Beyond those two, the choices are a bit ugly IMO (either promoting someone who just failed at U&D, or giving a seed to someone who doesn't have the resutlts). - There's lots of reaction here about NaNiwa and NesTea, but it's pretty easy to imagine a scenario in which they wouldn't play each other. - It's nice to see GOM once again trying to accomodate players going to foreign tournaments around the time of the Round of 32. It may seem like MKP dodged a bullet but lets take a closer look... Parting recently beat him in GSL, Yuhioh recently beat him in Code A and Symbol recently beat him in Iron Squid. So if the groups are correct it looks like a group for MKP redeem himself of be crushed by players who have recently beat him. | ||
TheRealNanMan
United States1471 Posts
I'm really excited to see how the groups get finalized ![]() | ||
NexUmbra
Scotland3776 Posts
On May 31 2012 22:35 Whynaut wrote: In pro sports, don't you have a team you cheer for? Whose games you preferentially watch compared to those of some other two teams of potentially higher skill? When you're watching the olympics, don't you cheer for the Belgian team/athletes, even though they might not be the best? Ever notice how whoever broadcasts the olympics in your country usually focuses on your country's athletes? All this is becasue most people are not emotionless fucking robots; it's alot more fun to watch anything competitive when you're rooting for one side to win. "Team foreigner" is a classic underdog story (though the script's getting a tad old at this point). My local football team NEVER gets to play in Europe because they are just not really that good in the grand scheme of things(like top 5 in Scotland) UEFA don't just say "ah those poor guys never get to play in the Europa League, lets just invite them anyways!" there is a fucking reason why this happens. They get into the qualifications(think of it like Code B ;p) and then they never ever ever make it out because they are just trash compared to most European teams. These lower tier European teams that fuck up my team are like Code A players. And even if by some miracle my team were to get into the actual competition. They would get crushed into a fine paste by the better teams such as Valencia, FC Porto and Athletic... i.e the Code S players of the Europa Cup Yes I continue to cheer for them, do I want them seeded into the Europa League? OF COURSE NOT. It would be an embarrassment to get beaten so hard. In the same way I don't want to see some foreigner such as NightEnd(who is actually getting quite good) to go into Code S when he is clearly not ready yet. | ||
Haustka
United States221 Posts
| ||
LeLfe
France3160 Posts
On May 31 2012 23:56 Haustka wrote: Thorzain, Stephano, and Naniwa in Code S? when was the last time we had three Foreigners in Code S? my memory is once again failing me cause I cannot remember... or NEVER? never happened | ||
CptGrackSparrow
United States278 Posts
On May 31 2012 23:56 Haustka wrote: Thorzain, Stephano, and Naniwa in Code S? when was the last time we had three Foreigners in Code S? my memory is once again failing me cause I cannot remember... or NEVER? code S never, but in the open tournaments (back in 2010) it happened at least twice if not all 3 times. Edit: GSL 1 - 4 Foreigners (Idra, Torch, Artosis, TLO) GSL 2 - 3 (Loner, Idra, TLO) GSL 3 - 5 (Idra, Ret, Haypro, Jinro, Sen) | ||
NexUmbra
Scotland3776 Posts
On June 01 2012 00:04 CptGrackSparrow wrote: code S never, but in the open tournaments (back in 2010) it happened at least twice if not all 3 times. In the first season we had 4 ![]() In the second season we had 3 ![]() In the third season we had the most foreigners ever, 5! ![]() | ||
FrostedMiniWheats
United States30730 Posts
On May 31 2012 23:17 FidoDido wrote: seems like a lot more zergs this season, hope at least some of them make it out of ro32.. With Violet being confirmed we're at 9, which puts us up +2 from the last season. Also, in the entire history of code S the highest number we've ever reached in zergs was... 9 (January 2011, season 1 2012, and this season). We usually hang between 8 and 7 for code S >_> | ||
Sorkoas
549 Posts
On May 31 2012 23:56 Haustka wrote: Thorzain, Stephano, and Naniwa in Code S? when was the last time we had three Foreigners in Code S? my memory is once again failing me cause I cannot remember... or NEVER? It's been brought up multiple times already that Stephano is not playing this season. He's going in August. | ||
pdd
Australia9933 Posts
On May 31 2012 19:03 yawnoC wrote: I hope he gets on eventually They missed their opportunity to give him at least an Up/Down seed in Season 1 (or was it 2) when he was actually coming off some decent performances at IEM, NASL2 and Assembly. Now he doesn't really deserve a seed as he hasn't done particularly well in recent tournaments. To be honest he's really been robbed of it, back when he deserved it. There were like 2 Up/Down slots last season and only 1 was taken (Huk). His recent performances however didn't warrant a seed in this season's Up/Down. | ||
Markwerf
Netherlands3728 Posts
Foreigner seeds for GSL are a good thing. It gives the tournament some international flavor. THe players only get seeded into code S and still have to win their rounds so it's not too unfair at all. Considering the risks foreign players have to take to travel to korea it's more then fair they get a seed to give them a garanteed incentive for the travel. It's not like 2 seeds ruin the entire fairness of the competition yet it does add a nice international flavor. I can't really complain with how they are doing the seeds at the moment, without them players like Naniwa might not even have bothered to go to Korea in the first place. I wouldn't like to see players like Nightend getting seeds before some serious results but the likes of Huk, Thorzain, Stephano, Polt etc are completely fine with me. It's not unfair to the other code S or koreans at all either. In fact it's only good for them. WIthout seeds the games would be watched way less and thus their would be less sponsors/money for the koreans. The 30 code S players benefit from the two seeded guys by adding popularity, it's good for everyone really. Despite some people claiming here they think it's unfair I bet 95% here are more likely to watch a Naniwa or Thorzain game then something like Supernova vs Ganzi | ||
Grampz
United States2147 Posts
| ||
Tidus Mino
United Kingdom1108 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:41 pdd wrote: Hmm.. what happened to Nightend then? He was mysteriously absent from Code A qualifiers and there doesn't seem to be a space for him in Code A already (40 players in it already). Although Violet and Thorzain are far better Code S seeds than Nightend. He was going to Korea to practice for Dreamhack, which is in 2 weeks, so I assume he will go back to Romania after Dreamhack | ||
Assirra
Belgium4169 Posts
On May 31 2012 22:35 Whynaut wrote: In pro sports, don't you have a team you cheer for? Whose games you preferentially watch compared to those of some other two teams of potentially higher skill? When you're watching the olympics, don't you cheer for the Belgian team/athletes, even though they might not be the best? Ever notice how whoever broadcasts the olympics in your country usually focuses on your country's athletes? All this is becasue most people are not emotionless fucking robots; it's alot more fun to watch anything competitive when you're rooting for one side to win. "Team foreigner" is a classic underdog story (though the script's getting a tad old at this point). Yea i do have a team i cheer for but i would find it dumb they get a free seed for stuff they simply don't deserve and probably will get slaughtered in. Yea i enjoy watching my favorite team getting destroyed, oh wait. | ||
trwkling
658 Posts
On May 31 2012 23:30 Kkxtrouble wrote: It may seem like MKP dodged a bullet but lets take a closer look... Parting recently beat him in GSL, Yuhioh recently beat him in Code A and Symbol recently beat him in Iron Squid. So if the groups are correct it looks like a group for MKP redeem himself of be crushed by players who have recently beat him. My first thoughts as well. Let's see whether MKP has matured from his last run! | ||
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
On June 01 2012 00:30 Markwerf wrote: Just see it like the olympics. There the competition isn't the highest level either per se as the players per country are capped. Players from a bad country often get in while they might not deserve it on their results alone. The international flavor of the event only adds to it's status though. Foreigner seeds for GSL are a good thing. It gives the tournament some international flavor. THe players only get seeded into code S and still have to win their rounds so it's not too unfair at all. Considering the risks foreign players have to take to travel to korea it's more then fair they get a seed to give them a garanteed incentive for the travel. It's not like 2 seeds ruin the entire fairness of the competition yet it does add a nice international flavor. I can't really complain with how they are doing the seeds at the moment, without them players like Naniwa might not even have bothered to go to Korea in the first place. I wouldn't like to see players like Nightend getting seeds before some serious results but the likes of Huk, Thorzain, Stephano, Polt etc are completely fine with me. It's not unfair to the other code S or koreans at all either. In fact it's only good for them. WIthout seeds the games would be watched way less and thus their would be less sponsors/money for the koreans. The 30 code S players benefit from the two seeded guys by adding popularity, it's good for everyone really. Despite some people claiming here they think it's unfair I bet 95% here are more likely to watch a Naniwa or Thorzain game then something like Supernova vs Ganzi It's only true if invitees don't make a fool out of themselves and discredit the competition. And stop compare GSL to Olympics. If GSL is only once every 4 years, they can invite whoever the heck they want. | ||
FrostedMiniWheats
United States30730 Posts
On June 01 2012 00:38 Grampz wrote: Need another zerggggg, sick race distribution! Zenio and B4 were so close >_< | ||
AxionSteel
United States7754 Posts
On May 31 2012 23:30 Kkxtrouble wrote: It may seem like MKP dodged a bullet but lets take a closer look... Parting recently beat him in GSL, Yuhioh recently beat him in Code A and Symbol recently beat him in Iron Squid. So if the groups are correct it looks like a group for MKP redeem himself of be crushed by players who have recently beat him. This isn't 6-8 months ago where MKP was a-moving groups of bio into siege lines and poorly executing gimmicky cheesy build orders, his tvt is really good now and has been for some time. I'd highly fancy him in a group full of terrans, as opposed to zergs as that matchup is hard these days. His tvp obviously kicks ass also, but parting is tough. | ||
Sorkoas
549 Posts
On June 01 2012 00:30 Markwerf wrote: Just see it like the olympics. Isn't WCG supposed to be the Olympics of eSports? | ||
Shield
Bulgaria4824 Posts
| ||
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
On June 01 2012 00:53 Sorkoas wrote: Isn't WCG supposed to be the Olympics of eSports? +1 User was warned for this post | ||
Mordiford
4448 Posts
On June 01 2012 00:45 ragz_gt wrote: It's only true if invitees don't make a fool out of themselves and discredit the competition. And stop compare GSL to Olympics. If GSL is only once every 4 years, they can invite whoever the heck they want. Also, the olympics is based around national representation. Basically, looking to find the best of each nation and pitting them against the best of other nations to find the best nation's representation in an event. The GSL doesn't put limits on national representation, it's nothing like the olympics so this is always horrible comparison whenever it's made. WCG is more like The Olympics in that sense. | ||
Inhumane
Canada145 Posts
On June 01 2012 00:57 darkness wrote: Funny how GOM put Nestea and Naniwa in the same group at first. I doubt it was coincidence. Uhh...you actually think GOM picks what players go in what group.....? | ||
jobber123rd
United States501 Posts
On June 01 2012 00:45 ragz_gt wrote: It's only true if invitees don't make a fool out of themselves and discredit the competition. And stop compare GSL to Olympics. If GSL is only once every 4 years, they can invite whoever the heck they want. For what it's worth, Mr. Chae's justification of the current format (in a January 2012 TL email interview) was quite similar: Many of the invited foreign players show poor games and are knocked out quickly. Taking this into consideration, aren't some of the Korean players or teams unhappy with the increased foreign seeds? The teams and players have no qualms. If you think about it the other way, Korean players already receive a higher number of seeds, and better placed seeds as well in foreign tournaments. It's the same principle as how foreign players don't have any complaints about that (although, I guess there may be some discontent?). If I can use the World Cup as an example, it might be easier to explain. If the World Cup went purely by FIFA rankings, Korea would never be able to play, and it would have become a tournament that only South America and Europe enjoyed. We don't want GSL to only establish itself as a Korean national league. We want to offer an incentive for foreign players to come to Korea, if they should ever have the opportunity. I think if they use the opportunity to come here and take in Korean pro-gaming culture, then they can become stronger than they are now. GSL wants to provide those kind of opportunities. Also, I think that we were relatively successful at that last year. Two years ago, could you have imagined so many foreign players working with Korean teams and coming to Korea? | ||
mememolly
4765 Posts
Violet has a good chance though | ||
FairForever
Canada2392 Posts
On June 01 2012 01:13 Inhumane wrote: Uhh...you actually think GOM picks what players go in what group.....? Read what the above announcement says. I would hope not, but the fact is they're rearranging groups to meet certain times. To me that is absolutely ridiculous and unfair. | ||
IPA
United States3206 Posts
| ||
00Visor
4337 Posts
On June 01 2012 00:53 Sorkoas wrote: Isn't WCG supposed to be the Olympics of eSports? Nah, WCG is just one company like all other organizers. They just used to be the only big one - with national qualifiers. Now we have Blizzard WCS as well, which seems to be a lot bigger. | ||
ES.Genie
Germany1370 Posts
On May 31 2012 23:00 Roxor9999 wrote: I guess being an ass online makes you sound more convincing. I guess...your statement is completely useless and adds nothing to the conversation. Thank you. | ||
Roxor9999
Netherlands771 Posts
On June 01 2012 01:55 ES.Genie wrote: I guess...your statement is completely useless and adds nothing to the conversation. Thank you. No problem. | ||
Adreme
United States5574 Posts
On May 31 2012 22:57 jobber123rd wrote: Brief thoughts: - IIRC Fionn called Mvp's pick of Line immediately after Line qualified. Well played. ![]() - No surprise with Squirtle's pick. - If the groups hold, MKP dodged a 75% chance of drawing a Terran for his first matchup (see my mockup of the group draw tiers) - Again, if the groups hold, the seed choices are the best ones given the current criteria (international tournament performance) and Stephano sitting out this season. Beyond those two, the choices are a bit ugly IMO (either promoting someone who just failed at U&D, or giving a seed to someone who doesn't have the resutlts). - There's lots of reaction here about NaNiwa and NesTea, but it's pretty easy to imagine a scenario in which they wouldn't play each other. - It's nice to see GOM once again trying to accomodate players going to foreign tournaments around the time of the Round of 32. To be fair everyone called MVP picking Line. It seemed like picking one of MVPs best MU against the weakest code S zerg was a no brainer. | ||
Adreme
United States5574 Posts
On June 01 2012 01:13 Inhumane wrote: Uhh...you actually think GOM picks what players go in what group.....? It is interesting how both Nestea and Naniwa are in same group and MKP is in a group with every player who has won a series off him in last 4 months (except Taeja) | ||
Fischbacher
Canada666 Posts
On June 01 2012 00:45 ragz_gt wrote: It's only true if invitees don't make a fool out of themselves and discredit the competition. And stop compare GSL to Olympics. If GSL is only once every 4 years, they can invite whoever the heck they want. k, what about the Tennis grand slams? They happen four times a year, and they ALL have wild cards that typically get eliminated in the first round (only two wild cards have ever won a Grand Slam, both players that came back from retirement). They even give a "pitty" invitation to the top-rated Asian player that isn't good enough to qualify on his/her own every year at the Australian Open to increase TV ratings form Asia. Point being, wild cards for the purpose of increasing TV ratings, local interest and diversity happens in virtually EVERY sport. I'm a part of a lot of sports fan commuities, and this is honestly the only one where I see people be so hot and bothered about wild card spots. I don't see any Tennis fan complain about how pitty invite Jonathan Dasnières de Veigy got humiliated by Juan Carlos Ferrero in the first round of the French Open and putting this up as an example of how inviting players that might attract TV ratings and fans is bad for the sport and saying that he should have refused his invitation and that he should have gone through the qualification tournament because he's terrible. Why is it that StarCraft fans have so much trouble accepting wild cards as a fact of life when its standard for virtually every individual sport's showcase event? | ||
Gorilla23
United States339 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:39 Fubi wrote: lol MKP/Parting/Symbol and poor Yugioh Poor Yugioh? You do know MKP was in U/D instead of straight to Code S because of Yugioh, right? I won't be voting on MKP to get out of this group, but who knows what will happen. Each player has a chance. | ||
-TesteR-
Canada1165 Posts
On May 31 2012 18:06 Coal wrote: Why don't we invite everyone that's GM@ NA? Imagine the viewer numbers!! Who needs Koreans when we could have a full foreigner league, in KOREA!!! ^_^ if skilled foreigners are good enough for RO8 GSL why not ^_^ | ||
MrMotionPicture
United States4327 Posts
| ||
SealOverseer
Netherlands159 Posts
| ||
TBone-
United States2309 Posts
| ||
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
On June 01 2012 02:39 SealOverseer wrote: I don't know how make you understand this, but Violet is not going to Korea. You are confusing viOLet with Stephano? Where does anyone say viOLet is not going? | ||
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
On June 01 2012 02:45 TBone- wrote: I say this every time a seed thread pops up, but I really dislike them. It devalues code s and all the hard work it takes to get there. Especially when you dodge all the monsters in code b. And there may even be more deserving players in code b. I understand it from a business perspective, but it hurts the integrity of the competition. I'm not against giving out seed to really deserving player who can't compete for code A / S spot (translate: not live in Korea). I don't see the harm in give out two seeds as long as they do not bring down the level of competition. | ||
Kilby
Finland1069 Posts
On June 01 2012 02:15 -TesteR- wrote: if skilled foreigners are good enough for RO8 GSL why not ^_^ There are actually quite many foreigners who are skilled. But not many of them could make it to Ro8 of GSL. But the first post has a point. On average, a Korean tournament does indeed get more foreigner viewers when there are foreigners playing. In two months or so we will see another skilled foreigner in GSL code S who could also make it to Ro8 or possibly even further and at least I will be watching all of his games. I would love to see a gigantic amount of NA/EU GMs participating in the GSL Code A qualifiers. But I don't think that's going to happen. | ||
Zorgaz
Sweden2951 Posts
| ||
Shiori
3815 Posts
On June 01 2012 02:50 ragz_gt wrote: I'm not against giving out seed to really deserving player who can't compete for code A / S spot (translate: not live in Korea). I don't see the harm in give out two seeds as long as they do not bring down the level of competition. There are literally like 30 Koreans not in Code S that are probably very capable of giving Thorzain a run for his money on a regular basis. The reason foreigners are picked is because they increase viewership. It really does ruin the competitive environment a bit, because you end up having walkover wins in some groups a lot of the time (remember Idra/Sen?). | ||
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
On June 01 2012 03:05 Shiori wrote: There are literally like 30 Koreans not in Code S that are probably very capable of giving Thorzain a run for his money on a regular basis. The reason foreigners are picked is because they increase viewership. It really does ruin the competitive environment a bit, because you end up having walkover wins in some groups a lot of the time (remember Idra/Sen?). Read my post again... I said deserving player, I did not name ThorZaIN, who I don't think have shown enough result consistently. I'm OK with viOLet, Nani last season, and Stephano (who have turned the Seed down). I don't think they should give Stephano a seed for next season, since he would be in Korea and he should compete through qualifier like everyone else. | ||
gedatsu
1286 Posts
On June 01 2012 02:45 TBone- wrote: I say this every time a seed thread pops up, but I really dislike them. It devalues code s and all the hard work it takes to get there. Especially when you dodge all the monsters in code b. And there may even be more deserving players in code b. I understand it from a business perspective, but it hurts the integrity of the competition. To get into code S, a Korean must: 1. be really good at Starcraft To get into code S, a non-Korean must: 1. buy tickets to Korea 2. find a home in Korea 3. leave everyone you know 4. live in a country where nobody speaks the same language as you 5. be really good at Starcraft A Korean can live with their mom and practice in the basement. Live their life pretty much as they always have. If they fail to qualify, it's no problem to try again next time. A foreigner needs to say goodbye pretty much to their whole life, find a place to stay (they don't know for how long), go through a complete culture clash where they can't talk to anyone and don't even know what food is good to eat. You have no way to buy a ticket back in advance. All these things considered, I don't think it's unreasonable to give seeds. There are simply so many obstacles for a foreigner to compete in GSL that it's alright to eliminate one other obstacle, the qualifiers. They have already demonstrated in other tournaments that they have the skill. Now I would personally prefer seeds into U&D instead of code S, but it doesn't "devalue code S" anymore than giving east Asian teams their own qualifiers for the football world cup. They make it a point to be the world cup. Otherwise there would only be teams from Europe and South America participating, perhaps one or two African ones. GSL also makes it a point to be the Global Starcraft2 League - thereby making sure that they have representation not just from a single country. | ||
Sorkoas
549 Posts
On June 01 2012 03:13 ragz_gt wrote: Read my post again... I said deserving player, I did not name ThorZaIN, who I don't think have shown enough result consistently. I'm OK with viOLet, Nani last season, and Stephano (who have turned the Seed down). I don't think they should give Stephano a seed for next season, since he would be in Korea and he should compete through qualifier like everyone else. I thought Stephano is going to Korea because he got invited to Code S. | ||
KazmA
United States117 Posts
| ||
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
On June 01 2012 03:20 Sorkoas wrote: I thought Stephano is going to Korea because he got invited to Code S. He will be going to Korea in August I think. He got an invite to Code S this season but he he turned it down already since he won't be there in time. | ||
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
On June 01 2012 03:19 gedatsu wrote: To get into code S, a Korean must: 1. be really good at Starcraft To get into code S, a non-Korean must: 1. buy tickets to Korea 2. find a home in Korea 3. leave everyone you know 4. live in a country where nobody speaks the same language as you 5. be really good at Starcraft A Korean can live with their mom and practice in the basement. Live their life pretty much as they always have. If they fail to qualify, it's no problem to try again next time. A foreigner needs to say goodbye pretty much to their whole life, find a place to stay (they don't know for how long), go through a complete culture clash where they can't talk to anyone and don't even know what food is good to eat. You have no way to buy a ticket back in advance. All these things considered, I don't think it's unreasonable to give seeds. There are simply so many obstacles for a foreigner to compete in GSL that it's alright to eliminate one other obstacle, the qualifiers. They have already demonstrated in other tournaments that they have the skill. Now I would personally prefer seeds into U&D instead of code S, but it doesn't "devalue code S" anymore than giving east Asian teams their own qualifiers for the football world cup. They make it a point to be the world cup. Otherwise there would only be teams from Europe and South America participating, perhaps one or two African ones. GSL also makes it a point to be the Global Starcraft2 League - thereby making sure that they have representation not just from a single country. Exactly. A non Korean player would have to be totally dedicated and have a lot of financial backing just to attempt to get in Code S. It's completely theoretically possible, and even likely, that there are player at Code S level who cannot qualify for it. And I don't think it's outrageous for GOM to invite these player to participate in a "Global StarCraft II League". I think what GOM have tripped was not whether invite players or not, but who they invited. | ||
CeriseCherries
6170 Posts
| ||
![]()
NovemberstOrm
Canada16217 Posts
| ||
GreEny K
Germany7312 Posts
| ||
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
On June 01 2012 03:37 NovemberstOrm wrote: Thorzain deserves the code s just as much as Stephano or any other foreigner, and Violet is a very good choice he's gotten a lot better than he used to be. How does ThorZaIN deserve the spot as much as Stephano? Yes, he did win DH, but who did he beat besides Polt? Socke and Monster are nice, but not exactly code S level competition. And since then he literally lost all MU against Code A+ competition except one series against JYP and his LOLvT and one series against viOLet (I'm counting him as Code A+). Meanwhile, Stephano have taken sets off PartinG, Squitle, MC, Ganzi, Heart, Ryung at a fairly consistent rate. EDIT: It makes me sick to speak up for Stephano. Not a fan of his arrogance (not a witty kind like MC, just dry and mean), and really dislike his no shows over online events. However, let's be honest here, he is better and more achieved than ThorZaIN by a decent margin currently. | ||
NexUmbra
Scotland3776 Posts
On June 01 2012 03:19 gedatsu wrote: To get into code S, a Korean must: 1. be really good at Starcraft To get into code S, a non-Korean must: 1. buy tickets to Korea 2. find a home in Korea 3. leave everyone you know 4. live in a country where nobody speaks the same language as you 5. be really good at Starcraft A Korean can live with their mom and practice in the basement. Live their life pretty much as they always have. If they fail to qualify, it's no problem to try again next time. A foreigner needs to say goodbye pretty much to their whole life, find a place to stay (they don't know for how long), go through a complete culture clash where they can't talk to anyone and don't even know what food is good to eat. You have no way to buy a ticket back in advance. All these things considered, I don't think it's unreasonable to give seeds. There are simply so many obstacles for a foreigner to compete in GSL that it's alright to eliminate one other obstacle, the qualifiers. They have already demonstrated in other tournaments that they have the skill. Now I would personally prefer seeds into U&D instead of code S, but it doesn't "devalue code S" anymore than giving east Asian teams their own qualifiers for the football world cup. They make it a point to be the world cup. Otherwise there would only be teams from Europe and South America participating, perhaps one or two African ones. GSL also makes it a point to be the Global Starcraft2 League - thereby making sure that they have representation not just from a single country. It's no wonder that your name is Gedatsu, because what the fuck are you going on about? Have you ever heard of a Korean pro gaming house? Koreans have to live in pro gaming houses. Which means that they must find a home too. If you are good enough for Code S then you are probably on a good team, think of all the foreign players who can actually play in Code S. I would say Nani, Thorzain and Stephano. StarTaleQ, SlayersEG and whatever the TSL-Mill partnership is called ;p Yeah they have to go to a different country and stuff but its not like they are being forced. "How careless!" | ||
agh39
Sweden180 Posts
On June 01 2012 04:15 ragz_gt wrote: How does ThorZaIN deserve the spot as much as Stephano? Yes, he did win DH, but who did he beat besides Polt? Socke and Monster are nice, but not exactly code S level competition. And since then he literally lost all MU against Code A+ competition except one series against JYP and his LOLvT and one series against viOLet (I'm counting him as Code A+). Meanwhile, Stephano have taken sets off PartinG, Squitle, MC, Ganzi, Heart, Ryung at a fairly consistent rate. Ohh, I didn't know OZ was so low skilled that he wasn't qualified better than Code A. http://www.fnatic.com/news/9841/oz-loses-to-thorzain-in-mlg-prizefights.html | ||
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
On June 01 2012 04:30 NexUmbra wrote: It's no wonder that your name is Gedatsu, because what the fuck are you going on about? Have you ever heard of a Korean pro gaming house? Koreans have to live in pro gaming houses. Which means that they must find a home too. If you are good enough for Code S then you are probably on a good team, think of all the foreign players who can actually play in Code S. I would say Nani, Thorzain and Stephano. StarTaleQ, SlayersEG and whatever the TSL-Mill partnership is called ;p Yeah they have to go to a different country and stuff but its not like they are being forced. "How careless!" It's still considerable harder for foreigner. You should try live in a different country where you don't speak the language for a year (I lived in Finland and German for a year each, and more people speak better English there than in Korea I would assume, and it still sucked) and see how hard it is. Assume there are 100 Korean and 100 NA/EU player who are all Code S level (yeah, I know it's not realistic, that's not the point anyway, just entertain me), 60-80 of Korean ones can try to qualify for it, while MAYBE 20 of them can for foreigners. Foreigners will be under-represented in GSL after adjusted for skill, so it's not unreasonable to invite a very limited number of them without jeopardize the level of competition. Maybe they should rename the league to KSL (if the current KSL doesn't exist) and be better off, but that's a whole other discussion. | ||
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
On June 01 2012 04:34 agh39 wrote: Ohh, I didn't know OZ was so low skilled that he wasn't qualified better than Code A. http://www.fnatic.com/news/9841/oz-loses-to-thorzain-in-mlg-prizefights.html Ah, I was not aware of that series over the weekend, good for him. But still, that's not really a consistent winning rate. He may do well, he may not, he may do well and still couldn't make out the group (half the Code S doesn't make out the first group), but it's really hard to argue ThorZaIN is equal to Stephano currently. | ||
andaylin
United States10830 Posts
so random lol | ||
gedatsu
1286 Posts
On June 01 2012 04:30 NexUmbra wrote: It's no wonder that your name is Gedatsu, because what the fuck are you going on about? Have you ever heard of a Korean pro gaming house? Koreans have to live in pro gaming houses. Which means that they must find a home too. If you are good enough for Code S then you are probably on a good team, think of all the foreign players who can actually play in Code S. I would say Nani, Thorzain and Stephano. StarTaleQ, SlayersEG and whatever the TSL-Mill partnership is called ;p Yeah they have to go to a different country and stuff but its not like they are being forced. "How careless!" They don't have to live in a pro house. It is of course beneficial for them if they do, but they can live at home. There have already been people in code A who have done so. Likewise, a foreigner can get help from their team with both housing and plane ticket. But even so, trying to qualify for code A is still a much larger commitment for them. | ||
NOOBALOPSE
Canada802 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:21 shockaslim wrote: The groups for GSL 2012 Season 3 were posted for a VERY brief moment. But I did catch a glimpse of who were in the groups......ThorZain and viOlet being the two that stuck out the most. Did anyone else catch this or know if it is set in stone? No surprise to me. I was expecting ViOlet, but I would like it if they gave LucifroN the seed instead of ThorZaIN. He's much better than ThorZaIN, has proved himself and has actually 4-0'ed ThorzaIN at some tournament, not sure which one. and another + is he has no weak matchups as far as I can tell. | ||
andReslic
216 Posts
| ||
Aeroplaneoverthesea
United Kingdom1977 Posts
Shame Stephano didn't accept. Although I don't like him I'd be interested to see how he did in a GSL format. | ||
Deadstrider
Netherlands258 Posts
| ||
Bagration
United States18282 Posts
| ||
![]()
Whitewing
United States7483 Posts
| ||
Benjamin99
4176 Posts
| ||
Popkiller
3415 Posts
On June 01 2012 06:01 Bagration wrote: Thorzain got the invite because he won Dreamhack Stockholm. The 2 seeds were for strong performances in international tournaments, and Thorzain met that prerequisite. Are there more deserving invites perhaps? Maybe (I'm thinking of aLive and MMA, who won IPL 4 and Iron Squid respectively), but you can't say that Thorzain doesn't satisfy the requirements for the seed. Yeah but I don't think they'd invite people who are in Code A. Have they ever? | ||
Evangelist
1246 Posts
| ||
warcralft
Singapore609 Posts
On June 01 2012 07:21 Popkiller wrote: Yeah but I don't think they'd invite people who are in Code A. Have they ever? Nope, not invites. DRG got his Code S seed from MLG while he was in Code A though. | ||
Birdfood
United States33 Posts
| ||
Diavlo
Belgium2915 Posts
On June 01 2012 07:25 Evangelist wrote: I'd actually put Thorzain up against Stephano and expect him to win at the moment. Give him a few months living with SlayerS and he's going to be the scariest foreigner on the planet. Thorzain played against Stephano on EG practice stream. They played on Shakuras, he was ahead and then suddenly he wasn't and got smashed. I love Thorzain and i believe going to the Slayers house is going to make him very scary but right now he's just not on the same level as Stephano. | ||
kubiks
France1328 Posts
On June 01 2012 04:52 NOOBALOPSE wrote: No surprise to me. I was expecting ViOlet, but I would like it if they gave LucifroN the seed instead of ThorZaIN. He's much better than ThorZaIN, has proved himself and has actually 4-0'ed ThorzaIN at some tournament, not sure which one. and another + is he has no weak matchups as far as I can tell. On June 01 2012 05:36 Aeroplaneoverthesea wrote: Violet deserves it, Thorzain definitely doesn't. Dudes what do you have against thorzain ? No get 4-0' him "at some tournament" doesn't automatically make him terrible. He already went to korea and performed decently, won major championships, and did some major things in teramleague. Lucifron's achievements are quite weak in comparison, and even if thorzain seems in slump, I still go for the guy that already hold a championship (hi IMMVP ![]() Thorzain was without contest the best foregin terran for at least a year (and probably still is, I don't follow enough the foreign scene to be sure), it seems logical he gets a spot in code S. Obviously if stephano was avalaible he would take thorzain spot but he can't so I'm really happy for thorzain ![]() | ||
ravenKRaz
United States580 Posts
| ||
Orracle
United States314 Posts
| ||
Bagration
United States18282 Posts
On June 01 2012 07:44 Orracle wrote: Personally, I don't feel anyone deserves a seed. Players work their ass off just for a Code A spot. To give a player such as Thorizan or Stephano(who is a great player) a Code S seed just because they're foreigners is ridiculous. In an ideal world, we wouldn't need to have seeds. But it is relatively easy for us to think, but it is often times very challenging for someone to suddenly pack up and move to Korea for several months, where they are away from friends, family and experience culture shock, and often cannot speak the language. Few foreigners are willing to take the time to go to Korea for the Code A qualifiers, and sometimes even Code A itself. Why? Because of the costs far outweigh the reward for most progamers. You spend thousands of dollars on plane tickets to compete in a one-day qualifer, where if you are successful, you make Code A, where the largest prize possible (after 2 months of competition and assuming that one wins all 3 Bo3s) is less than 1000 USD. That usually won't even cover the cost of an international plane ticket these days. Only when you hit Code S do the prize pools begin to become substantial. But when most foreign progamers are not willing to travel to Korea to participate in the Code A qualifiers or Code A, how will foreigners get to Code S. Unfortunately, GSL wants more global participation, since it does help the scene in the long run, but critically also increases viewership. Thus, seeds are given out. Is it a bit ridiculous? Yes, but the seeds do try to address the issue of scarcity of foreigners in GSL, and it accomplishes that to some degree, even as it comes at the expense of the Korean players. | ||
mrtomjones
Canada4020 Posts
On June 01 2012 04:45 ragz_gt wrote: Ah, I was not aware of that series over the weekend, good for him. But still, that's not really a consistent winning rate. He may do well, he may not, he may do well and still couldn't make out the group (half the Code S doesn't make out the first group), but it's really hard to argue ThorZaIN is equal to Stephano currently. You need to learn to read before you come up and start complaining about Stephano being more deserving. Stephano is not in korea and has no plans of it until around August. Someone said this on page one dude. Stephano gets his seed when he wants it is the general consensus. | ||
SgtBromancer
Sweden21 Posts
| ||
Aeroplaneoverthesea
United Kingdom1977 Posts
On June 01 2012 08:04 Bagration wrote: In an ideal world, we wouldn't need to have seeds. But it is relatively easy for us to think, but it is often times very challenging for someone to suddenly pack up and move to Korea for several months, where they are away from friends, family and experience culture shock, and often cannot speak the language. Few foreigners are willing to take the time to go to Korea for the Code A qualifiers, and sometimes even Code A itself. Why? Because of the costs far outweigh the reward for most progamers. You spend thousands of dollars on plane tickets to compete in a one-day qualifer, where if you are successful, you make Code A, where the largest prize possible (after 2 months of competition and assuming that one wins all 3 Bo3s) is less than 1000 USD. That usually won't even cover the cost of an international plane ticket these days. Only when you hit Code S do the prize pools begin to become substantial. But when most foreign progamers are not willing to travel to Korea to participate in the Code A qualifiers or Code A, how will foreigners get to Code S. Unfortunately, GSL wants more global participation, since it does help the scene in the long run, but critically also increases viewership. Thus, seeds are given out. Is it a bit ridiculous? Yes, but the seeds do try to address the issue of scarcity of foreigners in GSL, and it accomplishes that to some degree, even as it comes at the expense of the Korean players. This post so fantastically misses the entire point of Esports it's unreal. Esports is an extension of marketing. Players who are good enough for Code A will absolutely not be paying their way there. Their teams will. What their teams want is sponsorship exposure. Few things (aside from winning a tournament) provide better exposure than playing GSL. As a foreigner if you make Code A you're the only guy playing Code A on that day there's several weeks of hype and merely by qualifying/playing in Code A you hugely raise your own profile as a player (thus securing future tournament invites) and provide great exposure for your team. Just look at Sase. Sase has pretty much no major results on LAN at all. He's beaten a few guys, made out of a few groups but that is it. HasuObs, Socke and Mana all have far better results on LAN than Sase but purely on the back of being in Korea and playing in Code A (and getting raped every time no less) he has a load of hype and is invited to tournaments like Red Bull and has one of the biggest fanbases/hype trains behind him. If you're not Naniwa/Huk or Stephano you're not making much money from winning tournaments as a non Korean anyway you're making money from your stream and your team. Nothing will raise you worth to your team in this scene and massively boost your stream numbers like playing in GSL, even if it's just getting stomped in round 1 of Code A. | ||
Aeroplaneoverthesea
United Kingdom1977 Posts
On June 01 2012 07:40 kubiks wrote: Dudes what do you have against thorzain ? No get 4-0' him "at some tournament" doesn't automatically make him terrible. He already went to korea and performed decently, won major championships, and did some major things in teramleague. Lucifron's achievements are quite weak in comparison, and even if thorzain seems in slump, I still go for the guy that already hold a championship (hi IMMVP ![]() Thorzain was without contest the best foregin terran for at least a year (and probably still is, I don't follow enough the foreign scene to be sure), it seems logical he gets a spot in code S. Obviously if stephano was avalaible he would take thorzain spot but he can't so I'm really happy for thorzain ![]() Violet won one of the most stacked foreign tournaments ever played at MLG Arena, he's placed well at so many LAN's this year and won IEM Brazil too. Thorzain beat Polt in a best of five in a tournament full of foreigners and Korean B teamers and has done literally nothing else of note all year aside from bombing out of almost everything he's played in. Stephano would have been deserving but obviously he declined. In his absence MMA should have got it. Or just had a playoff amongst the losing up/down players. | ||
![]()
opterown
![]()
Australia54784 Posts
On May 31 2012 22:57 jobber123rd wrote: Brief thoughts: - IIRC Fionn called Mvp's pick of Line immediately after Line qualified. Well played. ![]() - No surprise with Squirtle's pick. - If the groups hold, MKP dodged a 75% chance of drawing a Terran for his first matchup (see my mockup of the group draw tiers) - Again, if the groups hold, the seed choices are the best ones given the current criteria (international tournament performance) and Stephano sitting out this season. Beyond those two, the choices are a bit ugly IMO (either promoting someone who just failed at U&D, or giving a seed to someone who doesn't have the resutlts). - There's lots of reaction here about NaNiwa and NesTea, but it's pretty easy to imagine a scenario in which they wouldn't play each other. - It's nice to see GOM once again trying to accomodate players going to foreign tournaments around the time of the Round of 32. mkp has a very very good TvT, i'd much rather him go up against a terran than a zerg any day | ||
CarlosOmse
Germany507 Posts
| ||
mrtomjones
Canada4020 Posts
On June 01 2012 08:23 Aeroplaneoverthesea wrote: This post so fantastically misses the entire point of Esports it's unreal. Esports is an extension of marketing. Players who are good enough for Code A will absolutely not be paying their way there. Their teams will. What their teams want is sponsorship exposure. Few things (aside from winning a tournament) provide better exposure than playing GSL. As a foreigner if you make Code A you're the only guy playing Code A on that day there's several weeks of hype and merely by qualifying/playing in Code A you hugely raise your own profile as a player (thus securing future tournament invites) and provide great exposure for your team. Just look at Sase. Sase has pretty much no major results on LAN at all. He's beaten a few guys, made out of a few groups but that is it. HasuObs, Socke and Mana all have far better results on LAN than Sase but purely on the back of being in Korea and playing in Code A (and getting raped every time no less) he has a load of hype and is invited to tournaments like Red Bull and has one of the biggest fanbases/hype trains behind him. If you're not Naniwa/Huk or Stephano you're not making much money from winning tournaments as a non Korean anyway you're making money from your stream and your team. Nothing will raise you worth to your team in this scene and massively boost your stream numbers like playing in GSL, even if it's just getting stomped in round 1 of Code A. Until you have information on how much money a contract to someone who can finish top 8 or 16 in semi major tournaments is worth you can not make this assertion. It is more than likely that most players will make more money outside of Korea then they will be paid to be in Korea. | ||
An2quamaraN
Poland379 Posts
| ||
mrtomjones
Canada4020 Posts
On June 01 2012 08:59 An2quamaraN wrote: I understand Violet, but Thorzain...he is good but not THAT good... Of the performances who warranted an invite to code S, his was one of the better ones, he has not been given an opportunity before in code S and so has not fallen out(Like MMA recently did, as he is the only other name I could throw out there for someone who deserves the seed), and he brings with him a ton of fans, especially if he does well. He is also one of the few who have been considered in the top foreigner talk since Idra left GSL and slumped(Huk,Naniwa,Stephano,Thorzain) are the names I remember being mentioned at one point or the other. Dude deserves a shot to prove himself. Others do to but its his turn I guess ![]() | ||
pdd
Australia9933 Posts
On June 01 2012 05:36 Aeroplaneoverthesea wrote: Violet deserves it, Thorzain definitely doesn't. Shame Stephano didn't accept. Although I don't like him I'd be interested to see how he did in a GSL format. How is winning Dreamhack over a couple of Koreans including Code S runner-up Genius, foreign tournament prizepool bandit Polt and Code S foreigner Naniwa, not deserving of a Code S spot? | ||
Aeroplaneoverthesea
United Kingdom1977 Posts
On June 01 2012 10:48 pdd wrote: How is winning Dreamhack over a couple of Koreans including Code S runner-up Genius, foreign tournament prizepool bandit Polt and Code S foreigner Naniwa, not deserving of a Code S spot? He only played one of those players. He beat down a bunch of foreigners, a Code B Korean and Polt. He is 100% undeserving. On June 01 2012 08:49 mrtomjones wrote: Until you have information on how much money a contract to someone who can finish top 8 or 16 in semi major tournaments is worth you can not make this assertion. It is more than likely that most players will make more money outside of Korea then they will be paid to be in Korea. You really do have no idea how this scene works. (Hint: 98% of professional player don't make most of their money from prize money). | ||
bundo
Canada113 Posts
| ||
pdd
Australia9933 Posts
On June 01 2012 10:55 Aeroplaneoverthesea wrote: He only played one of those players. He beat down a bunch of foreigners, a Code B Korean and Polt. He is 100% undeserving. And yet he won the tournament when the others didn't. We're not talking about individual head-to-head. We're talking about actually winning the championships. Don't forget that DRG lost to Genius in the group stages of the Code S he won and Mvp lost to Ryung and HerO in the Code S he won. If we're going to consider individual head-to-head than DRG and Mvp's Code S championships should be questioned as well. We're not talking about whether or not he is better than other players or not. We're talking about qualifications BASED on GOM's own criteria for Code S seeds. Point is the seeds are given on international tournament performances (+ perhaps a bit more). Thorzain fits that criteria perfectly. Violet also fits that criteria perfectly. | ||
Aeroplaneoverthesea
United Kingdom1977 Posts
On June 01 2012 10:59 pdd wrote: And yet he won the tournament when the others didn't. We're not talking about individual head-to-head. We're talking about actually winning the championships. The Championship itself did not have a player pool to make it prestigious enough to deserve an invite to Code S, especially coupled with the fact that Thorzain has been awful in 2012 outside of that Dreamhack. Don't forget that DRG lost to Genius in the group stages of the Code S he won and Mvp lost to Ryung and HerO in the Code S he won. What does this have to do with anything? We're not talking about whether or not he is better than other players or not. We're talking about qualifications BASED on GOM's own criteria for Code S seeds. Point is the seeds are given on international tournament performances (+ perhaps a bit more). Thorzain fits that criteria perfectly. Violet also fits that criteria perfectly. Well that's are meaningless point as GOM don't have a criteria, they will invite whoever the fuck they want. Hence why they invited Sen who hadn't done anything worthwhile in months and months. Violet not only won a far, far harder to win tournament he also won IEM Brazil and has placed well in countless tournaments this year. Where as Thorzain hasn't done anything at all of note aside from at Dreamhack, where we've established he beat one player who is Code S level. At least Naniwa has beaten a shed load of Code S guys at foreign LAN's to 'earn' it. | ||
ZeroSC2
Korea (South)668 Posts
On May 31 2012 15:42 opterown wrote: whew mkp might not end up in that ugly group haha i am glad it is wrong would be an awful group for MKP, but an actually decent one for Oz. Though by the looks of it it looks like one of the death groups, but Oz has just scary PvZ, he can take it ThorZain might deserve a seed, but doubt he can take out Squirtle and Gumiho. | ||
desRow
Canada2654 Posts
| ||
Darion
Canada265 Posts
On June 01 2012 13:59 desRow wrote: Any updates on this ? You're the one in Korea, you tell us ![]() | ||
mrtomjones
Canada4020 Posts
On June 01 2012 11:04 Aeroplaneoverthesea wrote: The Championship itself did not have a player pool to make it prestigious enough to deserve an invite to Code S, especially coupled with the fact that Thorzain has been awful in 2012 outside of that Dreamhack. What does this have to do with anything? Well that's are meaningless point as GOM don't have a criteria, they will invite whoever the fuck they want. Hence why they invited Sen who hadn't done anything worthwhile in months and months. Violet not only won a far, far harder to win tournament he also won IEM Brazil and has placed well in countless tournaments this year. Where as Thorzain hasn't done anything at all of note aside from at Dreamhack, where we've established he beat one player who is Code S level. At least Naniwa has beaten a shed load of Code S guys at foreign LAN's to 'earn' it. Naniwa, Puma, Polt, Genius, Monster, Hyun. Sase, socke, Ret, TLO, Nericho. Not a bad field. Very hard to win. More than one code S player. Thorzain deserves the shot. | ||
FrostedMiniWheats
United States30730 Posts
| ||
![]()
opterown
![]()
Australia54784 Posts
mkp + 3 protoss e.g. nani, ace, oz creator + 3 zerg e.g. sniper, curious, nestea maru + 3 non zergs e.g. thestc, keen, mc byun + 3 terrans e.g. supernova, happy, taeja fingers crossed <3 | ||
SpecFire
United States1681 Posts
| ||
![]()
opterown
![]()
Australia54784 Posts
On June 01 2012 14:56 SpecFire wrote: Where are the brackets? not yet, hopefully soon | ||
Kiyo.
United States2284 Posts
On June 01 2012 14:52 opterown wrote: hope the groups look like: mkp + 3 protoss e.g. nani, ace, oz creator + 3 zerg e.g. sniper, curious, nestea maru + 3 non zergs e.g. thestc, keen, mc byun + 3 terrans e.g. supernova, happy, taeja fingers crossed <3 Those groups couldn't actually happen no matter how much you want them to ![]() | ||
ZeroSC2
Korea (South)668 Posts
On June 01 2012 14:52 opterown wrote: hope the groups look like: mkp + 3 protoss e.g. nani, ace, oz creator + 3 zerg e.g. sniper, curious, nestea maru + 3 non zergs e.g. thestc, keen, mc byun + 3 terrans e.g. supernova, happy, taeja fingers crossed <3 for some reason i would be glad if MKP really ended up in that PartinG, YuGiOh, SymboL group "diabolic laughter" Ace and Oz are actually pretty decent PvTler. So many top players missing, Mvp will have a field day crushing anybody trying to come close his GSL champion belt. | ||
| ||