EPTUser was temp banned for this post.
Some constructive criticism for tasteless? - Page 12
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
LeBroom
Germany67 Posts
User was temp banned for this post. | ||
|
Demonzii
Netherlands180 Posts
| ||
|
HoCRonin
Denmark23 Posts
My thoughts excatly. If you think you can do better and be more entertaning then apply to gomtv. I belive there is a job opening. http://www.gomtv.net/2011super1/news/65501 | ||
|
StavrosHL
Greece128 Posts
oic. at least the portion of them is like 10 to 500.  | ||
|
Ejohrik
Sweden219 Posts
Tasteless jokes a little too much. I trust his knowlege of the game, and of the korean scene in general.I would like to hear more of it. He states the obvious a little too much. He could show more passion for the matches. It's often Artosis being excited and Tasteless just saying "Yeah", in a common voice. Artosis also jokes too much. I sometimes feel his knowlege of the game is a little overrated. I don't like when he criticizes the players' choices instead of explaining them. He states the game is over way to fast. I feel that any caster should always wait for the gg before making assumptions. | ||
|
holycrapitsTony
United States330 Posts
| ||
|
mutantmagnet
United States3797 Posts
On June 12 2011 15:30 Melange wrote: Here we go again, why the exclusion? Do we want kids' moms to cut them off from anything SC2 related because a pair of casters talked about sex? Is this the kind of impression we want to be giving to the public? They actually should be excluded as long the current integrity of the casting remains. Their mom will ban them from watching or playing SC2. In the future one or all of them will get around to watching it when they are old enough to use their own judgement. They'll shrug when the majority of games don't have a sex joke that could make them uptight and accept the scene for what it is, a less uptight version of competitive sports. The OP has a point that TAsteless should offer better insight into his thought process when he ends up interrupting Artosis only to point out something amusing (which is a coin flip in the chuckle inducement because of the poor timing) or only to say something really simple like GOOD. He needs to take a breath and offer better commentary then. The rest of his casting is fine. Besides people should be less concerned about what Tasteless' casting is doing for the image of professionalism with esports than the reliance of ID tags for players. Our gamer mentality to refer people by their ID instead of their name is far more damaging. It would be preferable if the ID and names were interchangeable in usage but if I had to fall back on one to lend some more professionalism to the scene I would have to be forced to use a person's name. ID tags regardless of how you came up with them originally are filtered through the bias of what viewers know. A friend of mine has had a noticeable dislike for Marinekingprime primarily because of his ID. Whenever he makes mistakes he'll call him out on it with far more enthusiasm than other players. Lot's of people held their nose when a guy decided to call himself Alicia and they still do. Using actual names gives you a connection to the person's possible ethnic origin (which you can have an easier time identifying with), and allows you to speak about them in casual conversation without random jokes interrupting the flow of the conversation. | ||
|
everytimee
United States122 Posts
| ||
|
Onlinejaguar
Australia2823 Posts
| ||
|
Kazeyonoma
United States2912 Posts
On June 12 2011 15:22 hmunkey wrote: Disagree with everything completely except maybe the sex thing. I can see GSL as being a family show, so talking about sex and using vulgarities is probably not the best idea. Also, while a stronger diction couldn't hurt, I don't really mind Tasteless being Tasteless -- that's what makes their casting duo so good. This. I've never noticed tasteless cutting off Artosis, and aside from his sex remark (i noted it too and thought it was too off-topic even for tasteless) everything else about them is perfect. They fill time when there is no action better than any other casting pair, something that is very hard to do because you can say "and they're massing up.... yep" only so much. Who gives a shit about using some of the same words, he's been using more every cast too. I think you're nitpicking on things that bother you particularly. go back and watch more casts, you'll notice tasteless introduces new vocabulary on the nerd world fairly often. I know i've had to google some of his words more than once =P | ||
|
LeLeech
United Kingdom211 Posts
Don't see this thread surviving the weekend. | ||
|
ALPINA
3791 Posts
| ||
|
Blasphemi
United Kingdom980 Posts
| ||
|
DMKraft
476 Posts
Except Tasteless and Artosis, they are. | ||
|
DNA61289
United States665 Posts
Although I want to get on the hate bandwagon aswell. Tasteless why are you acting like yourself?!?!?!!? | ||
|
karpo
Sweden1998 Posts
On June 12 2011 21:07 Tolabakai wrote: My thoughts excatly. If you think you can do better and be more entertaning then apply to gomtv. I belive there is a job opening. http://www.gomtv.net/2011super1/news/65501 Great argument... Criticism should always be countered with "you do better!". Everyone can improve in what they do, be it work or hobby. As long as it's constructive and not offensive i really don't see a problem with providing some pointers. | ||
|
zs3000
United States43 Posts
| ||
|
pStar
996 Posts
Never noticed Tasteless cutting off Artosis. They are the perfect combo, like steak and chips or sausage and bacon DONT EVER CHANGE | ||
|
Tehkilla
Sweden75 Posts
Not really so much with 2. and 3. tho | ||
|
rysecake
United States2632 Posts
| ||
| ||
