|
On June 06 2011 14:22 DannyJ wrote:Show nested quote +On June 06 2011 14:18 Mailing wrote:On June 06 2011 14:15 Limenade wrote:On June 06 2011 13:33 jalstar wrote:On June 06 2011 13:29 GenesisX wrote:On June 06 2011 13:28 saefok wrote:On June 06 2011 13:27 GenesisX wrote: Match fixing? ...Must be joking right? I think IdrA is good enough to know if hes winning or losing. IdrA said he would have been dead if MMA had a round of marines coming, which he would have if he hadn't killed his OC. At least that's what I remember reading. Looking at the VOD Idra only had a small amount of mutas and zerglings, and looks like he would have been dead if MMA had been rallying marines to his base. idra had 16 mutas sitting over the undefended tanks, mma only had 22 marines all out of place. Idra wouldve easily cleaned uip the 8 tanks that were left before marines couldve reached the mutas. Then with lings reinforcing and mutas he couldve cleaned up any marines that would reinforce and easily take out the gold of mma easily ending the game WE know this. IdrA did not. He thought MMA was taking his 4th gold base and had a 3 base eonomy and another round of marines on the way while he had 0 banes. IdrA left because he didn't know what mma had. If he knew he had enough muta left to keep going he would have. Sorry, but that bold sentence doesn't seem kinda nuts to you?
I'll dare to fix that sentence on his behalf:
'IdrA left because he had WRONG information about what MMA had'
|
On June 06 2011 14:18 Mailing wrote:Show nested quote +On June 06 2011 14:15 Limenade wrote:On June 06 2011 13:33 jalstar wrote:On June 06 2011 13:29 GenesisX wrote:On June 06 2011 13:28 saefok wrote:On June 06 2011 13:27 GenesisX wrote: Match fixing? ...Must be joking right? I think IdrA is good enough to know if hes winning or losing. IdrA said he would have been dead if MMA had a round of marines coming, which he would have if he hadn't killed his OC. At least that's what I remember reading. Looking at the VOD Idra only had a small amount of mutas and zerglings, and looks like he would have been dead if MMA had been rallying marines to his base. idra had 16 mutas sitting over the undefended tanks, mma only had 22 marines all out of place. Idra wouldve easily cleaned uip the 8 tanks that were left before marines couldve reached the mutas. Then with lings reinforcing and mutas he couldve cleaned up any marines that would reinforce and easily take out the gold of mma easily ending the game WE know this. IdrA did not. He thought MMA was taking his 4th gold base and had a 3 base eonomy and another round of marines on the way while he had 0 banes. IdrA left because he didn't know what mma had. If he knew he had enough muta left to keep going he would have.
that is bs for idra though. i mean how can u assess the situation within 2 seconds and call gg? He must've saw his natural and it looked as if that drop killed all the drones, infact the drones were stacked in the gas geyser. prompting him to gg.
but even if MMA had another round of marines on the way he had sufficient bases to repel the attack. He didn't even play it out for the fans watching the match. Part of you playing is to win, but the other part is to atleast give an entertaining game for YOUR FANS.
buuuuuuuut ultimately why would you gg so soon when you can stand a chance. I mean a one in a million chance could happen like MMA misclicked into banelings or walked into burrowed banes. Why would you have the mentality of 'hes good, he must not be making mistakes'?
|
Despite all the problems Idra had on the third day, I was quite impressed that he was able to collect himself in the final game, and give a very strong showing.
|
Cheers all around.....and then silences..........
|
|
The fact that MMA destroyed his own CC made that situation even more complex.
|
On June 06 2011 14:06 Mailing wrote:Show nested quote +On June 06 2011 14:04 Defacer wrote:On June 06 2011 13:59 Zhyq wrote: Really guys? You really argue that it was lack of mental strength that led IdrA to those loses? I would strongly suggest it was that exact mental strength that shined. It is remarkable to see a player who is able to foresee 5-6 moves ahead and -know- whether (under perfect play from both sides) he will win or lose.
As said earlier, if MMA had the OC at the gold base up and running, he'd have another round of reinforcements which would defeat IdrA. In a scenario that MMA plays perfect and IdrA plays perfect as well, after that last battle, IdrA loses. Why wait it out when you know the outcome?
As far as the MC games are concerned, again IdrA would lose 3 out of 4 of them eventually (again given no mistakes from MC). However, IdrA could have easily won game 4 if he had teched a bit better, rather than remaining stuck with hydra/roach/corruptor forever. That you can fault him on.
Now, one can say that IdrA was tired and didn't make proper decisions as far as his STRATEGY was concerned, and indeed I believe that this was the case. Still, I feel IdrA is not being appreciated for his greatest strength, that is, his ability to read the game flow.
It is a feat of extremely high intelligence to be able to know if you've lost 10 minutes before you do, and that should be recognized rather than criticized. IdrA's really smart, but he's also fucking arrogant if he thinks he can predict the future. Imagine IdrA is a goalie in hockey. A player on the opposing team manages to get a breakway, and is racing towards him undefended. At this point, Idra just skates off the ice, leaving the net open because he just assumes that the opposing player has the optimal conditions to score, is reasonably talented, and will score anyway. GG! IdrA assumes players like MMA don't kill their own orbital or MC let a nydus pop in his main next to a probe. This is not arrogance. He just has this false idea that SC2 koreans are as good as their BW counterparts when in truth is that the koreans make a shit ton of mistakes in SC2 that he could abuse. It's more humble than arrogant to assume your opponent doesn't do stupid shit.
I'd argue it's incredibly arrogant to assume your opponent will never make mistakes firstly because it's completely stupid when you think about how life actually works. Nobody is perfect and you have to be completely naive to think that you can expect perfection from people all the time in a complicated task like SC2, even from the best.
But mostly it seems ridiculously arrogant because it indicates that Idra feels like it's not worth his time to play people that don't play perfectly, an indication that he feels that he should be included as one of those perfect players. Which is stupid when you consider the fact that the reason he's behind is because he made some mistake at some point.
Ultimately, I feel like Idra is not stupid enough to actually think that even the best pros play perfectly all the time, but it's instead a reflection of trying to seem perfect himself by saying that he only plays against inhuman, perfect gods of starcraft.
|
On June 06 2011 14:24 BaronFel wrote: For koreans, "cool" means something along the lines of "I don't really care" attitude. Like if you get blown off and you go "whatever" and act like is no big deal, that's being cool.
yup and along that line I would like to correct the mistranslation from the event
MMA never said anything about 'being positive'
This is what MMA actually said but lost in translation 'From this game, I hope Idra is able to learn some perseverance/fortitude'
|
On June 06 2011 14:18 Mailing wrote:Show nested quote +On June 06 2011 14:15 Limenade wrote:On June 06 2011 13:33 jalstar wrote:On June 06 2011 13:29 GenesisX wrote:On June 06 2011 13:28 saefok wrote:On June 06 2011 13:27 GenesisX wrote: Match fixing? ...Must be joking right? I think IdrA is good enough to know if hes winning or losing. IdrA said he would have been dead if MMA had a round of marines coming, which he would have if he hadn't killed his OC. At least that's what I remember reading. Looking at the VOD Idra only had a small amount of mutas and zerglings, and looks like he would have been dead if MMA had been rallying marines to his base. idra had 16 mutas sitting over the undefended tanks, mma only had 22 marines all out of place. Idra wouldve easily cleaned uip the 8 tanks that were left before marines couldve reached the mutas. Then with lings reinforcing and mutas he couldve cleaned up any marines that would reinforce and easily take out the gold of mma easily ending the game WE know this. IdrA did not. He thought MMA was taking his 4th gold base and had a 3 base eonomy and another round of marines on the way while he had 0 banes. IdrA left because he didn't know what mma had. If he knew he had enough muta left to keep going he would have.
Well duh, then Why did he leave when he didn't know what mma had? Why not find out? There is zero excuse for this, really.
|
On June 06 2011 14:29 Garnet wrote: The fact that MMA destroyed his own CC made that situation even more complex.
I was laughing and at the same time thinking what's wrong with you. Was amazing.
|
Idra is becoming more and more mentally fragile the more tournaments I see. How many more games is he gonna premature gg? How many more times is he just gonna go majorly on tilt like in the series vs MC? He's his own worst enemy, and it's becoming increasingly difficult to see him as a major contender ;/ Maybe he needs to find a sports psychologist practice partner(hohoho).
|
Everyone makes mistakes, so you should never assume that disadvantages can't be overcome. And you can never make a comeback victory if you don't give yourself the chance. Some quit early when they think they're too disadvantaged and don't want to get angry or tilted but really they're going to be angry/tilted anyways and are probably better off taking a few minutes to make your opponent earn the win (even though you may fail to come back most of the time) and cool off a bit and come to terms with their loss rather than jumping straight into the next match while in a bad mental state.
|
lol first huk with the hallucinations and now idrA just straight up leaving hahah
|
On June 06 2011 14:33 Tachion wrote: Idra is becoming more and more mentally fragile the more tournaments I see. How many more games is he gonna premature gg? How many more times is he just gonna go majorly on tilt like in the series vs MC? He's his own worst enemy, and it's becoming increasingly difficult to see him as a major contender ;/ Maybe he needs to find a sports psychologist practice partner(hohoho).
someone was offering idra professional psychology lessons for $300/hr in the LR thread
cruel but... lol
|
On June 06 2011 14:31 Emporio wrote:Show nested quote +On June 06 2011 14:06 Mailing wrote:On June 06 2011 14:04 Defacer wrote:On June 06 2011 13:59 Zhyq wrote: Really guys? You really argue that it was lack of mental strength that led IdrA to those loses? I would strongly suggest it was that exact mental strength that shined. It is remarkable to see a player who is able to foresee 5-6 moves ahead and -know- whether (under perfect play from both sides) he will win or lose.
As said earlier, if MMA had the OC at the gold base up and running, he'd have another round of reinforcements which would defeat IdrA. In a scenario that MMA plays perfect and IdrA plays perfect as well, after that last battle, IdrA loses. Why wait it out when you know the outcome?
As far as the MC games are concerned, again IdrA would lose 3 out of 4 of them eventually (again given no mistakes from MC). However, IdrA could have easily won game 4 if he had teched a bit better, rather than remaining stuck with hydra/roach/corruptor forever. That you can fault him on.
Now, one can say that IdrA was tired and didn't make proper decisions as far as his STRATEGY was concerned, and indeed I believe that this was the case. Still, I feel IdrA is not being appreciated for his greatest strength, that is, his ability to read the game flow.
It is a feat of extremely high intelligence to be able to know if you've lost 10 minutes before you do, and that should be recognized rather than criticized. IdrA's really smart, but he's also fucking arrogant if he thinks he can predict the future. Imagine IdrA is a goalie in hockey. A player on the opposing team manages to get a breakway, and is racing towards him undefended. At this point, Idra just skates off the ice, leaving the net open because he just assumes that the opposing player has the optimal conditions to score, is reasonably talented, and will score anyway. GG! IdrA assumes players like MMA don't kill their own orbital or MC let a nydus pop in his main next to a probe. This is not arrogance. He just has this false idea that SC2 koreans are as good as their BW counterparts when in truth is that the koreans make a shit ton of mistakes in SC2 that he could abuse. It's more humble than arrogant to assume your opponent doesn't do stupid shit. I'd argue it's incredibly arrogant to assume your opponent will never make mistakes firstly because it's completely stupid when you think about how life actually works. Nobody is perfect and you have to be completely naive to think that you can expect perfection from people all the time in a complicated task like SC2, even from the best. But mostly it seems ridiculously arrogant because it indicates that Idra feels like it's not worth his time to play people that don't play perfectly, an indication that he feels that he should be included as one of those perfect players. Which is stupid when you consider the fact that the reason he's behind is because he made some mistake at some point. Ultimately, I feel like Idra is not stupid enough to actually think that even the best pros play perfectly all the time, but it's instead a reflection of trying to seem perfect himself by saying that he only plays against inhuman, perfect gods of starcraft.
How on earth does the fact that IdrA assumes his opponents won't make mistakes mean that he doesn't feel it's worth it to play people who are imperfect?
|
Idra clearly saw that MMA had a CC BUILDING at the gold during the final battle which makes it all the more confusing. If he didn't notice it... well that's just bad because it was 1 foot away from the marines he was focusing with mutas.
|
He doesn't play till the final whistle. That's always been Idra's problem and sadly it's leaked from his ladder play to matches that actually mean something in SC2. I'll be honest and say I root for his failure because I don't like his attitude towards his opponents and about himself. Saying that I was even feeling sorry for him with that GG to MMA.
You aren't a serious competitor if you don't play till the final whistle because ANY serious competitor knows that ANYTHING can happen and you play it out till you have no more moves to make or the clock runs out. Pressure is a powerful thing in competition and people make the silliest mistakes when put under it. Until Idra gets that mentality he'll continue to say woulda/coulda/shoulda. It's sad really.
|
I beleive it was on "Inside the Game" when they talked about GG timings. IdrA says that his bad habit of early GGs is because he expects his opponents to play the game out PERFECTLY. of course players do make mistakes (ahem inca v rainbow) but he says he expects them to play the game out without any.
of course... the other players are humans and not robots. but he doesn't realize that >_>
|
I just wish idra would play his games out, take a lesson from day9 and "never give up, never surrender." :/
After watching that on the livestream my jaw literally dropped and I just stared at the screen, moments earlier I was thinking wow idra is going to win mlg, he is looking way too solid, then it all just falls apart...
On the plus side + Show Spoiler + MMA gets a spot in code S!!!
|
On June 06 2011 14:39 Blitz Beat wrote: I beleive it was on "Inside the Game" when they talked about GG timings. IdrA says that his bad habit of early GGs is because he expects his opponents to play the game out PERFECTLY. of course players do make mistakes (ahem inca v rainbow) but he says he expects them to play the game out without any.
of course... the other players are humans and not robots. but he doesn't realize that >_>
He obviously realizes it but I think that when his inner machine self makes a mistake or is behind in the game, he gets frustrated and doesn't want to play out a losing battle EVEN if he wins for some reason.
|
|
|
|