| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Kajarn
United States126 Posts
If you don't find Tyler's, Artosis' or Lea's perspectives and opinions interesting, but instead think the show is "boring." Simply put, your watching the wrong show. The show is about Starcraft 2, not a Jay P McDaniel or Geoff Robinson stand up comedy act. | ||
|
IWANTHOTDOG
United States13 Posts
On July 21 2011 09:17 Kajarn wrote: I don't understand the negative feedback about the "lack of entertainment" or "I want Geoff back." If you don't find Tyler's, Artosis' or Lea's perspectives and opinions interesting, but instead think the show is "boring." Simply put, your watching the wrong show. The show is about Starcraft 2, not a Jay P McDaniel or Geoff Robinson stand up comedy act. Well obviously they are putting out there, their concerns, in hope of things changing. Otherwise, yes they will stop watching. You got your wish. | ||
|
Shelke14
Canada6655 Posts
Keep up the good work Leah! | ||
|
ApBuLLet
United States604 Posts
Artosis is the absolute best person you could've added to the cast, and I am really happy you made that choice, but despite that the show just seems stale and the discussions either seem weak or forced. Like others have said, making the casters speak in turns is not good for the show. How are you supposed to have a discussion if you need to talk in turns? Sure for some things it works fine, but for many topics it is just too restrictive for anything worth hearing to get started. Another thing is, I really think that Geoff should be brought back on the show. I don't know if there are any reasons why he hasn't been as far as the JP/MLG side of the deal goes, but we've already been told that Geoff would accept an offer to return to the show both as a pillar or as a guest, and that EG has no problem with that. So if it is possible, please bring Geoff back! Whether you love him or hate him, he made the show interesting because he sparked the discussion. He is a very involved person as a professional player, caster, and as a community member, so he has a lot of knowledge about all aspects of eSports and StarCraft 2 itself. He's also very honest about everything and speaks his opinion. The other members on the show are a bit more conservative in what they say and how much they argue a point because they either have their own image/reputation to uphold, or that of the organization they are a part of. That's all well and good but it seems like no discussion ever happens anymore because nobody is bold enough to throw their brutally honest opinion out there and make people argue their side of the issue. It gets boring fast when everyone just states their opinion and accepts everyone else's even though they are on different sides of the fence. I want to here a true discussion, not just the censored version of everybody's thoughts. I intend for this to be constructive criticism for you guys, not harmful. I hope it doesn't appear that way. Like I've said I've always been one of the guys to back you up and I want to continue to be =). Either way, I'll continue to tune in every Tuesday and hopefully some of our complaints/concerns are answered, because I really want to see State of the Game return to its' old shape. | ||
|
happyness
United States2400 Posts
On July 21 2011 09:17 Kajarn wrote: I don't understand the negative feedback about the "lack of entertainment" or "I want Geoff back." If you don't find Tyler's, Artosis' or Lea's perspectives and opinions interesting, but instead think the show is "boring." Simply put, your watching the wrong show. The show is about Starcraft 2, not a Jay P McDaniel or Geoff Robinson stand up comedy act. This. How could anyone not love artosis is what I want to know. We have Geoff for ITG and can here his perspective their. In Sotg we have different perspectives which is nice | ||
|
Fanta_Rules
Sweden669 Posts
On July 21 2011 05:22 Pyre wrote: I'm not sure how imformed Leah is, every awnser she gave was IEM or TSL3. This makes me believe this is the only 2 turnoments she has kept up with. I hope she not on the show only because she is a women. To be honest, Leah sounds more informed about recent events than Tyler, JP AND Artosis. She seems to watch every single tourney and keeps up with all the happenings around SC2, so I don't know what the hell you're talking about. Like other people have written before, she actually corrects/reminds the others when they don't remember something correctly. Stop being an idiot and listen to what she's saying. As for iNcontrol coming back, yeah, it could be fun to have him on the show again, but if I had to choose between him, Artosis and Tyler, I'd go with Tyler and Artosis any day. He could replace Day as a pillar instead, since he's never got the time for the show anyway. Of course I would prefer it if they were all on the show at once, though. | ||
|
gregnog
United States289 Posts
| ||
|
crms
United States11933 Posts
| ||
|
Strike_
Netherlands704 Posts
| ||
|
Fanta_Rules
Sweden669 Posts
On July 21 2011 11:33 crms wrote: Why are people crying? Artosis is so fucking good! I miss IdrA more than anything. I wish oh wish it could be artosis, idra, tyler in JP as the 4 pillars. oh yeah! I agree. That would have been perfect.  | ||
|
TedJustice
Canada1324 Posts
On July 21 2011 11:33 Strike_ wrote: There should be a special reunion episode with every person that has been on sotg ever You do realize how many people that is, right? That would be a disaster. Unless maybe they weren't on all at once. | ||
|
NickOgden
13 Posts
While i didn't really like Geoff too much, just me!, he did instigate discussion, argument and emotion from the others. Without Day9 aswell the show lacked dynamics. I don't like Leah because she seems more like a Gossip columnist, and the "state of the e sports" show isn't something for me, but yeah, just my opinion | ||
|
Astro-Penguin
554 Posts
On July 21 2011 05:41 MuseMike wrote: You have to be trolling. Sweet baby Jesus I hope you are trolling. JP is working full-time at MLG, that is showing his passion for E-sports. Artosis is probably the person most in love with the game and most the passionate. Obviously some may say Tyler lost his passion, but it seems like there are other personal reasons for not being able to show it via practice/tournament results. I'm hoping you are trolling, but in case you weren't I went ahead and posted this lol. Lol that comment was meant to mimic all of these forum qqers and make fun of them | ||
|
Kamuy
United States212 Posts
| ||
|
Wedberg
Sweden169 Posts
On July 21 2011 12:40 Kamuy wrote: Wait, can someone point out where it was said Leah is a new pillar? God I hope not. As far as I know, she isn't. | ||
|
Floydian
United Kingdom374 Posts
 | ||
|
Ostby
Norway38 Posts
| ||
|
ProxyKnoxy
United Kingdom2576 Posts
| ||
|
Thrombozyt
Germany1269 Posts
On July 21 2011 17:39 Ostby wrote: I think JP needs to get a Terran and Zerg to join the show, all this protoss talk is not very interesting for 2/3 of the starcraft community. I think Tyler is the problem, because he ONLY talk about protoss, and he tends to get a bit dominant in the discussions. True. Tyler is the most serious pro-gamer as all other participants don't play as their main occupation. Thus in game related items Tyler seems to dominate and with him the very protoss-centric view on the game. Artosis is a great addition and Leah isn't bad, but Artosis has the same role as Sean and Leah the same background as JP. So where we had 2 players and 2 non-players before, we now have 1 player and 4 non-players and that shows. Get 1 Zerg and 1 Terran pro in (e.g. Destiny and QXC). You need more players in my eyes. | ||
|
RogerChillingworth
Chad3132 Posts
Only for a few minutes, of course. They don't need too much more free press. | ||
| ||
|
|
The PondCast
Replay Cast
CrankTV Team League
Replay Cast
CrankTV Team League
Replay Cast
RSL Revival
Clem vs Lambo
Scarlett vs Cure
CranKy Ducklings
IPSL
Dragon vs Hawk
RSL Revival
Classic vs Trap
herO vs SHIN
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
