|
Ok so I ran a few searchs and I couldn't find anyone talking about this. I'm wondering if anyone else is having this issue with the beta.
When I watch a replay the APM pane average counter doesn't seem to be very accurate. It'll be ok for a while but then it will just jump by almost a hundred for no reason. The constant APM readout seems pretty accurate but the average is definitely not...
I'm sorry but I don't have an average APM of 180+, I just don't, lol.
PS: I also have the same issue with the EPM counters.
|
APM on HOTS seems to be calculated way higher from replays than in WoL. I also doubt I have 400 apm when playing zerg, it should be around 300. But maybe theyre calculting it as real seconds apm or something...
|
If that is the case it seems kind of stupid to change one of the key metrics for measuring mechanical player ability...
|
I've had higher average apm in hots than in wol since I started playing a couple of months ago. Not sure if it's a bug or they've just changed how it's calculated. It's not the same at least and it's been there since the start of the beta as far as I'm aware.
|
I have also had higher APM by a lot, but i think i am actually doing more. The WOL counter also doesnt count screen hotkeys
|
They may have started doing it by real time APM, as opposed to Blizzard time.
|
I think it's just working like it's supposed to now, besides the season average counter.
|
On February 05 2013 06:26 kollin wrote: They may have started doing it by real time APM, as opposed to Blizzard time.
|
I think it only displays your peak APM. Not the average like it should.
|
In the score-screen it says my average apm is 932... must be true. :D
|
On February 05 2013 07:43 Grapefruit wrote: I think it only displays your peak APM. Not the average like it should.
This is not true. My peak apm is always around like 500-600 in any SC1/SC2 game and my average in HotS after every game is about 280-350.
They are either counting in real time now AND counting more action types OR they have a fucked up counter that is just wrong atm.
|
it's 100% broken...all the stats are wrong 100% broken, My average apm in wol is like 80-120 and in hots it say 900-1900 year right that crap is 100% wrong lol I hate how they record useless information in hots. I wish they bring back WOL stats after each game.
I find it much more useful to see the worker count of each player for econ results vs the new stupid apm.
Apm means nothing imo unless ur top gm/pro player, as most apm from players are useless spam, does not help anyone improve to know what someones apm is, bring back the info wol shows after each match, Beta stats is just useless
|
It's possible that it's by real time + includes screen movement actions (clicking minimap + location hotkeys), but I think it's just fucked up. My average real time APM according to SC2 gears was ~190 and in HotS my apm is recorded at ~280, so this seems reasonable to me, but based on some of the above numbers this doesn't seem likely.
|
I believe that APM is calculated in real time now. So it should naturally be at least 25% or so? higher than your WoL APM, even if you don't play any better.
|
On February 05 2013 07:02 ailouros wrote: I think it's just working like it's supposed to now, besides the season average counter. There is no way it is working as intended. In Almost all of my replays zergs average over 400 apm while terrain and toss average 350ish. I haven't seen anyone with less than 300. Its calculating per real minute but being divided by the fake in game minute which is inflating the number.
|
Yeah, I warmed up with a HotS game and had 100 apm and then all the 3v3 WoL games I played next had 50-60 apm. A little irritating, but at my level apm isn't the most important thing I need to worry about (map awareness, scouting, saturating bases ect), so it isn't the worst bug for the beta to have
|
|
|
For me, it's accurate (based on my WoL APM) some of the times, but I think it's glitched. Most of the time, it says my APM is 1000+, which is funny because even if it's calculated in real time, I still don't have an APM of 800.
I guess the real time thing makes sense for when it's actually working because I did see an increase in APM, even though I'm still not as good at HotS as I am at WoL. It does make me happy when I see that my APM is 2384. (o^-^)o Although I would like to know my actual APM without having to pull up a replay.
|
The APM counter in WoL wasn't showing your real speed. It is showing actions per ~43 seconds, a minute in game time, (60 seconds / 1.4), not actions per real minute, which HoTs is showing.
|
On February 05 2013 12:27 SoFrOsTy wrote:Show nested quote +On February 05 2013 07:02 ailouros wrote: I think it's just working like it's supposed to now, besides the season average counter. There is no way it is working as intended. In Almost all of my replays zergs average over 400 apm while terrain and toss average 350ish. I haven't seen anyone with less than 300. Its calculating per real minute but being divided by the fake in game minute which is inflating the number. It's working fine for me at least, it's about what I had in Brood War.
|
On February 05 2013 18:27 ghost_face wrote: The APM counter in WoL wasn't showing your real speed. It is showing actions per ~43 seconds, a minute in game time, (60 seconds / 1.4), not actions per real minute, which HoTs is showing.
Unfortunately, that still doesn't explain why it showed that I had 1000+ APM in my games. My APM is 110 at most (game time), and if you do the math, that doesn't equate to 1000 in real time.
|
I still miss the old WoL counter. For good old loyal players, that is the way to compare how fast are u playing.
|
Something is wrong with the APM stats for sure. I'm fairly new to SC2, not terrible but I've been playing for less than 6 months and am low master league level on an average day and my "average apm" is shown as like 330; I know from experience how long it takes to get comfortable enough with a game that you play with 300 apm on average, probably at least a year and a half of ~20-30 games per day. My highest apm for a mathup is definitely PvT and it feels like MAYBE 160 apm to me, no more.
It's definitely not taking your peak/max apm, though, because I have right click bound to the mousewheel and if it was reading peak apm it would be reading like 1k apm whenever I set rally points or something. I also seriously doubt that it's just the difference between taking the apm in real time or not, because the difference between "faster" and real time seconds is, iirc, 1.4 or 1.8 or something (I don't know for sure but it's above 1 and below 2); the difference between "330 apm" and a more realistic 150 apm is a lot more drastic than that.
I think it's just totally screwed up at the moment, but I wouldn't totally write off Blizzard tampering with it to artificially double your apm to make you "feel better about yourself"; between hiding your true MMR and separating the ladder into a billion little leagues and divisions, they seem to be completely comfortable with the idea of putting out artificially inflated data and statistics to make players feel like they are a lot "better" than they really are.
That said, although it isn't a huge deal I would like to be able to see my actual apm; looking at the stats screen and thinking "okay, that's total bullshit, there is NO WAY that's accurate" doesn't increase my self esteem, it just frustrates me. If they are going to give APM stats, I'd like them to be accurate so I can see if I'm undergoing improvement or if I'm slacking off.
I do really like the idea of showing your stats each game as compared to your average stats, it's a cool idea, but please make them correct!
|
I think me having an APM of 938 at the score screen is pretty accurate, I'm just that good.
|
On February 05 2013 21:06 Belha wrote: I still miss the old WoL counter. For good old loyal players, that is the way to compare how fast are u playing. apm wol isn't even in real time, actually you have no way in sc2 (beside sc2 gears and other tier program) to know your apm. I don't know how it's possible for Blizzard to mess up so badly the apm counter.
In wol I was at 170-200 apm (from sc2 gears), and in hots I've got 250apm. I may be a bit faster since there is more to do in hots, but probably not by 50-70 apm
|
The hots thing is kinda buggy, or was. i had 1300 apm in some games, and 0 in others. maybe they fixed it cause in recent games i have had like normal apm.
|
My APM in HotS tops out at 4,780. This sounds about right for me--probably not bugged.
|
I believe the reason everyones APM is so high for zerg is because of larva. Say you have like 30 larva and hold down z to spawn 30 lings it takes less than a second and counts each one of those spawns as apm, so really increases your apm.
|
i know i have high apm between 340-420 even in broodwar times, but now the game trys to telling me i have 8000 and i DONT THINK SO xD
|
On February 06 2013 01:30 scanders wrote: I believe the reason everyones APM is so high for zerg is because of larva. Say you have like 30 larva and hold down z to spawn 30 lings it takes less than a second and counts each one of those spawns as apm, so really increases your apm.
That might be true, but I play Protoss and I got readings of 1000 APM. Haha.
|
Mine went from 130 to 160
|
its broken, but u shouldnt give a damn about apm. look at what u do wrong ingame, not how fast u (most likely) spam.
|
WOL/SC2 Gears doesn't count a request to train a unit if you don't have the money for it (BW Chart did,) nor does it count camera hotkeys. Anyone know if HOTS is taking these into account?
So if you are hearing "You require more minerals" (as you should be) or mashing an upgrade hotkey repeatedly when one is about to finish, in WOL, it is not counting those as actions
|
On February 05 2013 21:06 Belha wrote: I still miss the old WoL counter. For good old loyal players, that is the way to compare how fast are u playing. No, you're wrong. The WoL counter is broken (and always has been). Sure, so is the HotS one, but at least they are trying to fix it .
The Broodwar counter is the most accurate.
|
HotS APM is higher and there is definitely more to it than just Blizzard to real time conversion. My APM in WoL, real time, according to SC2Gears was generally around 160-180. In HotS I'm consistently above 230. I do feel like I'm playing faster in HotS but not so much that it would explain such a large increase.. Would really like to know exactly where the discrepancies are coming from.
|
Guys, the APM tab is obviously correct, I mean, last game it said my average APM has been 830. And I am quite confident that I can regularly hit 800 throughout a game. /sarcasm.
The APM shown for the game you just played seems to be a little bit higher too, it seems to be about 50 or so higher for me each game.
|
|
|
|
|
|