|
Hmm so this whole time I've been doing Back Lever with my palms facing down. Just browsing some stuff on it as I come close to achieving this and I see everyone with hands pronated. Fortunately I came across this on the CrossFit boards as I was writing this post:
Steve Low wrote on August 10, 2010: Hands pronated makes it SLIGHTLY easier, but if you want to work higher level gymnastics strength you need to do it with palms facing down. Yay! I was worried for a second I learned it wrong/suboptimally.
|
On March 14 2013 05:35 mordek wrote:Hmm so this whole time I've been doing Back Lever with my palms facing down. Just browsing some stuff on it as I come close to achieving this and I see everyone with hands pronated. Fortunately I came across this on the CrossFit boards as I was writing this post: Show nested quote +Steve Low wrote on August 10, 2010: Hands pronated makes it SLIGHTLY easier, but if you want to work higher level gymnastics strength you need to do it with palms facing down. Yay! I was worried for a second I learned it wrong/suboptimally.
If you plan on learning more movements (higher level strength) then you did learn it wrong....
You need the elbow conditioning for the hands facing down for things such as one arm pullup, cross, planche, etc.
|
On March 13 2013 18:20 paulcostin wrote: Hi eshlow,
Im new here but I read your book "Overcoming Gravity" (a masterpiece on BW training) and started with the training progressions. Currently Im doing the level 3-4 dynamic workout (i prefer dynamic work over static holds) for 3 times a week.
It looks lke that:
Warmup Skill work (Lsit,handstand) Muscel up assistance Box Hanstand PU Dips on Rings Pullups on Rings RTO Pushups Rows
I can do now 10 reps for 3 sets for each of these exercices and I have a few questions concerning further progression:
1. I read the part where you compare the strength needed eg. for a OAC is comparable with a 90% BW Pullup. My goals look more like achieving a full front lever pullup, but would it be better to just add weights to my pullups and when I reach a proper amount of strength to do some skill work or should i just take the next progression from your book (level 5 -6) and dont add weights to my pullups ( the same question i have also for dips)?
2. If I will add weigths to pullups which type of pullups should I do to gain the most strength for further progressions? Chinups, Bar Pullups or Ring Pullups
3. If I do weighted Ring dips should I do them with RTO or not?
4. Any tips to progress faster with freestanding Handstand? It just seems it takes ages to hold a freestanding Handstand cause I can keep the balance just for a few seconds . Im afraid now that I come to the point where I can do 10 Wall Hanstandpushups but I wont be able to progress to do them freestanding.
Sorry for the long post, but Im just at the beginning and I dont want to do mistakes already.
Thank you very much
If you can handle that many exercises near the beginning be careful... I typically suggest the 2 push/2 pull because any more and you may develop overuse injuries. So just be aware if you are starting to get any nagging uncomfortableness or pain.
1. Read the one arm chinup training section... it details a bunch of things I think you should know. I typically suggest working up to at elast 50% bw pullup but from there you can start assist OAC or eccentric work, but you can still work it up with weighted pullups too.
2. Chins on bar are typically best, unless you are aiming eventually for a one arm pullup (as opposed to one arm chin)
3. RTO is the best way to progress with strength IMO
4. Lots more practice. Practice your handstand on your off days as well.
Best way to get feedback is from criqitue though... feel free to post a vid.
Let me know if you have any other questions, and don't forget to submit an Amazon review.
Steve
|
On March 14 2013 21:08 eshlow wrote:Show nested quote +On March 14 2013 05:35 mordek wrote:Hmm so this whole time I've been doing Back Lever with my palms facing down. Just browsing some stuff on it as I come close to achieving this and I see everyone with hands pronated. Fortunately I came across this on the CrossFit boards as I was writing this post: Steve Low wrote on August 10, 2010: Hands pronated makes it SLIGHTLY easier, but if you want to work higher level gymnastics strength you need to do it with palms facing down. Yay! I was worried for a second I learned it wrong/suboptimally. If you plan on learning more movements (higher level strength) then you did learn it wrong.... You need the elbow conditioning for the hands facing down for things such as one arm pullup, cross, planche, etc. Ok, I think one of us is mixed up (probably me ) Your post says palms down is better... which is what I said I had been doing. I get a tad confused when using pronated when your hanging from bar but hopefully this clarifies. When I set up I reach my arms behind to grab the bar. If there was a shelf behind me I could rest my palms on the shelf (not my knuckles) and I grab the bar like this.
Actually simple solution. I do it the opposite of this guy:
|
Thanks for the fast reply,
Actually i feel some pain after muscle up work in my elbows , so i guess it will be the best to stop it and do some weighted pullups and dips till my muscles and tendons get used to it.
I got it with the OAC progression, but as i wrote OAC are not my primary goal. Im a little confused now cause i dont know if I should start with the next pullup progression which would be for level 5/6, tuck FL pullups or if i should just add weights to the pullups/chinups?
If you recommend weighted Chinups, do you mean they are best for OAC progression or are they also superior to Ring Pullups if I want to learn skills as FL and BL? I also read that Ring pullups are better for shoulder health.
I ll write an review , best book out there for BW training
|
@mordek: you're doing BL the better way (palms facing down, thumbs pointing outside, not towards eachother like in the picture). Where were you browsing stuff btw? I don't like watching stuff on youtube, most of the stuff I've seen is done with atrocious form and then titled as a high progression =/
@paulcostin: IMO treat tuck FL pullups as a separate rowing/horizontal pulling exercise and not as a progression to regular pullups/chinups, so go with adding weight.
|
On March 15 2013 00:28 4thHatchery wrote: @mordek: you're doing BL the better way (palms facing down, thumbs pointing outside, not towards eachother like in the picture). Where were you browsing stuff btw? I don't like watching stuff on youtube, most of the stuff I've seen is done with atrocious form and then titled as a high progression =/
@paulcostin: IMO treat tuck FL pullups as a separate rowing/horizontal pulling exercise and not as a progression to regular pullups/chinups, so go with adding weight. Awesome thanks 4th. I should have thought of which way the thumbs are pointing Just browsing anything tagged back lever. Beastskills, crossfit forums. Just browsing really seeing if I could glean anything.
|
When doing pullups, how straight should the arms be in terms of ROF? I feel like my ROF is getting worse with weighted pullups, and i'm not sure if that is worse than using a 'full' ROF with less weight. If that makes sense.
I'm also getting extreme shoulder and neck issues on my left side when doing weighted dips, is it common to get some strain (probably not the correct word) when doing BW + more than half BW?
Cheers
|
On March 15 2013 00:36 Rixxe wrote: When doing pullups, how straight should the arms be in terms of ROF? I feel like my ROF is getting worse with weighted pullups, and i'm not sure if that is worse than using a 'full' ROF with less weight. If that makes sense.
I'm also getting extreme shoulder and neck issues on my left side when doing weighted dips, is it common to get some strain (probably not the correct word) when doing BW + more than half BW?
Cheers
Are you talking about ROF on the bottom (full extension), or ROF at the top (full lock)? I definitely think you should reduce weight until you can full lock off to your chest as that is a really important part of the pullup when transitioning to a mantle or muscle up. Not sure about extension, although I always go from a fullest hang just because that is the motion in the real world when climbing something. I guess you could stress your shoulders though with enough extra weight, so I'll let eschlow weigh in.
|
Mordek,
My bad you're right I read it wrong. Hands down is the correct way. Keep it up.
On March 14 2013 22:52 paulcostin wrote: Thanks for the fast reply,
Actually i feel some pain after muscle up work in my elbows , so i guess it will be the best to stop it and do some weighted pullups and dips till my muscles and tendons get used to it.
I got it with the OAC progression, but as i wrote OAC are not my primary goal. Im a little confused now cause i dont know if I should start with the next pullup progression which would be for level 5/6, tuck FL pullups or if i should just add weights to the pullups/chinups?
If you recommend weighted Chinups, do you mean they are best for OAC progression or are they also superior to Ring Pullups if I want to learn skills as FL and BL? I also read that Ring pullups are better for shoulder health.
I ll write an review , best book out there for BW training
1. The transition can be tough on the elbow (as can deep dips). Don't be afraid to take a bit of time off if they continue to be sore.
2. Doesn't matter.
The progressions I prefer for general strength are: ~pullups -> back lever -> some form of weighted pullups/OAC/cross and ~ rows -> front lever pullups.
If I were going to build someone up I would do it like that
3. Thanks for teh compliments.
|
On March 15 2013 00:36 Rixxe wrote: When doing pullups, how straight should the arms be in terms of ROF? I feel like my ROF is getting worse with weighted pullups, and i'm not sure if that is worse than using a 'full' ROF with less weight. If that makes sense.
I'm also getting extreme shoulder and neck issues on my left side when doing weighted dips, is it common to get some strain (probably not the correct word) when doing BW + more than half BW?
Cheers
What the heck is ROF?
Full range of motion is what yo want to do, unless you have an injury.
If an exercise is giving you issues I wouldn't do it because if it's painful it can wreck you more if you keep pushing through
|
Pretty bummed I seem to have pushed too hard and now have a minor strain in what I would guess is my proximal biceps tendon/shoulder (aggravated doing straight arm work, back lever, weighted chins). And this is after two weeks off from the gym and being sick most of that time! Going to follow the tendonitis protocol but disappointed I'm going to lose out on another few weeks of training. Goes to show you can push the joints/tendons too fast though.
|
On March 21 2013 21:12 mordek wrote: Pretty bummed I seem to have pushed too hard and now have a minor strain in what I would guess is my proximal biceps tendon/shoulder (aggravated doing straight arm work, back lever, weighted chins). And this is after two weeks off from the gym and being sick most of that time! Going to follow the tendonitis protocol but disappointed I'm going to lose out on another few weeks of training. Goes to show you can push the joints/tendons too fast though.
Yeah, the major thing with progressing fast with bodyweight is it's tough on the connective tissues.
|
Hi,
lately I've been interested in bodyweight training, but there's one thing I'm concerned with. I have slight scoliosis (my left shoulder is lower) and the consequence is slightly bigger left/right pectoralis/shoulder. Most people, even after telling them, aren't noticing it. The thing that annoys me is while using compound exercises I get much better left pectoralis activation (especially in the upper part), while on the other side shoulder gets more activated. With isolation exercises, activation is more balanced (left side of the chest is still better activated), but I find basing chest training on mostly cables limiting and little boring ...
I'm afraid if I start doing bodyweight training (and currently really want to do it exclusively), imbalance might get even bigger. Last night I did some push-ups, and noticed that my right shoulder does part of the job (at the expense of upper part of right pectoral muscle), but both sides of the chest got nice pump. Of course, I'm not, and don't plan to be, huge ... just to be in shape. I'm entirely fine with current imbalance, just don't want to develop it even more.
I'd be grateful if someone has experienced something similar and has some pieces of advice. Plan is to stay away for some time from pike push-ups (and similar that emphasize shoulders), and do mostly for chest with adding extra dumbbell front raises for front portion of left shoulder and slightly incline press for right pectoralis (try to squeeze it, minimal right shoulder involvement) as correction. I might be completely wrong ...
Thanks!
|
On March 29 2013 01:16 Hyaena wrote: Hi,
lately I've been interested in bodyweight training, but there's one thing I'm concerned with. I have slight scoliosis (my left shoulder is lower) and the consequence is slightly bigger left/right pectoralis/shoulder. Most people, even after telling them, aren't noticing it. The thing that annoys me is while using compound exercises I get much better left pectoralis activation (especially in the upper part), while on the other side shoulder gets more activated. With isolation exercises, activation is more balanced (left side of the chest is still better activated), but I find basing chest training on mostly cables limiting and little boring ...
I'm afraid if I start doing bodyweight training (and currently really want to do it exclusively), imbalance might get even bigger. Last night I did some push-ups, and noticed that my right shoulder does part of the job (at the expense of upper part of right pectoral muscle), but both sides of the chest got nice pump. Of course, I'm not, and don't plan to be, huge ... just to be in shape. I'm entirely fine with current imbalance, just don't want to develop it even more.
I'd be grateful if someone has experienced something similar and has some pieces of advice. Plan is to stay away for some time from pike push-ups (and similar that emphasize shoulders), and do mostly for chest with adding extra dumbbell front raises for front portion of left shoulder and slightly incline press for right pectoralis (try to squeeze it, minimal right shoulder involvement) as correction. I might be completely wrong ...
Thanks!
Hi,
Don't worry too much about muscle symmetry, you can correct that in a couple weeks in a gym with isolation exercices (not sure about bodyweight exercices though since they are compound exercises... should be possible but it's more difficult). I've got no symmetry whatsoever in my chest (pecs, abs, ..., nothing's balanced) but with increased definition, development & a lil' bit of time, everything'll be straightened out. Besides, unless they're huge imbalances, noone'll notice. Like noone, seriously.
|
On March 29 2013 01:56 Adel wrote:+ Show Spoiler +On March 29 2013 01:16 Hyaena wrote:+ Show Spoiler + Hi,
lately I've been interested in bodyweight training, but there's one thing I'm concerned with. I have slight scoliosis (my left shoulder is lower) and the consequence is slightly bigger left/right pectoralis/shoulder. Most people, even after telling them, aren't noticing it. The thing that annoys me is while using compound exercises I get much better left pectoralis activation (especially in the upper part), while on the other side shoulder gets more activated. With isolation exercises, activation is more balanced (left side of the chest is still better activated), but I find basing chest training on mostly cables limiting and little boring ...
I'm afraid if I start doing bodyweight training (and currently really want to do it exclusively), imbalance might get even bigger. Last night I did some push-ups, and noticed that my right shoulder does part of the job (at the expense of upper part of right pectoral muscle), but both sides of the chest got nice pump. Of course, I'm not, and don't plan to be, huge ... just to be in shape. I'm entirely fine with current imbalance, just don't want to develop it even more.
I'd be grateful if someone has experienced something similar and has some pieces of advice. Plan is to stay away for some time from pike push-ups (and similar that emphasize shoulders), and do mostly for chest with adding extra dumbbell front raises for front portion of left shoulder and slightly incline press for right pectoralis (try to squeeze it, minimal right shoulder involvement) as correction. I might be completely wrong ...
Thanks!
Hi, Don't worry too much about muscle symmetry, you can correct that in a couple weeks in a gym with isolation exercices (not sure about bodyweight exercices though since they are compound exercises... should be possible but it's more difficult). I've got no symmetry whatsoever in my chest (pecs, abs, ..., nothing's balanced) but with increased definition, development & a lil' bit of time, everything'll be straightened out. Besides, unless they're huge imbalances, noone'll notice. Like noone, seriously. Thanks for the answer ... the thing is, for me, it goes much slower. Trained for several months using mostly cables for chest, and things started to look more balanced, but at the expense of weaker (and smaller) chest. Upper part of right pectoralis is problematic.
No one is perfectly symmetrical and that's not what I'm aiming at. Couldn't care less if I'm not entirely symmetrical as long as I get almost the same feel in each desired part of targeted muscle(s). Current visual difference isn't what worries me ... it's weaker activation (especially with compound exercises) of already smaller right pectoralis, and possible further visual (and potentionally functional) difference increase. That's why I'd like to know if someone's experienced something similar ... or I'm worrying too much, and should just do bodyweight training and observe how body responds. Hopefully, I won't end up stuck with isolation as only viable option for somewhat similar activation for both sides of pectoral muscles.
|
Isolation strength training for your right side should solve the activation problem. Like 3-5 reps bench press with a dumbell (well this is a compound exercise but still), or 3-5 reps on pec decks with only one arm. You can also do pushups with a wider grip and instead of lowering your body so that your nose touches the ground at the same distance from both hands, touch the ground closer to your right hand to shift your bodyweight there and lift up your right leg (bring your knee to the side). It's hard to explain, kinda similar to side to side push ups but with only one foot touching the ground.
|
Barbells/DBs are probably better for correcting imbalances, but generally if you keep good form with bodyweight then things should start to even out.
|
60 second skin the cat hang. Taking the progression slower. Next working towards 60s back lever tuck.
|
I'm sure this gets asked from time to time in the thread but I don't see anything related to it in the op.
What is a cost effective protein powder? I've seen such a range in prices and I can't base a decision off of the advertising and online reviews (which are often fake!). Can anyone here make an informed recommendation on which ones are most worth purchasing for cost effectiveness.
|
|
|
|