|
hm. imo Fantasy should be a little higher up going 2-1 vs Calm including a win in an ACE match should merit something higher than 9
Entries 4 , 5 , and 6 are in my opinion totally interchangable. Both Stork, Effort and ZeRo are playing great starcraft Stork : getting back in shape for a great OSL run ZeRO : playing light's out in PL Effort : being a beast in whatever he does
but imo ZeRO should be higher than both of them with his 9-1 record in PL he is the #1 reason that the Stars are as high as they are
|
On December 01 2009 06:03 Djabanete wrote: Whoa, WHOA, surely I'm not the only one shocked by Fantasy's placement? He
a) destroyed Hoejja, wasn't even close [W] b) lost to Flash in TvT, but who doesn't [L] c) beat Baby (didn't see that game) [W] d) embarrassed Calm in the OSL [W] e) lost a game to Calm in PL but didn't play badly at all [L] f) walked all over Calm again in a lategame TvZ with sick micro and good multitask [W]
Basically, all month I haven't seen him play a bad game; he's 2-2 against other PR players; 2-0 against non-PR players; his bio vs Z has never looked better; and you say he's slipping? I just don't understand where you're coming from.
(edit: yeah I'm not the only one, and I got ninja'd hard)
I agree that he should be higher than Calm, but I think that's the correct placement of fantasy. Like everyone is saying, Calm is slumping. Going 2-1 against someone slumping that bad is not an accomplishment, its something everyone expects someone on the power ranks to be able to do. The only time he's played against someone higher up in the rankings than he is was that game against Flash, which he lost. He hasn't shown the dominance to move up the rankings, while others have played much better. I think fantasy should be #9 and Calm either #10 or not on the PR at all.
|
I would like BeSt in #10 instead of Kwanro - great PR otherwise  3 kings at the top is always good
|
On December 01 2009 08:03 synapse wrote:I would like BeSt in #10 instead of Kwanro - great PR otherwise  3 kings at the top is always good isn't best out of both SL's? while his PL play is getting better there's a difference between a "good" PL player and a "good" SL player
Or else HyuN would be all over this
|
I wonder how long we'll have to wait before we get a BoX between Flash and Jaedong.
Only then will we know who truely deserves 1 and who is 2.
|
On December 01 2009 08:37 DreaM)XeRO wrote:Show nested quote +On December 01 2009 08:03 synapse wrote:I would like BeSt in #10 instead of Kwanro - great PR otherwise  3 kings at the top is always good isn't best out of both SL's? while his PL play is getting better there's a difference between a "good" PL player and a "good" SL player Or else HyuN would be all over this Best is into the RO16 of the MSL.
|
Good to see Sea here. You misspelt recent, resent. Awesome power rank. ;D
|
I am mixed about this PR. I like ZerO been higher or Sea entering but in my view, instead of making big jumps (like Bisu, Stork, fantasy, Kwanro) you should put here Violet, Really, Kal and Shine. (in this order).
The PR is kinda flawed even with Jaedong, with him making incredibly many mistakes, or with Calm, who is unrecognazible... And EffOrt is at the lower limit too.
|
Holy crap I just checked Flash's stats. He's a crazy little monster!
|
I've always felt great PL performances by players that aren't in any leagues are overrated.
Regardless of what the players might say, they want to advance in the individuals (especially since it's only R1 of proleague) and it's a LOT harder to prepare for both individuals and PL.
I think Sea's placement is about right but maybe even a little too high.
|
I want to see Flash vs Jaedong Bo5 so bad it hurts sometimes
|
fantasy dropped to hard imo.
|
ZerO should be #2 imo
|
On December 01 2009 08:38 On_Slaught wrote: I wonder how long we'll have to wait before we get a BoX between Flash and Jaedong.
Only then will we know who truely deserves 1 and who is 2.
I can't wait for this to happen... but check out the stats page if you are not sure who truly deserves spot 1 right now.
|
Flash seems to regularly get on these insane runs, where he just stomps everything in his path. The poor boy can't keep it up though, I hope for him he gets a title this season.
|
Canada9720 Posts
no mention of really for cbnc? he went 6-1 during november in PL, including sea's only loss
|
Surprised Really and Movie were not mentioned.
|
On December 01 2009 08:37 DreaM)XeRO wrote:Show nested quote +On December 01 2009 08:03 synapse wrote:I would like BeSt in #10 instead of Kwanro - great PR otherwise  3 kings at the top is always good isn't best out of both SL's? while his PL play is getting better there's a difference between a "good" PL player and a "good" SL player Or else HyuN would be all over this
BeSt 2-0d his MSL group with Calm, Light, and fOrGG.
BeSt looks invincible in PvT and pretty strong in PvP. He should be above Kwanro i think as well.
|
On December 01 2009 10:10 DoctorHelvetica wrote:Surprised Really and Movie were not mentioned.
Yeah I would have expected to see Movie on CBNC at least, until the last two days. I think someone doped him and Stork before the MSL matches...
|
I don't see the problem with dropping Calm off of the list even though he was number 3 last month. One time a number 1 was left off of the list in the next month's rank. 
'Course that wasn't the same guy doing the list...
|
|
|
|