EPT[M][N] I'm a cop you idiot! - Round 2
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
On September 29 2020 03:06 GlowingBear wrote: I don't believe you so ##Unvote ##Vote: Dadred No, I'm not the cop. This is bad and makes me think maybe mafia... | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
On September 29 2020 03:09 CopCake wrote: But where is the robotic long message for claiming? Don't really care for long posts atm, I'm confirmed town! Or in a 1 v 1 duel tomorrow. So exciting. | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
I've been in a lot of 1 v 1. And while this setup will drag out, will be good I hope. | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
Welp sorry guys. | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
So I guess I have to actually play hard now n0 and press people to get a final reads list out. | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
Gb could potentially be town as well for the reaction to my stupidity now. | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
This is obviously very off the cuff. Like the more I think about it the more I like Shockeyy and GB reaction to me. They paid attention and saw what was wrong. Also worth noting the tone of gb first post reads town, in the first pm gb probably rolled mafia and got town this time. It's legit read there | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
But just nothing to remove him yet. | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
I do also like his post on GB, he while not a great read I also like his tone and it seems he is trying to solve the game rather than sow discord. Like his interaction with Shockeyy and his "slip" is a reaction that town rayn would have to it. | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
On September 29 2020 05:22 raynpelikoneet wrote: What did GB see as "what was wrong" as his initial reaction to your claim? I take it he knew the setup instantly | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
On September 29 2020 05:31 raynpelikoneet wrote: What do you mean? My question is, at least at this point you didn't believe GB knew the correct setup and thought doc could act N0. Why is questioning the correct play for a cop (which is also in line with your last game claim) reasonable? At the time GB initial attack under my assumption (same setup) is scummy. It's the right play to claim when I did early no fanfare and look for a 1 v 1. With the knowledge that GB knew the setup and that's why he went for me, it's a bit towny that he would attack me for trying to bait the cop out if inwas scum in his perspective. However gb does hinder his cause by instantly not cop, if he truly believed I was scum he wouldn't say that as it would shrink the pool to shoot into for scum. | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
GB why did you say not cop when you didn't believe me | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
On September 29 2020 05:38 GlowingBear wrote: Sorry, I didn't understand your question. Did you ask why didn't I believe in your claim? If that's your question, it was basically gut feeling. Like "this post doesn't sound genuine". I basically do that every game to generate discussion while still being true to my intuition. I have no other reason to doubt your claim. No you said that you were not the cop. Why would you do that and shrink the pool to shoot into if you think I am scum. | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
On September 29 2020 05:41 raynpelikoneet wrote: this: are you saying you believe GB lied and how he is lying about he lied earlier and you stil lthink he is town???? No if I think he lied then I think he's leaning scum. I also think the way he handled the claim and saying he was not cop would not happen if he is town. It hurts town if he thinks I'm scum to make that statement | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
On September 29 2020 05:44 raynpelikoneet wrote: to clarify: if "With the knowledge that GB knew the setup and that's why he went for me" is true then GB lied about not knowing the setup and you think he is town for that?????? shockeyy came out with the "real setup", then GB lied about not knowing it (why, if he is town? -- he can just say "yeah fuck you shockeyy i was trying to bait or whatever") if not that then what???? I feel like I just answered this. I think that if GB is lying about not knowing the setup he is probably mafia for his reaction to the claim. But that's all dependent on if I think GB forgot the setup or lied | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
I am literally saying GB saying, I am not cop is the worst play to do if he is town. It does not make sense to do coming from a town perspective if he knows the setup. I have been very clear I feel in my posts. | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
On September 29 2020 06:03 raynpelikoneet wrote: Okay Damdred, let's get this thing settled. Let's assume GB is telling the truth at all times he has been posting. Why is he town in your opinion (you said he could be -- let's not get into semantics), what are the things that make him town? I am going to say this plainly, my initial thought process on GB went like this. GB suspects me being scum for being cop->I think this is mafia indicative behavior trying to downplay me for partner to claim-> Oh wait, GB knew the setup and there are two possibilities GB either thinks I am mafia trying to get a cop outed, or thinks i'm an idiot. Seemed it was option one-> This line of thought is town indicative at least on surface level. What actually happened GB suspects me for just claiming cop and does not know the settup and instantly says that GB is not the cop (this might be where the disconnect comes from). This is not a towny play, if he is town he should never identify himself as not a role in this scenario if he does not believe the initial claim as that condenses the pool to shoot into. Just laying cards on the table, I am more neutral on GB. I don't think GB has any reason to lie about not knowing the setup, but I think there are some things I don't like about the actual scenario that played out. But I also don't like how you keep saying i'm townreading GB when i've been saying for the past 5 posts that his play doesn't make sense from town with the new information. | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
Are you scum reading copcake or what exactly is your aim with this questioning | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
That's good to know then. So second scum can't be GB then, the fight back and forth felt to real. Ruxxar is town to I think. Shockeyy still feel is town Cop is more than likely town, though with the knowledge that Rayn is scum the heat cop out on GB feels strange. But, the attitude cop had towards rayn in the question kinda points to town still. So kinda has to be Rayn/mendal | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
Rayns play doesn't make sense to cc me partway through the day. I really don't want to turn the thread into me v rayn today though, I was kinda looking forward to dying meh. In any case, I think the game is easy now Rayn and Mend. But kinda seems a bit easy. | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
I don't want to spend the rest of my night getting frustrated arguing with rayn and him spamming faces when I could spend time reading to my girl and catching up when I'm done. I think that's fair. | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
Monadel posts have been pretty good coming out of no where, like his tone. His direction and how he is looking at things. Cop fell a little bit in the exchanges for me so far | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
Shock GB Ruxx Cop Monadel Rayn | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
On September 30 2020 03:14 CopCake wrote: Can I know why Monadel is mafia-ish in your list? It's just POE . I like his posts | ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
|
Dadred
249 Posts
| ||
| ||
