A normal game just for JAT <3

On April 16 2016 14:31 rsoultin wrote:


i'm expected to be superwoman it's okay...i'm coming to terms with it and am trying to take it as a compliment rather than get frustrated at it lol >< you seeing anything i'm not?

On April 17 2016 04:50 rsoultin wrote:


actually what that should say is his case is wrong but his read could be right

On April 17 2016 05:09 gumshoe wrote:


It might just be a case of there not being a better case / :

we have 3 shitters (onegu, fazzer, sicklicker,) who are basically all coinflips

3 reasonably townie townies(im fairly confident that you and jat are town, judging by your dialogue with one another early on, I also have a good feel about jas based off him attacking tumble early and he seems to pretty involved by this games standards.)

3 players who are kinda meh (gb, rsoul(the whole circumstance of her train is painfully weak) obi(bit less certain bout him then I was of him early as his stuff is pretty shallow right now)

this leaves 3 potential agreed scum prospects, palmer (notable for the gap between his reputation and his actual contribution) tumble (shoddy for the late entry, the fazzer thing, his mild rsoul push and his wierd jas hand toss) and super.

Super obviusly cant attack himself and he probs hasnt noticed tumble which leaves palmer.

So if his case and reasoning is weak, it might just be a result of the game being slow as opposed to him bieng scum trying to come up with contrivances.

On April 17 2016 06:38 Superbia wrote:


... Wow this is actually calling me TMI town.

On April 17 2016 06:49 rsoultin wrote:
i think the only one i'd be fine with shennanigans on is gb at this point. i can't see how tw does this as town though, i really can't -_-

On April 17 2016 07:14 Fazers wrote:

SECONDED.

On April 18 2016 06:08 gumshoe wrote:


I 100 percent disagree with super being scum with tumble. Had they both been scum it would have likely been more of an outright bus / : Think about it, if super was bussing tumble, why would he claim? Then tumble dies and hes put in the spotlight and likely dies after if he cant substantiate his blue claim.

This all happened before the gb debacle, (which was total luck if tumble outside of any plan). It is a terrible terrible move, would've been far better to just let things take their course and have the living scummer take cred.

Seriously, super may be scum, but he is 100 percent not scum with tumble because of the heat that claim brings down on him.

On April 18 2016 18:40 sicklucker wrote:
riveting activity guys! I love when im the only one posting for the first 36 hours of the day but im the bad guy when shit comes up for the last 12

On April 19 2016 01:14 gumshoe wrote:


well see / : if super doesnt flip rb, your double scum day 1 lynch theory falls apart : P

On April 19 2016 01:25 rsoultin wrote:


oh poo i'm probably wrong :/ ows was on super so that makes it less likely. oh well. i'm way ahead of myself as it is lol

On April 19 2016 02:41 Tumblewood wrote:
OWS what is the point of these emoticons
"oh no he felt angry face he must be town"

On April 17 2016 06:15 Tumblewood wrote:
jat is a tw approved townie
rels, jas, and gumshoe are not but are not scumreads either

On April 17 2016 06:51 Tumblewood wrote:

jat is town
jas is ??? but should be more apparent after he says who he is; giving him BotD
superbia is maybe scum (i have no good reasons on this one)
palmar is null because he's not really out of his comfort zone
i want to call rels and gumshoe scummy but that's mostly omgus
sl is a 49 out of 100 on the mafia scale for being inactive and saaying one slightly scummy thing
gb is a 50 out of 100 on the mafia scale for being inactive and saying nothing
onegu is a 51 out of 100 on the mafia scale for being inactive and saying nothing of value
ows is town because i like how he continued to townread me
fazers is scummy but also new so maybe just a scrub

tbh my reads are all based on spidey senses right now

On April 19 2016 11:38 gumshoe wrote:
you guys are so insynch its amazing,

1 hour ago I posted my initial question

17 minutes later you respond at almost the exact same time after not bieng in thread for hours

then I gloat a bit (at about 23 minutes ago) and then 19 minutes later you respond again within a minute of one another XD this is just the greatest feeling right now T_T I may never feel this cathartic again.

On April 19 2016 11:47 gumshoe wrote:



you said it : D not me

On April 19 2016 13:17 rsoultin wrote:


nah lol i was tinfoiling hard. i'm not sure what you are but if you're mafia it's not for insisting we shouldn't lynch super i was being kinda retarded there

i still don't think i've seen much brilliance from you. i actually am accustomed to seeing it from a town ows even if other people might say differently

On April 19 2016 11:37 Tumblewood wrote:

I'll start with you because you asked

Jashape: I wouldn't rule him out but no reason to think he's scum yet. Really hasn't done very much to give me an opinion on him.

JAT: Scum because he's so focused on the two people that he's invariably going to lynch anyway.

SL: He's cocky in the right way, and his curiosity about the vig seems genuine.

Onegu: Since I can't content read someone with so little content, spidey senses say town.

Gumshoe: If he were evaluating how his posts looked about half of what he has would never see the light of day. Since he's not, town.

Superbia: scum

Rsoul: scum

OWS: Town unless I'm being pocketed hard. Would like him to explain why he thinks I'm town.

Rels: His D1 was about how mine would have gone if I were in his situation (and town). You think someone really messed up and is clear scum, you make sure they die no matter what. Inactivity concerns me a little but I'll give him time. Slight townread.

On April 20 2016 00:21 justanothertownie wrote:

You could push someone else instead of keeping it up if you really believe this. What a dumb post.

On April 18 2016 04:25 rsoultin wrote:


why?

On April 18 2016 05:23 rsoultin wrote:


okay, so honestly, you're just really confusing me here. like you're not making sense and my first instinct is that should be scum but i think even scum would make more sense here, so i must just not be understanding @.@

it's as simple as...the wagons are between super and myself. if i want to live i need to vote super

then

the wagons are between gb, super and myself. if i want to live i need to vote one of them

why would your scumread flipping town be worse than your null read flipping town?

On April 18 2016 05:25 Superbia wrote:
If I'm the vigi I'm shooting Palmar.

If I'm the doctor I'm saving Gumshoe.


Yolo.

On April 25 2016 00:21 justanothertownie wrote:

Yes, now I am.

On April 25 2016 00:53 justanothertownie wrote:

Working on it. So far nope. But you should still put in a little effort - you are the laziest confirmed town since coag.
:p

On April 25 2016 01:03 justanothertownie wrote:

Then look for mafia nr 2.

On April 25 2016 01:09 justanothertownie wrote:
I am still wondering what the day1 stuff means. Was mafia just praying we would start something so save super once he fakeclaimed? Because only town did anything about it.
Maybe gumshoe was right about the tumble thing.

What do you make of it?

On April 25 2016 11:58 Tumblewood wrote:
I think a scumteam without Onegu can't exist because otherwise whoever is scum would just coast through this. It's not like Rels or JAT or SL would get punished for being AFK, because Onegu is even more AFK.
Still think SL is town, but the shouting match with Rels has me a little worried. I don't want to go into the final four with my townread on SL requiring me to overlook his flaws. In a TvS shouting match, town doesn't always come out of it looking as solid as before... agh still makes me uneasy though.

On April 25 2016 12:21 Tumblewood wrote:

I am saying two things here:
- A scum team doesn't exist without Onegu.
- I still think SL is town, but the recent shouting match between him and Rels makes me less comfortable about it.

On April 25 2016 23:42 Onegu wrote:



How is this even remotely true. I found scum tumble. We should have lynched him yesterday. Fine I will look into who is the final scum between Rels and SL and actually give you a case.

On April 26 2016 00:04 Onegu wrote:
JAT and obi if you really dont see this than that is on you.

On April 26 2016 01:24 justanothertownie wrote:
Onegus day1 vote looks bad.
day2 is irrelevant.
day3 is unknown but I don't think it makes him town regardless of tumbles alignment.

Nightkills:
Idk if Palmar had any opinion on Onegu. Probably not.
Rsoultin scumread him.
Gumshoe scumread him hardcore.

On April 26 2016 01:54 justanothertownie wrote:

I don't think his rb was getting lynched when he voted, right?

On April 25 2016 20:59 Rels wrote:
Now that I think of it, every killed town had one hard scumread in mind.
Palmar => Superbia
rsoul => Tumble
gumshoe => Onegu
The NKs are solving the game for us. Yeah I know gumshoe scumread me quite a lot too, but Onegu was his main target.

On April 25 2016 21:16 Rels wrote:
Gotta stop for now but I've seen enough to make up my mind unless something drastic happens.
JAT is town because he's super townie and he has been town spewed by both Superbia & Onegu, assuming Onegu flips scum.

SL is town because he attacked both Onegu and Superbia D1, so unless Onegu is not scum it's unlikely he's partners with us both. He voted Superbia D1 and AFKd his vote on him. He was AFK during portions of the game but when he played he had this style of posting quick successions of posts that he has a hard time replicating as scum. He's implicated to solving the game when he usually doesn't care enough to play a lot as scum.

Onegu is scum because he's super useless. He scumread Superbia and said he would sheep Palmar D1 while ultimately wasting his vote. He never commited to a read on rsoul who he usually is super wary off but wasted his time joking with her instead. He's hiding his reads behind "mechanical" stuff like "Superbia is scum because scumslip" or "Tumble is scum because Rels & SL are not partners" in order to not commit to actually scumreading his partner. Superbia townreads him when he had no reason to and when Onegu is an easy mislynch to push. He scumreads me but he has no reason to scumread me apart from "coping out", whatever that means.

Tumble is scum because when pressured to explain something, he invented a reason that was proven to be bullshit. He scumread Superbia for being AFK but attacked rsoul because she scumreads Superbia for the same reason. He scumread Superbia but didn't vote him EOD1 to save his life, he voted GB instead who he was null on. Superbia only fakeclaimed when it was clear GB was the second wagon, he didn't when Tumble was the second wagon. He was OK lynching rsoul D1 after Palmar and JAT both seem to be OK with it. He scumreads me but he doesn't have any reason to scumread me apart from "he only pushes my lynch when it's useful for scum to do it", when I have pushed him over Shape who was town so it doesn't make sense.

In addition, the three NKs points at this conclusion, it looks like they all chose a target each night: N1 Superbia, N2 Tumble, N3 Onegu.

On April 26 2016 05:40 justanothertownie wrote:
Obi, you still there? Or is all of this pointless anyways?