[M][N]Holy Guardians Chapter 1 - Page 36

On June 04 2015 16:30 scott31337 wrote:
Milo -


This looks like a "I solved the game" post which can come from either alignment, although unsure how serious he is. I saw Shining do this and got scummed for it hard when he was town though.

Unless this is a smurf, I do not see this read coming so early by his posts.


Showing anger and emotion - Mafia 101?


He doesn't quote the interesting Fidei's post but he quotes every other post from his filter above and below this. hmmm

This looks like a really wishy washy reply about Milo- And i'm not town-reading Tictock yet.

I had Milo townread yesterday by his defense to the pressure though.

Still worries me no one defending GG much.

Going to sleep now I think.

On June 05 2015 01:16 Damdred wrote:
Its pretty annoying half of the people keep throwing my name out for lynch but won't actually push me or try to lynch me.

So lets go if you think I'm scum male a case push me instead of half pushing

On June 03 2015 08:05 Damdred wrote:
Firstly I don't think I have a town read on Milo, he's still null for me at this point but he is on the upper level of null.

I kinda going to put kick towards the bottom of null here.
.

On June 04 2015 01:39 Damdred wrote:
Actually there is a very large difference to you making a bad point that I'm not responding to you whip I'm not here or you are still posting. To me saying you ignored my post since it was three hours after my initial post and you decided to interact with another post on a superficial level and now you are only making a show because you got called out.

On June 04 2015 05:25 Damdred wrote:
So basically almost 24 hours in game you only have a strong opinion that 2 people are town one lean and the rest is null. Meh that post just irks me, it says a lot without actually doing much bah.

On June 04 2015 10:27 Damdred wrote:

I'm leaving of fi now because his post was...interesting.

On June 04 2015 10:27 Damdred wrote:
kick
templars
chocolate

On June 03 2015 18:32 GGTeMpLaR wrote:


I also find your suspicion of milo to be very townie. I disagree with the read, but respect where it is coming from and think you are town for it.

On June 03 2015 06:24 Tictock wrote:
@ ritoky

Ok, I'll bite

##Vote ritoky

For spamming graphics and one liners. Not even trying to push people yet, such scum.

On June 04 2015 15:04 ritoky wrote:


The only warning sign for me was his last post where he put milo and fid in town and dropped me out of it and didn't explain why any of that really occurred. Outside of that I don't see why people are "disappointed in him" or find anything he has done particularly scummy.

On June 04 2015 15:30 Kickstart wrote:
The post you just quoted was the one all of us found most suspicious, I pointed out how he just put random people in his town list without ever mentioning them before, check his filter. Also note how he just calls this and that person town based on what seems to be very little. All of that is odd to me and why my vote is on him atm, not sure how I feel about the votes stacking up on him though, makes me uneasy that people see him as an easy target, will see how it develops.

On June 04 2015 17:37 Tictock wrote:
@ scott

My read on you had changed even before you posted your little quote + picture thing. Your a weak town lean for me atm.

My initial read on you was actually kinda null. I mentioned you might be scum since I was noticing a similarity in your posts this game to last game where you were mafia. The whole thing was a pretty weak meta read tbh. In fact having reviewed some of the post game stuff from NSM X I see that you went inactive that game due to internet issues, not anything to do with alignment.

Given that, I do need to give you a fresh read, so here I go.

First I notice you've mentioned this a couple times...

I kinda like your thought process here. Your saying that since nobody is even trying to defend him it suggests to you that he is Town yes?

I see one flaw in that thinking and would like to use last game as evidence. Whats to stop scum from bussing their partner? That's what your team did last game when you fell under suspicion and were not around to defend yourself.

Besides, there is one person who has been pretty outspoken about defending GG, and you just spent the last page interacting with him. Not sure how you missed ritoky saying this...

The bolded part is just me picking at Nits again. I find it odd that ritoky throws in a subtle "I'm town" in the middle of his read on GG. Still his overall points aren't too bad, and even has me rethinking my own position a little.

I'd still like to hear from GG himself though. It really does bug me that he'd scum me early on then ignore my reactions to it. Him asking me to restate my response didn't help, kus it also tells me that he isn't willing to do his own reading + Show Spoiler +

This has me questioning just how much you yourself are paying attn to this game. I'm not going to scum you for not having 100% perfect reading retention or comprehension though.

Actually the whole interaction I saw between you and ritoky looked pretty good. This question to Kick was great,

That tells me that even though you're scumming GG you are looking beyond him as well. That is great town thinking imo, scum would just focus w/e target they pick and try to get others to do the same no?

I also like how you pointed out that my "read" on milo there was kinda bad. I don't really like the term "wishy washy" I think it's one of those political terms that attacks indecisiveness, but w/e you have a point. I was giving milo some benefit of the doubt for being new here and was mostly saying I need to see more from him to get a solid read.

Thus far I'm not super impressed with him. He's a slight scum lean to me. I poked him a little when I was interacting with ritoky to see what he would do. Mostly I saw him deflecting and not wanting to get pulled into the discussion there. I did find it interesting how me mentions that he doesn't agree with GG being a good lynch.

Actually...
@milo
Care to expand on your thoughts on GG?

On June 05 2015 01:41 Damdred wrote:
not sure why me not wanting to lynch fi because you said it before makes me scum?

On June 05 2015 01:41 Damdred wrote:
The point is that kick was giving everyone hard times about giving reads and not doing so himself and when pressed didn't even answer the questions applied to him. So how does this make me scum?

On June 05 2015 01:41 Damdred wrote:
None of this makes me scum a majority of it makes me town and you neither state why it males me scum or any conclusion you bring yourself on the matter.