EPTYou can't call me scum because I haven't been leading the game all game if you don't implicate everyone who has been fooled/indecisive all game as well.
[T] Cell (Mini?) Mafia III - Page 12
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
You can't call me scum because I haven't been leading the game all game if you don't implicate everyone who has been fooled/indecisive all game as well. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
| ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
I want to say town because the latter half of the game including now is analysis I would expect to from you but so much of the shit you've brought has been so terrible Oh and speaking of which that's more analysis you ignored and original thought in regards to your horrible meta reads and out of game tells all game that look awful. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
On September 05 2014 08:45 Holyflare wrote: I gtg to bed now which is annoying because whichever one of you twat faces is mafia will start pushing me like crazy when i am asleep. Just know that I'm town and will always be town and couldn't have made the fucking trap in the first place unless i was town so whoever is town shape up and vote the other one. I was just about to post about this. This is either the scum midst thing you've said thus far or the Townes. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
| ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
On September 05 2014 08:48 Holyflare wrote: Well the majority of this game has been spent in hospital with my gf's sister on my phone, I was at home for the past 3 days but now I'm out again. Hence why i did analysis when i could. Not that I think you're lying but bad meta analysis is still analysis. I don't see what the quality of your play has to do with that because if you could have done half the thing you did earlier in the game you could have done the good things as well. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
And just because it's right doesn't make it good. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
And if all your meta analysis is right and you're scum reading me now then something has to give. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
Because either scenario seems likely to me, though I liked MM1s recent analysis more. On that note if he's scum with TMI pointing out towny things I've done, why are you seemingly disagreeing with him? My phones gonna die Be back in 2h ish | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
On September 05 2014 08:59 Holyflare wrote: Because it was inconsistent with all his other games so it was correct and it gave me some info towards people that were defending him before he even posted that excuse It's not correct unless he flips scum. It can't be correct 'at the time' | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
On September 05 2014 09:01 Holyflare wrote: I'm not scum reading you by meta????? I'm saying you haven't pushed any proper original thought What? I never said you were | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
| ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
| ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
On September 05 2014 08:45 Holyflare wrote: I gtg to bed now which is annoying because whichever one of you twat faces is mafia will start pushing me like crazy when i am asleep. Just know that I'm town and will always be town and couldn't have made the fucking trap in the first place unless i was town so whoever is town shape up and vote the other one. I hate this post so very much. Like obviously you must see how fucking scummy it is to try and pre-emptively dissuade anyone from getting a read on you or find you scummy. The biggest problem overall is you either just showcased massive mafia mindset, or you're simply telling the truth with the bolded. While it is overwhelmingly likely that town is the one to make a trap like this (however dumb it is), the fact remains that you knew what you were doing when you set the trap, as you specifically set it for me and tongue-in-cheekily added that smiley. (Never mind the fact that you try to downplay your early scumread on me by calling it a joke which I honestly don't believe as I've already said---way too much reference and thoughts brought up about it but I digress slightly) The point is you know very well what I think about traps from the last game and you know how people read you for setting the trap in the first place. The fact that it was almost one of the first things you did in the game rather than an afterthought later on or just something you came up with randomly makes me believe that it could have been a plan from the start. Surely nobody who sets a trap, as bad as it is, could be mafia? What purpose could scum ever have from pulling that sort of thing? Well, WIFOM but exactly that. The fact that you also consider the fact that Artanis would give out the role PM to the scumteam may also belie prior knowledge of this actually happening. (but then again a good scummer would never bring this up in thread for precisely that reason...ugh) Under normal circumstances I would be keeping it simple (stupid) and assuming you're town for the trap but you're also fucking HF and I've assumed the most likely scenario on you and been burned by it before. I'd like to know what outside parties have to say about this in terms of likelihood as playing a shit ton of games with HF could be clouding my judgment. On August 30 2014 05:19 Holyflare wrote: Poat your new tenancy agreement too Ugh shit like this now that I have the 'prior knowedge' thing in my head---if BH was scum then it makes a lot of sense that HF would ask for all of the things that BH could obviously provide to make the both of them look better. On August 31 2014 02:46 Holyflare wrote: Where has bunnies been analytical in the slightest??? Also if you are town and are voting for yourself i won't hesitate to follow you up for a ban But then this---it's kind of shitty but there's a line that has to be drawn somewhere and I truly don't see scum writing this. Like....there's playing with fire for towncred and then there's actively preventing the mislynch you want from occurring even while it happens. On September 03 2014 09:57 Holyflare wrote: lots of super scum reads on bunnies, so many scum reads! Wagon atm: Bunnies .....vote now on: bunnies ^^^^ toad case THAT ALSO RELATES TO LILWADE WTF WADE ALSO VOTES BH OVER BSNACKS so bs reason to switch. Current wagon at time: bunnies with sentiment to wade ..... current vote: bunnies current wagon: just onto lilwade now current wagon: lilwade.... current vote: now conveniently lilwade so he spends all this time on bunnies but then the wagon switches to town lilwade and all his scum reads totally fall out of the window and his reason to switch is apathy's convincing case which applied to wade too, then WITH 5 MINUTES TO GO SWITCHES BACK TO BUNNIES????????? Not only that but in the post that I keep referring to as the slip he says "i'm wary because mafia are voting their partner" when 3 people in our cell were voting bunnies. The wagon was on bunnies at this time and lilwade hadn't flipped town yet so there is absolutely NO way that anyone knows if mafia are voting for their partner or for a towny. He should have been EVEN MORE WARY when the wagon speedy went to unanimous wade but he WAS NOT AT ALL. He also tries to justify his calling bunnies mafia before wade even flipped town here: On September 03 2014 07:55 MysteryMeat1 wrote: are you actually a dumbass HF? If all people from the cell vote for bunnies, or course one mafia is voting on their partner. The fact is bunnies was probably mafia, as no one voted for apathy. Either we just got rolled or bunnies was mafia. Same thing with ritoky. You also did the same thing iirc, you voted on your partner and then used some dumb excuse to switch your vote to a town When you piece together the above with: If you see someone trying to question the hell out of your scum read then why would this be questionable at all??? If he has a town read on wave, like I did, then who else does he think I would be calling scum in our group? Some magical non-being? Either way, wade flips town, mm1 doesn't even rethink over this read at all but instead says "hm that guy who tried to bury probable MAFIA must also be MAFIA with her". No. Who does that?! Instead, out of the blue it's: kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk also, sarcastic comments about how this day is productive but then afking, + other tidbits which i cba to talk about And this monstrosity---actually. As an aside there's a couple things about MM1 I actually note in here. Mm1 is very focused on who is voting for whom as though that should clear people or nail them to the wall on their own, including the post where he listed all the towny things about me (which HF lovingly ignores). The ONE reason MM1 thinks I could be scum despite all the apparently scummy things HF has brought up about me recently is because my votes were off, when he is currently scumreading HF for something similar. On September 05 2014 08:08 MysteryMeat1 wrote: Honestly the longer the bickering went on between me and HF and the fact that you haven't jumped on to a clear side is what gives you the most town points soo far. If you were scum, i think you would be content with letting this go on considering its been a couple of days in real time that me and HF have been at each others throats trying to get the other person lynched. Its pretty much the same reason i was giving professor apathy points for earlier when his cell was up for voting. Also the fact that you want both of us to read you, in my mind is very pro town. During the first cell voting phase you also switched your vote not in an effort to bandwagon but to pressure people into talking more. Even during the second cell that was up for lynch, you weren't afraid to switch your vote around to get people to talk more. The only problem that i have with you is that all your votes ended up on town. There were certain times in the thread that i remember agreeing with you. Bunnies actually scumreads me cause i move my vote off of her to someone that she later votes on. When even till now, people still think apathy was town. In another one of her posts she pretty much claims that his makes me scummier than HF who also is voting on BS. Really though the main problem i have is that you ended up placing your vote on town, even though all three of us basically did it in the end. Not counting your mom lynch since everyone pretty much just plynched him. Those bolded parts. Why am I not then obvious town to you like amiko who did the same thing if the rest of my game has been so great? And what does the section in between the bolded have to do with anything? I suppose I see what HF talks about earlier when On the one hand it reminds me of the townplay of KSC last game where many of his reads were based on whether his target's other reads were congruent, but this doesn't even go that far. This is simply looking at votes without the analysis. Like I had forgotten about that HF scumread for voting a scum partner when other people are cleared for it in MM1's eyes. (and I still don't think it's a slip) It's lazy and scummy. I'm going to have to make a decision either way because I can't be sure I'll be able to post much tomorrow and while the idea of HFscum will forever be nagging at me, I can't let the noob card be the only reason that MM1 is town. There were way too many moments throughout the game that yelled MM1 scum to my face to ignore, On August 28 2014 21:51 WaveofShadow wrote: So I guess our group is solved huh Lol mm1kinda reminds me of when I try to push my town meta as scum On September 03 2014 08:54 WaveofShadow wrote: Sounds exciting and hilarious, but we have to actually get there. I'm so fucking nervous about this YM lynch because everybody is on it and it feels like a coinflip in either direction. lol HF you just got fucking told The only issue I have with HF scum right now is if he is, for him to have been fairly conclusively caught by MM1 and everyone else waffling all over the place is unlikely (no offense). HF is one of if not THE best scum on TL right now, and he's not Hapa to get caught by shitlogic/shitcases. His play is still wrong but I have no clue why. As for you, MM1, how come the bolded logic doesn't apply to me or to the bunch of other people who started out voting bunnies/BH and then switched to the alternatives? Looks more like you've already decided HF is scum and are applying tidbits you find posthumously. I also have a problem with this; despite how well you presume to know bunnies, the bolded is not necessarily enough. If people would always be simply happy to be sheeped by everyone else you would lose way more often than you'd win. Ugh I almost hope we lose today because I'm fucking shit at LYLO. Amiko I'm counting on you if we get there. lolol I forgot about my own post i made earlier which reinforces my points I ignored those moments with other people earlier on and paid for it (especially with bunnies). This cell has been way too fucking difficult and I can't keep my head straight about it. I think with HF I am more willing to believe he picked up on a few scummy things earlier and only later tried to put effort into doing stuff (since it does fit with his overall play this game) about it rather than MM1's POV which is that HF has been shit-flinging at him all game simply to try and get him lynched. I will try to continue reading tomorrow and hopefully be able to answer the odd question here and there. ##Vote: mysterymeat1 | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
Actually I liked this post. What is bad about it? | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
| ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
On September 05 2014 12:43 MysteryMeat1 wrote: Also if you want some more meta analysis, go read the games where i get mislynched d1, and i'm playing the exact same way, cause your about to mislynch a town and throw the game. Except this is the exact problem I talked about earlier. A newbie game is the absolute EASIEST meta to replicate as scum, and self-reference to meta for the most part doesn't mean shit because all it means is you're aware of how you play, thus able to change it as you see fit. Your entire long post doesn't do anything to disprove HF's points, all it serves to do is throw shit back at him (by literally calling him shitflare lol) which, considering how seemingly pissed off you are at him doing that, you think you wouldn't do. How is HF's posting not benefiting the town exactly? | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
| ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
| ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
It's in my filter. There are simply more reasons for you to be scum than town, and the opposite for HF | ||
| ||
