They shot someone who got healed/bh got rb'd again. It looks so bad for bh AGAIN and onegu is literally forced to reveal today because of thread pressure that the only thing he can do is scum preservation and the balls to the wall play of linking him and Bh together. There is nothing else they can do at this point

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

October 28 2013 17:34 GMT

#4702

So who should we lynch tomorrow?

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

October 28 2013 17:39 GMT

#4703

Bh/onegu either is fine. I'm inclined to think nobody framed the check if there is a framer at this point and so onegu would probably be my first choice. If and when he flips scum he has pretty much tied himself to BH so that's an easy 2 scum kills. The last memver if it's hopeless or whatever can be found by scum hunting/looking at ties.

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

October 28 2013 17:41 GMT

#4704

Why is either fine if your theory is that Onegu was forced to claim to save BH, who Onegu is by the way also bussing then.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

October 28 2013 17:47 GMT

#4705

On October 29 2013 02:41 syllogism wrote:
Why is either fine if your theory is that Onegu was forced to claim to save BH, who Onegu is by the way also bussing then.

On October 23 2013 02:03 Onegu wrote:

Show nested quote +

Check my meta sn0 I like to bus as scum, please dont let this be the only reason you give me a town read. I am going to catch more scum though!!!

No need to mention that either? I am so sure that this isn't town BH that I'm comfortable lynching him first it really doesn't matter what order it's in if i think both are scum does it?

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

October 28 2013 17:49 GMT

#4706

Well your theory is that he was forced to claim to save BH and he isn't even trying to save him and frankly if it's a fake claim, it seems very unlikely that mafia thought that would save BH, assuming he is mafia.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

October 28 2013 17:56 GMT

#4707

On October 29 2013 02:49 syllogism wrote:
Well your theory is that he was forced to claim to save BH and he isn't even trying to save him and frankly if it's a fake claim, it seems very unlikely that mafia thought that would save BH, assuming he is mafia.

What's your theory then oh great one.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

October 28 2013 17:58 GMT

#4708

It's great you're all focusing on his claim and nothing about his filter though, just what he wanted.

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

October 28 2013 17:58 GMT

#4709

My theory is that onegu seems like a bad lynch tomorrow compared to some alternatives. I wasn't trying to trash your theory, but trying to understand where you were coming from and whether it made sense for you to be pushing Onegu lynch this much over BH when much of what you were saying relied on BH being mafia.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

October 28 2013 18:00 GMT

#4710

Not a chance anyone shot onegu, even more so with lumos on you. There is no alternative.

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

October 28 2013 18:03 GMT

#4711

Mafia is really stupid if they sent BH to perform the kill twice in a row and Hopeless doesn't seem like a much better shot and was much more likely to draw sn0's protection than Onegu. Onegu was also going to claim tonight and for all they knew it was going to be a really towny role. Yes, it can be a fake claim and we should look into his play, but I don't you can say the shot doesn't make sense.

Sn0_Man

Tebellong44238 Posts

October 28 2013 18:08 GMT

#4712

You know, having medic plus vet plus medic plus mocsta claims to have a "hide" plus "hide" potion ALL ON TOWN seems pretty illegit.

Onegu

United States9699 Posts

October 28 2013 18:11 GMT

#4713

On October 29 2013 03:08 Sn0_Man wrote:
You know, having medic plus vet plus medic plus mocsta claims to have a "hide" plus "hide" potion ALL ON TOWN seems pretty illegit.

To be honest so does town haveing 5 JoaT. Jat, mocsta, syllo, hopeless, and storrzerg.

Sn0_Man

Tebellong44238 Posts

October 28 2013 18:12 GMT

#4714

hopeless is no jack.

Onegu

United States9699 Posts

October 28 2013 18:13 GMT

#4715

His potions can do multiple things, that seems like a jack to me.

Sn0_Man

Tebellong44238 Posts

October 28 2013 18:18 GMT

#4716

U sound like scum trying to justify ur loss or something.

Onegu

United States9699 Posts

October 28 2013 18:19 GMT

#4717

On October 29 2013 03:18 Sn0_Man wrote:
U sound like scum trying to justify ur loss or something.

Huh? How is what I said any different than what you said?

justanothertownie

16342 Posts

October 28 2013 18:21 GMT

#4718

On October 29 2013 03:12 Sn0_Man wrote:
hopeless is no jack.

Me neither. I just got lucky.

Hopeless1der

United States5836 Posts

October 28 2013 18:21 GMT

#4719

On October 29 2013 03:12 Sn0_Man wrote:
hopeless is no jack.

am i a jill then?

raynpelikonoshi

Cayman Islands1087 Posts

October 28 2013 18:47 GMT

#4720

A while ago i finshed reading Grackaroni's filter. Since other people i consider town are filtering other suspects i decided to do Grack first. This is what i find important:
(1) Grack has a lot of scumreads. Nothing but Skanjabs last for like a half of a page in his filter (besides his townread on BH - for what?).
(2) He does never really try to push a lynch on Skanjabs. Not on D2, when he makes the case, not on D3 when he thought Cephiro was town. There is always a better alternative in the end, despite Skanjabs remaining as his scumread for the whole game since he made the case.
(3) He asks people a lot about Skanjabs, but never follows these questions up. In addition to that, he does never really interact with Skanjabs in any way - trying to find out who he is scum with, or making him say something that could enforce his case.
(4) In fact, his interactions with other people do not seem like he is really trying to scumhunt. Half of his filter is pure trolling and other half is calling Skanjabs scum while never pushing his lynch like a townie should push his scumread (taking account his interactions with other people regarding Skan).
(5) None of the people that i think have a chance of flipping scum in this game do not consider Grackaroni as scum. Why is that? He is one of the people whose role is not confirmed nor does it point heavily towards him being town. He is a possible mislynch for scum, in case he is town. Why is there zero scum at least putting up some suspicion on him? Given what he has done this game i find that really fishy.