|
Sanya12364 Posts
On July 29 2013 02:42 FirmTofu wrote:
If anyone has any questions for me at all, please ask. I'll be completely honest. I don't think Vivax would push cDg so heavily if he was scum. There were clear reasons to think cDg was scum and I echoed his sentiment. I totally got what Vivax was trying to say from a town perspective. Austin has also looked town to me this entire game.
Just my 2cents. I know they don't matter much anymore. Looks like I'm a naive cop and 5T is paranoid. That's a bit odd.
So convenient, now that you turnout naive cop. So convenient. Of your totally bullshit anti-town plan.
You're not DT. You're scum.
LOL @backtrack from last night.
|
On July 29 2013 02:50 TanGeng wrote:
@VE & Marv
Onegu was totally looking for a veteran to sheep and I'm looking at you.
After yesterday's mess, I'll be available if you ever want to hear and breakdown my case against FirmTofu & austinmcc/Vivax.
If you think I've got my read right, then you can make one last appeal and lead these townies to victory.
I was looking for the vet who has shared my same reads for the entire game to talk with so we could figure this game out.
@5T my scumteam is Jrkirby and either austin/vivax or JJD let me know what you think when you catch up.
|
@firmtofu you believe jrkirby is scum yet, look at his actions last night they look really bad add into his previous bad filter and he is scum.
|
On July 29 2013 02:50 TanGeng wrote:
@VE & Marv
Onegu was totally looking for a veteran to sheep and I'm looking at you.
After yesterday's mess, I'll be available if you ever want to hear and breakdown my case against FirmTofu & austinmcc/Vivax.
If you think I've got my read right, then you can make one last appeal and lead these townies to victory.
Bring forth your case on me thanks. I can't speak for austin, but I can speak for myself.
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
Right, gonna try to catch up a bit.
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
On July 28 2013 06:35 Vivax wrote:Show nested quote +On July 28 2013 06:13 FirmTofu wrote:
vivax, are you out there? Can you vote today? Do you think TG/Cora is a likely scum team? Why or why not? I posted the part I found iffy about Cora's claim alreadz. I also voted, TG. Kirby does look odd and I found him mainly scummy for his position on the TAA wagon, if he is though, then he has been bussed, which fits into the way the DrH slot played, first push him, find a reason to shoot someone else, then push him again. I don't find DrH's slots' reasons for his read 180s very credible. Your DT checks tell us nothing, DT should have stayed silent until he had a chance to check somebody else he was sure of being town. Now we don't know if he's insane or paranoid. Thing is though, Cora's claim timing was scummy and looked like it was designed to save TAA, again, sub-optimal play for a DT to claim in that situation in any case. He should have kept the role secret and watched how the flip went, and then adjust his scumreads accordingly without using his role as a reason, but meh, doesn't really matter anymore. That leads us to Cora still being alive after his claim, I don't know his checks atm, but I've gotten from the thread that he's supposedly sane?That leads us to the question why scum would leave him alive then. Cause of that, I'd probably not lynch him today and consider him for lynch if he survives another night and depending on the check he returns. Lucky for us, he can't claim RB. As conclusion, I stick to the opinion that we should lynch TG for being alive after D1, I'm suspicious of DrH's behavior during that day, and anyone not wanting to lynch TGis banking on the fact that a flipped scum somehow missed the deadline, and not just that, cause TG's lynch wasn't exactly last minute shit. Question: Who replaced Zephirdd? I didn't like his last post during D1.
This post is disgusting. Really disgusting. Why would Cora ever have died before getmoript, the DT with a redcheck and red-lynch?
Cora's claim timing was pretty damn townie as I've explained before. Ewwwww Vivax. Eww.
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
I'm up to page 111. I felt compelled to temporarily abandon my read to tell everyone that if Firm isn't mafia, he's doing a fucking bang-up job of pushing mafia objectives. Christ almighty.
|
On July 29 2013 08:22 FiveTouch wrote:Show nested quote +On July 28 2013 06:35 Vivax wrote:On July 28 2013 06:13 FirmTofu wrote:
vivax, are you out there? Can you vote today? Do you think TG/Cora is a likely scum team? Why or why not? I posted the part I found iffy about Cora's claim alreadz. I also voted, TG. Kirby does look odd and I found him mainly scummy for his position on the TAA wagon, if he is though, then he has been bussed, which fits into the way the DrH slot played, first push him, find a reason to shoot someone else, then push him again. I don't find DrH's slots' reasons for his read 180s very credible. Your DT checks tell us nothing, DT should have stayed silent until he had a chance to check somebody else he was sure of being town. Now we don't know if he's insane or paranoid. Thing is though, Cora's claim timing was scummy and looked like it was designed to save TAA, again, sub-optimal play for a DT to claim in that situation in any case. He should have kept the role secret and watched how the flip went, and then adjust his scumreads accordingly without using his role as a reason, but meh, doesn't really matter anymore. That leads us to Cora still being alive after his claim, I don't know his checks atm, but I've gotten from the thread that he's supposedly sane?That leads us to the question why scum would leave him alive then. Cause of that, I'd probably not lynch him today and consider him for lynch if he survives another night and depending on the check he returns. Lucky for us, he can't claim RB. As conclusion, I stick to the opinion that we should lynch TG for being alive after D1, I'm suspicious of DrH's behavior during that day, and anyone not wanting to lynch TGis banking on the fact that a flipped scum somehow missed the deadline, and not just that, cause TG's lynch wasn't exactly last minute shit. Question: Who replaced Zephirdd? I didn't like his last post during D1. This post is disgusting. Really disgusting. Why would Cora ever have died before getmoript, the DT with a redcheck and red-lynch? Cora's claim timing was pretty damn townie as I've explained before. Ewwwww Vivax. Eww.
Good argument, but hindsight, and late. Furthermore, your other head did seem to have a few doubts about your conclusion.
What are your conclusions regarding my general play, aside from this post where you found something I didn't reach a right conclusion from.
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
It's not hindsight, I'd put those god damn things in the thread already.
Your play is bad because if you'd been paying any attention to the thread you'd KNOW why Corazon was alive. So you're either totally not readnig the thread or wilfully twisting what happened to make Cora look bad.
|
Sanya12364 Posts
@Onegu
See getmoript's comment about jrkirby. The guy is a newbie lurker that is lynchbait. Scum team needs to keep him around to win. That's why Tofu made the huge move. Scum need you to mislynch on jrkirby. If jrkirby isn't around town wins via process of elimination.
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
Like given you replaced in, you must have had to READ the thread, and you'd have read the progression getmo claims DT -> lynches TAA -> gets killed at night -> then yesterday happened.
You should damn well KNOW why Corazon wasn't killed at night. Why didn't you know that?
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
People need to stop colouring shit in red because it just makes people look bad when they're inevitably wrong.
raaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaage
|
Sanya12364 Posts
Sorry, 5T...
Are you going to hear me out on Vivax & Tofu, now?
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
I'm going to finish reading first. I'm awake for another hour, and I'll be kinda baked for a decent part of it. le sigh.
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
On July 28 2013 15:16 Onegu wrote:
How can you guys not see JrKirby is scum?
Wow... this is really horrible. God. This might be the scummiest thing I've seen so far :/
where was this conviction during the lynch??
|
On July 29 2013 08:57 FiveTouch wrote:
Like given you replaced in, you must have had to READ the thread, and you'd have read the progression getmo claims DT -> lynches TAA -> gets killed at night -> then yesterday happened.
You should damn well KNOW why Corazon wasn't killed at night. Why didn't you know that?
There was a Vanilla Rayn kill in between afaik.
|
|
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
Ok I'm done. This is hard to me because everyone is so O.o
I really think Firm is town actually. I think he's DT. I find a lot of what he says sincere, if wrong.
My faith in Onegu has been shaken markedly. He's really done so little. I don't know if I can be calling him scum yet, but I think everyone needs to keep in mind the possibility of a scum vigilante - his claim alone doesn't make him town.
Tangeng maybe town? ugh
kirby still looks pretty bad. austin/vivax not looking great to me either. JJD looks ok maybe?
And holy fuck Vivax has basically not been reading the thread.
On July 29 2013 09:30 Vivax wrote:Show nested quote +On July 29 2013 08:57 FiveTouch wrote:
Like given you replaced in, you must have had to READ the thread, and you'd have read the progression getmo claims DT -> lynches TAA -> gets killed at night -> then yesterday happened.
You should damn well KNOW why Corazon wasn't killed at night. Why didn't you know that? There was a Vanilla Rayn kill in between afaik.
On July 29 2013 09:33 Vivax wrote:
Oh and Oats.
Firstly, rayn was the n1 kill. You would know this if you even had done any basic reading of the thread.
Secondly, Oats was shot by the vigilante, how on earth would that be a reason for Corazon to die?
|
On July 29 2013 08:53 FiveTouch wrote:
I'm up to page 111. I felt compelled to temporarily abandon my read to tell everyone that if Firm isn't mafia, he's doing a fucking bang-up job of pushing mafia objectives. Christ almighty. In order for me to believe tofu is mafia, I need to hear some kind of explaination for how scum knew that making a 3rd detective claim would end up being a good play. The play is suicide untill you say ur also detective.
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
