Personality Mafia 2 - Page 97

On March 13 2013 07:00 VisceraEyes wrote:
BC you're missing the point. Why wouldn't he use it on a town-aligned you? Or a town-aligned Ver? Or a town-aligned Foolish? Or a town-aligned marv? The point is he used it in a way that helped town - removing someone shitting up the thread - instead of a way that irrevocably harms town - killing a strong player with potential to lead town.

No one is arguing that his role makes him town - Acro is saying that his USE of the role makes him town. That's all we can ever go on.

On March 13 2013 07:02 Vivax wrote:
BC I want to cry with you. The worst is that you might be gone tomorrow and I'll be alone...Arguing against insulting elements who say Ockham's razor is when the guy shooting town is town.

On March 13 2013 07:06 Acrofales wrote:
Vivax: I have argued the role all which ways. The second part which you bolded is pretty much EXACTLY what Yamato claimed. He picks a target and vig-shoots them if town, or DT checks them if scum. IF he is scum, that means he is a dayvig, because why on earth bother DT checking your scumbuddies? Now how about you start READING and THINKING instead of spewing drivel all the time.

C: there might be some merit to that. I once mentioned offhandedly to Greymist that I found it funny that his Ace Attorney role is always considered confirmed town, and he said he had wanted to make it scum (in PU I think), but there were balance reasons not to, or the roles didn't work out properly, or something. Anyway, you bring up something worth considering.

On March 13 2013 07:02 BloodyC0bbler wrote:


Simple. If as mafia he used it on me and I flipped town and got shot, he'd be instantly castrated for taking out a town heavy hitter and a townie who knows his role will kill a green/blue check is a retard to use it on a high profile target unless the suspicion of him being scum is there. Choosing one of us day 2 or 3 makes sense but within the first like 24ish hours of day 1? No chance in hell.

Object is to confirm your alignment, not solidify your trip to the gallows.

On March 13 2013 07:08 Acrofales wrote:
Oh, and that whole spiel is if you assume the DT check and the vig shot are separate from each other. If they're not, and you simply believe Yamato's role, then his USE of the power makes no sense.

He could have just silently and quietly shot any of the heavy hitters and nobody would have known unless he started yelling that he was MZ.

On March 13 2013 07:06 Acrofales wrote:
Vivax: I have argued the role all which ways. The second part which you bolded is pretty much EXACTLY what Yamato claimed. He picks a target and vig-shoots them if town, or DT checks them if scum. IF he is scum, that means he is a dayvig, because why on earth bother DT checking your scumbuddies? Now how about you start READING and THINKING instead of spewing drivel all the time.

C: there might be some merit to that. I once mentioned offhandedly to Greymist that I found it funny that his Ace Attorney role is always considered confirmed town, and he said he had wanted to make it scum (in PU I think), but there were balance reasons not to, or the roles didn't work out properly, or something. Anyway, you bring up something worth considering.

On March 13 2013 06:44 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
Also the case on me by prpl makes me laugh. Try harder mr try hard.

Austin also super baddy. Why would bc change his posting style in a game with altered personalities. Likely because hes playing his personality. Themed games dont equal normal. Nor does the fact I have less time now to actively play.

However good try captain try hard 2.

On March 13 2013 06:48 BloodyC0bbler wrote:


Its prpl and austin. Both are experienced enough to know better. Also, marv has outright lied about how he garners reads on me. As he was unsure of my alignment in LX and was basing my alignment on if I got shot n1 or not. Given his tried and true method is not neccesarily in play this game given that there are so many big names to shoot him outright saying I have a tell for him d1 is an outright lie.

Now the only reason I mention it is he made a huge deal of foolishness lying yet does it himself. Hypocritical actions make BC sad.

On March 13 2013 07:13 austinmcc wrote:
Themed games don't equal normal. And the less time thing flies with me, I care more about what you did post than how much of it there was.

But I don't know who your personality is, nor do I know how hard you're roleplaying as that person. "It's a personality game and I might be acting out of the part of some unknown person" is not as airtight an explanation as you're thinking. You might be roleplaying. You might be scum. Either way, your play this game looks scummy.

On March 13 2013 07:10 BloodyC0bbler wrote:


Again. Issue is if there is anyone in the game that reveals peoples personalities. In a game such as this there could very well be. For all we know he is forced to claim in some way (via pro gf snipe comment or the like) to give a hint as to his role.

Hitting a heavy hitter still makes no sense as it outs a scum role day 1. If he were to use it and missfire day 2 or 3 on someone the thread considered mafia then he'd get away scott free, but not day 1.

On March 13 2013 07:13 marvellosity wrote:


... you were smurfing and for almost the whole first day you spoke in Vayesh speak. Are you really equating how you play as Vayesh, when you speak in 3rd person and speak in riddles, with how you play under this username? Seriously?

On February 26 2013 09:49 VayeshMoru wrote:
It was a dark day for the settlers. With the children of atom back Vayesh knew work had to be done. He began to sift through the remains of his fallen friends. Sadly after a quick glance of both bodies it was clear no new information could be garnered. It was then that Vayesh knew it was time for the detailed job.

Hours seemed to pass as he poured through the historical documents on the children of atom. It was well known they had a lust for genocide but they seemed to have some other goal in mind as well. All of the relevant information seemed to have been purged however. Only the generic rise and fall of the cult in the past was recorded.

Vayesh thought all hope was lost then realized that the answer may actually be held by the machines left behind to deal with the threat. Gazing at the automatons a plan began to appear.

Vayesh marched his way to the center of the throng, pushing his way to the center of the commotion.

People were fretting over who should replace gmarshal as mayor. It seemed fitting that the men who killed him would clamor to the front hoping to gain some edge of power to use against Vayesh and his friends. So far none of the men who had come to plea their case were trustworthy. Vayesh had seen all he needed to be disgusted.

This town needed order, this town needed guidence, this town needed chezinu

On March 13 2013 07:14 strongandbig wrote:

looking scummy is part roleplaying his personality

On March 13 2013 07:15 Acrofales wrote:

I don't buy that scum is paranoid enough to live in permanent fear of role/name cops. Scum fake claim in closed themed games all the time. Any role/name cop could catch them out, yet I've only seen it happen ONCE (my own check on Toad in CT).

On March 13 2013 07:17 HiroPro wrote:
i dont like prplz case. from what i have seen bc spends a lot of time looking to punish bad play or things he doesnt like even if they arent about finding mafia. look at lviii where he says to kill palmar even thoufh clearly town and then later in obs qt says he did it just cause he thought palmars play was antitown. if bc just keeps spending his time saying same things over and over about yamato then kill him but otherwise look at his other stuff i say.

bc tell us about people other than yamto and ver. i already know what you say about them. you are familar with supersoft? what do you think of him.