I want to say test-subject is scum because of his willingness to drop a one-liner to get majority on you and then lurk away. Best case scenario for scum is to get a lynch quick without having to commit which is exactly what he did there.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

March 11 2013 21:27 GMT

#4255

The thing is, I don't think Dr.H ever set the train on anybody. Lets go by the lynch order. Prom, chez, geript, gluri, and vivax.

Prom- lots of people made cases on him Dr.H was one of him, but I believe prom would have been lynched without Dr.H
Chez- pretty much all wade.
Geript- started with wade, then pretty much geript himself self-exploding.
Glurio- Started from macho man, then milk got behind it. I forgot how Dr.H fit in here
Vivax- JJ + milksuckler figuring out night action logic which pointed towards vivax

In none of them would I say Dr.H set the train. He was relatively involved in all of them, but I think they would have happened without him.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

March 11 2013 21:32 GMT

#4259

That was towards WoS. It's pretty much meant for:

On March 12 2013 06:21 WaveofShadow wrote:
DrH is just so much more believable than me I guess ever since his effort on D1, but now he's doing the exact same thing he did before. Put in a whole bunch of effort knowing that the train is set, then leaves.

He even said he was going to do a full case on me but never did because HE DIDN'T NEED TO. He'd already convinced all of you with minimal effort. Just quoted his own earlier post on me from fucking two weeks ago, even though he had since changed his opinion of me and called me towny. Like...what else do you need me to show you guys??

I'm just trying to see how Dr.H ever set the train.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

March 11 2013 21:41 GMT

#4266

I sort of want to believe WoS about Dr.H because not being target of scum is one thing, and you do that by not being super correct nailing scum left and right, but you want to contribute so town doesn't lynch you. Especially as a vet, town would expect Dr.H to contribute, but Dr.H has done it in a way so he's not a big target for scum, as proven by the fact that he's alive. In that sense I can understand seeing bartender out of Dr.H. His play would fit that role.

However, I can't get over the fact that a Dr.H bartender would have never ignited night 5.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

March 12 2013 19:52 GMT

#4301

On March 13 2013 04:27 grush57 wrote:
Regardless if he is scum or bartender he didn't put in much effort so I guess I'll lynch him.

Coming from you!? I have put more effort in 3 posts than your whole filter.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

March 12 2013 19:54 GMT

#4302

Where were you yesterday when it was probably the most important lynch for town? You dropped 1 post on a non-contender and disappeared. Where have you been all game besides hiding behind starsense?

randombum

United States2378 Posts

March 12 2013 20:41 GMT

#4307

How did I claim scum?

randombum

United States2378 Posts

March 12 2013 20:43 GMT

#4309

What I don't grush is how you are so dead set on me. Yeah I lurked. You lurked. and so did testsubject. But you seem to only care about me, why?

randombum

United States2378 Posts

March 12 2013 20:44 GMT

#4310

There's only 3 players left with 1 bartender 1 scum 1 town. The town KNOWS he's town and knows the other's are not.

This game no longer matter about town reads, it's who you want as a person/poster to want to win.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

March 12 2013 20:48 GMT

#4312

I wasn't calling him not pro-town enough. I was just calling out that him calling me a lurker is ironic considering how much he lurks.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

March 12 2013 20:49 GMT

#4313

You jumping to scum conclusion implies your the bar-tender though.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

March 12 2013 20:58 GMT

#4315

It's funny, I've never seen this situation before.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

March 12 2013 20:58 GMT

#4316

Also, changing my vote because I don't like how test subject has 3 letters in his name.

randombum

United States2378 Posts

March 12 2013 21:12 GMT

#4318

Yeah, Whoops. Can I ask why you ignited night 5? I'm guessing you assumed milksuckler told the truth and would be shot so you might as well go out with a bang?

randombum

United States2378 Posts

March 12 2013 21:20 GMT

#4319

Actually how would the game turn out if last town got lynched and bartender/scum took each other out at the same time? A draw?

randombum

United States2378 Posts

March 12 2013 22:30 GMT

#4322

On March 13 2013 06:21 grush57 wrote:
why tie when testsubject can win?

I was just curios.

randombum