|
HEY EVERYONE. WE ARE PLAYING PARANOIA MAFIA. IT IS A CLOSED SETUP. WE HAVE HAD NINE BILLION POWER ROLES CLAIMED.
I actually BELIEVE that our masons are masoned. Ta da. But everyone needs to remember, being a mason =/= being TOWN. Stop saying they are confirmed townies, stop thinking that way, because we don't know. Scum masons happen. Cults happen. There is absolutely no reason to believe that our masons have to be town, so knock it off.
Given that the game is PARANOIA mafia, and we've got 4.5 billion mason pairs now...I actually think it's far more likely that one or both mason pairs could be scum/town than it is that they're all town, or one pair is fakeclaiming. That's way too risky when scum already lost VE, no way they put 2 members in harm's way.
At this point, gut feeling, Keirathi is town, WBG is scum, and they ARE masons.
There is absolutely no reason to believe that masons have to be town. Same way we can't be sure DYH is a vigi, or a TOWN vigi at that.
GRATUITOUS USE OF CAPSLOCK LYNCH WBG.
|
There's no way around it: we must lynch WBG now. His flip will (at least most likely) clear up this mess and otherwise we'll be just speculating the setup tomorrow. I didn't believe he was Mafia before, but I believe BH/MrZentor as the Mason pair more.
|
I keep getting hung up on how BH "forgot" who his Mason partner was.
It wasn't like it was very far into the day. Like, how does that even make sense?
Now, would it make sense for a scum to make a case on their partner early, then say "Whoops guys, NVM!"? Much, much more sense than a FUCKING MASON DOING IT.
|
ohhh shit. Austin with breaking analysis
|
Austin that is kinda smart actually... Keir, is there anything that ACTUALLY confirms WBG being town in your role pm/mod?
|
Here's my role PM:
You are Big Bird. You can chat with your fellow muppet, wherebugsgo, outside of the thread. (Mason)
|
On December 05 2012 07:35 Keirathi wrote:
Here's my role PM:
You are Big Bird. You can chat with your fellow muppet, wherebugsgo, outside of the thread. (Mason) Well, that seals the deal I guess.
|
In no way does that seal the deal. That tells us that
IF Keirathi is telling the truth
THEN Keirathi is blue, town, and a mason.
It tells us absolutely nothing about WBG's alignment.
|
You are Mace Windu. A member of the Jedi Council. You know your fellow councilmember, BlazingHand, is town. You may communicate with them outside the thread. (mason)
Yeah, you made the wrong thing blue.
You're scum.
|
On December 05 2012 07:38 austinmcc wrote:
In no way does that seal the deal. That tells us that
IF Keirathi is telling the truth
THEN Keirathi is blue, town, and a mason.
It tells us absolutely nothing about WBG's alignment. Well, I meant it more in a like''Now I'm 100%-sure I want to lynch WBG''-way
|
This game keeps getting from hard to harder. ObsQT must be having a blast. But what other option is there than lynching WBG? If we lynch ShiaoPi and he flips town, we'll just be speculating all day about these claims, when we could confirm Keirathi as either Mafia or Mason right now.
|
What are the odds those role PM's contain different information like that?
|
On December 05 2012 07:38 MrZentor wrote:
You are Mace Windu. A member of the Jedi Council. You know your fellow councilmember, BlazingHand, is town. You may communicate with them outside the thread. (mason)
Yeah, you made the wrong thing blue.
You're scum.
On December 05 2012 07:35 Keirathi wrote:
Here's my role PM:
You are Big Bird. You can chat with your fellow muppet, wherebugsgo, outside of the thread. (Mason) Huh.
|
Again, more caps. The game is PARANOIA MAFIA. The intro says NOT TO TRUST STUFF (see marv's maybe questioning his sanity).
So far, there has been no paranoia. Nothing out of the ordinary that would make a closed setup interesting. Mason pairs that cross alignments are absolutely something that could make a closed setup interesting, and absolutely something that could create paranoia.
ESPECIALLY with two mason pairs. What if one is town/mafia and the other is town/town. Or town/mafia and mafia/mafia. 4 confirmable townies, not just that, but townies that can talk to each other outside thread and share ideas and become super scumhunting machines (seriously, if you haven't been a mason, it's RIDICULOUSLY strong) seems like way too much. Those are exactly the sorts of scenarios that create paranoia.
If we lynch WBG and he's town...WHAT DO WE DO. Maybe keirathi is lying, maybe one of MrZ and BH is mafia, WHO KNOWS!!!! If we lynch him and he's mafia...WHAT DO WE DO. Maybe keirathi is telling the truth, maybe none/one/both of MrZ and BH are mafia, WHO KNOWS!!!
That's paranoia. That fits this game. Plus...seriously, WBG totes mafia.
|
Blazinghand
United States25558 Posts
i am back and at a computer
On December 05 2012 06:59 Keirathi wrote:
Bah, fine DYH is forcing my hand.
WBG and I are MASONS
Now can we please vote ShiaoPi for the love of god?
On December 05 2012 07:35 Keirathi wrote:
Here's my role PM:
You are Big Bird. You can chat with your fellow muppet, wherebugsgo, outside of the thread. (Mason)
nice color coding. Masons are definitely blue, not green.
You are Yoda. A member of the Jedi Council. You know your fellow councilmember, MrZentor, is town. You may communicate with them outside the thread. (mason)
|
Yeah, in my pm the words 'you' and 'are' are also blue.
You didn't notice that?
|
They have different stuff highlighted. And MrZ's says that BH is town, where Keir's does not say his partner is town.
MrZs looks a little sloppy though lol
|
Hey everyone. Check ur role pms. See if they highlight You are
|
Blazinghand
United States25558 Posts
In any case, MrZ and I have been working together all game and defending each other. if anyone doesn't understand the crumb post I made from my phone let me know and I'll explain more thoroughly.
|
On December 05 2012 07:38 MrZentor wrote:
You are Mace Windu. A member of the Jedi Council. You know your fellow councilmember, BlazingHand, is town. You may communicate with them outside the thread. (mason)
Yeah, you made the wrong thing blue.
You're scum.
Oh really?
On December 02 2012 08:10 Hopeless1der wrote:
You are Captain Lee Adama. You're usually pretty persuasive, if a bit bad at following orders. Your vote is your only weapon right now, because your Viper is down for maintenance.
On December 03 2012 08:04 JingleHell wrote:
You are Jamie Hyneman. Your love of the scientific method makes it possible for you to find out how shit works. You've also got a cool collection of cameras and stuff, that you can totally use to track people. (Detective)
Mafia Goon. You may carry an NK. You win with scum. Your team consists of yeah right, that would be embarrassing.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
