EPTAlso, who has the detective item?
Aperture Mafia - Page 115
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
phagga
Switzerland2194 Posts
Also, who has the detective item? | ||
|
Nisani201
United States1400 Posts
On April 02 2012 05:04 phagga wrote: Oh, and food for thought: We don't know if Foolishness used the double-kill shot last night. Perhaps he saved it to use it later to gain instant victory as cell? (He could triple kill if he combines it with the cell KP) Also, who has the detective item? Kenpachi had it, but he got removed fro the game. I'm not sure what happened to them. Where do Kenpachi's items go? Are they distributed randomly to people who voted for GLaDOS? | ||
|
Nisani201
United States1400 Posts
So after reading through the filters of Phagga and Maverick, I have deduced that Maverick is the last cell. Phagga was actively commenting on a lot of people, something that a Cell member wouldn't want to do, in case they accidentally call out one of their teammates. Therefore that leaves Maverick. Pretty sure he's the last cell. ##Vote: Maverick | ||
|
Nisani201
United States1400 Posts
| ||
|
Mementoss
Canada2595 Posts
Damn that Kenpachi situation sucks. I was so curious to what it did, but damn the timing really puts the town in an awkward situation. But, a win is a win for him I guess QQ. That being said, since I have a condition that is not told to me about acquiring all the cores, I would like people to refrain from giving me them so I dont collect them all, in case its similar to a Kenpachi win con. I have been gone that last couple of days so i need to re-read the last few pages to try and figure out using the newly acquired information from the night kills, and re-examine the filters of remaining players. Will try to get a post tonight, at latest tommorrow mornin. | ||
|
Jayjay54
Germany2296 Posts
On April 02 2012 05:01 phagga wrote: Jayjay, if there is a constellation like 3-2-1, then we need to get rid of the sleeper cell first to avoid having 2 townies killed at night. If there is a constellation like 4-1-1, then it doesn't matter if we go for mafia or sleeper cell first, as long as we get the lynch right. wrong. a sleeper lynch with 3-2-1 will get us to 3-2. After the nightkill it will be 2-2 and game. On April 02 2012 05:54 Nisani201 wrote: I highly doubt Mementoss is scum simply because he has the computer terminal and I don't think that that kind of pro-town role would be given to cell. I also doubt that Foolishness is scum. How is the computer terminal pro town? It can be used for everything and can encourage item hunting for scum. In fact, you saw it being used against town already. In a game where we had a pro town bus driver, an anti-town mason and where we discuss an inventor being anti town, we can't conclude him as a safe town looking solely at the role. | ||
|
Jayjay54
Germany2296 Posts
No lynch is a bad option as well. So we should conclude on mementoss or mav. phagga looks way better than they do... | ||
|
Nisani201
United States1400 Posts
Foolishness isn't scum because he's been acting pro-town this entire game, much like Phagga. Mementoss is a good lynch for tomorrow if Maverick flips town. | ||
|
Jayjay54
Germany2296 Posts
4-1-1 would give us some space though. I am with you here Nisani. Mav or Mem needs to die, I'll be on until deadline to see what is possible. | ||
|
Jayjay54
Germany2296 Posts
Vote. Maverick32x | ||
|
Maverick32x
United States311 Posts
That being said.. I have an actual question- how do we know any scum is left? Couldn't there just be 1 sleeper cell remaining? This vote is difficult because of the potential for Sleeper Cell to be motivated to kill scum as much as allow town to kill themselves.... to be honest, and I know this is the you blame me, I blame you sort of thing.. but flipping through filters, almost everyone that is left has some sort of 'unique' job... the only person who hasn't discussed this yet is JJ and Phagga... And I know, before the pitchforks start coming at me... doesn't anyone think that is a bit suspicious? I'm a cop, Nisani is an inventor, Mementoss is a computer (GI joe reference), Foolishness talks in rhymes.... For a game with relatively intricate style.. those players have not brought up their roles at all... Obviously if they are medic or DT that makes sense and I understand.. however- I think it is still something to consider... I'm going to stick to a Phagga vote... I know he is one of the few people who didn't go after me in this thread, so I'm sure I'm slitting my own throat- but I'm going to go for it. | ||
|
Jayjay54
Germany2296 Posts
On April 02 2012 07:16 Maverick32x wrote: Ok, I'm not entirely sure if trying to defend myself is of much use. I get the strong feeling that JJ already has his heart set on me, so I get that this is an uphill battle.. however, I'm encouraging everyone left to think for themselves and not to simply bandwagon your way to a lose... I am not third party, and I am not scum.... That being said.. I have an actual question- how do we know any scum is left? Couldn't there just be 1 sleeper cell remaining? This vote is difficult because of the potential for Sleeper Cell to be motivated to kill scum as much as allow town to kill themselves.... to be honest, and I know this is the you blame me, I blame you sort of thing.. but flipping through filters, almost everyone that is left has some sort of 'unique' job... the only person who hasn't discussed this yet is JJ and Phagga... And I know, before the pitchforks start coming at me... doesn't anyone think that is a bit suspicious? I'm a cop, Nisani is an inventor, Mementoss is a computer (GI joe reference), Foolishness talks in rhymes.... For a game with relatively intricate style.. those players have not brought up their roles at all... Obviously if they are medic or DT that makes sense and I understand.. however- I think it is still something to consider... I'm going to stick to a Phagga vote... I know he is one of the few people who didn't go after me in this thread, so I'm sure I'm slitting my own throat- but I'm going to go for it. You read the threat at all? Phagga has been discussed quite a bit. Also, no, I have not decided. In fact, I'd much rather lynch mementoss, as I stated many times now. The problem is that Foolishness is no scum, Nisani is the inventor and most likely not scum and I have lynched both scum and cell. Which boils down to you three guys (phagga, mav, mem). For some reason people think mem is town for his role. Phagga made some good posts. This is why you are in the zone now. | ||
|
Jayjay54
Germany2296 Posts
| ||
|
phagga
Switzerland2194 Posts
also: I don't want to calculate too much, but: If we are at 3-2-1, and we kill mafia, that makes 3-1-1. Then there are 2 nightkills, which leave us at 1-1-1, which is nigh unwinnable. However, if we go from 3-2-1 to 3-2-0 and then 2-2-, we can win with an item of Nisani. HOWEVER, that assumes that there is still a cell member left to kill. This is why I stick to Foolishness. Maverick: You're right, it is possible that there is only one sleeper cell or one mafia left, as we do no know the flips of night one nor the size of the mafia group. What JJ and I are picturing here are the worst case scenarios. So you want to know my role? | ||
|
Jayjay54
Germany2296 Posts
On April 02 2012 07:27 phagga wrote: Uh, JJ, the Deadline is in 24 hours... also: I don't want to calculate too much, but: If we are at 3-2-1, and we kill mafia, that makes 3-1-1. Then there are 2 nightkills, which leave us at 1-1-1, which is nigh unwinnable. However, if we go from 3-2-1 to 3-2-0 and then 2-2-, we can win with an item of Nisani. HOWEVER, that assumes that there is still a cell member left to kill. This is why I stick to Foolishness. Maverick: You're right, it is possible that there is only one sleeper cell or one mafia left, as we do no know the flips of night one nor the size of the mafia group. What JJ and I are picturing here are the worst case scenarios. So you want to know my role? oh is it? that actually explains a lot :D Sorry for strssing out. I'll be voting mementoss again then: ##Vote: Mementoss The difference is that with 3-1-1 there's a fair chance that scum hits cell and vice versa. especially since they avoid me because of my item. we also don't know for sure, if cell has a KP, do we? I don't think so looking at last night, because there wasn't one. The bullet was a vig item bought on the black market ...We def should try to hit scum and not cell. Mav: I also basically claimed my role: I was a vig...and my shot was confirmed... | ||
|
phagga
Switzerland2194 Posts
On April 02 2012 07:34 Jayjay54 wrote: we also don't know for sure, if cell has a KP, do we? I don't think so looking at last night, because there wasn't one. The bullet was a vig item bought on the black market Uh, how do you know this? did I miss that somewhere in the thread? | ||
|
Jayjay54
Germany2296 Posts
On April 02 2012 07:38 phagga wrote: Uh, how do you know this? did I miss that somewhere in the thread? On March 27 2012 13:06 MidnightGladius wrote: In the Black Market thread, the player who bought the Companion Cube (smurf account that we all agreed to ignore) just bought a Sentry Gun (1kp) and is leading the auction for the Delicious Cake (forces a player to not post for 24 hours). Additionally, this player has some number of Letters (one-shot PMs), and no one else has bought any of them, so if any of you have been receiving such forms of communications, it should be this player. I also will note that the Radiator returned 1 Mafia. This likely means that there exists a mafia doctor/roleblocker/other strong PR, and the team decided it would be better to keep using that action. A mafia doctor would actually fit with what we've seen so far, as that would have accounted for Maverick's kp without refunding it, allowing kita to claim the actual kill. On March 28 2012 08:12 MidnightGladius wrote: "YellOw" just bought another Sentry Gun (for a total of 2kp currently in his possession), and he won the auction for the Delicious Cake (forces a player to not post for 24 hours). at least it makes perfect sense that this is not cell flavour, but this item... So far there is no flavour unaccounted other than both apererture kills last night. Which is why I assume no actual cell KP. They might have the second gun though...would kinda make sense that scum has KP and cell black market. we are not sure though | ||
|
phagga
Switzerland2194 Posts
I'll sleep over it, but I think I will switch my vote to Mementoss. | ||
|
Nisani201
United States1400 Posts
| ||
|
GreYMisT
United States6736 Posts
| ||
| ||
