EPTWerewolves Invade Teamliquid II - Page 4
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Probulous
Australia3894 Posts
| ||
|
Probulous
Australia3894 Posts
@Paperscraps. I wrote that post when you were writing yours, hence my follow up about ninjas in the wind. I see now that my word choice was probably not best. So no I did not see your post when I wrote that. Still nothing from Sentinel, so my vote stands. Looking forward to a greener town tomorrow with less mafia to muddy the waters. Goodnight all | ||
|
Probulous
Australia3894 Posts
 The only consolation for me is that Mattchew was on my townie list so it extra good that he is dead. Ok guys this is simple, we lynch Sentinel today. My case hasn't changed since yesterday and all that he has given is his defense. No attempt in actually helping town, just trying to save his ass. Now before you jump all over me for saying that town could do that as well let me walk you through his defense. On February 17 2012 05:48 [UoN]Sentinel wrote: If I were scum, I'd do my best to deny PMing them in the first place. Now prp was saying "I'm not revealing any other names", but IIRC he didn't even make the slightest attempt of discrediting SpiritClown. That only works if you are on the same team buddy. Plus I doubt Prpl would listen to you. He seems pretty set in doing what he wants. Note that Sentinel here doesn't even try and deny that he support rolefishing. He just says that he would tell prpl to not do it if he was scum. Then he goes and says this This is really bad logic. Just because Lanaia defends Prpl’s actions does not mean they are on the same team. Sure it would make Lanaia look scummy if Prpl flipped red but here he says he would straight up vote for her. He would lynch her based off a prpl flip. He takes up the argument in IRC Prpl never defended Lanaia, when asked he says The only thing that Prpl mentions about Lanaia is Which is hardly defending given no-one was attacking Lanaia. Sentinel has made a concerted effort to link Lanaia and prpl such that one’s alignment will confirm the other. And retracted it that same day... weren't you in IRC when I said "I give up?" I mean it's still scummy, I'll admit that, but I've made decisions like this on less evidence. Like when I voted risk.nuke in Hammer Mafia. There was more, but that wouldn't support your "concerted argument for nothing" argument now, would it? You only retracted that mate when both Lanaia and I pointed out how stupid it was. You were directly attacking her and when she pushed back you realised you couldn't make the case. That fact remains that you made a real attempt to link the two based off of one's flip. Read the last eight words I wrote in that quote and you'll see why you are wrong. That is your explanation? Seriously? That you expect to hear from him. If you truly wanted him to talk you have just straight up agreed that he needs to post. But no you write this lovely explanation why he doesn't have to post and then cover your ass with you expect him to post? I am sure he was shaking in his boots. You knew the whole point of my case was put a blowtorch under him and you doused it straight away. "Tried really hard" you give me way too much credit. I logged onto IRC, played with the idea for a few minutes, gave up when I got called out by both of them, and end of story. As for undermining your efforts, sometimes just because you think someone is scum... doesn't mean they're actually scum! Because there's an explanation for almost everything that can point to them being a townie, and mislynching won't do jackshit. Once he gets modkilled we'll see. The difference here is that you are scum. Why would you post that as town? On top of these scummy actions you have provided no cases, no content, no mafia for us to lynch. All you have done is subtly undermine me, and prevent me from pushing my cases. That isn't a problem if you provide something yourself, but no you have tried to gain town credit by pointing out the flaws in what I post. Easy way to look active without contributing. TLDR I see no reason to change my position from yesterday. If Sentinel finds me mafia I may reconsider but until then he has my vote. ##Vote [UoN]Sentinel | ||
|
Probulous
Australia3894 Posts
On February 15 2012 08:10 ghost_403 wrote: We've still got plenty of time left before the lynch, so it's too soon for me to cast a vote. Probulous does have good points here, and in two days, I will support his movement. Zeurg, start contributing or my FOS will become a vote. FOS zeurg If you aren't going to support the case then don't say anything because it gives the lurker an excuse not to post. If you have an issue with the case then point it out. If you are going to support the case don't give the guy an excuse not to post. I agree that Prpl's PM thing was a huge distraction (which he blames on me) but that doesn't make him mafia. Besides I agree with Palmar that he actively tried to get sinani to post before Palmar targeted him. That shows he was actively trying to avoid a possible miss-lynch as a mafia prpl would have let him fall. It is a small thing but the way prpl said it in IRC did not seem like he was trying to claim brownie points. So right now you are more suspicious to me than him. | ||
|
Probulous
Australia3894 Posts
On February 17 2012 09:09 Bluelightz wrote: Three Townies for one scum  like what Prob said .I'm getting on irc right now. Come join me, I am all by my lonesome... | ||
|
Probulous
Australia3894 Posts
Cause zeurg sure looked like mafia. | ||
|
Probulous
Australia3894 Posts
On February 17 2012 13:07 Grackaroni wrote: Funny coincidence that zeurg was the player replaced... Just from the fact that he would pop into IRC avoid talking and leave at the same time probulous started pming him. Really strange to sign up for a game in the first place and actively avoid talking, makes a little more sense from a scum perspective. IRC is waiting. This means nothing because we can never know why it was that zeurg was replaced and hufy was mod-killed. Well at least until the end of the game. | ||
|
Probulous
Australia3894 Posts
On February 17 2012 19:50 Bluelightz wrote: I think ghost is scum. Reasons: Let's look at his post's, Take a look at his filter, then take a look again at his filter but ignore his post's about prp let's see what it leaves, Take a look at those, over half of those post's are useless. Conclusion? He is being useless and keeps on tunneling prp for reasons. Also this, his 3rd point against prp 3) You still haven't told us the list of people you have PMd. If you were just breaking the ice, why not? What harm is there in saying "Outside of this thread, I talked to these people"? No harm at all. Instead, I see you purposefully hiding the list. What a scummy thing to do. Why is not telling the list of people he PMed scummy? PMs are "Private Message" amiright? So, ##Vote: ghost_403 This is terrible, terrible hypocrisy. For blatant sheeping and no attempt at even trying to provide some insight you go onto my naughty list. You have added nothing all game so to call someone out for making a case is too much. Naughty
| ||
|
Probulous
Australia3894 Posts
On February 18 2012 08:41 Palmar wrote: So, this game is weird. It's nice playing with new people because they actually bother to post in the thread and establish their innocence. Paperscraps is in my eyes basically confirmed town. Probulous is playing the most pro-town game of anyone here. froggynoddy is almost definitely town given his play in both thread and IRC on day one. bluelightz responded completely incorrectly to my pressure in the thread, but he seems to have done it in a very towny way. rgTS is a troll, but meh, he's probably town grackaroni is very towny based on his reactions to my pressure on day one. prplhz seems to be putting the effort into this game now that I'd expect him to. I'm least certain on him on this list. So, what is left is to find the scum in the following. phagga, sentinel, nisani, ghost, lanaia, mderg And I mean... we have probably at least 4-6 scum left, so fuck it. Just lynch into this list. If we have vigis, might as well shoot into it too, because why not. Chances of hitting scum are ridiculously high. gg no re Ok lets lynch [UoN]Sentinel (obviously) and Lanaia, less obvious but more to come. | ||
|
Probulous
Australia3894 Posts
 | ||
|
Probulous
Australia3894 Posts
On February 18 2012 09:23 Nisani201 wrote: WTF? This is the most stupid thing ever. You have no case against Lanaia and your case against Sentinel is very weak. You're simply bouncing off of the momentum Palmar is giving you. Palmar, what do you think of bluelightz? You should read On February 18 2012 08:41 Palmar wrote: bluelightz responded completely incorrectly to my pressure in the thread, but he seems to have done it in a very towny way. | ||
|
Probulous
Australia3894 Posts
 Obs QT? | ||
|
Probulous
Australia3894 Posts
On February 23 2012 01:01 syllogism wrote: prplhz: probulous was the godfather; he played well because he scanned scum every night and clearly knew what was going on ♥ syllo I didn't think Mattchew was scum when I scanned him so that was a mistake but I did pick Palmar day 2 and Lanaia day 3. Unfortunately they were on the same team. It was a hard role to play because I had to scum hunt but try and stay alive. Palmar played this like a pro. I think once both BH and layabout were shot town was already facing a major battle. The only person who was town and could stand up to Palmar with any credibility was Prpl and he got shot that night. The rest of town was far too passive and sheepy to ever put together a convincing case. Thanks guys it was fun, though I think I will stick to minis. | ||
|
Probulous
Australia3894 Posts
I am completing the library entry for this and was wondering whether anyone wanted to put together some analysis for me. I'll add mine but it always better if we have multiple entries. Thanks! | ||
| ||
