|
On February 08 2012 10:37 chaoser wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2012 10:33 kitaman27 wrote:
I'm not sure I like a CC lynch. It is pretty rare for a scum to post a plan guiding town's direction and generating discussion on day one. His thoughts about RG/Hugo don't really make much sense, but are they scummy? I haven't had a chance to read Sheth though, but I'll post again in a bit. If I don't like him, I'll try to suggest an alternate candidate (likely ico or kurumi). LSB did it in the hammer game I just played in. Show nested quote +On February 08 2012 10:27 Kurumi wrote:On February 08 2012 10:24 chaoser wrote:
Oh and he never puts any pressure at all on layabout. I would like to lynch layabout or wherebugsgo. If we manage to do that, the other one dies during the Night. Can You help me swing the lynch? lol no. WBG isn't even CLOSE to looking scummy to me. layabout either. I just said tunkeg is scummy to me. Those are your two choices if you're trying to get me to switch. CC or tunkeg. Take your pick.
Go Sheth. WBG is soft-defending him like he isn't.
Also, meta.
WBG is a lot more aggressive as town, a little as mafia but. He's REALLY active, like, being always on.
|
On February 07 2012 23:21 Kurumi wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2012 23:16 Jackal58 wrote:On February 07 2012 23:14 Kurumi wrote:On February 07 2012 23:13 Jackal58 wrote:
Kurumi - Insane inmates are the same as millers. They have no idea they'll check red. Ah fuck This still doesn't make sense from Town perspective, right? I'm not following. Millers are a pain if you're a DT but they should still be playing as a townie since they don't know they're millers. Well, since Penguin is the member of the Town in this game and Opz paints himself as one of the Inmates, why would he want to kill Penguin?
It's from actually playing Arkham City. Penguin blows the bridge leaving part of his inmates on the side of the Joker's territory to basically die.
|
My internet has gone out and I might not be able to fix it by the final vote. I'm able to read really slowly on my phone. If rg has really claimed DT then leave him alone, medics too. This phone internet is slow as hell so I won't catch up until I get my internet back. I read a little bit though. Man I don't even remember who it was who called me scum but talking about third party isn't scummy even day 2+, its just a bad focus and if you look at my recent posts they're off that topic. It sounds like you're looking at really thin scumtells and false contradictions but not the real content or motivation of what I'm saying. Its a bad analysis. That's all I have to say about that for now.
Dunno how much has changed in the last 10 pages but my last feeling was that cybercheese is batman and the CC lynch as suggested by toades and crew was the scum wagon as was kenpachi. It makes sense considering his horrible plan and obsession it, then when I just tried to point out to him and others why it was an anti-town plan he (and others) turn around on me to call me scum/catwoman for talking about it. Nothing he's done that I've seen suggests pro-town motives. It also makes sense that scum would want to lynch batman. Wasted lynch and it protects the GF. However other players have parroted CC in a way I find uncomfortable and scummy, like tunkeg, and it gives off that scum agenda feeling where they try to push the same ideas without directly interacting with each other. It happens a lot. This may be my last post before the night cycle starts so here are my suggestions in case I die tonight.
Poison ivy/hush: both of you protect jackal58.
Harley quinn/other medic (forgot name): use your own judgment.
DTs: use your own judgment, anyone who came under a fair amount of suspicion is a fair bet. I don't remember which named rroles are detectives but you can split it up and have half those name roles check people who were in the hot seat today and half check on lurkers, this somewhat prevents the chance of every dt checking the same guy.
|
On February 08 2012 10:39 ~OpZ~ wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2012 23:21 Kurumi wrote:On February 07 2012 23:16 Jackal58 wrote:On February 07 2012 23:14 Kurumi wrote:On February 07 2012 23:13 Jackal58 wrote:
Kurumi - Insane inmates are the same as millers. They have no idea they'll check red. Ah fuck This still doesn't make sense from Town perspective, right? I'm not following. Millers are a pain if you're a DT but they should still be playing as a townie since they don't know they're millers. Well, since Penguin is the member of the Town in this game and Opz paints himself as one of the Inmates, why would he want to kill Penguin? It's from actually playing Arkham City. Penguin blows the bridge leaving part of his inmates on the side of the Joker's territory to basically die.
Yes, but why Your freaking two posts are only about that?
|
DrH, why not protect Radfield too? I think both him and Jackal need time to heaten up and are GREAT Town players.
|
That's up to the medics to decide. Radfield is someone we don't want dead if he's town N1 obviously. They can make that judgment call without being directed by "town"
|
Okay I've read the thread in its entirety (slow day at work  ) and there are a few themes I'm noticing.
1) OMGUS
Too many votes (mine included) have been based solely on the fact that someone thinks you're scum.
2) Starfucking
Too many townies are depending on vets to win them the game like we did in L. There's a reason 2 people won that game, and it's certainly NOT because they waited for someone else to tell them who to vote for. Stop depending on others to scumhunt for you and do it yourself. It's more satisfying to hit red when you found the guy yourself and lead the lynch.
3) PR-Claiming
Stop fucking claiming. What the holy fuck, do you realize that we have outted at least 3 and possibly more PRs in DAY ONE?! Stop it!!! GAAAHHHHH!!!
Now, everyone needs to get back on the Sheth lynch. I'll elaborate when I get home, but after reading his filter in context (going back and seeing how people reacted to ALL of his posts -.-) I'm even more certain he's scum.
This has been a public service announcement.
|
kitaman27
United States9244 Posts
Sheth, mind posting when you are around? I have a question for you.
|
On February 08 2012 10:39 Kurumi wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2012 10:37 chaoser wrote:On February 08 2012 10:33 kitaman27 wrote:
I'm not sure I like a CC lynch. It is pretty rare for a scum to post a plan guiding town's direction and generating discussion on day one. His thoughts about RG/Hugo don't really make much sense, but are they scummy? I haven't had a chance to read Sheth though, but I'll post again in a bit. If I don't like him, I'll try to suggest an alternate candidate (likely ico or kurumi). LSB did it in the hammer game I just played in. On February 08 2012 10:27 Kurumi wrote:On February 08 2012 10:24 chaoser wrote:
Oh and he never puts any pressure at all on layabout. I would like to lynch layabout or wherebugsgo. If we manage to do that, the other one dies during the Night. Can You help me swing the lynch? lol no. WBG isn't even CLOSE to looking scummy to me. layabout either. I just said tunkeg is scummy to me. Those are your two choices if you're trying to get me to switch. CC or tunkeg. Take your pick. Go Sheth. WBG is soft-defending him like he isn't. Also, meta. WBG is a lot more aggressive as town, a little as mafia but. He's REALLY active, like, being always on.
This part is pure meta. And it's not even good meta. In the last few games WBG has been in, he's been a lot less active. And he's been town. That's a bullshit reason for thinking the guy is scummy.
Also, when you say go sheth, do you mean you want me to switch my vote to sheth?
|
On February 08 2012 10:33 Kurumi wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2012 10:31 Forumite wrote:On February 08 2012 08:59 layabout wrote:
Fuck it
##Vote: Kurumi
i do not want town blood on my hands! These lynches suck If you think someone is Town, then you defend them, you don´t just say the lynch sucks. Scum cast blame on Town that mislynch, Town try to prevent the lynch in the first place. I´m leaving my own vote on Sheth. It´s good that he´s finally returned to post, but I´m still leaning scum. Forumite, You have posted a lot less that I expected You to. I think You're actively lurking.
I´d like to say that I´m not posting much because I don´t want to flood the thread more than it allready is, but it´s actually because I´ve been busy, and most of the time I have goes into catching up in the thread. Being out of practice might be part of it too, I´ve hosted lately, instead of playing, which is much less stressfull.
Is there anything specific that you´d like me to post?
|
On February 08 2012 10:49 chaoser wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2012 10:39 Kurumi wrote:On February 08 2012 10:37 chaoser wrote:On February 08 2012 10:33 kitaman27 wrote:
I'm not sure I like a CC lynch. It is pretty rare for a scum to post a plan guiding town's direction and generating discussion on day one. His thoughts about RG/Hugo don't really make much sense, but are they scummy? I haven't had a chance to read Sheth though, but I'll post again in a bit. If I don't like him, I'll try to suggest an alternate candidate (likely ico or kurumi). LSB did it in the hammer game I just played in. On February 08 2012 10:27 Kurumi wrote:On February 08 2012 10:24 chaoser wrote:
Oh and he never puts any pressure at all on layabout. I would like to lynch layabout or wherebugsgo. If we manage to do that, the other one dies during the Night. Can You help me swing the lynch? lol no. WBG isn't even CLOSE to looking scummy to me. layabout either. I just said tunkeg is scummy to me. Those are your two choices if you're trying to get me to switch. CC or tunkeg. Take your pick. Go Sheth. WBG is soft-defending him like he isn't. Also, meta. WBG is a lot more aggressive as town, a little as mafia but. He's REALLY active, like, being always on. This part is pure meta. And it's not even good meta. In the last few games WBG has been in, he's been a lot less active. And he's been town. That's a bullshit reason for thinking the guy is scummy. Also, when you say go sheth, do you mean you want me to switch my vote to sheth?
I said it's meta. That's just unlikely for me to see WBG somehow not trying.. coupled that with soft-defending some people...
Yes, I'd like You to vote Sheth.
|
Oh damn forgot about Forumite:
No Broski, just play. Help us lynch scum.
|
On February 08 2012 10:52 Kurumi wrote:
Yes, I'd like You to vote Sheth.
Except before you said both sheth and CC were bad lynches, aka you thought they were townie. In like the last couple of minutes. What's with the change of mind?
|
On February 08 2012 10:54 chaoser wrote:Except before you said both sheth and CC were bad lynches, aka you thought they were townie. In like the last couple of minutes. What's with the change of mind?
I looked at the voting list once again and wbg posted with soft-defense of Sheth and voted CC using bullshit reason
"He looks bad town so he must be scum"
This is a terrible argument to lynch someone on. This is called bandwagoning.
|
Fwiw I think Sheth is a bad lynch today. If it's a choice between him and CC I'd prefer to see CC go. Cyber has been actively pursuing what at best appears to be really bad town policy at worse he's 3rd party. That's where my votes going unless Visc wants to claim scum for the 3rd game in a row. 
|
For all those asking for when day ends. Filter me and you will see I had posted last night on it.
For those who do not wish to do that, Day ends in 2 hours.
A votecount will be up shortly, sorry for the lack of one to this point (huzzah work).
As I have seen some players complain about insults, please keep all insults directed at the game. IE don't insult a person insult their play if you are going to be insulting. Make sure to clarify on this. Some players may not care if you call them bad, some obviously will.
As for claiming. You may name claim/which role it goes with. Basically, if the information is in the OP you may claim that information. If you have a role that is slightly modified than the norm you may not claim that. If you have a role that was modified but its power is something that directly impacts the game it may be discussed/claimed after use but not before.
|
Look:
My strongest scum read is WBG.
He came to the thread, made Toad case, then changed his mind and made Schworz case making two people change their vote and basically say "I agree", when the discussion on this guy was pretty much dead and irrevelant. Then he goes for CC, again weak case and bullshit argument.
No big efforts and backed up by scummy people.
Also, his case on Toad was built on basis that Toad had seen nothing wrong with DrH, while WBG does not comment himself on the case.
|
On February 08 2012 02:43 kitaman27 wrote:
ico's theme so far has been to promote a good thread environment. The only problem is that he is shooting down posts by others, but not making an attempt to improve the thread himself. He suggest that the discussion about random voting is derailing the thread, yet doesn't propose anything else to discuss. He makes an extremely safe comment about how the joker shouldn't claim, but has yet to make a legitimate contribution.
ico has shown no signs of scumhunting thus far. He has suggested a policy lynch on kenpachi and called Adam a threat to town for his random vote. However, in both situations he is not going after players he necessarily finds scummy, he is attacking players that are making "stupid" town plays. Stupid town play should be discussed post-game. The only people we should be lynching are those who are most likely mafia.
##Vote ico
Tobberoth has also flew under the radar. I'm not sure I've seen a single player mention him yet. His contributions have been safe and non-aggressive. He plays the noob card and spends most of his time discussing the setup. He jumps on the suspicion cast on kenpachi and VE, but doesn't add anything to the argument himself.
I'm going to sheep with Kitaman, because I think Kita's a beast, and I have to go buy dress pants + pretty button ups. New Job. And I'll never finish reading the thread before lynch time (Omg this game should not of started on Super Bowl Sunday....)
Unless of course I actually do finish reading thread.
Look, I'm sorry guys, I had a walk in interview today and got the job based on my best friend only....I start tomorrow at 9 a.m. training at a location an hour away. I'm sorry for my inactivity as of the moment. Plus the penguin left me on the wrong side of the bridge that piece of shit.
|
kitaman27
United States9244 Posts
|
I feel like Sheth is a bad lynch.
Schworz claimed DT, if he isn't dead soon, he's likely scum of some sort.
I'm not going to vote for myself.
Relative to those, I am comfortable with Ico based off Kitaman and Adam's cases.
Ico looks like he might gain enough votes to become a serious candidate.
##Unvote: rgtheSchworz
##Vote: Ico
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
