EPTBC's Arkham City - Page 40
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
| ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
| ||
|
Kurumi
Poland6130 Posts
mass claim is not an option fuck that | ||
|
Cyber_Cheese
Australia3615 Posts
Will reevaluate and get back to you guys. ##Unvote: Ico | ||
|
wherebugsgo
Japan10647 Posts
I actually can't reconcile whether you're just trolling me or scum, since some things you've said have made like 0 sense. Particularly, your stances on cyber cheese and layabout. On February 08 2012 10:39 Kurumi wrote: Go Sheth. WBG is soft-defending him like he isn't. Also, meta. WBG is a lot more aggressive as town, a little as mafia but. He's REALLY active, like, being always on. I'm defending Sheth because I don't think a mafia member would receive so many votes so fast with no defense at all from anyone. IMO, scum are pushing this lynch. Can you name one person (other than me) who has proclaimed a disapproval of the Sheth lynch? There's too many people on it too fast. You claim I'm bandwagoning, yet you completely ignore the half dozen or so people who bandwagoned Sheth. Look at Sheth's filter from Responsibility: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=295384&user=62163¤tpage=2 For the first day or two Sheth literally does nothing. He apologizes a bit and the ramps up his activity later in the game (at a point after everyone else was completely inactive as well) He received lynch attention from scum, kita. I remember because he was on my team and I recall kita and L both found sheth to be an easy push because he was the newest town player in that game (his only game as town, in fact.) I recall a short discussion in IRC and this post by kita in that game: Well that's disappointing. I was hoping to hear a real case on someone from you GM. Are you sure you're not just trying to match your town meta by accusing me? -_- I've been bringing up Sheth because he is the newest player and most likely to slip up from a random accusation. Go back in my history and I do this nearly every time. You accuse me of voting for someone who no one else is voting for, yet the vote was placed at the beginning of the day. Of course there wouldn't be any votes on him. That doesn't mean that is where my vote is going to stick by the end of the day. Yes, I've been prodding lurkers, but that's because its the people I find suspicious currently. I expect a lot more out of guys like Foolishness, BC and yourself. As for the LSB lynch, I have to go back and read through the thread again. I'll comment once I'm done. Kita straight up admitted (even in thread) that the reason he was pushing sheth was because sheth was new and likely to slip up. This is similar to what has happened here, except people are bandwagoning him a lotmore than they did in Responsibility, because people in this game, on average, are a lot more retarded than the stacked list of names in Responsibility. The simple fact is, right now I believe that Sheth is being pushed by mafia as an easy lynch. I strongly believe we should be getting the fuck off that train and focusing our efforts on other players. As for the 'also, meta' part : what part of my play is consistent with scum meta? How am I bandwagoning? How is bandwagoning part of my scum meta? (correct answers: I'm not and it isn't) How does my inactivity make me scum and how is it part of my scum meta? (correct answers: it doesn't and it isn't) How is "lack of aggressiveness" part of my scum meta? (correct answer: it isn't) I've already explained my lack of activity; I've started school again and I'm more busy this semester, I've been having keyboard issues (so I don't post at school anymore) and my "lack of aggression" is just because I've been working on being less abrasive. Granted, it still comes through sometimes because I can't help but call people retarded when they just straight up do stupid shit. On February 08 2012 10:36 Kurumi wrote: The funny thing is he thinks You're bad and ignored Your posts and said Your posts have nothing of substance without backing it up, then soft-defends Sheth calling him New Town for no reason, because a) Sheth played a lot of RL mafia b) Then, he is not new to the concept of mafia wait this might be a breakthrough I might vote Sheth. Yes, I ignored his posts just like I did in steamship. Guess what? CC was scum in that game and I was a retard for ignoring his posts just because they were bad. Same thing happened in PYP:I until we infiltrated his team and I shot his ass. You accuse me of calling CC bad and scum based on nothing but that's all you've done all game. You're calling me scum based on nothing, you're calling layabout scum based on nothing, and you're accusing me of being scum and saying sheth is a good lynch based on me "soft defending him" when in reality you're doing the exact same thing with cyber_cheese. Sheth has played one game on TL as town. How is playing RL mafia in anyway indicative of the kind of play that's necessary to build up experience as town in this game? On February 08 2012 10:57 Kurumi wrote: I looked at the voting list once again and wbg posted with soft-defense of Sheth and voted CC using bullshit reason "He looks bad town so he must be scum" This is a terrible argument to lynch someone on. This is called bandwagoning. So far, you've just been playing bad. However, this post actually makes me think you might be scum. To everyone else, this is why: Kurumi for a while has just been calling me scum for no reason and then later says it's meta (with no real explanation other than activity and lack of aggression; both of which are inaccurate on meta grounds and not even constructed properly to begin with) then, he accuses me of trying to lynch CC for being bad and soft-defending Sheth. And he says this is a bad argument and that I must die. If you think I'm scum, Kurumi, why is it that at no point have you voted me? Why is it that you haven't built a case? You just constantly seed doubt. It's like you're trying to undermine me. This is actually the thing that I find scummy about Kurumi, but since he's generally this useless I have no idea what to think of it atm. Also barring some crazy vote switch Kurumi has no chance of being lynched today, so I'll have to leave it till tomorrow. Basically, what's scummy here is that Kurumi constantly seeds the thread with the idea that I'm scum but doesn't strongly back it up. Most tellingly, he doesn't back it up with a vote. This suggests to me he's just trying to make me look bad and doesn't actually believe I'm scum, which would imply he is scum. | ||
|
wherebugsgo
Japan10647 Posts
On February 08 2012 11:03 Kurumi wrote: Look: My strongest scum read is WBG. He came to the thread, made Toad case, then changed his mind and made Schworz case making two people change their vote and basically say "I agree", when the discussion on this guy was pretty much dead and irrevelant. Then he goes for CC, again weak case and bullshit argument. No big efforts and backed up by scummy people. Also, his case on Toad was built on basis that Toad had seen nothing wrong with DrH, while WBG does not comment himself on the case. this is all false. My case on Toad was based on the fact that he had no opinions, not that he saw nothing wrong with Dr. H. At no point did I actually legitimately find Dr. H to be scummy, I just used that question as bait. How does changing my mind make me scum? Finally and most importantly: If I am your strongest scum read,why the fuck is your vote on sheth? | ||
|
Kurumi
Poland6130 Posts
| ||
|
Kurumi
Poland6130 Posts
| ||
Liquid`Sheth
United States2095 Posts
| ||
|
kitaman27
United States9244 Posts
| ||
|
Kurumi
Poland6130 Posts
10 votes are not on the main candidates, this is A LOT. I have 2, from BM and Layabout and Kenpachi voted Toad These three people I expect to swap really soon. | ||
|
wherebugsgo
Japan10647 Posts
On February 08 2012 03:32 Kurumi wrote: Im on a party , voting cyber cheese . On February 08 2012 07:34 Kurumi wrote: I am afraid because i have no time and my targets are not exactly the candidates Didnt look into sheth or cc too much is vote wbg if it would matter but it doesnt so i voted qualis because he is my strong scum read too On February 08 2012 10:28 Kurumi wrote: I think that neither Sheth or C_C are mafia. On February 08 2012 10:57 Kurumi wrote: I looked at the voting list once again and wbg posted with soft-defense of Sheth and voted CC using bullshit reason "He looks bad town so he must be scum" This is a terrible argument to lynch someone on. This is called bandwagoning. On February 08 2012 11:03 Kurumi wrote: Look: My strongest scum read is WBG. He came to the thread, made Toad case, then changed his mind and made Schworz case making two people change their vote and basically say "I agree", when the discussion on this guy was pretty much dead and irrevelant. Then he goes for CC, again weak case and bullshit argument. No big efforts and backed up by scummy people. Also, his case on Toad was built on basis that Toad had seen nothing wrong with DrH, while WBG does not comment himself on the case. fuck it, the double standards are way too much for Kurumi to be town. 1. says he's voting CC 2. 4 hours later says he didn't look into CC, would vote me if it mattered but it doesn't (wtf? so he knows a case on me would never fly?) 3. says neither sheth nor cc are mafia 4. tells people to vote sheth just because I defend him (yeah, that's a great reason to vote someone) Oh btw Kurumi, here's a shitty meta argument for you being scum: you're not trolling ##unvote ##vote Kurumi | ||
|
Kurumi
Poland6130 Posts
| ||
|
~OpZ~
United States3652 Posts
On February 08 2012 07:46 Jayjay54 wrote: also, Opz? http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=305850&user=15805 two posts, one is totally nonsense and one softdefend for (blue) rG. Why is he lurking that hardcore? Get in here and post. On February 08 2012 07:53 Toadesstern wrote: yeah opz is the same as hiro. I'd really like him to show up in here and post something. Heavy fos on him as well. Not sure if I already mentioned him but since you did I remembered I wanted to do that as well :. Anyways, he's not a valid option for today. ;-; I didn't know you guys loved me this much....Srsly...I'm a hard ass later on... Jaaaaaackal....Why does everyone mess with me when I don't post, but everyone leaves you alone?! | ||
|
Kurumi
Poland6130 Posts
| ||
|
~OpZ~
United States3652 Posts
I GOTTA SWIM IN THE ICEY WATER....I'm probably gonna freeze to death guys.... | ||
|
wherebugsgo
Japan10647 Posts
On February 08 2012 11:37 Kurumi wrote: Also, compare Your defense of Sheth to my defense of Schworz. yours is shit and mine is actually articulated and thought out? | ||
|
Jackal58
United States4264 Posts
| ||
|
Kurumi
Poland6130 Posts
Kenpachi, I know You're typing my name in vote thread. | ||
|
Liquid`Sheth
United States2095 Posts
| ||
| ||
