• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 13:10
CET 19:10
KST 03:10
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #2310[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over4Dark completes military service, returns to SC217[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Team Liquid Map Contest #23 Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon
Tourneys
soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16) Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
Light introduces ShieldBattery on his YouTube List of top players active on ShieldBattery BW General Discussion BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ NaDa's Body
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) [Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL23] Ro16 Group D - Sunday 21:00 CET [BSL23] Ro16 Group B - Saturday 21:00 CET
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
The PlayStation 5 Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne Nintendo Switch Thread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Artificial Intelligence Thread The Big Programming Thread Trading/Investing Thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 20959 users

European Politico-economics QA Mega-thread - Page 279

Forum Index > General Forum
Post a Reply
Prev 1 277 278 279 280 281 1432 Next
Although this thread does not function under the same strict guidelines as the USPMT, it is still a general practice on TL to provide a source with an explanation on why it is relevant and what purpose it adds to the discussion. Failure to do so will result in a mod action.
Faust852
Profile Joined February 2012
Luxembourg4004 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-11 19:40:38
September 11 2015 19:34 GMT
#5561
On September 12 2015 04:32 Acrofales wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 12 2015 04:27 Ghostcom wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


No, I want to help them in the first safe country they arrive at. I want to spend the money where it does the most good and not only help 6% of the Syrian refugees. Sending them back to the first safe country in which they arrive also ensures that people are not encouraged to take the trip across the Mediterranean in flimsy boats. I want EU (and the world) to start actually supporting the neighbouring countries which are being overrun because they don't have the resources to handle all the refugees on their own.

Agreed. But that doesn't solve, at all the short term problem, which is that Turkey and Lebanon cannot deal with the extreme influx of refugees, circumstances are subhuman and all those who possibly can are paying human traffickers to send them across the sea to Europe. It is going to take a while to change that, and the only humane way of dealing with those who HAVE made it to Europe is by letting them stay while we do indeed help out Jordan, Lebanon and Turkey with the gigantic problem of finding a safe and stable solution for the refugees flooding across their borders.

It would also be great if we could put some effective pressure on other Arabic nations to step the fuck up and do their part.

Subhumane ? The camps in turkey are more humane than any other in the EU.
http://www.euronews.com/2015/09/09/turkish-refugee-camps-for-syrians-set-high-standard/
Turkey is doing the impossible and we are there, being stupid deadbeat, not helping them with funding. Imagine how the €6bn from Germany would have help Turkey.

On September 12 2015 04:34 Acrofales wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 12 2015 04:30 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


Of course we should deal with the one already there. The current quotas are really low for everybody so it won't be really a pain in the ass for anyone (except maybe keeping them to flee in Germany). 130K migrants is nothing, but 1M3 become a problem.
But what we should also do is stopping the insentive of them coming to Europe because it's a supposed paradise. We should also reenforce the European borders, sending aid to Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan. Create safe zones in Syria.
That's the only "good" thing to do, not letting migrants into their illusions of grandeur.

On September 12 2015 04:28 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:21 Ghostcom wrote:
You should have listened more carefully to Rutte then, because you are consistently doing what he warned against: Failing to differentiate between immigrants and refugees.

Huh? I am talking specifically about refugees. Mainly Syrians, but Eritreans, Afghani and Pakistani refugees as well. They don't suddenly become economical immigrants because they managed to cross the border from Turkey to Greece (or further)

Actually yes they do becomes economical migrants once they leave the first safe country they reached.

Reinforcing the borders is fucking stupid. As if an extra border patrol is going to stop people willing to get into leaky rafts that can barely float, and then cross the Mediterranean.

We should accept that people WILL be fleeing into Europe and treat them as human beings, giving them a place to live, while simultaneously fixing the problem at the source, so less people will actually be willing to get into leaky shitboats and hazard a sea crossing.


We actually take them in in the Lybian seas, probably less than 5 miles from the coast. Why not just pushing them back from their points of origin. Especially since the one coming from Lybia aren't for the most part Syrians. Or is it better to let them drown by thousands?

Yup, patrol the sea, and push them back to where they come from, and giving them flyers explaining them how to do it the legal way.

Hungary is using over 3k soldiers to patrol their border now. I'd imagine you'd need less than that at the EU level to patrol the sea.
Ghostcom
Profile Joined March 2010
Denmark4783 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-11 19:39:34
September 11 2015 19:37 GMT
#5562
It's going to be a whole lot quicker to improve the conditions in Lebanon and Jordan than importing the remaining 94% Syrian refugees - and a whole lot safer. Of course the ones that are here now are here and we need to treat them humanely, however that doesn't mean allowing them to roam freely though Europe (in fact Danish police had to forcefully remove some dehydrated kids and bring them.to the hospital before bringing them back to their parents).

EDIT: We really should be doing all we can to prevent people from getting in boats and trying to cross the Mediterranean. Not preventing it is akin to encouraging suicidal behaviour.
WhiteDog
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
France8650 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-11 19:49:46
September 11 2015 19:39 GMT
#5563
How do you know? Of course I am ignorant about Marx; I am not convinced however that I am more ignorant about Marx than you are. Even presuming this to be the case, why does it matter? Why the defensiveness about Marx? Why the sneering at Tocqueville? Where are the erudite arguments to support your alleged insights? If you don't have any arguments, why bother?

Such hypocrisy. I pointed out what I thought was a ridiculous comment in your quote - because no one with a little objectivity could seriously say that Tocqueville is superior to Marx. Turns out your answer to that is a ridiculous and caricatural answer about orthodox marxism, reassuring myself that you are ignorant about Marx - and no I'm not ignorant about him.

Except I clarified that the asymmetry I was discussion was not German vs. Polish, but generic Western idealism vs. Third World realities. Such "cultural racism" is not the impression of a trained line of discourse. Some of us have actually lived in vastly different kinds of societies, and have a developed awareness of different kinds of humanity, and some of the psychological, ethical and social tendencies unique to a specific cultural climate. I am not interested in pursuing an alternative theoretical dialectic so long as my obligation is to the truth as I have seen and experienced it, and not to arbitrary philosophical fads.

You might have clarified, my point stands. Assymetry in compassion is not the right way to describe it. Compassion is a universally felt feeling - it's a humane trait, not something that appear in specific cultural context.

By the way, what you describe (how specific "culturate climate" define nations' emotions) is what I would describe as "arbitrary philosophical fads" - a psychologisation of european politics.
"every time WhiteDog overuses the word "seriously" in a comment I can make an observation on his fragile emotional state." MoltkeWarding
Acrofales
Profile Joined August 2010
Spain18503 Posts
September 11 2015 19:41 GMT
#5564
On September 12 2015 04:34 Faust852 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 12 2015 04:32 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:27 Ghostcom wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


No, I want to help them in the first safe country they arrive at. I want to spend the money where it does the most good and not only help 6% of the Syrian refugees. Sending them back to the first safe country in which they arrive also ensures that people are not encouraged to take the trip across the Mediterranean in flimsy boats. I want EU (and the world) to start actually supporting the neighbouring countries which are being overrun because they don't have the resources to handle all the refugees on their own.

Agreed. But that doesn't solve, at all the short term problem, which is that Turkey and Lebanon cannot deal with the extreme influx of refugees, circumstances are subhuman and all those who possibly can are paying human traffickers to send them across the sea to Europe. It is going to take a while to change that, and the only humane way of dealing with those who HAVE made it to Europe is by letting them stay while we do indeed help out Jordan, Lebanon and Turkey with the gigantic problem of finding a safe and stable solution for the refugees flooding across their borders.

It would also be great if we could put some effective pressure on other Arabic nations to step the fuck up and do their part.

Subhumane ? The camps in turkey are more humane than any other in the EU.
http://www.euronews.com/2015/09/09/turkish-refugee-camps-for-syrians-set-high-standard/
Turkey is doing the impossible and we are there, being stupid deadbeat, not helping them with funding. Imagine how the €6bn from Germany would have help Turkey.

Show nested quote +
On September 12 2015 04:34 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:30 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


Of course we should deal with the one already there. The current quotas are really low for everybody so it won't be really a pain in the ass for anyone (except maybe keeping them to flee in Germany). 130K migrants is nothing, but 1M3 become a problem.
But what we should also do is stopping the insentive of them coming to Europe because it's a supposed paradise. We should also reenforce the European borders, sending aid to Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan. Create safe zones in Syria.
That's the only "good" thing to do, not letting migrants into their illusions of grandeur.

On September 12 2015 04:28 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:21 Ghostcom wrote:
You should have listened more carefully to Rutte then, because you are consistently doing what he warned against: Failing to differentiate between immigrants and refugees.

Huh? I am talking specifically about refugees. Mainly Syrians, but Eritreans, Afghani and Pakistani refugees as well. They don't suddenly become economical immigrants because they managed to cross the border from Turkey to Greece (or further)

Actually yes they do becomes economical migrants once they leave the first safe country they reached.

Reinforcing the borders is fucking stupid. As if an extra border patrol is going to stop people willing to get into leaky rafts that can barely float, and then cross the Mediterranean.

We should accept that people WILL be fleeing into Europe and treat them as human beings, giving them a place to live, while simultaneously fixing the problem at the source, so less people will actually be willing to get into leaky shitboats and hazard a sea crossing.


We actually take them in in the Lybian seas, probably less than 5 miles from the coast. Why not just pushing them back from their points of origin. Especially since the one coming from Lybia aren't for the most part Syrians.

Yup, patrol the sea, and push them back to where they come from, and giving them flyers explaining them how to do it the legal way.

Hungary is using over 3k soldiers to patrol their border now. I'd imagine you'd need less than that at the EU level to patrol the sea.

If you had read that article to the end, you would have seen that only 1/10th of the Syrian refugees are finding homes in camps. The rest aren't in nearly as nice circumstances. I agree with you that we need more camps like that one! As you read in that article, the vast majority of those people don't even want to come to Europe.
Faust852
Profile Joined February 2012
Luxembourg4004 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-11 19:54:03
September 11 2015 19:52 GMT
#5565
On September 12 2015 04:41 Acrofales wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 12 2015 04:34 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:32 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:27 Ghostcom wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


No, I want to help them in the first safe country they arrive at. I want to spend the money where it does the most good and not only help 6% of the Syrian refugees. Sending them back to the first safe country in which they arrive also ensures that people are not encouraged to take the trip across the Mediterranean in flimsy boats. I want EU (and the world) to start actually supporting the neighbouring countries which are being overrun because they don't have the resources to handle all the refugees on their own.

Agreed. But that doesn't solve, at all the short term problem, which is that Turkey and Lebanon cannot deal with the extreme influx of refugees, circumstances are subhuman and all those who possibly can are paying human traffickers to send them across the sea to Europe. It is going to take a while to change that, and the only humane way of dealing with those who HAVE made it to Europe is by letting them stay while we do indeed help out Jordan, Lebanon and Turkey with the gigantic problem of finding a safe and stable solution for the refugees flooding across their borders.

It would also be great if we could put some effective pressure on other Arabic nations to step the fuck up and do their part.

Subhumane ? The camps in turkey are more humane than any other in the EU.
http://www.euronews.com/2015/09/09/turkish-refugee-camps-for-syrians-set-high-standard/
Turkey is doing the impossible and we are there, being stupid deadbeat, not helping them with funding. Imagine how the €6bn from Germany would have help Turkey.

On September 12 2015 04:34 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:30 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


Of course we should deal with the one already there. The current quotas are really low for everybody so it won't be really a pain in the ass for anyone (except maybe keeping them to flee in Germany). 130K migrants is nothing, but 1M3 become a problem.
But what we should also do is stopping the insentive of them coming to Europe because it's a supposed paradise. We should also reenforce the European borders, sending aid to Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan. Create safe zones in Syria.
That's the only "good" thing to do, not letting migrants into their illusions of grandeur.

On September 12 2015 04:28 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:21 Ghostcom wrote:
You should have listened more carefully to Rutte then, because you are consistently doing what he warned against: Failing to differentiate between immigrants and refugees.

Huh? I am talking specifically about refugees. Mainly Syrians, but Eritreans, Afghani and Pakistani refugees as well. They don't suddenly become economical immigrants because they managed to cross the border from Turkey to Greece (or further)

Actually yes they do becomes economical migrants once they leave the first safe country they reached.

Reinforcing the borders is fucking stupid. As if an extra border patrol is going to stop people willing to get into leaky rafts that can barely float, and then cross the Mediterranean.

We should accept that people WILL be fleeing into Europe and treat them as human beings, giving them a place to live, while simultaneously fixing the problem at the source, so less people will actually be willing to get into leaky shitboats and hazard a sea crossing.


We actually take them in in the Lybian seas, probably less than 5 miles from the coast. Why not just pushing them back from their points of origin. Especially since the one coming from Lybia aren't for the most part Syrians.

Yup, patrol the sea, and push them back to where they come from, and giving them flyers explaining them how to do it the legal way.

Hungary is using over 3k soldiers to patrol their border now. I'd imagine you'd need less than that at the EU level to patrol the sea.

If you had read that article to the end, you would have seen that only 1/10th of the Syrian refugees are finding homes in camps. The rest aren't in nearly as nice circumstances. I agree with you that we need more camps like that one! As you read in that article, the vast majority of those people don't even want to come to Europe.


And that's why we should vastly invest in these kind of camp in Syria's neighbours. It will cost much less to the EU, wont disturb the roads/transports. It will appaises the septics, will be easier for the refugee to integrate and transit back to Syria too.
You would reduce drastically the smugling market, the number of deaths, the racists riots, etc...
I mean, Australia will use $700m for 20k refugees, wtf. It will cost €6bn for Germany this year alone. I wonder how many hundred of thousand you could help with this money.
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
September 11 2015 19:59 GMT
#5566
On September 12 2015 04:52 Faust852 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 12 2015 04:41 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:34 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:32 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:27 Ghostcom wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


No, I want to help them in the first safe country they arrive at. I want to spend the money where it does the most good and not only help 6% of the Syrian refugees. Sending them back to the first safe country in which they arrive also ensures that people are not encouraged to take the trip across the Mediterranean in flimsy boats. I want EU (and the world) to start actually supporting the neighbouring countries which are being overrun because they don't have the resources to handle all the refugees on their own.

Agreed. But that doesn't solve, at all the short term problem, which is that Turkey and Lebanon cannot deal with the extreme influx of refugees, circumstances are subhuman and all those who possibly can are paying human traffickers to send them across the sea to Europe. It is going to take a while to change that, and the only humane way of dealing with those who HAVE made it to Europe is by letting them stay while we do indeed help out Jordan, Lebanon and Turkey with the gigantic problem of finding a safe and stable solution for the refugees flooding across their borders.

It would also be great if we could put some effective pressure on other Arabic nations to step the fuck up and do their part.

Subhumane ? The camps in turkey are more humane than any other in the EU.
http://www.euronews.com/2015/09/09/turkish-refugee-camps-for-syrians-set-high-standard/
Turkey is doing the impossible and we are there, being stupid deadbeat, not helping them with funding. Imagine how the €6bn from Germany would have help Turkey.

On September 12 2015 04:34 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:30 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


Of course we should deal with the one already there. The current quotas are really low for everybody so it won't be really a pain in the ass for anyone (except maybe keeping them to flee in Germany). 130K migrants is nothing, but 1M3 become a problem.
But what we should also do is stopping the insentive of them coming to Europe because it's a supposed paradise. We should also reenforce the European borders, sending aid to Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan. Create safe zones in Syria.
That's the only "good" thing to do, not letting migrants into their illusions of grandeur.

On September 12 2015 04:28 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:21 Ghostcom wrote:
You should have listened more carefully to Rutte then, because you are consistently doing what he warned against: Failing to differentiate between immigrants and refugees.

Huh? I am talking specifically about refugees. Mainly Syrians, but Eritreans, Afghani and Pakistani refugees as well. They don't suddenly become economical immigrants because they managed to cross the border from Turkey to Greece (or further)

Actually yes they do becomes economical migrants once they leave the first safe country they reached.

Reinforcing the borders is fucking stupid. As if an extra border patrol is going to stop people willing to get into leaky rafts that can barely float, and then cross the Mediterranean.

We should accept that people WILL be fleeing into Europe and treat them as human beings, giving them a place to live, while simultaneously fixing the problem at the source, so less people will actually be willing to get into leaky shitboats and hazard a sea crossing.


We actually take them in in the Lybian seas, probably less than 5 miles from the coast. Why not just pushing them back from their points of origin. Especially since the one coming from Lybia aren't for the most part Syrians.

Yup, patrol the sea, and push them back to where they come from, and giving them flyers explaining them how to do it the legal way.

Hungary is using over 3k soldiers to patrol their border now. I'd imagine you'd need less than that at the EU level to patrol the sea.

If you had read that article to the end, you would have seen that only 1/10th of the Syrian refugees are finding homes in camps. The rest aren't in nearly as nice circumstances. I agree with you that we need more camps like that one! As you read in that article, the vast majority of those people don't even want to come to Europe.


And that's why we should vastly invest in these kind of camp in Syria's neighbours. It will cost much less to the EU, wont disturb the roads/transports. It will appaises the septics, will be easier for the refugee to integrate and transit back to Syria too.
You would reduce drastically the smugling market, the number of deaths, the racists riots, etc...
I mean, Australia will use $700m for 20k refugees, wtf. It will cost €6bn for Germany this year alone. I wonder how many hundred of thousand you could help with this money.

I am 100% sure Turkey would be all about dealing with all the refugees in massive camps. Policing them and dealing with the crime and other issues. I especially like how you think it would reduce deaths and riots. Literally no flaws with that plan.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
Faust852
Profile Joined February 2012
Luxembourg4004 Posts
September 11 2015 20:04 GMT
#5567
On September 12 2015 04:59 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 12 2015 04:52 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:41 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:34 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:32 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:27 Ghostcom wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


No, I want to help them in the first safe country they arrive at. I want to spend the money where it does the most good and not only help 6% of the Syrian refugees. Sending them back to the first safe country in which they arrive also ensures that people are not encouraged to take the trip across the Mediterranean in flimsy boats. I want EU (and the world) to start actually supporting the neighbouring countries which are being overrun because they don't have the resources to handle all the refugees on their own.

Agreed. But that doesn't solve, at all the short term problem, which is that Turkey and Lebanon cannot deal with the extreme influx of refugees, circumstances are subhuman and all those who possibly can are paying human traffickers to send them across the sea to Europe. It is going to take a while to change that, and the only humane way of dealing with those who HAVE made it to Europe is by letting them stay while we do indeed help out Jordan, Lebanon and Turkey with the gigantic problem of finding a safe and stable solution for the refugees flooding across their borders.

It would also be great if we could put some effective pressure on other Arabic nations to step the fuck up and do their part.

Subhumane ? The camps in turkey are more humane than any other in the EU.
http://www.euronews.com/2015/09/09/turkish-refugee-camps-for-syrians-set-high-standard/
Turkey is doing the impossible and we are there, being stupid deadbeat, not helping them with funding. Imagine how the €6bn from Germany would have help Turkey.

On September 12 2015 04:34 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:30 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


Of course we should deal with the one already there. The current quotas are really low for everybody so it won't be really a pain in the ass for anyone (except maybe keeping them to flee in Germany). 130K migrants is nothing, but 1M3 become a problem.
But what we should also do is stopping the insentive of them coming to Europe because it's a supposed paradise. We should also reenforce the European borders, sending aid to Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan. Create safe zones in Syria.
That's the only "good" thing to do, not letting migrants into their illusions of grandeur.

On September 12 2015 04:28 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:21 Ghostcom wrote:
You should have listened more carefully to Rutte then, because you are consistently doing what he warned against: Failing to differentiate between immigrants and refugees.

Huh? I am talking specifically about refugees. Mainly Syrians, but Eritreans, Afghani and Pakistani refugees as well. They don't suddenly become economical immigrants because they managed to cross the border from Turkey to Greece (or further)

Actually yes they do becomes economical migrants once they leave the first safe country they reached.

Reinforcing the borders is fucking stupid. As if an extra border patrol is going to stop people willing to get into leaky rafts that can barely float, and then cross the Mediterranean.

We should accept that people WILL be fleeing into Europe and treat them as human beings, giving them a place to live, while simultaneously fixing the problem at the source, so less people will actually be willing to get into leaky shitboats and hazard a sea crossing.


We actually take them in in the Lybian seas, probably less than 5 miles from the coast. Why not just pushing them back from their points of origin. Especially since the one coming from Lybia aren't for the most part Syrians.

Yup, patrol the sea, and push them back to where they come from, and giving them flyers explaining them how to do it the legal way.

Hungary is using over 3k soldiers to patrol their border now. I'd imagine you'd need less than that at the EU level to patrol the sea.

If you had read that article to the end, you would have seen that only 1/10th of the Syrian refugees are finding homes in camps. The rest aren't in nearly as nice circumstances. I agree with you that we need more camps like that one! As you read in that article, the vast majority of those people don't even want to come to Europe.


And that's why we should vastly invest in these kind of camp in Syria's neighbours. It will cost much less to the EU, wont disturb the roads/transports. It will appaises the septics, will be easier for the refugee to integrate and transit back to Syria too.
You would reduce drastically the smugling market, the number of deaths, the racists riots, etc...
I mean, Australia will use $700m for 20k refugees, wtf. It will cost €6bn for Germany this year alone. I wonder how many hundred of thousand you could help with this money.

I am 100% sure Turkey would be all about dealing with all the refugees in massive camps. Policing them and dealing with the crime and other issues. I especially like how you think it would reduce deaths and riots. Literally no flaws with that plan.

Doesn't seem to be a huge deal to Turkey right now. It costs them money though so it might become one if we don't help.
Also I already said it's be much better to create safe zones in Syria but you like to cherry pick what I say anyway.
Acrofales
Profile Joined August 2010
Spain18503 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-11 20:21:54
September 11 2015 20:05 GMT
#5568
On September 12 2015 04:37 Ghostcom wrote:
It's going to be a whole lot quicker to improve the conditions in Lebanon and Jordan than importing the remaining 94% Syrian refugees - and a whole lot safer. Of course the ones that are here now are here and we need to treat them humanely, however that doesn't mean allowing them to roam freely though Europe (in fact Danish police had to forcefully remove some dehydrated kids and bring them.to the hospital before bringing them back to their parents).

EDIT: We really should be doing all we can to prevent people from getting in boats and trying to cross the Mediterranean. Not preventing it is akin to encouraging suicidal behaviour.

Yes, but it is far harder. The people fleeing through Lybia are also refugees. It's not as if South Sudan or Eritrea are for the most part any better than Syria. But Lybia is an unstable hellhole, and the only way we can stop people from using the absolute shits that are human traffickers is by working with other countries in the region (Egypt mostly) to offer a humane alternative.

EDIT: forgot to link a good article about the Lybia situation: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/apr/17/death-mediterranean-africans-migrant-sea-libya
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
September 11 2015 20:08 GMT
#5569
On September 12 2015 05:04 Faust852 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 12 2015 04:59 Plansix wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:52 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:41 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:34 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:32 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:27 Ghostcom wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


No, I want to help them in the first safe country they arrive at. I want to spend the money where it does the most good and not only help 6% of the Syrian refugees. Sending them back to the first safe country in which they arrive also ensures that people are not encouraged to take the trip across the Mediterranean in flimsy boats. I want EU (and the world) to start actually supporting the neighbouring countries which are being overrun because they don't have the resources to handle all the refugees on their own.

Agreed. But that doesn't solve, at all the short term problem, which is that Turkey and Lebanon cannot deal with the extreme influx of refugees, circumstances are subhuman and all those who possibly can are paying human traffickers to send them across the sea to Europe. It is going to take a while to change that, and the only humane way of dealing with those who HAVE made it to Europe is by letting them stay while we do indeed help out Jordan, Lebanon and Turkey with the gigantic problem of finding a safe and stable solution for the refugees flooding across their borders.

It would also be great if we could put some effective pressure on other Arabic nations to step the fuck up and do their part.

Subhumane ? The camps in turkey are more humane than any other in the EU.
http://www.euronews.com/2015/09/09/turkish-refugee-camps-for-syrians-set-high-standard/
Turkey is doing the impossible and we are there, being stupid deadbeat, not helping them with funding. Imagine how the €6bn from Germany would have help Turkey.

On September 12 2015 04:34 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:30 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


Of course we should deal with the one already there. The current quotas are really low for everybody so it won't be really a pain in the ass for anyone (except maybe keeping them to flee in Germany). 130K migrants is nothing, but 1M3 become a problem.
But what we should also do is stopping the insentive of them coming to Europe because it's a supposed paradise. We should also reenforce the European borders, sending aid to Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan. Create safe zones in Syria.
That's the only "good" thing to do, not letting migrants into their illusions of grandeur.

On September 12 2015 04:28 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:21 Ghostcom wrote:
You should have listened more carefully to Rutte then, because you are consistently doing what he warned against: Failing to differentiate between immigrants and refugees.

Huh? I am talking specifically about refugees. Mainly Syrians, but Eritreans, Afghani and Pakistani refugees as well. They don't suddenly become economical immigrants because they managed to cross the border from Turkey to Greece (or further)

Actually yes they do becomes economical migrants once they leave the first safe country they reached.

Reinforcing the borders is fucking stupid. As if an extra border patrol is going to stop people willing to get into leaky rafts that can barely float, and then cross the Mediterranean.

We should accept that people WILL be fleeing into Europe and treat them as human beings, giving them a place to live, while simultaneously fixing the problem at the source, so less people will actually be willing to get into leaky shitboats and hazard a sea crossing.


We actually take them in in the Lybian seas, probably less than 5 miles from the coast. Why not just pushing them back from their points of origin. Especially since the one coming from Lybia aren't for the most part Syrians.

Yup, patrol the sea, and push them back to where they come from, and giving them flyers explaining them how to do it the legal way.

Hungary is using over 3k soldiers to patrol their border now. I'd imagine you'd need less than that at the EU level to patrol the sea.

If you had read that article to the end, you would have seen that only 1/10th of the Syrian refugees are finding homes in camps. The rest aren't in nearly as nice circumstances. I agree with you that we need more camps like that one! As you read in that article, the vast majority of those people don't even want to come to Europe.


And that's why we should vastly invest in these kind of camp in Syria's neighbours. It will cost much less to the EU, wont disturb the roads/transports. It will appaises the septics, will be easier for the refugee to integrate and transit back to Syria too.
You would reduce drastically the smugling market, the number of deaths, the racists riots, etc...
I mean, Australia will use $700m for 20k refugees, wtf. It will cost €6bn for Germany this year alone. I wonder how many hundred of thousand you could help with this money.

I am 100% sure Turkey would be all about dealing with all the refugees in massive camps. Policing them and dealing with the crime and other issues. I especially like how you think it would reduce deaths and riots. Literally no flaws with that plan.

Doesn't seem to be a huge deal to Turkey right now. It costs them money though so it might become one if we don't help.
Also I already said it's be much better to create safe zones in Syria but you like to cherry pick what I say anyway.

That would involve sending UN troops to Syria to create safe zone. I fail to see how that is cheaper than the current plan.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
Acrofales
Profile Joined August 2010
Spain18503 Posts
September 11 2015 20:10 GMT
#5570
On September 12 2015 04:59 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 12 2015 04:52 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:41 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:34 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:32 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:27 Ghostcom wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


No, I want to help them in the first safe country they arrive at. I want to spend the money where it does the most good and not only help 6% of the Syrian refugees. Sending them back to the first safe country in which they arrive also ensures that people are not encouraged to take the trip across the Mediterranean in flimsy boats. I want EU (and the world) to start actually supporting the neighbouring countries which are being overrun because they don't have the resources to handle all the refugees on their own.

Agreed. But that doesn't solve, at all the short term problem, which is that Turkey and Lebanon cannot deal with the extreme influx of refugees, circumstances are subhuman and all those who possibly can are paying human traffickers to send them across the sea to Europe. It is going to take a while to change that, and the only humane way of dealing with those who HAVE made it to Europe is by letting them stay while we do indeed help out Jordan, Lebanon and Turkey with the gigantic problem of finding a safe and stable solution for the refugees flooding across their borders.

It would also be great if we could put some effective pressure on other Arabic nations to step the fuck up and do their part.

Subhumane ? The camps in turkey are more humane than any other in the EU.
http://www.euronews.com/2015/09/09/turkish-refugee-camps-for-syrians-set-high-standard/
Turkey is doing the impossible and we are there, being stupid deadbeat, not helping them with funding. Imagine how the €6bn from Germany would have help Turkey.

On September 12 2015 04:34 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:30 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


Of course we should deal with the one already there. The current quotas are really low for everybody so it won't be really a pain in the ass for anyone (except maybe keeping them to flee in Germany). 130K migrants is nothing, but 1M3 become a problem.
But what we should also do is stopping the insentive of them coming to Europe because it's a supposed paradise. We should also reenforce the European borders, sending aid to Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan. Create safe zones in Syria.
That's the only "good" thing to do, not letting migrants into their illusions of grandeur.

On September 12 2015 04:28 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:21 Ghostcom wrote:
You should have listened more carefully to Rutte then, because you are consistently doing what he warned against: Failing to differentiate between immigrants and refugees.

Huh? I am talking specifically about refugees. Mainly Syrians, but Eritreans, Afghani and Pakistani refugees as well. They don't suddenly become economical immigrants because they managed to cross the border from Turkey to Greece (or further)

Actually yes they do becomes economical migrants once they leave the first safe country they reached.

Reinforcing the borders is fucking stupid. As if an extra border patrol is going to stop people willing to get into leaky rafts that can barely float, and then cross the Mediterranean.

We should accept that people WILL be fleeing into Europe and treat them as human beings, giving them a place to live, while simultaneously fixing the problem at the source, so less people will actually be willing to get into leaky shitboats and hazard a sea crossing.


We actually take them in in the Lybian seas, probably less than 5 miles from the coast. Why not just pushing them back from their points of origin. Especially since the one coming from Lybia aren't for the most part Syrians.

Yup, patrol the sea, and push them back to where they come from, and giving them flyers explaining them how to do it the legal way.

Hungary is using over 3k soldiers to patrol their border now. I'd imagine you'd need less than that at the EU level to patrol the sea.

If you had read that article to the end, you would have seen that only 1/10th of the Syrian refugees are finding homes in camps. The rest aren't in nearly as nice circumstances. I agree with you that we need more camps like that one! As you read in that article, the vast majority of those people don't even want to come to Europe.


And that's why we should vastly invest in these kind of camp in Syria's neighbours. It will cost much less to the EU, wont disturb the roads/transports. It will appaises the septics, will be easier for the refugee to integrate and transit back to Syria too.
You would reduce drastically the smugling market, the number of deaths, the racists riots, etc...
I mean, Australia will use $700m for 20k refugees, wtf. It will cost €6bn for Germany this year alone. I wonder how many hundred of thousand you could help with this money.

I am 100% sure Turkey would be all about dealing with all the refugees in massive camps. Policing them and dealing with the crime and other issues. I especially like how you think it would reduce deaths and riots. Literally no flaws with that plan.

I'm not quite sure why you think Turkey unable to organize good, safe and humane refugee camps, given that they are already doing so. Whether we can realistically create the scale-up needed? I don't know. But I don't really know why they'd be worse off in Turkey (or Jordan or Lebanon, assuming Lebanon doesn't destabilize with the next elections). I think it's the best plan for everybody involved if capacity on site is extended to deal with as many people as possible, and overflow that still comes to Europe is offered asylum there too.
Acrofales
Profile Joined August 2010
Spain18503 Posts
September 11 2015 20:11 GMT
#5571
On September 12 2015 05:08 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 12 2015 05:04 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:59 Plansix wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:52 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:41 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:34 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:32 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:27 Ghostcom wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


No, I want to help them in the first safe country they arrive at. I want to spend the money where it does the most good and not only help 6% of the Syrian refugees. Sending them back to the first safe country in which they arrive also ensures that people are not encouraged to take the trip across the Mediterranean in flimsy boats. I want EU (and the world) to start actually supporting the neighbouring countries which are being overrun because they don't have the resources to handle all the refugees on their own.

Agreed. But that doesn't solve, at all the short term problem, which is that Turkey and Lebanon cannot deal with the extreme influx of refugees, circumstances are subhuman and all those who possibly can are paying human traffickers to send them across the sea to Europe. It is going to take a while to change that, and the only humane way of dealing with those who HAVE made it to Europe is by letting them stay while we do indeed help out Jordan, Lebanon and Turkey with the gigantic problem of finding a safe and stable solution for the refugees flooding across their borders.

It would also be great if we could put some effective pressure on other Arabic nations to step the fuck up and do their part.

Subhumane ? The camps in turkey are more humane than any other in the EU.
http://www.euronews.com/2015/09/09/turkish-refugee-camps-for-syrians-set-high-standard/
Turkey is doing the impossible and we are there, being stupid deadbeat, not helping them with funding. Imagine how the €6bn from Germany would have help Turkey.

On September 12 2015 04:34 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:30 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


Of course we should deal with the one already there. The current quotas are really low for everybody so it won't be really a pain in the ass for anyone (except maybe keeping them to flee in Germany). 130K migrants is nothing, but 1M3 become a problem.
But what we should also do is stopping the insentive of them coming to Europe because it's a supposed paradise. We should also reenforce the European borders, sending aid to Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan. Create safe zones in Syria.
That's the only "good" thing to do, not letting migrants into their illusions of grandeur.

On September 12 2015 04:28 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:21 Ghostcom wrote:
You should have listened more carefully to Rutte then, because you are consistently doing what he warned against: Failing to differentiate between immigrants and refugees.

Huh? I am talking specifically about refugees. Mainly Syrians, but Eritreans, Afghani and Pakistani refugees as well. They don't suddenly become economical immigrants because they managed to cross the border from Turkey to Greece (or further)

Actually yes they do becomes economical migrants once they leave the first safe country they reached.

Reinforcing the borders is fucking stupid. As if an extra border patrol is going to stop people willing to get into leaky rafts that can barely float, and then cross the Mediterranean.

We should accept that people WILL be fleeing into Europe and treat them as human beings, giving them a place to live, while simultaneously fixing the problem at the source, so less people will actually be willing to get into leaky shitboats and hazard a sea crossing.


We actually take them in in the Lybian seas, probably less than 5 miles from the coast. Why not just pushing them back from their points of origin. Especially since the one coming from Lybia aren't for the most part Syrians.

Yup, patrol the sea, and push them back to where they come from, and giving them flyers explaining them how to do it the legal way.

Hungary is using over 3k soldiers to patrol their border now. I'd imagine you'd need less than that at the EU level to patrol the sea.

If you had read that article to the end, you would have seen that only 1/10th of the Syrian refugees are finding homes in camps. The rest aren't in nearly as nice circumstances. I agree with you that we need more camps like that one! As you read in that article, the vast majority of those people don't even want to come to Europe.


And that's why we should vastly invest in these kind of camp in Syria's neighbours. It will cost much less to the EU, wont disturb the roads/transports. It will appaises the septics, will be easier for the refugee to integrate and transit back to Syria too.
You would reduce drastically the smugling market, the number of deaths, the racists riots, etc...
I mean, Australia will use $700m for 20k refugees, wtf. It will cost €6bn for Germany this year alone. I wonder how many hundred of thousand you could help with this money.

I am 100% sure Turkey would be all about dealing with all the refugees in massive camps. Policing them and dealing with the crime and other issues. I especially like how you think it would reduce deaths and riots. Literally no flaws with that plan.

Doesn't seem to be a huge deal to Turkey right now. It costs them money though so it might become one if we don't help.
Also I already said it's be much better to create safe zones in Syria but you like to cherry pick what I say anyway.

That would involve sending UN troops to Syria to create safe zone. I fail to see how that is cheaper than the current plan.

No? It just involves creating large refugee camps styled after the current ones in different regions of Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan. It might involve UN (or more likely, NATO) forces on the borders to stop ISIS or PKK terrorists from bombing refugee camps, though.
Faust852
Profile Joined February 2012
Luxembourg4004 Posts
September 11 2015 20:16 GMT
#5572
On September 12 2015 05:08 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 12 2015 05:04 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:59 Plansix wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:52 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:41 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:34 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:32 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:27 Ghostcom wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


No, I want to help them in the first safe country they arrive at. I want to spend the money where it does the most good and not only help 6% of the Syrian refugees. Sending them back to the first safe country in which they arrive also ensures that people are not encouraged to take the trip across the Mediterranean in flimsy boats. I want EU (and the world) to start actually supporting the neighbouring countries which are being overrun because they don't have the resources to handle all the refugees on their own.

Agreed. But that doesn't solve, at all the short term problem, which is that Turkey and Lebanon cannot deal with the extreme influx of refugees, circumstances are subhuman and all those who possibly can are paying human traffickers to send them across the sea to Europe. It is going to take a while to change that, and the only humane way of dealing with those who HAVE made it to Europe is by letting them stay while we do indeed help out Jordan, Lebanon and Turkey with the gigantic problem of finding a safe and stable solution for the refugees flooding across their borders.

It would also be great if we could put some effective pressure on other Arabic nations to step the fuck up and do their part.

Subhumane ? The camps in turkey are more humane than any other in the EU.
http://www.euronews.com/2015/09/09/turkish-refugee-camps-for-syrians-set-high-standard/
Turkey is doing the impossible and we are there, being stupid deadbeat, not helping them with funding. Imagine how the €6bn from Germany would have help Turkey.

On September 12 2015 04:34 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:30 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:16 Ghostcom wrote:
The real issue is that not all those currently walking through EU are actually Syrians. Then there are the Syrians demanding to go to Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Norway (yes, demanding) at which point they can hardly be considered refugees and they are actually resulting in less aid being send to those who can't afford to pay the human traffickers.

What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


Of course we should deal with the one already there. The current quotas are really low for everybody so it won't be really a pain in the ass for anyone (except maybe keeping them to flee in Germany). 130K migrants is nothing, but 1M3 become a problem.
But what we should also do is stopping the insentive of them coming to Europe because it's a supposed paradise. We should also reenforce the European borders, sending aid to Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan. Create safe zones in Syria.
That's the only "good" thing to do, not letting migrants into their illusions of grandeur.

On September 12 2015 04:28 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:21 Ghostcom wrote:
You should have listened more carefully to Rutte then, because you are consistently doing what he warned against: Failing to differentiate between immigrants and refugees.

Huh? I am talking specifically about refugees. Mainly Syrians, but Eritreans, Afghani and Pakistani refugees as well. They don't suddenly become economical immigrants because they managed to cross the border from Turkey to Greece (or further)

Actually yes they do becomes economical migrants once they leave the first safe country they reached.

Reinforcing the borders is fucking stupid. As if an extra border patrol is going to stop people willing to get into leaky rafts that can barely float, and then cross the Mediterranean.

We should accept that people WILL be fleeing into Europe and treat them as human beings, giving them a place to live, while simultaneously fixing the problem at the source, so less people will actually be willing to get into leaky shitboats and hazard a sea crossing.


We actually take them in in the Lybian seas, probably less than 5 miles from the coast. Why not just pushing them back from their points of origin. Especially since the one coming from Lybia aren't for the most part Syrians.

Yup, patrol the sea, and push them back to where they come from, and giving them flyers explaining them how to do it the legal way.

Hungary is using over 3k soldiers to patrol their border now. I'd imagine you'd need less than that at the EU level to patrol the sea.

If you had read that article to the end, you would have seen that only 1/10th of the Syrian refugees are finding homes in camps. The rest aren't in nearly as nice circumstances. I agree with you that we need more camps like that one! As you read in that article, the vast majority of those people don't even want to come to Europe.


And that's why we should vastly invest in these kind of camp in Syria's neighbours. It will cost much less to the EU, wont disturb the roads/transports. It will appaises the septics, will be easier for the refugee to integrate and transit back to Syria too.
You would reduce drastically the smugling market, the number of deaths, the racists riots, etc...
I mean, Australia will use $700m for 20k refugees, wtf. It will cost €6bn for Germany this year alone. I wonder how many hundred of thousand you could help with this money.

I am 100% sure Turkey would be all about dealing with all the refugees in massive camps. Policing them and dealing with the crime and other issues. I especially like how you think it would reduce deaths and riots. Literally no flaws with that plan.

Doesn't seem to be a huge deal to Turkey right now. It costs them money though so it might become one if we don't help.
Also I already said it's be much better to create safe zones in Syria but you like to cherry pick what I say anyway.

That would involve sending UN troops to Syria to create safe zone. I fail to see how that is cheaper than the current plan.

The great humanist you are should approve a NATO intervention in Syria though. There are probably over 300k deaths and rising, a military intervention will drastically reduce the future human cost. Even if it were to cost a shit ton, it's the most human thing to do ?

Anyway that wasn't my point, You just need to create safe zone, not going in all out war. You don't need 50k soldiers rooming Syrias land to create these havens.
Another way of doing it is financing already at war countries, like Turkey .
MoltkeWarding
Profile Joined November 2003
5195 Posts
September 11 2015 20:18 GMT
#5573
Such hypocrisy. I pointed out what I thought was a ridiculous comment in your quote - because no one with a little objectivity could seriously say that Tocqueville is superior to Marx. Turns out your answer to that is a ridiculous and caricatural answer about orthodox marxism, reassuring myself that you are ignorant about Marx - and no I'm not ignorant about him.


I read the Communist Manifesto by the time I was 13, the Capital by 16, the German Ideology by 18. Long before then, I grew up and began reading serious books, because no one with a little brain could take Marx seriously after puberty. Turns out your answer is a pointless exercise in chest-thumping to disguise your insecurity. I know more than you about Marx. And Tocqueville. Hypocrite. You’re ignorant.

You might have clarified, my point stands. Assymetry in compassion is not the right way to describe it. Compassion is a universally felt feeling - it's a humane trait, not something that appear in specific cultural context.

By the way, what you describe (how specific "culturate climate" define nations' emotions) is what I would describe as "arbitrary philosophical fads" - a psychologisation of european politics.


My point stands. Compassion is not a universal feeling, everyone feels it differently. No one with a little objectivity can say that I feel compassion the same way that a Chinese peasant does. Good to reassure myself that you are ignorant about foreign cultures and mentalities.

The serious point is: if you want to be taken seriously, behave like a grown-up. If I wanted to deal with debates like this I would have gone into remedial school teaching
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
September 11 2015 20:21 GMT
#5574
On September 12 2015 05:11 Acrofales wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 12 2015 05:08 Plansix wrote:
On September 12 2015 05:04 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:59 Plansix wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:52 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:41 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:34 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:32 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:27 Ghostcom wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
[quote]
What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


No, I want to help them in the first safe country they arrive at. I want to spend the money where it does the most good and not only help 6% of the Syrian refugees. Sending them back to the first safe country in which they arrive also ensures that people are not encouraged to take the trip across the Mediterranean in flimsy boats. I want EU (and the world) to start actually supporting the neighbouring countries which are being overrun because they don't have the resources to handle all the refugees on their own.

Agreed. But that doesn't solve, at all the short term problem, which is that Turkey and Lebanon cannot deal with the extreme influx of refugees, circumstances are subhuman and all those who possibly can are paying human traffickers to send them across the sea to Europe. It is going to take a while to change that, and the only humane way of dealing with those who HAVE made it to Europe is by letting them stay while we do indeed help out Jordan, Lebanon and Turkey with the gigantic problem of finding a safe and stable solution for the refugees flooding across their borders.

It would also be great if we could put some effective pressure on other Arabic nations to step the fuck up and do their part.

Subhumane ? The camps in turkey are more humane than any other in the EU.
http://www.euronews.com/2015/09/09/turkish-refugee-camps-for-syrians-set-high-standard/
Turkey is doing the impossible and we are there, being stupid deadbeat, not helping them with funding. Imagine how the €6bn from Germany would have help Turkey.

On September 12 2015 04:34 Acrofales wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:30 Faust852 wrote:
On September 12 2015 04:20 WhiteDog wrote:
[quote]
What do you want to do with them ? Send them back to Syria ? At some point we must acknowledge those people are there and we must take care of them.


Of course we should deal with the one already there. The current quotas are really low for everybody so it won't be really a pain in the ass for anyone (except maybe keeping them to flee in Germany). 130K migrants is nothing, but 1M3 become a problem.
But what we should also do is stopping the insentive of them coming to Europe because it's a supposed paradise. We should also reenforce the European borders, sending aid to Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan. Create safe zones in Syria.
That's the only "good" thing to do, not letting migrants into their illusions of grandeur.

On September 12 2015 04:28 Acrofales wrote:
[quote]
Huh? I am talking specifically about refugees. Mainly Syrians, but Eritreans, Afghani and Pakistani refugees as well. They don't suddenly become economical immigrants because they managed to cross the border from Turkey to Greece (or further)

Actually yes they do becomes economical migrants once they leave the first safe country they reached.

Reinforcing the borders is fucking stupid. As if an extra border patrol is going to stop people willing to get into leaky rafts that can barely float, and then cross the Mediterranean.

We should accept that people WILL be fleeing into Europe and treat them as human beings, giving them a place to live, while simultaneously fixing the problem at the source, so less people will actually be willing to get into leaky shitboats and hazard a sea crossing.


We actually take them in in the Lybian seas, probably less than 5 miles from the coast. Why not just pushing them back from their points of origin. Especially since the one coming from Lybia aren't for the most part Syrians.

Yup, patrol the sea, and push them back to where they come from, and giving them flyers explaining them how to do it the legal way.

Hungary is using over 3k soldiers to patrol their border now. I'd imagine you'd need less than that at the EU level to patrol the sea.

If you had read that article to the end, you would have seen that only 1/10th of the Syrian refugees are finding homes in camps. The rest aren't in nearly as nice circumstances. I agree with you that we need more camps like that one! As you read in that article, the vast majority of those people don't even want to come to Europe.


And that's why we should vastly invest in these kind of camp in Syria's neighbours. It will cost much less to the EU, wont disturb the roads/transports. It will appaises the septics, will be easier for the refugee to integrate and transit back to Syria too.
You would reduce drastically the smugling market, the number of deaths, the racists riots, etc...
I mean, Australia will use $700m for 20k refugees, wtf. It will cost €6bn for Germany this year alone. I wonder how many hundred of thousand you could help with this money.

I am 100% sure Turkey would be all about dealing with all the refugees in massive camps. Policing them and dealing with the crime and other issues. I especially like how you think it would reduce deaths and riots. Literally no flaws with that plan.

Doesn't seem to be a huge deal to Turkey right now. It costs them money though so it might become one if we don't help.
Also I already said it's be much better to create safe zones in Syria but you like to cherry pick what I say anyway.

That would involve sending UN troops to Syria to create safe zone. I fail to see how that is cheaper than the current plan.

No? It just involves creating large refugee camps styled after the current ones in different regions of Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan. It might involve UN (or more likely, NATO) forces on the borders to stop ISIS or PKK terrorists from bombing refugee camps, though.

Turkey is already hosting like 2 million Syrians and they are the most welcoming country from all reports. I really don't think they can deal with any more. There is a flat upper limit of refugees they can handle that no amount of money or spending will address.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
Faust852
Profile Joined February 2012
Luxembourg4004 Posts
September 11 2015 20:21 GMT
#5575
So, outside the whole migrant crisis, another shit is going upon EU !
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/11849126/Why-Catalonias-bid-for-independence-is-Europes-next-headache.html

whadya think about the whole independance thing ? IMO it won't go well for Catalonia if does ever happen.
WhiteDog
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
France8650 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-11 20:43:13
September 11 2015 20:30 GMT
#5576
On September 12 2015 05:18 MoltkeWarding wrote:
Show nested quote +
Such hypocrisy. I pointed out what I thought was a ridiculous comment in your quote - because no one with a little objectivity could seriously say that Tocqueville is superior to Marx. Turns out your answer to that is a ridiculous and caricatural answer about orthodox marxism, reassuring myself that you are ignorant about Marx - and no I'm not ignorant about him.


I read the Communist Manifesto by the time I was 13, the Capital by 16, the German Ideology by 18. Long before then, I grew up and began reading serious books, because no one with a little brain could take Marx seriously after puberty. Turns out your answer is a pointless exercise in chest-thumping to disguise your insecurity. I know more than you about Marx. And Tocqueville. Hypocrite. You’re ignorant.

Lol... And you read the 1844 manuscript at 10 ? Or the critique of Hegel's philosophy of right at 5 ? You know more than me about Marx ? You sure ?
The simple fact that you discard Marx shows that you are ignorant. Anybody who is a little educated know Marx is a huge pill to swallow - whatever their ideological background may be.

Show nested quote +
You might have clarified, my point stands. Assymetry in compassion is not the right way to describe it. Compassion is a universally felt feeling - it's a humane trait, not something that appear in specific cultural context.

By the way, what you describe (how specific "culturate climate" define nations' emotions) is what I would describe as "arbitrary philosophical fads" - a psychologisation of european politics.


My point stands. Compassion is not a universal feeling, everyone feels it differently. No one with a little objectivity can say that I feel compassion the same way that a Chinese peasant does. Good to reassure myself that you are ignorant about foreign cultures and mentalities.

The serious point is: if you want to be taken seriously, behave like a grown-up. If I wanted to deal with debates like this I would have gone into remedial school teaching

You need to take your pills and chill a little. I'm sure the chinese peasant does not feel compassion like you do - he did not read the capital at 16 after all (what a f-ing joke... hahahahaha).
Anyway, the way you feel compassion =/= the fact that some people feel more or less compassion. Again, the term assymetry of compassion means that some feel more (not differently) than others : my point stands (again). You have a little difficulty staying true to words.

PS : just out of curiosity, what is - to you - a "serious book" (the kind of book someone should read after Marx) ?
"every time WhiteDog overuses the word "seriously" in a comment I can make an observation on his fragile emotional state." MoltkeWarding
Acrofales
Profile Joined August 2010
Spain18503 Posts
September 11 2015 20:33 GMT
#5577
On September 12 2015 05:21 Faust852 wrote:
So, outside the whole migrant crisis, another shit is going upon EU !
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/11849126/Why-Catalonias-bid-for-independence-is-Europes-next-headache.html

whadya think about the whole independance thing ? IMO it won't go well for Catalonia if does ever happen.

Well, for now it's still just Spain's headache (and has been for the last 20 years or so with nothing much changing). Having lived in Barcelona for 5 years, I know that quite a large part of the current push is inspired by disgruntlement over how the economic crisis was handled. And that dragged in all the other little problems that Catalonians have with the federal government basically since Ferran married Isabel in 1469, uniting Castilia and Aragon, including Napoleon and Franco treating Catalans as second-rank citizens.

The main issue stopping independence is that it would be unconstitutional, and to change the constitution requires a change at the federal level, which obviously the Catalans don't have a majority for. So either the Catalans unilaterally rebel, or they continue doing what they have been doing for the last 20-30 years: rumble and grumble and use their position to slowly and steadily get increasing autonomy within a federated Spain. I don't think things have regressed far enough for outright rebellion to be an option. Artur Mas pulled the same stunt in 2010 to win the Catalan elections then, claiming he would lead Catalunya to independence. Didn't happen then, and nothing much has changed since.
MoltkeWarding
Profile Joined November 2003
5195 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-09-11 20:56:22
September 11 2015 20:49 GMT
#5578
Lol... And you read the 1844 manuscript at 10 ? Or the critique of Hegel's philosophy of right at 5 ? You know more than me about Marx ? You sure ?
The simple fact that you discard Marx shows that you are ignorant. Anybody who is a little educated know Marx is a huge pill to swallow - whatever their ideological background may be.


Pretty sure now. The simple fact that you never discarded Marx into adulthood shows that you're juvenile, or simply slow. Let me guess, you started reading at the age of 21 and only ever managed to read one book. The simple fact that you consider Marx to be a huge pill shows how poor your digestion is, no matter how late you attained functional literacy. That would explain why I have to clarify myself 3 times and you still don't understand the most basic sentences.

You probably cannot locate Marx within the nexus of German idealistic philosophy either, which is probably why you think he was an original thinker. Oh, never mind, I forgot, you are "not ignorant about Marx." That is why given the opportunity, you can't make a single argument about Marx's historical vision pace Tocqueville. Because that is what Marxist experts do. They tell you how smart they are. They are so smart they cannot argue, make points or provide exposition. Hilarious.

Ignorant. Hypocrite. LoL.

read the capital at 16 after all (what a f-ing joke... hahahahaha).
Anyway, the way you feel compassion =/= the fact that some people feel more or less compassion. Again, the term assymetry of compassion means that some feel more (not differently) than others : my point stands (again). You have a little difficulty staying true to words.


Nope. Symmetry is a geometrical, not an arithmetic term. I thought France was supposed to be an upper-mid-tier PISA country, yet no literacy. No mathematics.

You need to take your pills and chill a little.


I can't. I'm going full WhiteDog mode. I like being a rude, arrogant Frenchman. It is far more fun than having good manners.
LegalLord
Profile Blog Joined April 2013
United States13779 Posts
September 11 2015 20:57 GMT
#5579
Take this whole Marx "argument" elsewhere. Even the original point was only tangentially related to the rest of this discussion and this is just a back and forth game of "no u" that serves no real purpose.
History will sooner or later sweep the European Union away without mercy.
xM(Z
Profile Joined November 2006
Romania5299 Posts
September 11 2015 21:01 GMT
#5580
i have zero compassion for syrian male refugees. none, nada.
they should go back and fight/die for their country.
And my fury stands ready. I bring all your plans to nought. My bleak heart beats steady. 'Tis you whom I have sought.
Prev 1 277 278 279 280 281 1432 Next
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
OSC
01:00
OSC 5000
EmpressLilyy31
Liquipedia
Patches Events
23:00
Patch Clash S1: Monthly #4
RotterdaM374
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
Serral 1805
ProTech143
MindelVK 20
EmSc Tv 1
StarCraft: Brood War
Britney 23559
Mini 610
Shuttle 588
EffOrt 477
Rush 119
Dewaltoss 105
Mind 80
firebathero 59
ToSsGirL 35
Barracks 21
[ Show more ]
910 19
Sacsri 14
soO 10
ivOry 5
Dota 2
qojqva3393
Dendi1137
420jenkins346
monkeys_forever260
League of Legends
Trikslyr76
Counter-Strike
pashabiceps1832
ceh9588
Other Games
singsing3135
FrodaN1201
Beastyqt384
RotterdaM374
B2W.Neo312
ArmadaUGS233
QueenE95
KnowMe77
DeMusliM61
UpATreeSC38
Railgan8
Organizations
Other Games
BasetradeTV144
StarCraft 2
angryscii 14
EmSc Tv 1
EmSc2Tv 1
[ Show 14 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• Adnapsc2 9
• Reevou 6
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• WagamamaTV552
League of Legends
• TFBlade769
Other Games
• Shiphtur382
• imaqtpie39
Upcoming Events
Replay Cast
4h 50m
KCM Race Survival
15h 50m
Ultimate Battle
17h 50m
ZerO vs Bisu
RSL Revival
1d 16h
BSL
2 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
2 days
IPSL
2 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
3 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
3 days
WardiTV Weekly
3 days
[ Show More ]
Kung Fu Cup
4 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
5 days
The PondCast
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-17
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.