• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 04:59
CET 10:59
KST 18:59
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #235[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over1Dark completes military service, returns to SC216[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 Team Liquid Map Contest #23 Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon No more SC2 streamers on team liquid?
Tourneys
Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ List of top players active on ShieldBattery BW General Discussion NaDa's Body Shield Battery Server New Patch
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) [IPSL] Winter 26-27 Round of 16! [Megathread] Daily Proleagues 2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc List of Game Threads The PlayStation 5
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Trading/Investing Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Socialism Anyone?
GreenHorizons
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 11995 users

UK Politics Mega-thread - Page 248

Forum Index > General Forum
Post a Reply
Prev 1 246 247 248 249 250 648 Next
In order to ensure that this thread meets TL standards and follows the proper guidelines, we ask that everyone please adhere to this mod note.

Posts containing only Tweets or articles adds nothing to the discussions. Therefore, when providing a source, explain why you feel it is relevant and what purpose it adds to the discussion.
Also take note that unsubstantiated tweets/posts meant only to rekindle old arguments will be actioned upon.

All in all, please continue to enjoy posting in TL General and partake in discussions as much as you want! But please be respectful when posting or replying to someone. There is a clear difference between constructive criticism/discussion and just plain being rude and insulting.

https://www.registertovote.service.gov.uk
bardtown
Profile Joined June 2011
England2313 Posts
Last Edited: 2016-11-03 16:47:35
November 03 2016 16:40 GMT
#4941
On November 04 2016 01:33 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2016 01:22 LegalLord wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:07 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
In an effort to dig out facts in a non-partisan way I've dug out a 2015 government report on the impacts of migration in the UK. One would hope it is neutral and represents our administration's consensual and factual view. The report strikes a mostly positive tone and goes into fascinating detail.

Excerpts that looked salient :

' “The people that we need are not available in the UK. … There is not the capability within the UK any longer to meet our
aspirations.” (Manager, Aerospace, Bristol, 5-10% migrants, Large)'

'Empirical evidence – aggregate impacts of immigration on productivity

There is little existing empirical literature that examines the impacts of immigration on productivity. The literature that does exist however emphasises that the effects will vary by different types of migrants, for example by age on arrival, by skill level and by language ability (Alexsynka and Tritah, 2009 and Dadush, 2014). Kangasniemi et al. (2012) finds for the UK from 1996-2005 that although the quality of immigrants did impact positively on labour productivity, this was largely outweighed by the quantity effect of migrants. That is, while there was a growth in output this was largely because of an increase in the quantity of workers, rather than through productivity gains, and so the net effect of immigration on productivity was only marginally positive in the UK. Rolfe et al. (2013) find a positive relationship between the proportion of immigrants in employment for region-sectors and labour productivity, from their descriptive statistics for 1997-2007. In addition their econometric study shows a positive and significant association between increases in the proportion of immigrant workers and labour productivity growth, after controlling for changes in the skill mix of employees. However the positive effect is relatively small, with a 1% change in immigrant share of employment increasing labour
productivity by only 0.06 to 0.07%.'

www.gov.uk

It would appear the aggregate effect has been a small positive for years. As per one of my previous posts, the report makes a statistical distinction between low- and high-skilled workers, one that some may think less-than-honest politicians would be tempted to talk down and take advantage of. Worth reading the full report.

Somewhere upthread I linked another study commissioned by the U.K. Parliament that analyzed the net effect of immigrants, coming to the conclusion that there is such a thing as good and bad immigrants, and that those who took a "immigrants good, immigrants always good" stance are just wrong. I'm on mobile so I'm not about to dig for it, but it's there. The basic takeaway from these reports in conjunction is that there is a perfectly valid case for limiting immigration to encourage "good immigration" and discourage "bad immigration."


You agree with the last paragraph of my post - I said that it is right to cluster into good and bad.

I say - the government says - the net, total, aggregate, impact - the sum - is a small positive. Happy to dig further into the multiple research studies here.

I am arguing that the distribution is bimodal and skewed and it is, in fact, intellectually dishonest to hide that fact for ideological reasons. Because voters are counted by number and not by tax impact, it makes political sense to court low-skilled domestic voters dealing with low-skilled migrants, because there are many more, when in fact their cost to the country is more than offset by the much smaller number of high-skilled migrants. This is what a skewed distribution does ( refer Pareto, etc ).

The May government has shown an uncanny predisposition to tar all migrants with one brush by referring to them all as 'foreigners' and suggested they be 'counted' so that businesses could be 'named and shamed'. This fallacy is inflammatory to all migrants including the high-skilled ones.

But then, since we all agree here that Brexit is a cost and a risk : why take away a small positive at a great cost and great risk ? It would only make sense to get greedy if, in fact, the process was riskless and painless.

Common sense.


The study does not suggest that free movement is good, it suggests that there is a small net benefit to immigration as a whole with high skilled immigration counteracting unskilled immigration. If you limit unhelpful immigration then you improve the margin.

Also, 'net' benefit is not the most useful measure because it does not address the issue of inequality.

Key point: please be careful when referring to immigration/Leave voters. It is a huge leap to suggest that Leave voters are against skilled immigration and not just free movement. Polls consistently show healthy support for skilled immigration.
MyLovelyLurker
Profile Joined April 2007
France756 Posts
November 03 2016 16:47 GMT
#4942
On November 04 2016 01:40 bardtown wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2016 01:33 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:22 LegalLord wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:07 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
In an effort to dig out facts in a non-partisan way I've dug out a 2015 government report on the impacts of migration in the UK. One would hope it is neutral and represents our administration's consensual and factual view. The report strikes a mostly positive tone and goes into fascinating detail.

Excerpts that looked salient :

' “The people that we need are not available in the UK. … There is not the capability within the UK any longer to meet our
aspirations.” (Manager, Aerospace, Bristol, 5-10% migrants, Large)'

'Empirical evidence – aggregate impacts of immigration on productivity

There is little existing empirical literature that examines the impacts of immigration on productivity. The literature that does exist however emphasises that the effects will vary by different types of migrants, for example by age on arrival, by skill level and by language ability (Alexsynka and Tritah, 2009 and Dadush, 2014). Kangasniemi et al. (2012) finds for the UK from 1996-2005 that although the quality of immigrants did impact positively on labour productivity, this was largely outweighed by the quantity effect of migrants. That is, while there was a growth in output this was largely because of an increase in the quantity of workers, rather than through productivity gains, and so the net effect of immigration on productivity was only marginally positive in the UK. Rolfe et al. (2013) find a positive relationship between the proportion of immigrants in employment for region-sectors and labour productivity, from their descriptive statistics for 1997-2007. In addition their econometric study shows a positive and significant association between increases in the proportion of immigrant workers and labour productivity growth, after controlling for changes in the skill mix of employees. However the positive effect is relatively small, with a 1% change in immigrant share of employment increasing labour
productivity by only 0.06 to 0.07%.'

www.gov.uk

It would appear the aggregate effect has been a small positive for years. As per one of my previous posts, the report makes a statistical distinction between low- and high-skilled workers, one that some may think less-than-honest politicians would be tempted to talk down and take advantage of. Worth reading the full report.

Somewhere upthread I linked another study commissioned by the U.K. Parliament that analyzed the net effect of immigrants, coming to the conclusion that there is such a thing as good and bad immigrants, and that those who took a "immigrants good, immigrants always good" stance are just wrong. I'm on mobile so I'm not about to dig for it, but it's there. The basic takeaway from these reports in conjunction is that there is a perfectly valid case for limiting immigration to encourage "good immigration" and discourage "bad immigration."


You agree with the last paragraph of my post - I said that it is right to cluster into good and bad.

I say - the government says - the net, total, aggregate, impact - the sum - is a small positive. Happy to dig further into the multiple research studies here.

I am arguing that the distribution is bimodal and skewed and it is, in fact, intellectually dishonest to hide that fact for ideological reasons. Because voters are counted by number and not by tax impact, it makes political sense to court low-skilled domestic voters dealing with low-skilled migrants, because there are many more, when in fact their cost to the country is more than offset by the much smaller number of high-skilled migrants. This is what a skewed distribution does ( refer Pareto, etc ).

The May government has shown an uncanny predisposition to tar all migrants with one brush by referring to them all as 'foreigners' and suggested they be 'counted' so that businesses could be 'named and shamed'. This fallacy is inflammatory to all migrants including the high-skilled ones.

But then, since we all agree here that Brexit is a cost and a risk : why take away a small positive at a great cost and great risk ? It would only make sense to get greedy if, in fact, the process was riskless and painless.

Common sense.


The study does not suggest that free movement is good, it suggests that there is a small net benefit to immigration as a whole with high skilled immigration counteracting unskilled immigration. If you limit unhelpful immigration then you improve the margin.

Also, 'net' benefit is not the most useful measure because it does not address the issue of inequality.


Bardtown, this is one of your weaker points. I'm saying if it's not broken ( and you gonna pay £100 to do so ), don't fix it.
"I just say, it doesn't matter win or lose, I just love Starcraft 2, I love this game, I love this stage, just play like in practice" - TIME/Oliveira
bardtown
Profile Joined June 2011
England2313 Posts
November 03 2016 16:48 GMT
#4943
On November 04 2016 01:47 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2016 01:40 bardtown wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:33 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:22 LegalLord wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:07 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
In an effort to dig out facts in a non-partisan way I've dug out a 2015 government report on the impacts of migration in the UK. One would hope it is neutral and represents our administration's consensual and factual view. The report strikes a mostly positive tone and goes into fascinating detail.

Excerpts that looked salient :

' “The people that we need are not available in the UK. … There is not the capability within the UK any longer to meet our
aspirations.” (Manager, Aerospace, Bristol, 5-10% migrants, Large)'

'Empirical evidence – aggregate impacts of immigration on productivity

There is little existing empirical literature that examines the impacts of immigration on productivity. The literature that does exist however emphasises that the effects will vary by different types of migrants, for example by age on arrival, by skill level and by language ability (Alexsynka and Tritah, 2009 and Dadush, 2014). Kangasniemi et al. (2012) finds for the UK from 1996-2005 that although the quality of immigrants did impact positively on labour productivity, this was largely outweighed by the quantity effect of migrants. That is, while there was a growth in output this was largely because of an increase in the quantity of workers, rather than through productivity gains, and so the net effect of immigration on productivity was only marginally positive in the UK. Rolfe et al. (2013) find a positive relationship between the proportion of immigrants in employment for region-sectors and labour productivity, from their descriptive statistics for 1997-2007. In addition their econometric study shows a positive and significant association between increases in the proportion of immigrant workers and labour productivity growth, after controlling for changes in the skill mix of employees. However the positive effect is relatively small, with a 1% change in immigrant share of employment increasing labour
productivity by only 0.06 to 0.07%.'

www.gov.uk

It would appear the aggregate effect has been a small positive for years. As per one of my previous posts, the report makes a statistical distinction between low- and high-skilled workers, one that some may think less-than-honest politicians would be tempted to talk down and take advantage of. Worth reading the full report.

Somewhere upthread I linked another study commissioned by the U.K. Parliament that analyzed the net effect of immigrants, coming to the conclusion that there is such a thing as good and bad immigrants, and that those who took a "immigrants good, immigrants always good" stance are just wrong. I'm on mobile so I'm not about to dig for it, but it's there. The basic takeaway from these reports in conjunction is that there is a perfectly valid case for limiting immigration to encourage "good immigration" and discourage "bad immigration."


You agree with the last paragraph of my post - I said that it is right to cluster into good and bad.

I say - the government says - the net, total, aggregate, impact - the sum - is a small positive. Happy to dig further into the multiple research studies here.

I am arguing that the distribution is bimodal and skewed and it is, in fact, intellectually dishonest to hide that fact for ideological reasons. Because voters are counted by number and not by tax impact, it makes political sense to court low-skilled domestic voters dealing with low-skilled migrants, because there are many more, when in fact their cost to the country is more than offset by the much smaller number of high-skilled migrants. This is what a skewed distribution does ( refer Pareto, etc ).

The May government has shown an uncanny predisposition to tar all migrants with one brush by referring to them all as 'foreigners' and suggested they be 'counted' so that businesses could be 'named and shamed'. This fallacy is inflammatory to all migrants including the high-skilled ones.

But then, since we all agree here that Brexit is a cost and a risk : why take away a small positive at a great cost and great risk ? It would only make sense to get greedy if, in fact, the process was riskless and painless.

Common sense.


The study does not suggest that free movement is good, it suggests that there is a small net benefit to immigration as a whole with high skilled immigration counteracting unskilled immigration. If you limit unhelpful immigration then you improve the margin.

Also, 'net' benefit is not the most useful measure because it does not address the issue of inequality.


Bardtown, this is one of your weaker points. I'm saying if it's not broken ( and you gonna pay £100 to do so ), don't fix it.


But it is broken. Immigration is driving inequality when it needn't do so if we only had the capacity to stop free movement of unskilled labour.
MyLovelyLurker
Profile Joined April 2007
France756 Posts
November 03 2016 16:49 GMT
#4944
On November 04 2016 01:40 bardtown wrote:

Also, 'net' benefit is not the most useful measure because it does not address the issue of inequality.


You really don't need to Brexit to tackle income inequality, standard policy response is to just increase the highest tax brackets ( instead of keeping such loopholes as non-dom taxation open ). That way you save yourself the years of legal limbo, the Zimbabwean currency devaluation, etc. We've addressed that before : if anything, economic shocks impact the poorest the most, it's common sense once again. Abramovich doesn't care that Ben&Jerry's is £2 more at Tesco's or the latest Macbook is +£200.
"I just say, it doesn't matter win or lose, I just love Starcraft 2, I love this game, I love this stage, just play like in practice" - TIME/Oliveira
bardtown
Profile Joined June 2011
England2313 Posts
Last Edited: 2016-11-03 16:54:38
November 03 2016 16:54 GMT
#4945
On November 04 2016 01:49 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2016 01:40 bardtown wrote:

Also, 'net' benefit is not the most useful measure because it does not address the issue of inequality.


You really don't need to Brexit to tackle income inequality, standard policy response is to just increase the highest tax brackets ( instead of keeping such loopholes as non-dom taxation open ). That way you save yourself the years of legal limbo, the Zimbabwean currency devaluation, etc. We've addressed that before : if anything, economic shocks impact the poorest the most, it's common sense once again. Abramovich doesn't care that Ben&Jerry's is £2 more at Tesco's or the latest Macbook is +£200.


Increasing taxes on the rich to pay for an influx of people is not something you can sustain indefinitely. It's a bubble, not a solution.

More people come (remember we have no power to limit the numbers), so you increase taxation and public spending to support the current standard of living which then, in turn, incentivises more to come.
kollin
Profile Blog Joined March 2011
United Kingdom8380 Posts
November 03 2016 16:55 GMT
#4946
I don't know if this has already been said but legally it would've been insane if the government was able to bypass parliament, and would have enormous constitutional implications for the country
LegalLord
Profile Blog Joined April 2013
United States13779 Posts
November 03 2016 16:55 GMT
#4947
On November 04 2016 01:33 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2016 01:22 LegalLord wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:07 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
In an effort to dig out facts in a non-partisan way I've dug out a 2015 government report on the impacts of migration in the UK. One would hope it is neutral and represents our administration's consensual and factual view. The report strikes a mostly positive tone and goes into fascinating detail.

Excerpts that looked salient :

' “The people that we need are not available in the UK. … There is not the capability within the UK any longer to meet our
aspirations.” (Manager, Aerospace, Bristol, 5-10% migrants, Large)'

'Empirical evidence – aggregate impacts of immigration on productivity

There is little existing empirical literature that examines the impacts of immigration on productivity. The literature that does exist however emphasises that the effects will vary by different types of migrants, for example by age on arrival, by skill level and by language ability (Alexsynka and Tritah, 2009 and Dadush, 2014). Kangasniemi et al. (2012) finds for the UK from 1996-2005 that although the quality of immigrants did impact positively on labour productivity, this was largely outweighed by the quantity effect of migrants. That is, while there was a growth in output this was largely because of an increase in the quantity of workers, rather than through productivity gains, and so the net effect of immigration on productivity was only marginally positive in the UK. Rolfe et al. (2013) find a positive relationship between the proportion of immigrants in employment for region-sectors and labour productivity, from their descriptive statistics for 1997-2007. In addition their econometric study shows a positive and significant association between increases in the proportion of immigrant workers and labour productivity growth, after controlling for changes in the skill mix of employees. However the positive effect is relatively small, with a 1% change in immigrant share of employment increasing labour
productivity by only 0.06 to 0.07%.'

www.gov.uk

It would appear the aggregate effect has been a small positive for years. As per one of my previous posts, the report makes a statistical distinction between low- and high-skilled workers, one that some may think less-than-honest politicians would be tempted to talk down and take advantage of. Worth reading the full report.

Somewhere upthread I linked another study commissioned by the U.K. Parliament that analyzed the net effect of immigrants, coming to the conclusion that there is such a thing as good and bad immigrants, and that those who took a "immigrants good, immigrants always good" stance are just wrong. I'm on mobile so I'm not about to dig for it, but it's there. The basic takeaway from these reports in conjunction is that there is a perfectly valid case for limiting immigration to encourage "good immigration" and discourage "bad immigration."


You agree with the last paragraph of my post - I said that it is right to cluster into good and bad.

I say - the government says - the net, total, aggregate, impact - the sum - is a small positive. Happy to dig further into the multiple research studies here.

I am arguing that the distribution is bimodal and skewed and it is, in fact, intellectually dishonest to hide that fact for ideological reasons. Because voters are counted by number and not by tax impact, it makes political sense to court low-skilled domestic voters dealing with low-skilled migrants, because there are many more, when in fact their cost to the country is more than offset by the much smaller number of high-skilled migrants. This is what a skewed distribution does ( refer Pareto, etc ).

The May government has shown an uncanny predisposition to tar all migrants with one brush by referring to them all as 'foreigners' and suggested they be 'counted' so that businesses could be 'named and shamed'. This fallacy is inflammatory to all migrants including the high-skilled ones.

But then, since we all agree here that Brexit is a cost and a risk : why take away a small positive at a great cost and great risk ? It would only make sense to get greedy if, in fact, the process was riskless and painless.

Common sense.

I'll give a longer response when I get home tonight. The general response though is simply that if there are good and bad immigrants, certainly it doesn't make sense to take a "all immigrants can GTFO" approach, but at the same time an "open the floodgates and let loose the tide of immigrants" is also wrong. It makes perfect sense to have a strict but not un-nuanced immigration policy.
History will sooner or later sweep the European Union away without mercy.
MyLovelyLurker
Profile Joined April 2007
France756 Posts
November 03 2016 16:55 GMT
#4948
On November 04 2016 01:48 bardtown wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2016 01:47 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:40 bardtown wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:33 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:22 LegalLord wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:07 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
In an effort to dig out facts in a non-partisan way I've dug out a 2015 government report on the impacts of migration in the UK. One would hope it is neutral and represents our administration's consensual and factual view. The report strikes a mostly positive tone and goes into fascinating detail.

Excerpts that looked salient :

' “The people that we need are not available in the UK. … There is not the capability within the UK any longer to meet our
aspirations.” (Manager, Aerospace, Bristol, 5-10% migrants, Large)'

'Empirical evidence – aggregate impacts of immigration on productivity

There is little existing empirical literature that examines the impacts of immigration on productivity. The literature that does exist however emphasises that the effects will vary by different types of migrants, for example by age on arrival, by skill level and by language ability (Alexsynka and Tritah, 2009 and Dadush, 2014). Kangasniemi et al. (2012) finds for the UK from 1996-2005 that although the quality of immigrants did impact positively on labour productivity, this was largely outweighed by the quantity effect of migrants. That is, while there was a growth in output this was largely because of an increase in the quantity of workers, rather than through productivity gains, and so the net effect of immigration on productivity was only marginally positive in the UK. Rolfe et al. (2013) find a positive relationship between the proportion of immigrants in employment for region-sectors and labour productivity, from their descriptive statistics for 1997-2007. In addition their econometric study shows a positive and significant association between increases in the proportion of immigrant workers and labour productivity growth, after controlling for changes in the skill mix of employees. However the positive effect is relatively small, with a 1% change in immigrant share of employment increasing labour
productivity by only 0.06 to 0.07%.'

www.gov.uk

It would appear the aggregate effect has been a small positive for years. As per one of my previous posts, the report makes a statistical distinction between low- and high-skilled workers, one that some may think less-than-honest politicians would be tempted to talk down and take advantage of. Worth reading the full report.

Somewhere upthread I linked another study commissioned by the U.K. Parliament that analyzed the net effect of immigrants, coming to the conclusion that there is such a thing as good and bad immigrants, and that those who took a "immigrants good, immigrants always good" stance are just wrong. I'm on mobile so I'm not about to dig for it, but it's there. The basic takeaway from these reports in conjunction is that there is a perfectly valid case for limiting immigration to encourage "good immigration" and discourage "bad immigration."


You agree with the last paragraph of my post - I said that it is right to cluster into good and bad.

I say - the government says - the net, total, aggregate, impact - the sum - is a small positive. Happy to dig further into the multiple research studies here.

I am arguing that the distribution is bimodal and skewed and it is, in fact, intellectually dishonest to hide that fact for ideological reasons. Because voters are counted by number and not by tax impact, it makes political sense to court low-skilled domestic voters dealing with low-skilled migrants, because there are many more, when in fact their cost to the country is more than offset by the much smaller number of high-skilled migrants. This is what a skewed distribution does ( refer Pareto, etc ).

The May government has shown an uncanny predisposition to tar all migrants with one brush by referring to them all as 'foreigners' and suggested they be 'counted' so that businesses could be 'named and shamed'. This fallacy is inflammatory to all migrants including the high-skilled ones.

But then, since we all agree here that Brexit is a cost and a risk : why take away a small positive at a great cost and great risk ? It would only make sense to get greedy if, in fact, the process was riskless and painless.

Common sense.


The study does not suggest that free movement is good, it suggests that there is a small net benefit to immigration as a whole with high skilled immigration counteracting unskilled immigration. If you limit unhelpful immigration then you improve the margin.

Also, 'net' benefit is not the most useful measure because it does not address the issue of inequality.


Bardtown, this is one of your weaker points. I'm saying if it's not broken ( and you gonna pay £100 to do so ), don't fix it.


But it is broken. Immigration is driving inequality when it needn't do so if we only had the capacity to stop free movement of unskilled labour.


So this is very interesting. Basically I am saying I'd rather have higher aggregate numbers even at the expense of slightly more inequality, because ultimately a rising tide lifts all boats. Think the US instead of Ukraine ; I know which country I'd rather live in.

Again first you lift standards then you redistribute. If redistribution has failed to occcur, you vote for Labour, not for Brexit, which would first and foremost make everyone poorer.

I also dispute that immigration is driving inequality in a functioning tax environment. Immigrants pay taxes as per the state's prerogative. It is up to the state to act on the Gini ( measure of the shape of the income distribution ) through sound fiscal policy.

A lot of the study when you read it says many job positions would simply not be filled at both ends of the spectrum ( Italian speaking tour operator, European aerospace engineer ). These people's PAYE tax contributions then are a net benefit to the economy as they grow it overall. There would be no GDP gain without them. Legacy of the Void.
"I just say, it doesn't matter win or lose, I just love Starcraft 2, I love this game, I love this stage, just play like in practice" - TIME/Oliveira
MyLovelyLurker
Profile Joined April 2007
France756 Posts
November 03 2016 16:59 GMT
#4949
On November 04 2016 01:54 bardtown wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2016 01:49 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:40 bardtown wrote:

Also, 'net' benefit is not the most useful measure because it does not address the issue of inequality.


You really don't need to Brexit to tackle income inequality, standard policy response is to just increase the highest tax brackets ( instead of keeping such loopholes as non-dom taxation open ). That way you save yourself the years of legal limbo, the Zimbabwean currency devaluation, etc. We've addressed that before : if anything, economic shocks impact the poorest the most, it's common sense once again. Abramovich doesn't care that Ben&Jerry's is £2 more at Tesco's or the latest Macbook is +£200.


Increasing taxes on the rich to pay for an influx of people is not something you can sustain indefinitely. It's a bubble, not a solution.

More people come (remember we have no power to limit the numbers), so you increase taxation and public spending to support the current standard of living which then, in turn, incentivises more to come.


Again, sorry but mathematically wrong. The imbalance would not be if 'more people came', but if 'more low-skilled migrants than high-skilled ones' started coming. All evidence, including that report, and the superior productivity of London compared to the rest of the country, points towards the fact that the repartition has been stable.

Increasing taxes is not a bubble. London has less all-in income tax than NYC when you add state and federal tax. The US economy is more than fine.

Again : a marginal, speculative effect on the Gini is irrelevant and not worth 10% of your currency, increasing taxes or other economic solutions exist to tackle inequality and making everyone poorer is definitely not one of them.

"I just say, it doesn't matter win or lose, I just love Starcraft 2, I love this game, I love this stage, just play like in practice" - TIME/Oliveira
bardtown
Profile Joined June 2011
England2313 Posts
Last Edited: 2016-11-03 17:12:16
November 03 2016 17:07 GMT
#4950
On November 04 2016 01:59 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2016 01:54 bardtown wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:49 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:40 bardtown wrote:

Also, 'net' benefit is not the most useful measure because it does not address the issue of inequality.


You really don't need to Brexit to tackle income inequality, standard policy response is to just increase the highest tax brackets ( instead of keeping such loopholes as non-dom taxation open ). That way you save yourself the years of legal limbo, the Zimbabwean currency devaluation, etc. We've addressed that before : if anything, economic shocks impact the poorest the most, it's common sense once again. Abramovich doesn't care that Ben&Jerry's is £2 more at Tesco's or the latest Macbook is +£200.


Increasing taxes on the rich to pay for an influx of people is not something you can sustain indefinitely. It's a bubble, not a solution.

More people come (remember we have no power to limit the numbers), so you increase taxation and public spending to support the current standard of living which then, in turn, incentivises more to come.


Again, sorry but mathematically wrong. The imbalance would not be if 'more people came', but if 'more low-skilled migrants than high-skilled ones' started coming. All evidence, including that report, and the superior productivity of London compared to the rest of the country, points towards the fact that the repartition has been stable.

Increasing taxes is not a bubble. London has less all-in income tax than NYC when you add state and federal tax. The US economy is more than fine.

Again : a marginal, speculative effect on the Gini is irrelevant and not worth 10% of your currency, increasing taxes or other economic solutions exist to tackle inequality and making everyone poorer is definitely not one of them.



No, it's not about the ratio of low:high skilled labour, it's about the measure of inequality. At the current ratio, wages for the low skilled have been tumbling while, for the country as a whole, they have been rising. Now the govt. has not attempted to address this by increasing welfare/infrastructure spending by taxing the rich, as you suggest, but if they did it would be a bubble. As it stands, it's just left as rising inequality.

The US/Ukraine comparison isn't fair either. I would choose to live in Norway or Finland over the US, especially if I was poor.
LegalLord
Profile Blog Joined April 2013
United States13779 Posts
November 03 2016 17:11 GMT
#4951
On November 04 2016 01:55 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2016 01:48 bardtown wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:47 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:40 bardtown wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:33 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:22 LegalLord wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:07 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
In an effort to dig out facts in a non-partisan way I've dug out a 2015 government report on the impacts of migration in the UK. One would hope it is neutral and represents our administration's consensual and factual view. The report strikes a mostly positive tone and goes into fascinating detail.

Excerpts that looked salient :

' “The people that we need are not available in the UK. … There is not the capability within the UK any longer to meet our
aspirations.” (Manager, Aerospace, Bristol, 5-10% migrants, Large)'

'Empirical evidence – aggregate impacts of immigration on productivity

There is little existing empirical literature that examines the impacts of immigration on productivity. The literature that does exist however emphasises that the effects will vary by different types of migrants, for example by age on arrival, by skill level and by language ability (Alexsynka and Tritah, 2009 and Dadush, 2014). Kangasniemi et al. (2012) finds for the UK from 1996-2005 that although the quality of immigrants did impact positively on labour productivity, this was largely outweighed by the quantity effect of migrants. That is, while there was a growth in output this was largely because of an increase in the quantity of workers, rather than through productivity gains, and so the net effect of immigration on productivity was only marginally positive in the UK. Rolfe et al. (2013) find a positive relationship between the proportion of immigrants in employment for region-sectors and labour productivity, from their descriptive statistics for 1997-2007. In addition their econometric study shows a positive and significant association between increases in the proportion of immigrant workers and labour productivity growth, after controlling for changes in the skill mix of employees. However the positive effect is relatively small, with a 1% change in immigrant share of employment increasing labour
productivity by only 0.06 to 0.07%.'

www.gov.uk

It would appear the aggregate effect has been a small positive for years. As per one of my previous posts, the report makes a statistical distinction between low- and high-skilled workers, one that some may think less-than-honest politicians would be tempted to talk down and take advantage of. Worth reading the full report.

Somewhere upthread I linked another study commissioned by the U.K. Parliament that analyzed the net effect of immigrants, coming to the conclusion that there is such a thing as good and bad immigrants, and that those who took a "immigrants good, immigrants always good" stance are just wrong. I'm on mobile so I'm not about to dig for it, but it's there. The basic takeaway from these reports in conjunction is that there is a perfectly valid case for limiting immigration to encourage "good immigration" and discourage "bad immigration."


You agree with the last paragraph of my post - I said that it is right to cluster into good and bad.

I say - the government says - the net, total, aggregate, impact - the sum - is a small positive. Happy to dig further into the multiple research studies here.

I am arguing that the distribution is bimodal and skewed and it is, in fact, intellectually dishonest to hide that fact for ideological reasons. Because voters are counted by number and not by tax impact, it makes political sense to court low-skilled domestic voters dealing with low-skilled migrants, because there are many more, when in fact their cost to the country is more than offset by the much smaller number of high-skilled migrants. This is what a skewed distribution does ( refer Pareto, etc ).

The May government has shown an uncanny predisposition to tar all migrants with one brush by referring to them all as 'foreigners' and suggested they be 'counted' so that businesses could be 'named and shamed'. This fallacy is inflammatory to all migrants including the high-skilled ones.

But then, since we all agree here that Brexit is a cost and a risk : why take away a small positive at a great cost and great risk ? It would only make sense to get greedy if, in fact, the process was riskless and painless.

Common sense.


The study does not suggest that free movement is good, it suggests that there is a small net benefit to immigration as a whole with high skilled immigration counteracting unskilled immigration. If you limit unhelpful immigration then you improve the margin.

Also, 'net' benefit is not the most useful measure because it does not address the issue of inequality.


Bardtown, this is one of your weaker points. I'm saying if it's not broken ( and you gonna pay £100 to do so ), don't fix it.


But it is broken. Immigration is driving inequality when it needn't do so if we only had the capacity to stop free movement of unskilled labour.


So this is very interesting. Basically I am saying I'd rather have higher aggregate numbers even at the expense of slightly more inequality, because ultimately a rising tide lifts all boats. Think the US instead of Ukraine ; I know which country I'd rather live in.

Would you rather be a billionaire in the Ukraine or a peasant in the US? I know I'd rather be the billionaire, even if I did have to put up with dealing with all the things there is to dislike about life in the Ukraine.
History will sooner or later sweep the European Union away without mercy.
MyLovelyLurker
Profile Joined April 2007
France756 Posts
November 03 2016 17:13 GMT
#4952
On November 04 2016 01:55 LegalLord wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2016 01:33 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:22 LegalLord wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:07 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
In an effort to dig out facts in a non-partisan way I've dug out a 2015 government report on the impacts of migration in the UK. One would hope it is neutral and represents our administration's consensual and factual view. The report strikes a mostly positive tone and goes into fascinating detail.

Excerpts that looked salient :

' “The people that we need are not available in the UK. … There is not the capability within the UK any longer to meet our
aspirations.” (Manager, Aerospace, Bristol, 5-10% migrants, Large)'

'Empirical evidence – aggregate impacts of immigration on productivity

There is little existing empirical literature that examines the impacts of immigration on productivity. The literature that does exist however emphasises that the effects will vary by different types of migrants, for example by age on arrival, by skill level and by language ability (Alexsynka and Tritah, 2009 and Dadush, 2014). Kangasniemi et al. (2012) finds for the UK from 1996-2005 that although the quality of immigrants did impact positively on labour productivity, this was largely outweighed by the quantity effect of migrants. That is, while there was a growth in output this was largely because of an increase in the quantity of workers, rather than through productivity gains, and so the net effect of immigration on productivity was only marginally positive in the UK. Rolfe et al. (2013) find a positive relationship between the proportion of immigrants in employment for region-sectors and labour productivity, from their descriptive statistics for 1997-2007. In addition their econometric study shows a positive and significant association between increases in the proportion of immigrant workers and labour productivity growth, after controlling for changes in the skill mix of employees. However the positive effect is relatively small, with a 1% change in immigrant share of employment increasing labour
productivity by only 0.06 to 0.07%.'

www.gov.uk

It would appear the aggregate effect has been a small positive for years. As per one of my previous posts, the report makes a statistical distinction between low- and high-skilled workers, one that some may think less-than-honest politicians would be tempted to talk down and take advantage of. Worth reading the full report.

Somewhere upthread I linked another study commissioned by the U.K. Parliament that analyzed the net effect of immigrants, coming to the conclusion that there is such a thing as good and bad immigrants, and that those who took a "immigrants good, immigrants always good" stance are just wrong. I'm on mobile so I'm not about to dig for it, but it's there. The basic takeaway from these reports in conjunction is that there is a perfectly valid case for limiting immigration to encourage "good immigration" and discourage "bad immigration."


You agree with the last paragraph of my post - I said that it is right to cluster into good and bad.

I say - the government says - the net, total, aggregate, impact - the sum - is a small positive. Happy to dig further into the multiple research studies here.

I am arguing that the distribution is bimodal and skewed and it is, in fact, intellectually dishonest to hide that fact for ideological reasons. Because voters are counted by number and not by tax impact, it makes political sense to court low-skilled domestic voters dealing with low-skilled migrants, because there are many more, when in fact their cost to the country is more than offset by the much smaller number of high-skilled migrants. This is what a skewed distribution does ( refer Pareto, etc ).

The May government has shown an uncanny predisposition to tar all migrants with one brush by referring to them all as 'foreigners' and suggested they be 'counted' so that businesses could be 'named and shamed'. This fallacy is inflammatory to all migrants including the high-skilled ones.

But then, since we all agree here that Brexit is a cost and a risk : why take away a small positive at a great cost and great risk ? It would only make sense to get greedy if, in fact, the process was riskless and painless.

Common sense.

I'll give a longer response when I get home tonight. The general response though is simply that if there are good and bad immigrants, certainly it doesn't make sense to take a "all immigrants can GTFO" approach, but at the same time an "open the floodgates and let loose the tide of immigrants" is also wrong. It makes perfect sense to have a strict but not un-nuanced immigration policy.


Sure, take your time. And precisely. The former approach is exactly what we've seen from Amber Rudd et al. We agree it is wrong and damaging, and in fact, outright undemocratic insofar as the mandate for Brexit was too weak to grant such a radical stance.

On the other hand, we now have a policy which while less than ideal, has in fact carried small benefits for the last 10 years according to the government, and whose withdrawal is currently putting our economy under a lot of strain.
"I just say, it doesn't matter win or lose, I just love Starcraft 2, I love this game, I love this stage, just play like in practice" - TIME/Oliveira
bardtown
Profile Joined June 2011
England2313 Posts
Last Edited: 2016-11-03 17:14:29
November 03 2016 17:13 GMT
#4953
On November 04 2016 02:11 LegalLord wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2016 01:55 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:48 bardtown wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:47 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:40 bardtown wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:33 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:22 LegalLord wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:07 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
In an effort to dig out facts in a non-partisan way I've dug out a 2015 government report on the impacts of migration in the UK. One would hope it is neutral and represents our administration's consensual and factual view. The report strikes a mostly positive tone and goes into fascinating detail.

Excerpts that looked salient :

' “The people that we need are not available in the UK. … There is not the capability within the UK any longer to meet our
aspirations.” (Manager, Aerospace, Bristol, 5-10% migrants, Large)'

'Empirical evidence – aggregate impacts of immigration on productivity

There is little existing empirical literature that examines the impacts of immigration on productivity. The literature that does exist however emphasises that the effects will vary by different types of migrants, for example by age on arrival, by skill level and by language ability (Alexsynka and Tritah, 2009 and Dadush, 2014). Kangasniemi et al. (2012) finds for the UK from 1996-2005 that although the quality of immigrants did impact positively on labour productivity, this was largely outweighed by the quantity effect of migrants. That is, while there was a growth in output this was largely because of an increase in the quantity of workers, rather than through productivity gains, and so the net effect of immigration on productivity was only marginally positive in the UK. Rolfe et al. (2013) find a positive relationship between the proportion of immigrants in employment for region-sectors and labour productivity, from their descriptive statistics for 1997-2007. In addition their econometric study shows a positive and significant association between increases in the proportion of immigrant workers and labour productivity growth, after controlling for changes in the skill mix of employees. However the positive effect is relatively small, with a 1% change in immigrant share of employment increasing labour
productivity by only 0.06 to 0.07%.'

www.gov.uk

It would appear the aggregate effect has been a small positive for years. As per one of my previous posts, the report makes a statistical distinction between low- and high-skilled workers, one that some may think less-than-honest politicians would be tempted to talk down and take advantage of. Worth reading the full report.

Somewhere upthread I linked another study commissioned by the U.K. Parliament that analyzed the net effect of immigrants, coming to the conclusion that there is such a thing as good and bad immigrants, and that those who took a "immigrants good, immigrants always good" stance are just wrong. I'm on mobile so I'm not about to dig for it, but it's there. The basic takeaway from these reports in conjunction is that there is a perfectly valid case for limiting immigration to encourage "good immigration" and discourage "bad immigration."


You agree with the last paragraph of my post - I said that it is right to cluster into good and bad.

I say - the government says - the net, total, aggregate, impact - the sum - is a small positive. Happy to dig further into the multiple research studies here.

I am arguing that the distribution is bimodal and skewed and it is, in fact, intellectually dishonest to hide that fact for ideological reasons. Because voters are counted by number and not by tax impact, it makes political sense to court low-skilled domestic voters dealing with low-skilled migrants, because there are many more, when in fact their cost to the country is more than offset by the much smaller number of high-skilled migrants. This is what a skewed distribution does ( refer Pareto, etc ).

The May government has shown an uncanny predisposition to tar all migrants with one brush by referring to them all as 'foreigners' and suggested they be 'counted' so that businesses could be 'named and shamed'. This fallacy is inflammatory to all migrants including the high-skilled ones.

But then, since we all agree here that Brexit is a cost and a risk : why take away a small positive at a great cost and great risk ? It would only make sense to get greedy if, in fact, the process was riskless and painless.

Common sense.


The study does not suggest that free movement is good, it suggests that there is a small net benefit to immigration as a whole with high skilled immigration counteracting unskilled immigration. If you limit unhelpful immigration then you improve the margin.

Also, 'net' benefit is not the most useful measure because it does not address the issue of inequality.


Bardtown, this is one of your weaker points. I'm saying if it's not broken ( and you gonna pay £100 to do so ), don't fix it.


But it is broken. Immigration is driving inequality when it needn't do so if we only had the capacity to stop free movement of unskilled labour.


So this is very interesting. Basically I am saying I'd rather have higher aggregate numbers even at the expense of slightly more inequality, because ultimately a rising tide lifts all boats. Think the US instead of Ukraine ; I know which country I'd rather live in.

Would you rather be a billionaire in the Ukraine or a peasant in the US? I know I'd rather be the billionaire, even if I did have to put up with dealing with all the things there is to dislike about life in the Ukraine.


Why do you emphasise 'the'? IIRC they avoid use of 'the Ukraine' to dissociate themselves from the USSR.
LegalLord
Profile Blog Joined April 2013
United States13779 Posts
November 03 2016 17:16 GMT
#4954
Because people make a big deal out of it when it literally doesn't matter. There are no articles (e.g. "the") in Russian but at the same time it's a big deal in the US for some reason, with some people using "the" and some not using it. Just a bit of subtle mockery, nothing to see here.
History will sooner or later sweep the European Union away without mercy.
MyLovelyLurker
Profile Joined April 2007
France756 Posts
November 03 2016 17:19 GMT
#4955
On November 04 2016 02:07 bardtown wrote:



No, it's not about the ratio of low:high skilled labour, it's about the measure of inequality. At the current ratio, wages for the low skilled have been tumbling while, for the country as a whole, they have been rising. Now the govt. has not attempted to address this by increasing welfare/infrastructure spending by taxing the rich, as you suggest, but if they did it would be a bubble. As it stands, it's just left as rising inequality.


After your earlier multiplication and currency fiascos I'll take my math over yours, with no disrespect, but again, you're mistaking Schengen for globalisation. If you're taking a long-term, 20 year view on the economic benefits of Brexit, the correct policy response is to invest in education so as to make more domestic workers skilled, rather than fighting a race to the bottom in low-marging sectors, many of which will be automated. Think teach a man how to fish.


The US/Ukraine comparison isn't fair either. I would choose to live in Norway or Finland over the US, especially if I was poor.


Erhm, these are countries with 60-65% all-in income tax, I thought you said rising taxes were a bubble exactly one post earlier ?

Mathematically, again, countries are concerned with growth level, before its distribution. It's just standard economic theory that you place yourself in a 'risk neutral world' ( no risk aversion premium ) to evaluate your outcomes. Morally right or wrong, confer standard textbooks. That has very little to do with Brexit.
"I just say, it doesn't matter win or lose, I just love Starcraft 2, I love this game, I love this stage, just play like in practice" - TIME/Oliveira
MyLovelyLurker
Profile Joined April 2007
France756 Posts
November 03 2016 17:20 GMT
#4956
On November 04 2016 02:13 bardtown wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2016 02:11 LegalLord wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:55 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:48 bardtown wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:47 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:40 bardtown wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:33 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:22 LegalLord wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:07 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
In an effort to dig out facts in a non-partisan way I've dug out a 2015 government report on the impacts of migration in the UK. One would hope it is neutral and represents our administration's consensual and factual view. The report strikes a mostly positive tone and goes into fascinating detail.

Excerpts that looked salient :

' “The people that we need are not available in the UK. … There is not the capability within the UK any longer to meet our
aspirations.” (Manager, Aerospace, Bristol, 5-10% migrants, Large)'

'Empirical evidence – aggregate impacts of immigration on productivity

There is little existing empirical literature that examines the impacts of immigration on productivity. The literature that does exist however emphasises that the effects will vary by different types of migrants, for example by age on arrival, by skill level and by language ability (Alexsynka and Tritah, 2009 and Dadush, 2014). Kangasniemi et al. (2012) finds for the UK from 1996-2005 that although the quality of immigrants did impact positively on labour productivity, this was largely outweighed by the quantity effect of migrants. That is, while there was a growth in output this was largely because of an increase in the quantity of workers, rather than through productivity gains, and so the net effect of immigration on productivity was only marginally positive in the UK. Rolfe et al. (2013) find a positive relationship between the proportion of immigrants in employment for region-sectors and labour productivity, from their descriptive statistics for 1997-2007. In addition their econometric study shows a positive and significant association between increases in the proportion of immigrant workers and labour productivity growth, after controlling for changes in the skill mix of employees. However the positive effect is relatively small, with a 1% change in immigrant share of employment increasing labour
productivity by only 0.06 to 0.07%.'

www.gov.uk

It would appear the aggregate effect has been a small positive for years. As per one of my previous posts, the report makes a statistical distinction between low- and high-skilled workers, one that some may think less-than-honest politicians would be tempted to talk down and take advantage of. Worth reading the full report.

Somewhere upthread I linked another study commissioned by the U.K. Parliament that analyzed the net effect of immigrants, coming to the conclusion that there is such a thing as good and bad immigrants, and that those who took a "immigrants good, immigrants always good" stance are just wrong. I'm on mobile so I'm not about to dig for it, but it's there. The basic takeaway from these reports in conjunction is that there is a perfectly valid case for limiting immigration to encourage "good immigration" and discourage "bad immigration."


You agree with the last paragraph of my post - I said that it is right to cluster into good and bad.

I say - the government says - the net, total, aggregate, impact - the sum - is a small positive. Happy to dig further into the multiple research studies here.

I am arguing that the distribution is bimodal and skewed and it is, in fact, intellectually dishonest to hide that fact for ideological reasons. Because voters are counted by number and not by tax impact, it makes political sense to court low-skilled domestic voters dealing with low-skilled migrants, because there are many more, when in fact their cost to the country is more than offset by the much smaller number of high-skilled migrants. This is what a skewed distribution does ( refer Pareto, etc ).

The May government has shown an uncanny predisposition to tar all migrants with one brush by referring to them all as 'foreigners' and suggested they be 'counted' so that businesses could be 'named and shamed'. This fallacy is inflammatory to all migrants including the high-skilled ones.

But then, since we all agree here that Brexit is a cost and a risk : why take away a small positive at a great cost and great risk ? It would only make sense to get greedy if, in fact, the process was riskless and painless.

Common sense.


The study does not suggest that free movement is good, it suggests that there is a small net benefit to immigration as a whole with high skilled immigration counteracting unskilled immigration. If you limit unhelpful immigration then you improve the margin.

Also, 'net' benefit is not the most useful measure because it does not address the issue of inequality.


Bardtown, this is one of your weaker points. I'm saying if it's not broken ( and you gonna pay £100 to do so ), don't fix it.


But it is broken. Immigration is driving inequality when it needn't do so if we only had the capacity to stop free movement of unskilled labour.


So this is very interesting. Basically I am saying I'd rather have higher aggregate numbers even at the expense of slightly more inequality, because ultimately a rising tide lifts all boats. Think the US instead of Ukraine ; I know which country I'd rather live in.

Would you rather be a billionaire in the Ukraine or a peasant in the US? I know I'd rather be the billionaire, even if I did have to put up with dealing with all the things there is to dislike about life in the Ukraine.


Why do you emphasise 'the'? IIRC they avoid use of 'the Ukraine' to dissociate themselves from the USSR.


It took us another 10 pages to agree, but my girlfriend is Russian/Ukrainian/British and she says Ukraine as well, quoting that very reason.

"I just say, it doesn't matter win or lose, I just love Starcraft 2, I love this game, I love this stage, just play like in practice" - TIME/Oliveira
bardtown
Profile Joined June 2011
England2313 Posts
November 03 2016 17:26 GMT
#4957
On November 04 2016 02:19 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2016 02:07 bardtown wrote:



No, it's not about the ratio of low:high skilled labour, it's about the measure of inequality. At the current ratio, wages for the low skilled have been tumbling while, for the country as a whole, they have been rising. Now the govt. has not attempted to address this by increasing welfare/infrastructure spending by taxing the rich, as you suggest, but if they did it would be a bubble. As it stands, it's just left as rising inequality.


After your earlier multiplication and currency fiascos I'll take my math over yours, with no disrespect, but again, you're mistaking Schengen for globalisation. If you're taking a long-term, 20 year view on the economic benefits of Brexit, the correct policy response is to invest in education so as to make more domestic workers skilled, rather than fighting a race to the bottom in low-marging sectors, many of which will be automated. Think teach a man how to fish.

Show nested quote +

The US/Ukraine comparison isn't fair either. I would choose to live in Norway or Finland over the US, especially if I was poor.


Erhm, these are countries with 60-65% all-in income tax, I thought you said rising taxes were a bubble exactly one post earlier ?

Mathematically, again, countries are concerned with growth level, before its distribution. It's just standard economic theory that you place yourself in a 'risk neutral world' ( no risk aversion premium ) to evaluate your outcomes. Morally right or wrong, confer standard textbooks. That has very little to do with Brexit.


Your calculations have been consistently atrocious when you are even talking about the right measures. BoE today predicted inflation of 2.7% so your 6-10% prediction is off by a factor of 2-4. And your assertion that their previous prediction of 2.5% would at least double to 5% was also completely wrong.

My point about Nordic countries vs. the US is that they prioritise addressing inequality vs. attracting businesses. Free movement is unsustainable for them, too, and Scandinavians are likely to be among the first to follow the UK out of the EU/single market.
LegalLord
Profile Blog Joined April 2013
United States13779 Posts
November 03 2016 17:26 GMT
#4958
On November 04 2016 02:20 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2016 02:13 bardtown wrote:
On November 04 2016 02:11 LegalLord wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:55 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:48 bardtown wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:47 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:40 bardtown wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:33 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:22 LegalLord wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:07 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
In an effort to dig out facts in a non-partisan way I've dug out a 2015 government report on the impacts of migration in the UK. One would hope it is neutral and represents our administration's consensual and factual view. The report strikes a mostly positive tone and goes into fascinating detail.

Excerpts that looked salient :

' “The people that we need are not available in the UK. … There is not the capability within the UK any longer to meet our
aspirations.” (Manager, Aerospace, Bristol, 5-10% migrants, Large)'

'Empirical evidence – aggregate impacts of immigration on productivity

There is little existing empirical literature that examines the impacts of immigration on productivity. The literature that does exist however emphasises that the effects will vary by different types of migrants, for example by age on arrival, by skill level and by language ability (Alexsynka and Tritah, 2009 and Dadush, 2014). Kangasniemi et al. (2012) finds for the UK from 1996-2005 that although the quality of immigrants did impact positively on labour productivity, this was largely outweighed by the quantity effect of migrants. That is, while there was a growth in output this was largely because of an increase in the quantity of workers, rather than through productivity gains, and so the net effect of immigration on productivity was only marginally positive in the UK. Rolfe et al. (2013) find a positive relationship between the proportion of immigrants in employment for region-sectors and labour productivity, from their descriptive statistics for 1997-2007. In addition their econometric study shows a positive and significant association between increases in the proportion of immigrant workers and labour productivity growth, after controlling for changes in the skill mix of employees. However the positive effect is relatively small, with a 1% change in immigrant share of employment increasing labour
productivity by only 0.06 to 0.07%.'

www.gov.uk

It would appear the aggregate effect has been a small positive for years. As per one of my previous posts, the report makes a statistical distinction between low- and high-skilled workers, one that some may think less-than-honest politicians would be tempted to talk down and take advantage of. Worth reading the full report.

Somewhere upthread I linked another study commissioned by the U.K. Parliament that analyzed the net effect of immigrants, coming to the conclusion that there is such a thing as good and bad immigrants, and that those who took a "immigrants good, immigrants always good" stance are just wrong. I'm on mobile so I'm not about to dig for it, but it's there. The basic takeaway from these reports in conjunction is that there is a perfectly valid case for limiting immigration to encourage "good immigration" and discourage "bad immigration."


You agree with the last paragraph of my post - I said that it is right to cluster into good and bad.

I say - the government says - the net, total, aggregate, impact - the sum - is a small positive. Happy to dig further into the multiple research studies here.

I am arguing that the distribution is bimodal and skewed and it is, in fact, intellectually dishonest to hide that fact for ideological reasons. Because voters are counted by number and not by tax impact, it makes political sense to court low-skilled domestic voters dealing with low-skilled migrants, because there are many more, when in fact their cost to the country is more than offset by the much smaller number of high-skilled migrants. This is what a skewed distribution does ( refer Pareto, etc ).

The May government has shown an uncanny predisposition to tar all migrants with one brush by referring to them all as 'foreigners' and suggested they be 'counted' so that businesses could be 'named and shamed'. This fallacy is inflammatory to all migrants including the high-skilled ones.

But then, since we all agree here that Brexit is a cost and a risk : why take away a small positive at a great cost and great risk ? It would only make sense to get greedy if, in fact, the process was riskless and painless.

Common sense.


The study does not suggest that free movement is good, it suggests that there is a small net benefit to immigration as a whole with high skilled immigration counteracting unskilled immigration. If you limit unhelpful immigration then you improve the margin.

Also, 'net' benefit is not the most useful measure because it does not address the issue of inequality.


Bardtown, this is one of your weaker points. I'm saying if it's not broken ( and you gonna pay £100 to do so ), don't fix it.


But it is broken. Immigration is driving inequality when it needn't do so if we only had the capacity to stop free movement of unskilled labour.


So this is very interesting. Basically I am saying I'd rather have higher aggregate numbers even at the expense of slightly more inequality, because ultimately a rising tide lifts all boats. Think the US instead of Ukraine ; I know which country I'd rather live in.

Would you rather be a billionaire in the Ukraine or a peasant in the US? I know I'd rather be the billionaire, even if I did have to put up with dealing with all the things there is to dislike about life in the Ukraine.


Why do you emphasise 'the'? IIRC they avoid use of 'the Ukraine' to dissociate themselves from the USSR.


It took us another 10 pages to agree, but my girlfriend is Russian/Ukrainian/British and she says Ukraine as well, quoting that very reason.


I use "Ukraine" as well, but I wouldn't have used "the Ukraine" thirty years ago either. In Russian it's just a non-issue and I mostly just see it as a contention that is more fun to poke fun at than actually relevant to anything.
History will sooner or later sweep the European Union away without mercy.
MyLovelyLurker
Profile Joined April 2007
France756 Posts
November 03 2016 17:26 GMT
#4959
On November 04 2016 02:11 LegalLord wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2016 01:55 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:48 bardtown wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:47 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:40 bardtown wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:33 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:22 LegalLord wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:07 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
In an effort to dig out facts in a non-partisan way I've dug out a 2015 government report on the impacts of migration in the UK. One would hope it is neutral and represents our administration's consensual and factual view. The report strikes a mostly positive tone and goes into fascinating detail.

Excerpts that looked salient :

' “The people that we need are not available in the UK. … There is not the capability within the UK any longer to meet our
aspirations.” (Manager, Aerospace, Bristol, 5-10% migrants, Large)'

'Empirical evidence – aggregate impacts of immigration on productivity

There is little existing empirical literature that examines the impacts of immigration on productivity. The literature that does exist however emphasises that the effects will vary by different types of migrants, for example by age on arrival, by skill level and by language ability (Alexsynka and Tritah, 2009 and Dadush, 2014). Kangasniemi et al. (2012) finds for the UK from 1996-2005 that although the quality of immigrants did impact positively on labour productivity, this was largely outweighed by the quantity effect of migrants. That is, while there was a growth in output this was largely because of an increase in the quantity of workers, rather than through productivity gains, and so the net effect of immigration on productivity was only marginally positive in the UK. Rolfe et al. (2013) find a positive relationship between the proportion of immigrants in employment for region-sectors and labour productivity, from their descriptive statistics for 1997-2007. In addition their econometric study shows a positive and significant association between increases in the proportion of immigrant workers and labour productivity growth, after controlling for changes in the skill mix of employees. However the positive effect is relatively small, with a 1% change in immigrant share of employment increasing labour
productivity by only 0.06 to 0.07%.'

www.gov.uk

It would appear the aggregate effect has been a small positive for years. As per one of my previous posts, the report makes a statistical distinction between low- and high-skilled workers, one that some may think less-than-honest politicians would be tempted to talk down and take advantage of. Worth reading the full report.

Somewhere upthread I linked another study commissioned by the U.K. Parliament that analyzed the net effect of immigrants, coming to the conclusion that there is such a thing as good and bad immigrants, and that those who took a "immigrants good, immigrants always good" stance are just wrong. I'm on mobile so I'm not about to dig for it, but it's there. The basic takeaway from these reports in conjunction is that there is a perfectly valid case for limiting immigration to encourage "good immigration" and discourage "bad immigration."


You agree with the last paragraph of my post - I said that it is right to cluster into good and bad.

I say - the government says - the net, total, aggregate, impact - the sum - is a small positive. Happy to dig further into the multiple research studies here.

I am arguing that the distribution is bimodal and skewed and it is, in fact, intellectually dishonest to hide that fact for ideological reasons. Because voters are counted by number and not by tax impact, it makes political sense to court low-skilled domestic voters dealing with low-skilled migrants, because there are many more, when in fact their cost to the country is more than offset by the much smaller number of high-skilled migrants. This is what a skewed distribution does ( refer Pareto, etc ).

The May government has shown an uncanny predisposition to tar all migrants with one brush by referring to them all as 'foreigners' and suggested they be 'counted' so that businesses could be 'named and shamed'. This fallacy is inflammatory to all migrants including the high-skilled ones.

But then, since we all agree here that Brexit is a cost and a risk : why take away a small positive at a great cost and great risk ? It would only make sense to get greedy if, in fact, the process was riskless and painless.

Common sense.


The study does not suggest that free movement is good, it suggests that there is a small net benefit to immigration as a whole with high skilled immigration counteracting unskilled immigration. If you limit unhelpful immigration then you improve the margin.

Also, 'net' benefit is not the most useful measure because it does not address the issue of inequality.


Bardtown, this is one of your weaker points. I'm saying if it's not broken ( and you gonna pay £100 to do so ), don't fix it.


But it is broken. Immigration is driving inequality when it needn't do so if we only had the capacity to stop free movement of unskilled labour.


So this is very interesting. Basically I am saying I'd rather have higher aggregate numbers even at the expense of slightly more inequality, because ultimately a rising tide lifts all boats. Think the US instead of Ukraine ; I know which country I'd rather live in.

Would you rather be a billionaire in the Ukraine or a peasant in the US? I know I'd rather be the billionaire, even if I did have to put up with dealing with all the things there is to dislike about life in the Ukraine.


Respectfully I'm not sure I understand the question. Like many in this country I'm a millionaire in hryvnias, but I'm certainly not moving to Kiev anytime soon. All I'm saying is when trying to affect the moments of a statistical distribution, you move the first order ( average/median level ) first, before tackling the second/third orders ( variance, skew, the markers of inequality ). This is the same as saying you walk a flight of stairs up from the bottom one. It's common sense as recessions hit the poorest the most.

( We can then turn the focus on the dodgy things you'd have to have done in order to become a billionaire in the Ukraine... )
"I just say, it doesn't matter win or lose, I just love Starcraft 2, I love this game, I love this stage, just play like in practice" - TIME/Oliveira
LegalLord
Profile Blog Joined April 2013
United States13779 Posts
November 03 2016 17:35 GMT
#4960
On November 04 2016 02:26 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
Show nested quote +
On November 04 2016 02:11 LegalLord wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:55 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:48 bardtown wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:47 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:40 bardtown wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:33 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:22 LegalLord wrote:
On November 04 2016 01:07 MyLovelyLurker wrote:
In an effort to dig out facts in a non-partisan way I've dug out a 2015 government report on the impacts of migration in the UK. One would hope it is neutral and represents our administration's consensual and factual view. The report strikes a mostly positive tone and goes into fascinating detail.

Excerpts that looked salient :

' “The people that we need are not available in the UK. … There is not the capability within the UK any longer to meet our
aspirations.” (Manager, Aerospace, Bristol, 5-10% migrants, Large)'

'Empirical evidence – aggregate impacts of immigration on productivity

There is little existing empirical literature that examines the impacts of immigration on productivity. The literature that does exist however emphasises that the effects will vary by different types of migrants, for example by age on arrival, by skill level and by language ability (Alexsynka and Tritah, 2009 and Dadush, 2014). Kangasniemi et al. (2012) finds for the UK from 1996-2005 that although the quality of immigrants did impact positively on labour productivity, this was largely outweighed by the quantity effect of migrants. That is, while there was a growth in output this was largely because of an increase in the quantity of workers, rather than through productivity gains, and so the net effect of immigration on productivity was only marginally positive in the UK. Rolfe et al. (2013) find a positive relationship between the proportion of immigrants in employment for region-sectors and labour productivity, from their descriptive statistics for 1997-2007. In addition their econometric study shows a positive and significant association between increases in the proportion of immigrant workers and labour productivity growth, after controlling for changes in the skill mix of employees. However the positive effect is relatively small, with a 1% change in immigrant share of employment increasing labour
productivity by only 0.06 to 0.07%.'

www.gov.uk

It would appear the aggregate effect has been a small positive for years. As per one of my previous posts, the report makes a statistical distinction between low- and high-skilled workers, one that some may think less-than-honest politicians would be tempted to talk down and take advantage of. Worth reading the full report.

Somewhere upthread I linked another study commissioned by the U.K. Parliament that analyzed the net effect of immigrants, coming to the conclusion that there is such a thing as good and bad immigrants, and that those who took a "immigrants good, immigrants always good" stance are just wrong. I'm on mobile so I'm not about to dig for it, but it's there. The basic takeaway from these reports in conjunction is that there is a perfectly valid case for limiting immigration to encourage "good immigration" and discourage "bad immigration."


You agree with the last paragraph of my post - I said that it is right to cluster into good and bad.

I say - the government says - the net, total, aggregate, impact - the sum - is a small positive. Happy to dig further into the multiple research studies here.

I am arguing that the distribution is bimodal and skewed and it is, in fact, intellectually dishonest to hide that fact for ideological reasons. Because voters are counted by number and not by tax impact, it makes political sense to court low-skilled domestic voters dealing with low-skilled migrants, because there are many more, when in fact their cost to the country is more than offset by the much smaller number of high-skilled migrants. This is what a skewed distribution does ( refer Pareto, etc ).

The May government has shown an uncanny predisposition to tar all migrants with one brush by referring to them all as 'foreigners' and suggested they be 'counted' so that businesses could be 'named and shamed'. This fallacy is inflammatory to all migrants including the high-skilled ones.

But then, since we all agree here that Brexit is a cost and a risk : why take away a small positive at a great cost and great risk ? It would only make sense to get greedy if, in fact, the process was riskless and painless.

Common sense.


The study does not suggest that free movement is good, it suggests that there is a small net benefit to immigration as a whole with high skilled immigration counteracting unskilled immigration. If you limit unhelpful immigration then you improve the margin.

Also, 'net' benefit is not the most useful measure because it does not address the issue of inequality.


Bardtown, this is one of your weaker points. I'm saying if it's not broken ( and you gonna pay £100 to do so ), don't fix it.


But it is broken. Immigration is driving inequality when it needn't do so if we only had the capacity to stop free movement of unskilled labour.


So this is very interesting. Basically I am saying I'd rather have higher aggregate numbers even at the expense of slightly more inequality, because ultimately a rising tide lifts all boats. Think the US instead of Ukraine ; I know which country I'd rather live in.

Would you rather be a billionaire in the Ukraine or a peasant in the US? I know I'd rather be the billionaire, even if I did have to put up with dealing with all the things there is to dislike about life in the Ukraine.


Respectfully I'm not sure I understand the question. Like many in this country I'm a millionaire in hryvnias, but I'm certainly not moving to Kiev anytime soon. All I'm saying is when trying to affect the moments of a statistical distribution, you move the first order ( average/median level ) first, before tackling the second/third orders ( variance, skew, the markers of inequality ). This is the same as saying you walk a flight of stairs up from the bottom one. It's common sense as recessions hit the poorest the most.

( We can then turn the focus on the dodgy things you'd have to have done in order to become a billionaire in the Ukraine... )

In terms of policy I mostly agree with the "a rising tide lifts all boats" line in principle, and that sometimes wealth generation takes priority over minimizing inequality. But my small point is that you may very well want to be on the top of the Ukraine curve than on the mid-low end of the US curve.

(More to come when I finish my work day; minor points for now.)
History will sooner or later sweep the European Union away without mercy.
Prev 1 246 247 248 249 250 648 Next
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Next event in 1m
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
ProTech153
StarCraft: Brood War
Calm 7665
Bisu 967
actioN 476
Soulkey 343
Hyuk 300
Larva 147
firebathero 129
hero 123
Barracks 101
Snow 85
[ Show more ]
Light 84
Mind 77
ToSsGirL 68
ggaemo 49
Stork 43
Rush 37
Free 33
EffOrt 33
JYJ 32
Killer 19
Sharp 18
ZerO 14
sOs 13
Terrorterran 12
910 11
soO 9
yabsab 9
League of Legends
JimRising 475
Counter-Strike
olofmeister565
shoxiejesuss489
allub163
Heroes of the Storm
Trikslyr44
Other Games
summit1g12044
ceh9612
Fuzer 104
crisheroes92
ZerO(Twitch)3
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick590
[ Show 11 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• LUISG 4
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• iopq 7
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• lizZardDota2222
Upcoming Events
The PondCast
1m
LiuLi Cup
1h 1m
Rogue vs TBD
Maru vs TBD
OSC
6h 1m
Replay Cast
13h 1m
GSL
1d 1h
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
1d 4h
OSC
1d 6h
Replay Cast
1d 13h
KCM Race Survival
2 days
Ultimate Battle
2 days
ZerO vs Bisu
[ Show More ]
RSL Revival
3 days
BSL
3 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
4 days
IPSL
4 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
4 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
4 days
WardiTV Weekly
5 days
Kung Fu Cup
6 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-16
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.