|
United Kingdom13775 Posts
North Korea and its other neighbors and their place in all this.
On April 15, 2017, Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi made an emergency phone call to Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov to discuss the burgeoning security crisis on the Korean peninsula. During their correspondence, Wang Yi requested Russia’s help in preventing a conflict between the United States and North Korea from taking place.
Even though Russia and China are North Korea’s most important international allies, collaboration between Moscow and Beijing on the Korean security crisis has historically been confined to a multilateral rather than a bilateral framework.
The recent upsurge in bilateral cooperation between Moscow and Beijing on North Korea can be explained by two factors. First, both Russia and China stridently oppose a unilateral U.S. military strike against North Korea’s nuclear facilities. Second, Russian and Chinese officials believe that Moscow-Pyongyang and Beijing-Pyongyang bilateral diplomacy can pressure Kim Jong-Un to transition towards a more peaceful foreign policy course.
Even though Russia and China have rhetorically criticized North Korea’s nuclear tests and ballistic missile program, both countries have consistently opposed a military intervention to disarm North Korea of its nuclear capabilities. As the Trump administration has expressed its willingness to use military force to resolve the Korean peninsula security crisis, Moscow’s and Beijing’s concerns about an imminent U.S. military strike against Pyongyang have become more pronounced than during previous phases of heightened North Korean belligerence.
Cooperation between Russia and China against a unilateral U.S. military strike on North Korea has consisted of systematic violations of international sanctions and military activities aimed at deterring a U.S. military intervention. As the 2003 Iraq War and 2011 Libyan intervention demonstrated Washington’s tendency to use stringent economic isolation as a precursor to forceful regime change, Moscow and Beijing have violated carte blanche UN sanctions against the North Korean economy, and supported more limited punitive measures against the DPRK’s military-industrial complex.
Source
|
Apparently Duterte, who by his own account has killed at least 3 people when he was mayor, and ordered and oversaw the killing of many people, either suspected criminals never given a trial or completely innocent people, this Duterte is now getting scared of all the irrational war talk of Trump. Duterte is calling for Trump to display constraint.
So Trump has Duterte scared. Well done, Trump. I guess when you live in your own imaginary world, you do not need balls of steel. I guess when you do not know that missiles 'explode and kill people', you don't need to worry about the consequences of an all out artillery barrage on Seoul, or even nuclear war.
Let's hope Kim Jong Un, or whatever general that is his puppet-master, realizes that he is the rational agent here.
|
So what do you guys think of this outline of the DPRK government?
http://www.lalkar.org/article/2654/the-democratic-structure-of-the-dprk
+ Show Spoiler +The ‘Democratic People’s Republic’ in ‘DPRK’ is often laughed at by reactionaries and ‘left’ liberals who compare it to the ‘Socialism’ in ‘National Socialism’. However, the DPRK has a complicated and advanced democratic structure, at all levels, and its citizens have access to a level of democracy not seen in the so called ‘free’ nations of the West. We will investigate, briefly, how their governmental and management system works.
The Rights of Citizens
Citizens of the DPRK enjoy a wide range of rights, and many rights are relevant to democratic establishments. We will quote from their constitution to demonstrate these rights:
Article 4
The sovereignty of the DPRK resides in the workers, peasants, working intellectuals and all other working people. The working people exercise power through their representative organs—the Supreme People’s Assembly and local people’s assemblies at all levels.
Article 5
All the State organs in the DPRK are formed and function on the principle of democratic centralism.
Article 6
The organs of State power at all levels, from the county People’s Assembly to the SPA, are elected on the principle of universal, equal and direct suffrage by secret ballot.
Article 7
Deputies to the organs of State power at all levels have close ties with their constituents and are accountable to them for their work.
The electors may recall the deputies they have elected if the latter are not to be trusted.
Article 64
The State shall effectively guarantee genuine democratic rights and liberties as well as the material and cultural well-being of its citizens.
In the DPRK the rights and freedom of citizens shall be amplified with the consolidation and development of the social system.
Article 65
Citizens enjoy equal rights in all spheres of State and public activities.
Article 67
Citizens are guaranteed freedom of speech, of the press, of assembly, demonstration and association.
The State shall guarantee conditions for the free activity of democratic political parties and social organisations.
Article 73
Citizens have the right to education. This right is ensured by an advanced educational system and by the educational measures enacted by the State for the benefit of the people
As can be seen, the DPRKorean citizens have universal suffrage by secret ballot, and all citizens over the age of 17 are allowed to run for public office, regardless of economic situation or political allegiance. We mentioned the right to education, because this too is important for democracy. True democracy can only come about among an informed people, because if the people are misled or ignorant they cannot make choices that best represent them and their desires.
Therefore the DPRK’s constitutionally guaranteed right to education (including at university level) is an important democratic right, one which is lacking in most capitalist ‘democracies’ which require heaps of money to afford a university education, or which put so little funding into their public schools system that it cannot be expected to function properly, thus leaving poorer children unable to access education to the same standard as the wealthier, privately educated children.
There are many organs of state power in the DPRK, all of which are elected democratically. The following section will explain what each of these are and how they interact.
The Supreme People’s Assembly
The Supreme People’s Assembly (SPA) is the highest organ of state power in the DPRK, above roles like Chairman and Supreme Leader. It is composed of elected workers and peasants, primarily representing the Workers’ Party of Korea, and it has the power to make new laws and remove old ones, as well as to edit the nation’s constitution.
Meetings of the SPA happen once or twice a year (national elections happen every five years), but extraordinary meetings can be called by the Presidium or by a petition by at least one third of the members.
The Supreme People’s Assembly Presidium
The SPA Presidium is the equivalent of the Central Council in the USSR, and it is an elected council of full-time politicians who handle the day-to-day operations of the state. While the SPA is not in session, it is the highest organ of state power.
The SPA elects a Chair, a vice-Chair, as well as secretaries and general members. This Presidium does NOT have the authority to amend the constitution, or to introduce new major laws – that can only happen via democratic vote in the SPA, apart from in the instance of invasion, and even then the priority is to try and convene an emergency meeting of the SPA.
The Presidium’s primary role is to carry out the decisions reached by the SPA, to supervise the various committees set up by the SPA, and to work with the Local People’s Assemblies and with the Courts system.
The National Defence Commission
We will briefly mention the National Defence Commission (NDC), as, owing to the nature of the DPRK’s Songun (military first) policy, it is an important organ in the nation. The NDC is also elected by the SPA, and operates in a similar manner to the Presidium.
The NDC’s main role is to oversee the continued expansion of the DPRK’s military and nuclear programme. It has the power to declare a state of war and to mobilise units in such an event.
The Cabinet
The Cabinet’s primary role is that of overseeing of the DPRK’s planned economy, in order to maintain balanced growth, and to carry out diplomatic work with other states.
It too is appointed by the SPA, and it is subordinate to the SPA, and to the Presidium when the SPA is not convened. All national organs of state power in the DPRK are elected, either by the people or by their representatives in the SPA.
The Cabinet can adopt measures, but not new laws or constitutional amendments. The Premier of the Cabinet is the official representative of the DPRK, the role of which is currently occupied by Comrade Pak Pong-ju.
The Local People’s Assembly
The Local People’s Assembly (LPA) is the DPRK’s equivalent of the British model of County Councils, only the LPA has much more power and ability to aid its area than its British equivalents.
It is also elected in the same way as the Supreme People’s Assembly for five years. It can adopt measures to carry out laws, organise plans to carry out the decisions of the Cabinet as to the economy (the DPRK’s nature as a planned economy means that organs such as the LPA have much more power over the local economy than in market economies), and elect or recall judges and other members of the Courts system.
The Local People’s Committee
The Local People’s Committee is the equivalent of the Presidium for the LPA, and it is elected by the LPA.
The Taean Work System
The Taean Work System is the equivalent of how the USSR’s Worker Soviets would work. Places of work are managed by an elected Committee, who decide how to implement the Cabinet’s and the SPA’s decrees as to the economic targets.
This committee must be composed of at least 60% workers, to avoid the council being dominated by old-bourgeois elements. The Party Committee itself elects an executive committee, which takes the role of the day-to-day running of the workplace, the equivalent of the Presidium and the Local People’s Committee.
The Union System
A short mention of the DPRK’s union system is important for truly understanding the democratic nature of the country, where people’s power is truly realised. Unlike in capitalist economies, where unions are seen as impediments to the ever-present profit motive, unions are heavily encouraged and subsidised by the DPRKorean government. The unions have the power to go on strike if they see fit, and look out for their individual group’s needs, within the collectivist system which sees to it that all work together.
There is even an active Children’s Union, much to the horror of the imperialist states which barely allow adults to have unions.
This union system provides reinforcement of the dictatorship of the proletariat, allowing the people multiple democratic methods to see that their wishes and needs are fulfilled.
Comments
What we can see from this is that the DPRK’s democratic system is realised on every level, and that even in the midst of brutal imperialist sanctions and aggression against the state, they maintain their people’s power to an incredibly impressive level.
Quite apart from the standard, racist image in the West of a ‘weird monarchy’ or ‘dynastic dictatorship’, the Kims are very much a part of this system. Comrade Kim Jong Un (who is leader of the Workers’ Party of Korea) is elected, and, if it were wished by the people, could be removed.
We are told that it’s ‘impossible’ for the Korean people to continue to want the same person as their leader (so accustomed are we in the West to poor-quality leaders elected because ‘well, at least they’re not as bad as x’). The Kim family are held in huge respect by the DPRKorean people, and they so far have chosen Kim Jong Il to replace Kim Il Sung and Kim Jong Un to replace him. We are fed this view of Comrade Kim Jong Un as a ‘mad monster’ who gleefully oppresses the ‘poor, brainwashed Korean people’ (the irony of Western liberals calling anyone else brainwashed!) but it is simply not true. It is pure racism to believe that the Korean people would be happy with a government which oppresses them in increasingly ludicrous ways.
If such a regime were to exist as the Western conception of the DPRK surely it would be overthrown in days? The reality is that it there is no such regime. What the DPRK is is in the name – a democratic people’s republic.
Is there any truth to this?
edit- Can anyone that lives in south korea describe how the south views the north these days? Would they support going to war?
|
United States42606 Posts
Stalin's USSR had a very liberal constitution too. It's a nonsense. You can write any constitution you like but if you execute dissenters by shredding them with an anti aircraft cannon then the constitution probably isn't in use.
|
Zurich15325 Posts
In typicallly North Korean hilarious news:
In Germany, North Korea was banned today from renting out their Berlin embassy as a hotel. NK is running a hotel and rents out meeting rooms on their Berlin embassy premises to generate foreign exchange revenue.
The ban is part of economic sanctions against NK aimed to dry out funding for their nuclear armament program.
|
On May 10 2017 19:07 zatic wrote:
In typicallly North Korean hilarious news:
In Germany, North Korea was banned today from renting out their Berlin embassy as a hotel. NK is running a hotel and rents out meeting rooms on their Berlin embassy premises to generate foreign exchange revenue.
The ban is part of economic sanctions against NK aimed to dry out funding for their nuclear armament program.
This is absolutely fantastic. It's like the scheme someone from a children's cartoon would come up with it's so stupid.
|
You know what would be awesome? If they hosted escape games in the embassy instead, appropriately themed of course.
|
United States42606 Posts
North Korea has always been hatching fun schemes to generate foreign currency out of its embassies. From superdollars to meth labs they're never boring.
|
China allegedly stopped a North Korean nuclear test by threatening sanctions!
|
NK is such a funny country. One of the 2 countries in history who have been cut off from the oil supply (the other one being Cuba) and in the light of it they still try to develop more and more military while people are starving (unlike Cuba, where the government was handing out seeds and told people to grow food wherever they can, every piece of land could be used to grow food). They're so dumb I don't even know if I should laugh or cry...
|
On May 03 2017 10:40 Coagulation wrote:So what do you guys think of this outline of the DPRK government? http://www.lalkar.org/article/2654/the-democratic-structure-of-the-dprk+ Show Spoiler +The ‘Democratic People’s Republic’ in ‘DPRK’ is often laughed at by reactionaries and ‘left’ liberals who compare it to the ‘Socialism’ in ‘National Socialism’. However, the DPRK has a complicated and advanced democratic structure, at all levels, and its citizens have access to a level of democracy not seen in the so called ‘free’ nations of the West. We will investigate, briefly, how their governmental and management system works.
The Rights of Citizens
Citizens of the DPRK enjoy a wide range of rights, and many rights are relevant to democratic establishments. We will quote from their constitution to demonstrate these rights:
Article 4
The sovereignty of the DPRK resides in the workers, peasants, working intellectuals and all other working people. The working people exercise power through their representative organs—the Supreme People’s Assembly and local people’s assemblies at all levels.
Article 5
All the State organs in the DPRK are formed and function on the principle of democratic centralism.
Article 6
The organs of State power at all levels, from the county People’s Assembly to the SPA, are elected on the principle of universal, equal and direct suffrage by secret ballot.
Article 7
Deputies to the organs of State power at all levels have close ties with their constituents and are accountable to them for their work.
The electors may recall the deputies they have elected if the latter are not to be trusted.
Article 64
The State shall effectively guarantee genuine democratic rights and liberties as well as the material and cultural well-being of its citizens.
In the DPRK the rights and freedom of citizens shall be amplified with the consolidation and development of the social system.
Article 65
Citizens enjoy equal rights in all spheres of State and public activities.
Article 67
Citizens are guaranteed freedom of speech, of the press, of assembly, demonstration and association.
The State shall guarantee conditions for the free activity of democratic political parties and social organisations.
Article 73
Citizens have the right to education. This right is ensured by an advanced educational system and by the educational measures enacted by the State for the benefit of the people
As can be seen, the DPRKorean citizens have universal suffrage by secret ballot, and all citizens over the age of 17 are allowed to run for public office, regardless of economic situation or political allegiance. We mentioned the right to education, because this too is important for democracy. True democracy can only come about among an informed people, because if the people are misled or ignorant they cannot make choices that best represent them and their desires.
Therefore the DPRK’s constitutionally guaranteed right to education (including at university level) is an important democratic right, one which is lacking in most capitalist ‘democracies’ which require heaps of money to afford a university education, or which put so little funding into their public schools system that it cannot be expected to function properly, thus leaving poorer children unable to access education to the same standard as the wealthier, privately educated children.
There are many organs of state power in the DPRK, all of which are elected democratically. The following section will explain what each of these are and how they interact.
The Supreme People’s Assembly
The Supreme People’s Assembly (SPA) is the highest organ of state power in the DPRK, above roles like Chairman and Supreme Leader. It is composed of elected workers and peasants, primarily representing the Workers’ Party of Korea, and it has the power to make new laws and remove old ones, as well as to edit the nation’s constitution.
Meetings of the SPA happen once or twice a year (national elections happen every five years), but extraordinary meetings can be called by the Presidium or by a petition by at least one third of the members.
The Supreme People’s Assembly Presidium
The SPA Presidium is the equivalent of the Central Council in the USSR, and it is an elected council of full-time politicians who handle the day-to-day operations of the state. While the SPA is not in session, it is the highest organ of state power.
The SPA elects a Chair, a vice-Chair, as well as secretaries and general members. This Presidium does NOT have the authority to amend the constitution, or to introduce new major laws – that can only happen via democratic vote in the SPA, apart from in the instance of invasion, and even then the priority is to try and convene an emergency meeting of the SPA.
The Presidium’s primary role is to carry out the decisions reached by the SPA, to supervise the various committees set up by the SPA, and to work with the Local People’s Assemblies and with the Courts system.
The National Defence Commission
We will briefly mention the National Defence Commission (NDC), as, owing to the nature of the DPRK’s Songun (military first) policy, it is an important organ in the nation. The NDC is also elected by the SPA, and operates in a similar manner to the Presidium.
The NDC’s main role is to oversee the continued expansion of the DPRK’s military and nuclear programme. It has the power to declare a state of war and to mobilise units in such an event.
The Cabinet
The Cabinet’s primary role is that of overseeing of the DPRK’s planned economy, in order to maintain balanced growth, and to carry out diplomatic work with other states.
It too is appointed by the SPA, and it is subordinate to the SPA, and to the Presidium when the SPA is not convened. All national organs of state power in the DPRK are elected, either by the people or by their representatives in the SPA.
The Cabinet can adopt measures, but not new laws or constitutional amendments. The Premier of the Cabinet is the official representative of the DPRK, the role of which is currently occupied by Comrade Pak Pong-ju.
The Local People’s Assembly
The Local People’s Assembly (LPA) is the DPRK’s equivalent of the British model of County Councils, only the LPA has much more power and ability to aid its area than its British equivalents.
It is also elected in the same way as the Supreme People’s Assembly for five years. It can adopt measures to carry out laws, organise plans to carry out the decisions of the Cabinet as to the economy (the DPRK’s nature as a planned economy means that organs such as the LPA have much more power over the local economy than in market economies), and elect or recall judges and other members of the Courts system.
The Local People’s Committee
The Local People’s Committee is the equivalent of the Presidium for the LPA, and it is elected by the LPA.
The Taean Work System
The Taean Work System is the equivalent of how the USSR’s Worker Soviets would work. Places of work are managed by an elected Committee, who decide how to implement the Cabinet’s and the SPA’s decrees as to the economic targets.
This committee must be composed of at least 60% workers, to avoid the council being dominated by old-bourgeois elements. The Party Committee itself elects an executive committee, which takes the role of the day-to-day running of the workplace, the equivalent of the Presidium and the Local People’s Committee.
The Union System
A short mention of the DPRK’s union system is important for truly understanding the democratic nature of the country, where people’s power is truly realised. Unlike in capitalist economies, where unions are seen as impediments to the ever-present profit motive, unions are heavily encouraged and subsidised by the DPRKorean government. The unions have the power to go on strike if they see fit, and look out for their individual group’s needs, within the collectivist system which sees to it that all work together.
There is even an active Children’s Union, much to the horror of the imperialist states which barely allow adults to have unions.
This union system provides reinforcement of the dictatorship of the proletariat, allowing the people multiple democratic methods to see that their wishes and needs are fulfilled.
Comments
What we can see from this is that the DPRK’s democratic system is realised on every level, and that even in the midst of brutal imperialist sanctions and aggression against the state, they maintain their people’s power to an incredibly impressive level.
Quite apart from the standard, racist image in the West of a ‘weird monarchy’ or ‘dynastic dictatorship’, the Kims are very much a part of this system. Comrade Kim Jong Un (who is leader of the Workers’ Party of Korea) is elected, and, if it were wished by the people, could be removed.
We are told that it’s ‘impossible’ for the Korean people to continue to want the same person as their leader (so accustomed are we in the West to poor-quality leaders elected because ‘well, at least they’re not as bad as x’). The Kim family are held in huge respect by the DPRKorean people, and they so far have chosen Kim Jong Il to replace Kim Il Sung and Kim Jong Un to replace him. We are fed this view of Comrade Kim Jong Un as a ‘mad monster’ who gleefully oppresses the ‘poor, brainwashed Korean people’ (the irony of Western liberals calling anyone else brainwashed!) but it is simply not true. It is pure racism to believe that the Korean people would be happy with a government which oppresses them in increasingly ludicrous ways.
If such a regime were to exist as the Western conception of the DPRK surely it would be overthrown in days? The reality is that it there is no such regime. What the DPRK is is in the name – a democratic people’s republic. Is there any truth to this? edit- Can anyone that lives in south korea describe how the south views the north these days? Would they support going to war?
It sounds like typical propaganda or fake. Just reading this part should be enough for your conclusion :
"Article 67
Citizens are guaranteed freedom of speech, of the press, of assembly, demonstration and association.
The State shall guarantee conditions for the free activity of democratic political parties and social organisations."
|
Yeah. Basically, either everything else i have heard of NK so far is totally fake, or that article is fake and/or completely illusory propaganda.
What a country says how things work is not necessarily how they actually work. A constitution is only paper. It is only relevant if it has any influence on what people do.
That article leaves you with one of two possible conclusions. Either there is a giant conspiracy among basically anyone (media, governments, whereever you get any information on NK from) except NK to make NK look bad, or NK is bad and that article is bullshit. Occams Razor favors the second conclusion.
|
United States42606 Posts
North Korea's endless war against the Sea of Japan continues.
|
The bigger story is that the US is about to deploy a third carrier strike group over there. That usually doesn't happen unless military strikes are imminent.
|
On May 29 2017 09:48 KwarK wrote:
North Korea's endless war against the Sea of Japan continues.
Well they're definitely making waves
|
On May 29 2017 10:48 Scarecrow wrote:Show nested quote +On May 29 2017 09:48 KwarK wrote:
North Korea's endless war against the Sea of Japan continues. Well they're definitely making waves
Haha, well done
|
fwiw, I just saw a report in german tv where some reporter said that (according to chinese people near the north korean border) the chinese authorities have shut down smuggling across the border for real now (which they had not done before, despite UN sanctions against NK). He said that might be an indicator of china losing patience with NK.
|
United Kingdom13775 Posts
China has been particularly annoyed with NK ever since NK bombed SK islands a few years back and it's only gotten progressively less tolerant of NK since then.
|
So with NK's latest test:
SEOUL, South Korea — “Self-restraint” is all that is keeping the United States and South Korea from going to war with the North, the top American general in South Korea said on Wednesday. His comment came as the South’s defense minister indicated that the North’s first intercontinental ballistic missile had the potential to reach Hawaii.
Source: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/05/world/asia/north-korea-war-us-icbm.html
The way I see it: North Korea is making notable progress. Their rate of capability increase is troubling. From my perspective, at one point, they'll be able to just directly bomb the US. I can't decide if I think they'd actually do that. I'm not actually sure what their end game is or if they even have one. Everyone knows what happens when you bomb Hawaii.
Regardless, it feels to me like we are perhaps letting NK get strong enough so that we are not blamed for what happens next.
|
Rational state actors can generally be expected to use nuclear capability as a deterrent. Of course, the rub here is that it's somewhat up in the air as to whether someone who executes people with AA cannons and mortars is a "rational state actor."
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
