| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
hyptonic
2155 Posts
Some reports are saying that those beheaded were believe to be talbian spies by the taliban. Dancing/Mingling may not have been the underlying reason... Another BBC report says that they were government workers "The BBC's Quentin Somerville, in the capital Kabul, says some reports suggest the 17 were killed because they were local government workers." http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-19388869 | ||
|
boomudead1
United States186 Posts
| ||
|
Silidons
United States2813 Posts
On August 28 2012 09:16 Xiron wrote: *For human life. I think this is just a media strike to reignite the hate towards those terrorists. 17 dead are nothing special in afghanistan right now. It's really sad this stuff happens all the time though. the difference is that these people think they are going to be rewarded in the afterlife for killing these people because their special book says that it's okay | ||
|
Silentness
United States2821 Posts
 | ||
|
zalz
Netherlands3704 Posts
What the Taliban does in that regard is no so unique, only that they have the power to execute their policies and take it a great deal further than other denominations. The logic is a simple one: This world is temporary, the world beyond is eternal. What we do now will forever seal our fate in the afterworld. So, if this is what you believe to be a 100% fact, then why on earth would you risk your soul for earthly pleasures? Why would you dance or sing? Music is widely considered "haram" (against Islamic code/ethics), and the same basis is in the hatred of the earthly. With music, the Taliban isn't that strange. There are a lot of muslim/christian/jew denominations that warn for the threat of music, considering it too subtle to be resisted, and thus Satan's favorite tool to lead people into sin. The Taliban simply applies this practice to everything from which you can derive earthly enjoyment. There is a famous book, called the Kite Runner, about the Taliban in Afghanistan, the name being derived from when the Taliban banned kite flying in the country, before that a popular past-time for children and adults. Other things are simple scriptural bans, like shellfish, but most are grounded in the same reasoning. Hell is real, earthly temptations distract us from our plight to god. A hundred years of suffering is nothing compared to an eternity in hell. Now, this is the ideological grounding for the Taliban. How far each of the members agrees with it can be questioned, but in general they all adhere to it pretty strictly, simply because it is a maffia-like environment. Either you are with them, or you're against them, and you better show them that you are with them, or else. The Taliban itself, though, is a peculiar beast. The defense on their treatment of women is always the same. They beat them to keep them in line, they cover them to protect their integrity, etc, they pretend like they are all about caring for the women, in their own sick and twisted way. But during their rule, they trafficked women and forced them into sex slavery. There is just something strange about the Taliban. For everything that it says, it has no moral grounding. It has no real beliefs, it has no convictions or goals. It just crushes the human spirit and kills. It even violates its own beliefs when they don't go far enough in inflicting human suffering. There seems to be no greater goal than to inflict suffering. And some would argue that we should pull our hands off Afghanistan and let them take over. Sorry girls, hope you like acid to the face, because we need to balance our budget. An entire generation of Afghan girls are being raised on education. How many of them will avoid a life of intellectual retardation by being given the chance to study? That alone makes the struggle worth it. I don't care why they were beheaded. No matter what they did or who they are, this is really crazy. Getting decapitated/beheaded is just straight up torture. Unfortunately I have seen some of those beheading videos (uncut) and it's really rough to watch. Their capital punishment is gruesome... Not that I am planning on either, but I much prefer a guilotine to an electric chair. | ||
|
Flamingo777
United States1190 Posts
On August 28 2012 12:04 hyptonic wrote: Some reports are saying that those beheaded were believe to be talbian spies by the taliban. Dancing/Mingling may not have been the underlying reason... Another BBC report says that they were government workers "The BBC's Quentin Somerville, in the capital Kabul, says some reports suggest the 17 were killed because they were local government workers." http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-19388869 It will be hard to have a good discussion with inconsistencies such as this still out there. But regardless, that's a lot of executions, and it's entirely inexcusable. | ||
|
RageBot
Israel1530 Posts
On August 28 2012 09:16 Xiron wrote: *For human life. I think this is just a media strike to reignite the hate towards those terrorists. 17 dead are nothing special in afghanistan right now. It's really sad this stuff happens all the time though. Also dog can cat life. | ||
|
iDope
Saudi Arabia223 Posts
On August 28 2012 09:14 Verator wrote: First of all, its not really laws, its religious text. And dancing is a sin, their text says sins should be punished with death, so they kill them. Its the same as if people actually followed the old testament's commands in the bible. There is no text in Islam that says that singing or dancing is punishable by death. Please don't attribute things to sharia law unless you are absolutely certain of what you are talking about. | ||
|
Le French
France782 Posts
| ||
|
branflakes14
2082 Posts
| ||
|
LastKarma
Romania11 Posts
On August 28 2012 12:33 Silentness wrote: I don't care why they were beheaded. No matter what they did or who they are, this is really crazy. Getting decapitated/beheaded is just straight up torture. Unfortunately I have seen some of those beheading videos (uncut) and it's really rough to watch. Their capital punishment is gruesome... While I am in agreement with the opinion of most that it is unspeakable to kill someone with justification from the Qu'ran, I am also pretty sure that beheading is not torture; it is quick and painless; we see it as gruesome because of the visual effect, but the person involved feels nothing. We see it as degrading the body, as an act of barbarism. I am sure though that it is better to be beheaded rather than be stoned to death, or other penalties described and used by muslim extremists. Also I am sure the taleban mostly use the Qu'ran for political means. They interpret it the best they can to destroy opponents. They seem rather paranoid though ... opponents everywhere. | ||
|
lem0ncake
England85 Posts
| ||
|
kafkaesque
Germany2006 Posts
It looks a little like this: | ||
|
thurst0n
United States611 Posts
If you shame the community, you could be banished, and possibly killed by your own brother or father. | ||
|
Sea_Food
Finland1612 Posts
17 killed by islamist extreamist? Better make a military campaing against them that will kill 100 000 more people. RIP dancers. PS. Not saying that the killing of the 17 was justified, but it was not just dancing, they were also listening to non koranic music, and it was a mixed sex gathering, and neither of those are allowed either acording to the people who did the killing. | ||
|
Alpino
Brazil4390 Posts
On August 28 2012 22:48 Sea_Food wrote: They just want to spread hate against terrorist, ignoring that US soldiers have killed over a thousand times moer innocent civilians for actually no reason. 17 killed by islamist extreamist? Better make a military campaing against them that will kill 100 000 more people. RIP dancers. Rest assured that both sides are in the wrong here. | ||
|
CrtBalorda
Slovenia704 Posts
I think. Its still pretty stupid of them to start dancing if there are laws against it though. | ||
|
Sea_Food
Finland1612 Posts
On August 28 2012 22:51 CrtBalorda wrote: Well I guess where I live isnt that bad. I think. Its still pretty stupid of them to start dancing if there are laws against it though. IIRC the law has not pervented what they were doing since 2001, but the people who did the killing support the old law, so what the killers did was illeagal acording to national law, not what the dancers did. | ||
|
Khainer
Netherlands54 Posts
On August 28 2012 11:43 BroOd wrote: Theory of the attack seems to be evolving: http://www.aljazeera.com/news/asia/2012/08/2012827141644149141.html I still find it weird how so many people are turning this into a religion and/or cultural debate. There are many gangs in america who kill on daily basis aswell, but no one blames the american culture for that. We have some random shootings here in the Netherlands aswell, but no one blames the dutch culture for that. As soon as something happens in the middle eastern regions, the finger gets pointed to culture. There are plenty of nutjobs in every region, their actions are crazy, unbelievable and i can't comprehend why anyone would do that. If you say it happens more in the middle east then any other culture, you're wrong, look at Africa, more shit is happening there then in the middle east. They just make sure it doesn't go public as much. Now if you look at this case, you see the government (same culture as where the tragic event happened) is reporting it. This is a very good development. The more crap like this is being made public the sooner it will stop. No one will endorse this except the purpetraiters and their followers. That being said my sorrow goes the the family of all the victims. | ||
|
TheFish7
United States2824 Posts
http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2012/07/09/120709fa_fact_filkins | ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Britney Counter-Strike  18843Soulkey  563Shuttle 370Horang2 345Mini 333Shine 91firebathero  70910 39Mong 33Trap 27[ Show more ] Heroes of the Storm Other Games |
|
PiGosaur Cup
The PondCast
Kung Fu Cup
Replay Cast
KCM Race Survival
IntoTheTV X SOOP
OSC
Replay Cast
IntoTheTV X SOOP
Replay Cast
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
