|
On September 16 2012 23:23 abalam wrote:Show nested quote +On September 16 2012 23:06 Wetty wrote:On September 16 2012 22:42 abalam wrote:On September 16 2012 21:41 iNbluE wrote:
Okay, got to try some new stuff. Laphroaig 18 (holy shit...), Ardbeg Alligator (HOLY SHIT...) and Ardbeg Uigeadail.
I'm so thankful to have tried them. Laphroaig 10 seems just boring when you come back from these :D
The alligator is impressive. At first it seems kind of weak, but it develops over a huge timespan, it is powerful, smoky, and a strong iodine taste. We were underwhelmed by the Uigeadail though, and all agreed that it wasn't as complex as we thought it would be. Maybe next time..? You should try Ardbeg Supernova (if you can manage to get one), should be something you'll enjoy. Also try out Bowmore Tempest to get your mind blown. Weird though that you get iodine with the Alligator, I'd rather match that taste with some of the Laphroaigs (Quartercask especially). So I got my hands onto the new Ardbeg Galileo which is matured in first fill burbon casks and then finished in marsala whine casks. Tried it the first day and didn't really like it. Tasted like licking the tarmac off a freshly paved road. There was some fruit there but it was just too much tar (not smoke or peat, tar). Tried it again today and it's much more balanced, more fruity and pleasant. The tar notes are still there (along with some smoke notes) but just as a side note. + Show Spoiler + Really excited for the Galileo, I may have spent far too much money ordering one, hoping it will be worth it :D How does it compare to the standard Ardbeg 10? Can't really compare them. Galileo is definitely more complex. My favorite Ardbeg is still the Alligator (very closely followed by the Supernova, though again I don't think you can compare them), though the Galileo is rapidly growing on me. How much did you spend ? I paid 75 € (minus 19% German VAT).
105 euro equiv. at current exchange rates, + possibly tax @ ~20 euros. So a lot more >.>
|
On September 10 2012 19:45 Wetty wrote:Show nested quote +On September 09 2012 04:00 Equity213 wrote:On September 08 2012 12:08 Wetty wrote:On September 08 2012 11:57 Abraxas514 wrote:On September 07 2012 06:25 Pulimuli wrote:On September 07 2012 05:55 iNbluE wrote:
Just got into whiskey very recently through a friend of mine. I really really enjoyed Ardbeg and Laphroaig (both 10 years I think?). How do these two compare to others of the same kind? Are they amongst the good, the very good, or are they just "average"? I can just speak for Laphroaigh, since its my favorite whisky (which probably makes me a bit biased) but Laphroaigh 10year is awesome. Really nice taste if you like smoky whiskies Try the quarter cask, and some lagavulin for moar. Its also significantly cheaper than the other bottles we're talking about (the quarter cask being the most expensive, but definitely worth the investment) Interesting, in Canada the quarter cask is the least expensive. On September 08 2012 13:29 TotalBalanceSC2 wrote:
Can I just ask if anyone has any experience with Glenfiddich, what was your opinion on their products? I personally avoid alcohol like the plague but some relatives enjoy the stuff and it is good to know what Whiskey drinkers think is a good product. Overheard them talking about whiskey brands and that is the only one I remember. What of their products would you guys recomend as a gift. When it comes to Glenfiddich, the 12 is boring but decent, worth the price. The 15 is alot better and damn good value imho. Its only like 6$ more than the 12. Havent tried the 18 but hear its not worth the price. Get the 15 as a gift for sure. We're talking about the same thing with the Glenfiddich, I was saying 8 and 12 before when I should of been saying 12 and 15, not sure how I managed that one. I agree with you completely. Sadly in Aus, the price difference isnt $6, it's $50 :/ Soooo silly.
wait what? you pay 50$ more for the 15 over the 12? thats fucking insane. here its like ~24€ for the 12 and ~35€ for the 15.
didnt even know a 8 years one existed.
|
On September 17 2012 00:52 BeMannerDuPenner wrote:Show nested quote +On September 10 2012 19:45 Wetty wrote:On September 09 2012 04:00 Equity213 wrote:On September 08 2012 12:08 Wetty wrote:On September 08 2012 11:57 Abraxas514 wrote:On September 07 2012 06:25 Pulimuli wrote:On September 07 2012 05:55 iNbluE wrote:
Just got into whiskey very recently through a friend of mine. I really really enjoyed Ardbeg and Laphroaig (both 10 years I think?). How do these two compare to others of the same kind? Are they amongst the good, the very good, or are they just "average"? I can just speak for Laphroaigh, since its my favorite whisky (which probably makes me a bit biased) but Laphroaigh 10year is awesome. Really nice taste if you like smoky whiskies Try the quarter cask, and some lagavulin for moar. Its also significantly cheaper than the other bottles we're talking about (the quarter cask being the most expensive, but definitely worth the investment) Interesting, in Canada the quarter cask is the least expensive. On September 08 2012 13:29 TotalBalanceSC2 wrote:
Can I just ask if anyone has any experience with Glenfiddich, what was your opinion on their products? I personally avoid alcohol like the plague but some relatives enjoy the stuff and it is good to know what Whiskey drinkers think is a good product. Overheard them talking about whiskey brands and that is the only one I remember. What of their products would you guys recomend as a gift. When it comes to Glenfiddich, the 12 is boring but decent, worth the price. The 15 is alot better and damn good value imho. Its only like 6$ more than the 12. Havent tried the 18 but hear its not worth the price. Get the 15 as a gift for sure. We're talking about the same thing with the Glenfiddich, I was saying 8 and 12 before when I should of been saying 12 and 15, not sure how I managed that one. I agree with you completely. Sadly in Aus, the price difference isnt $6, it's $50 :/ Soooo silly. wait what? you pay 50$ more for the 15 over the 12? thats fucking insane. here its like ~24€ for the 12 and ~35€ for the 15. didnt even know a 8 years one existed.
The 8 year old was a typo, thats not a thing. But thats the price different between 12 and 15. http://danmurphys.com.au/dm/home.jsp is the best priced liquor here, and $60 AUD compared to $93 AUD.(~26.5 euro difference, more than your 12yr, its so silly :/)
|
Hi,
just bought Balblair 2001 vintage, will try it this weekend.
Anyone tried it?
|
I enjoy drinking scotchs as well as bourbons. I am in possession of Chivas (12 & 18 y), virginia, 4 roses, jim bean...
btw, the fact is that you can enjoy a great bourbon with a proper budget, but here is few 'premium' bourbons (at least aviliable in europe). And in contrast, the really low prizes scotch are not that good but became really interresting as far as your budget grows.
|
I'm new to this whole idea, but so far, I've had quite good expiriences. Currently I've got Glenfiddich 12yo, Taketsuru 12yo and Jack Daniels single barrel.
Those more knowledgeable TL members, what would you recommend in the 25-40€ price range for a next purchase (probably in a few months, as this is quite an expensive ''hobby'')
|
On October 08 2012 01:50 Manijak wrote:
I'm new to this whole idea, but so far, I've had quite good expiriences. Currently I've got Glenfiddich 12yo, Taketsuru 12yo and Jack Daniels single barrel.
Those more knowledgeable TL members, what would you recommend in the 25-40€ price range for a next purchase (probably in a few months, as this is quite an expensive ''hobby'')
dalwhinnie 15, laphroaig quarter cask and for us wild turkey rare breed are three very different choices that come to mind. should all be between 30€ and 40€ and all very good.
|
On October 08 2012 01:50 Manijak wrote:
I'm new to this whole idea, but so far, I've had quite good expiriences. Currently I've got Glenfiddich 12yo, Taketsuru 12yo and Jack Daniels single barrel.
Those more knowledgeable TL members, what would you recommend in the 25-40€ price range for a next purchase (probably in a few months, as this is quite an expensive ''hobby'')
I just finished a Glenfiddich 15, good choice, was delicious. The next thing I got was a Talisker 10. Definitely recommended if you want something with a little stronger taste. It's quite good for when you just want to sit back and enjoy a good glass.
|
On October 08 2012 04:16 BeMannerDuPenner wrote:Show nested quote +On October 08 2012 01:50 Manijak wrote:
I'm new to this whole idea, but so far, I've had quite good expiriences. Currently I've got Glenfiddich 12yo, Taketsuru 12yo and Jack Daniels single barrel.
Those more knowledgeable TL members, what would you recommend in the 25-40€ price range for a next purchase (probably in a few months, as this is quite an expensive ''hobby'') dalwhinnie 15, laphroaig quarter cask and for us wild turkey rare breed are three very different choices that come to mind. should all be between 30€ and 40€ and all very good.
I think Laphroaig is WAY too smokey for a beginner. I'd recommend (besides Dalwhinnie 15) Old Pulteney 12, I think it has a really good balance and you can taste a wide variety of flavors. Really interesting single malt.
You could also go for Cardhu 12 or 15. I tried the Cardhu 12 when I was starting with drinking whiksey and surely don't regret buying. It has quite a strong note of honey.
|
On October 08 2012 04:53 Rubyfire wrote:Show nested quote +On October 08 2012 04:16 BeMannerDuPenner wrote:On October 08 2012 01:50 Manijak wrote:
I'm new to this whole idea, but so far, I've had quite good expiriences. Currently I've got Glenfiddich 12yo, Taketsuru 12yo and Jack Daniels single barrel.
Those more knowledgeable TL members, what would you recommend in the 25-40€ price range for a next purchase (probably in a few months, as this is quite an expensive ''hobby'') dalwhinnie 15, laphroaig quarter cask and for us wild turkey rare breed are three very different choices that come to mind. should all be between 30€ and 40€ and all very good. I think Laphroaig is WAY too smokey for a beginner. I'd recommend (besides Dalwhinnie 15) Old Pulteney 12, I think it has a really good balance and you can taste a wide variety of flavors. Really interesting single malt. You could also go for Cardhu 12 or 15. I tried the Cardhu 12 when I was starting with drinking whiksey and surely don't regret buying. It has quite a strong note of honey.
its worth a try and there are way worse once out there. for me one of my first good quality whiskys was a laphroaig 10. and when i recently offered two beginner friends to test some of my stuff it was the laphroaig that one of them bought for themselves shortly after. btw the dalwhinnie was what the other got, you just convince evryone with that one since its so "userfriendly" :>
|
On October 08 2012 05:07 BeMannerDuPenner wrote:Show nested quote +On October 08 2012 04:53 Rubyfire wrote:On October 08 2012 04:16 BeMannerDuPenner wrote:On October 08 2012 01:50 Manijak wrote:
I'm new to this whole idea, but so far, I've had quite good expiriences. Currently I've got Glenfiddich 12yo, Taketsuru 12yo and Jack Daniels single barrel.
Those more knowledgeable TL members, what would you recommend in the 25-40€ price range for a next purchase (probably in a few months, as this is quite an expensive ''hobby'') dalwhinnie 15, laphroaig quarter cask and for us wild turkey rare breed are three very different choices that come to mind. should all be between 30€ and 40€ and all very good. I think Laphroaig is WAY too smokey for a beginner. I'd recommend (besides Dalwhinnie 15) Old Pulteney 12, I think it has a really good balance and you can taste a wide variety of flavors. Really interesting single malt. You could also go for Cardhu 12 or 15. I tried the Cardhu 12 when I was starting with drinking whiksey and surely don't regret buying. It has quite a strong note of honey. its worth a try and there are way worse once out there. for me one of my first good quality whiskys was a laphroaig 10. and when i recently offered two beginner friends to test some of my stuff it was the laphroaig that one of them bought for themselves shortly after. btw the dalwhinnie was what the other got, you just convince evryone with that one since its so "userfriendly" :>
Don't get me wrong. I LOVE Laphroaig. Be it the usual 10 yo or quarter cask.
Well maybe you're right. It's worth a shot and see if the "dark" side of whiskey is for you. :D
It's good to see people liking turfy whiskeys, especially beginners. Most of the people I know don't like them at all, that's why I thought it's maybe too smokey for somebody to begin with. 
|
I had a few glasses of Balblair 2001 vintage this weekend and it surprised me with its smoothness. It was really different from Edradour Caledonia, the other highland whisky I tried.
|
On October 08 2012 05:26 xaoteca wrote:
I had a few glasses of Balblair 2001 vintage this weekend and it surprised me with its smoothness. It was really different from Edradour Caledonia, the other highland whisky I tried.
Thank you so much! I was on the lookout for something new to try.
After reading your post and looking for the Balblair '01 I just had to order a bottle. 
|
On October 08 2012 05:45 Rubyfire wrote:+ Show Spoiler +On October 08 2012 05:26 xaoteca wrote:
I had a few glasses of Balblair 2001 vintage this weekend and it surprised me with its smoothness. It was really different from Edradour Caledonia, the other highland whisky I tried. Thank you so much! I was on the lookout for something new to try. After reading your post and looking for the Balblair '01 I just had to order a bottle.
Happy to help with your choice! I hope you like it.
On October 08 2012 05:07 BeMannerDuPenner wrote:+ Show Spoiler +On October 08 2012 04:53 Rubyfire wrote:Show nested quote +On October 08 2012 04:16 BeMannerDuPenner wrote:On October 08 2012 01:50 Manijak wrote:
I'm new to this whole idea, but so far, I've had quite good expiriences. Currently I've got Glenfiddich 12yo, Taketsuru 12yo and Jack Daniels single barrel.
Those more knowledgeable TL members, what would you recommend in the 25-40€ price range for a next purchase (probably in a few months, as this is quite an expensive ''hobby'') dalwhinnie 15, laphroaig quarter cask and for us wild turkey rare breed are three very different choices that come to mind. should all be between 30€ and 40€ and all very good. I think Laphroaig is WAY too smokey for a beginner. I'd recommend (besides Dalwhinnie 15) Old Pulteney 12, I think it has a really good balance and you can taste a wide variety of flavors. Really interesting single malt. You could also go for Cardhu 12 or 15. I tried the Cardhu 12 when I was starting with drinking whiksey and surely don't regret buying. It has quite a strong note of honey. its worth a try and there are way worse once out there. for me one of my first good quality whiskys was a laphroaig 10. and when i recently offered two beginner friends to test some of my stuff it was the laphroaig that one of them bought for themselves shortly after. btw the dalwhinnie was what the other got, you just convince evryone with that one since its so "userfriendly" :>
I heard a few people say that they wouldn't recommend Laphroaig to beginners, but it is actually one of the single malts I enjoyed the most. So far I had Laphroaig 10 and Signatory Vintage 2000.
I do agree with Rubyfire that Cardhu 12 is great as well.
|
What a glorious thread! I recently started absolutely loving whiskey! I have basically been drinking Jameson straight from the bottle every weekend for the last few months! Personally I think it's quite a shame adding anything to it. You just have to get used to it and then there is no turning back
Generally I slightly prefer the Irish whiskey over Scotch but only slightly! Both kinds are really delicious in their own way!
Haven't tried any Bourbon. The only American one I have tried is Jack D which I really didn't like as much as my Irish one love, but it did taste like it would be pretty good to mix with for some reason.
To be fair I was living in Ireland for a few months so I'm biased as hell 
Cheers!
|
On October 08 2012 07:17 Cereb wrote:What a glorious thread! I recently started absolutely loving whiskey! I have basically been drinking Jameson straight from the bottle every weekend for the last few months! Personally I think it's quite a shame adding anything to it. You just have to get used to it and then there is no turning back Generally I slightly prefer the Irish whiskey over Scotch but only slightly! Both kinds are really delicious in their own way! Haven't tried any Bourbon. The only American one I have tried is Jack D which I really didn't like as much as my Irish one love, but it did taste like it would be pretty good to mix with for some reason. To be fair I was living in Ireland for a few months so I'm biased as hell Cheers!
Jack Daniels isn't a bourbon, and I feel the same way about it - it's a little too "watery" to stand on it's own, especially if you're used to drinking bourbon. Goes well in a mixed drink though, which is certainly a formula for business success.
On that note, I'm looking to add to my bourbon collection. Anyone have any suggestions or personal favorites?
|
Whatever hits up like a baccardi is the one i'll go for anyday
|
+ Show Spoiler +On October 08 2012 07:27 phyre112 wrote:Show nested quote +On October 08 2012 07:17 Cereb wrote:What a glorious thread! I recently started absolutely loving whiskey! I have basically been drinking Jameson straight from the bottle every weekend for the last few months! Personally I think it's quite a shame adding anything to it. You just have to get used to it and then there is no turning back Generally I slightly prefer the Irish whiskey over Scotch but only slightly! Both kinds are really delicious in their own way! Haven't tried any Bourbon. The only American one I have tried is Jack D which I really didn't like as much as my Irish one love, but it did taste like it would be pretty good to mix with for some reason. To be fair I was living in Ireland for a few months so I'm biased as hell Cheers! Jack Daniels isn't a bourbon, and I feel the same way about it - it's a little too "watery" to stand on it's own, especially if you're used to drinking bourbon. Goes well in a mixed drink though, which is certainly a formula for business success. On that note, I'm looking to add to my bourbon collection. Anyone have any suggestions or personal favorites?
Give Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select a try, it's a really delicious smooth bourbon. Has a slightly sweet vanilla/honey taste and a lot of "warmth" to it. I'm usually more of a scotch drinker, but it's my favorite by far if I want bourbon.
Also, if anyone's tried both Macallan 12yo AND 10yo could tell me if the difference between em is worth the extra $30 for a 12yo I'd appreciate it <3
|
On October 08 2012 08:03 Chylith wrote:+ Show Spoiler +On October 08 2012 07:27 phyre112 wrote:Show nested quote +On October 08 2012 07:17 Cereb wrote:What a glorious thread! I recently started absolutely loving whiskey! I have basically been drinking Jameson straight from the bottle every weekend for the last few months! Personally I think it's quite a shame adding anything to it. You just have to get used to it and then there is no turning back Generally I slightly prefer the Irish whiskey over Scotch but only slightly! Both kinds are really delicious in their own way! Haven't tried any Bourbon. The only American one I have tried is Jack D which I really didn't like as much as my Irish one love, but it did taste like it would be pretty good to mix with for some reason. To be fair I was living in Ireland for a few months so I'm biased as hell Cheers! Jack Daniels isn't a bourbon, and I feel the same way about it - it's a little too "watery" to stand on it's own, especially if you're used to drinking bourbon. Goes well in a mixed drink though, which is certainly a formula for business success. On that note, I'm looking to add to my bourbon collection. Anyone have any suggestions or personal favorites? Give Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select a try, it's a really delicious smooth bourbon. Has a slightly sweet vanilla/honey taste and a lot of "warmth" to it. I'm usually more of a scotch drinker, but it's my favorite by far if I want bourbon. Also, if anyone's tried both Macallan 12yo AND 10yo could tell me if the difference between em is worth the extra $30 for a 12yo I'd appreciate it <3
Agreed, Woodford Reserve is pretty good.
I'd also recommend Canadian Club for bourbon whiskeys,
|
On October 08 2012 07:27 phyre112 wrote:Show nested quote +On October 08 2012 07:17 Cereb wrote:What a glorious thread! I recently started absolutely loving whiskey! I have basically been drinking Jameson straight from the bottle every weekend for the last few months! Personally I think it's quite a shame adding anything to it. You just have to get used to it and then there is no turning back Generally I slightly prefer the Irish whiskey over Scotch but only slightly! Both kinds are really delicious in their own way! Haven't tried any Bourbon. The only American one I have tried is Jack D which I really didn't like as much as my Irish one love, but it did taste like it would be pretty good to mix with for some reason. To be fair I was living in Ireland for a few months so I'm biased as hell Cheers! Jack Daniels isn't a bourbon, and I feel the same way about it - it's a little too "watery" to stand on it's own, especially if you're used to drinking bourbon. Goes well in a mixed drink though, which is certainly a formula for business success. On that note, I'm looking to add to my bourbon collection. Anyone have any suggestions or personal favorites?
im not a big bourbon guy but i like the wild turkey rare breed for bang/buck value and the blantons straight from the barrel. my bottle came at ~67.2 so you have to water it down some but then its quite smooth and tasty.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT![[image loading]](http://img.thewhiskyexchange.com/l/abgob.1999v1.jpg)
