|
god, I can't believe some of the things people are willing to accept.
This simply isn't biologically possible.
On May 04 2010 20:28 Zurles wrote:Show nested quote +On May 04 2010 20:23 Garnet wrote: Read more about Tibetan people if you don't believe this. or more about human biology and science if you do? winnerrrrrr
On May 04 2010 22:29 stafu wrote:Show nested quote +On May 04 2010 22:01 RaNgeD wrote: Jesus answered, "It is written: 'Man does not live on bread alone, but on every word that comes from the mouth of God. (Matthew 4:4) Please.. meditation and Buddhism as a philosophy is nothing like the silly myth of Christianity. Thank you!
|
On May 04 2010 22:01 RaNgeD wrote: Jesus answered, "It is written: 'Man does not live on bread alone, but on every word that comes from the mouth of God. (Matthew 4:4)
edited: cbf stirring. As for what I believe, I don't know. Without water seems improbable, though without food I can somewhat believe. I'd be interested to see the outcome of this if it is truly scientific and not tabloid nonsense.
|
On May 04 2010 19:38 Craz wrote: His moms cooking must have been terrible for him to stop eating at age 13.
hahahhaha! win!
|
edit: whoops, double post
|
On May 04 2010 18:59 Divinek wrote: Prahlad Jani says he has survived without food and water for more than seven decades. India's Defense Institute of Physiology & Allied Science is researching the 83-year-old's claims.
And I thought America did stupid shit with tax money.
|
On May 04 2010 22:19 ChinaRestaurant wrote: I for one am interested to see how this works out. One would assume this is total bullshit but when you look at what abilities people have achieved through extensive meditation and training, its not that unbelievable for me that he might be able to control his bodily functions to a degree where he can get all the nutrition he needs from sunlight and the humidity. Still, i dont think hes gone 70 years without eating and drinking.
How can you actually believe the words that you are saying? All of the things people have been proven to be able to do through meditation are at least reasonable. It's mostly just being able to control heart rate/blood pressure/state of mind/etc. None of it has ever done anything like allow us to obtain nutrients in ways that we cannot do. How exactly is meditation going to cause us to get nutrition from sunlight? Our body has absolutely no mechanism for turning sunlight into every essential nutrient. This is just blatantly retarded, and basic physics shows us that it's not possible to survive without taking in a certain number of calories.
Do I think that through meditation we can control metabolism and slow down many bodily functions and thus decrease our need for food? Yes, that's possible, but that's completely different than what this man claims to be doing.
|
On May 04 2010 22:18 creepcolony wrote: Is there any living beeing on the planet that can survive without any water ? I dont think so. So why should we be able to do that ? No way this is true.
The kangaroo rat in Australia does I believe. It goes without drinking a drop of water it's entire life. The trick is that it gets all the water it needs from the leaves it eats.
|
Also, there was a guy in my home state in India who fasted for 42 something days without food or water but he eventually died. He's one of the local heroes as he was the primary reason we got statehood.
|
On May 04 2010 22:36 PJA wrote:Show nested quote +On May 04 2010 22:19 ChinaRestaurant wrote: I for one am interested to see how this works out. One would assume this is total bullshit but when you look at what abilities people have achieved through extensive meditation and training, its not that unbelievable for me that he might be able to control his bodily functions to a degree where he can get all the nutrition he needs from sunlight and the humidity. Still, i dont think hes gone 70 years without eating and drinking. How can you actually believe the words that you are saying? All of the things people have been proven to be able to do through meditation are at least reasonable. It's mostly just being able to control heart rate/blood pressure/state of mind/etc. None of it has ever done anything like allow us to obtain nutrients in ways that we cannot do. How exactly is meditation going to cause us to get nutrition from sunlight? Our body has absolutely no mechanism for turning sunlight into every essential nutrient. This is just blatantly retarded, and basic physics shows us that it's not possible to survive without taking in a certain number of calories. Do I think that through meditation we can control metabolism and slow down many bodily functions and thus decrease our need for food? Yes, that's possible, but that's completely different than what this man claims to be doing.
Sunlight is essential for any living being, without it certain nutritients cant be created by a chemical process. Also i didnt say i believe in the story of the man, i just said that it isnt in the reaches of unbelievable things like for instance use the force if you meditate long enough. That being said as i have stated before i dont think he actually did this for 70 years so wheres your reason to get all excited about my post? I will only believe this once i see solid proof for it. So you can chill again ;P
edit: sorry i misread that part about sunlight getting him everything necessary.
|
this reminds me of when man said its impossible to build flying craft, its impossible to get man into space, its impossible to go above 40mph, see my point? Wait for the test results, if we say impossible, end of.. Man would still be living in caves.
|
The sad thing is that people even need to discuss if this could be possible. What I find more interesting about this guy and cases of "psychics" is what is going on in their head. They are blatantly lying their asses off, and taking active measures to support their lie. I still wonder though if they believe their own bullshit even while they're doing cold reading or eating and drinking (like the guy could have subsisted on a minimal diet, and then convinced himself that he didn't eat for 70 years somehow).
|
On May 04 2010 22:51 eNoq wrote: this reminds me of when man said its impossible to build flying craft, its impossible to get man into space, its impossible to go above 40mph, see my point? Wait for the test results, if we say impossible, end of.. Man would still be living in caves.
This tbh,
Most likely it's some sort of scam, but you don't have to look down on people who believe otherwise >_>
|
On May 04 2010 22:56 kuresuti wrote:Show nested quote +On May 04 2010 22:51 eNoq wrote: this reminds me of when man said its impossible to build flying craft, its impossible to get man into space, its impossible to go above 40mph, see my point? Wait for the test results, if we say impossible, end of.. Man would still be living in caves.
This tbh, Most likely it's some sort of scam, but you don't have to look down on people who believe otherwise >_>
correctomundo
|
It was so hard to resist the urge to troll this thread. As far as I'm concerned this doesn't even warrant debate. The truth of this matter is obvious to all but the most stupid.
|
On May 04 2010 22:51 eNoq wrote: this reminds me of when man said its impossible to build flying craft, its impossible to get man into space, its impossible to go above 40mph, see my point? Wait for the test results, if we say impossible, end of.. Man would still be living in caves.
The critical thinking thread sucks but somehow I got the feeling you have to go through that stuff, young padawan
|
let's just say that i chuckled
|
Doesn't seem so outrageous to me. I've read about breatharians before, there's a lot about the human body that remains a mystery. Did you know we don't know shit? All that stuff about the lock and key methods of hormones and enzymes may be b.s According to a book called Energy Medicine a scientific approach there i evidence that things like adrenaline, which cause a change in your body in seconds does not use the lock and key method wich counts on probability which takes forever but instead has an energy signature that signals all cells it comes near. Wish i could state study but cant find book. Also Matter is just energy. Energy equals mass times the speed of light squared. E=mc2. So food is just condensed energy. There is electromagnetic energy emerging from the earth at all times, as well as coming from the sun. If you could harness enough of it perhaps our body can use it to make solids such as water, protein etc. Not saying i know for sure, but i do know that we don't know shit. =)
|
Have you ever wondered what he could have done in 65 years without wasting time eating and drinking?
+ Show Spoiler +
|
On May 04 2010 22:58 ChinaRestaurant wrote:Show nested quote +On May 04 2010 22:56 kuresuti wrote:On May 04 2010 22:51 eNoq wrote: this reminds me of when man said its impossible to build flying craft, its impossible to get man into space, its impossible to go above 40mph, see my point? Wait for the test results, if we say impossible, end of.. Man would still be living in caves.
This tbh, Most likely it's some sort of scam, but you don't have to look down on people who believe otherwise >_> correctomundo
Yeah it's more just fun to think 'what if', even though it's a big big fucking if
Like what if it was possible, imagine the impact it could have. I mean that's how great things happen
I don't believe it's reasonably possible but god damn what if
|
Probably a hoax, but I see nothing wrong with scientifically observing him under proper conditions given that he is both willing to be examined and that the Indian government has a legit interest in his supposed powers for future space missions. Oftentimes these types will refuse to have their claims scientifically tested and then you're just like yeah, whatever. I also kinda wish news agencies didn't report on such matters until after the claims have been proven / disproven lol... guess they need their readers tho.
|
|
|
|