Am I constantly producing workers?
Am I constantly producing units?
Do I have enough buildings to support my income?
Am I using my racial abilities constantly (chronoboost, mules, larvae injects etc...)
Am I going to be supply blocked? (Still suck at this)
then when I started really putting more effort into each game it started working. If you can just push yourself a little harder you'll start to outproduce your opponent in everything (workers, units, ability to reinforce your army) and then you'll see that the composition or build order won't matter so much. All this is not to say don't go into a game with a plan but just go in like ok I'm going to 2 rax expand and then get a bio ball, rather than plan out every single unit and all that and you'll see you're going to hit 200/200 supply faster or have more income and all that so you will be free to do more things.
Td;dr challenge yourself to push your limits a little more and try to be a bit faster and soon you'll find yourself rolling opponents who used to be your skill with just pure might rather than lucky build order wins and such.