EPT
Poem for IB English A2(second language) class
| Blogs > DragoonPK |
|
DragoonPK
3259 Posts
| ||
micronesia
United States24488 Posts
I'm not good with poems, but can you explain to me what "For what had been done was for the cursed land to blame" means? | ||
|
DragoonPK
3259 Posts
On October 15 2008 04:52 micronesia wrote: Your usage of 'chipper' is apparently not incorrect, but caught me by surprise. I don't recall ever seeing it used as a verb before. I'm not good with poems, but can you explain to me what "For what had been done was for the cursed land to blame" means? If you read the book then I think you will understand, but its basically all because of the "Island"'s effect as it changed the boys after a while into savages. | ||
|
micronesia
United States24488 Posts
On October 15 2008 04:56 DragoonPK wrote: If you read the book then I think you will understand, but its basically all because of the "Island"'s effect as it changed the boys after a while into savages. I read the book a while ago so I really don't remember it that well... but I thought the island was not actually to blame... it was the human nature which the island failed to prevent due to being nothing more than a vacant island... | ||
|
Tensai176
Canada2061 Posts
And i also agree with micronesia that the book was more trying to highlight points of what desperation and isolation from a modern government can do. Probably worded that wrong but i believe the kids formed governments of their own and such. Not a major in english, those are just my two cents. Goodluck with this though! | ||
|
Oracle
Canada411 Posts
On October 15 2008 04:57 micronesia wrote: I read the book a while ago so I really don't remember it that well... but I thought the island was not actually to blame... it was the human nature which the island failed to prevent due to being nothing more than a vacant island... the island was simply a metaphor for paradise then when 'humans' touch it, the very first thing that happens is the 'scar' among other things... the island wasnt the cause for the transformation it's the "inner beast" which was | ||
|
o3.power91
Bahrain5288 Posts
 I've never read "Lord of the Flies" btw XD | ||
|
Archaic
United States4024 Posts
And, to clarify: The island was meant to be perfect. The point Golding was trying to make was to state that "human nature is inherently evil." Hrm... let me see if I can remember the quote. I'll just paraphrase: The point of the book was to trace the defects of society back to defects of human nature. Back to the point of the island being perfect: It was stated that it was the nature of the children that created the ending. Good poem, but it only skims the deeper meaning of the book. | ||
| ||
